Industries / Finance and business services / Legal and professional services / Accounting / Tax preparation
Planning
Planning is arranging a person's or a company's affairs, within the law, so that less tax is due or it is due later; it is bounded by rules that set aside steps taken only to save tax.
5
Milestones achieved, from 1935 to 2023.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1935
Planning allowed, shams not
In Helvering v. Gregory, decided on 19 March 1934, Judge Learned Hand of the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit wrote that "Any one may so arrange his affairs that his taxes shall be as low as possible", but held that a transfer of shares dressed up as a company reorganization did not count as one. The Supreme Court agreed on 7 January 1935 in Gregory v. Helvering, calling the deal "an elaborate and devious form of conveyance masquerading as a corporate reorganization" with "no business or corporate purpose".
LessonLowering one's tax is lawful, but a step with no purpose other than saving tax can be disregarded.
Credit
Judge Learned Hand; Justice Sutherland, for the Supreme Court
2005
A shelter fraud admitted
KPMG admitted criminal wrongdoing over four tax shelters, called FLIP, OPIS, BLIPS and SOS, that it designed and sold from 1996 to 2003 to wealthy people who needed $10 million or $20 million of tax losses; by court papers they generated at least $11 billion of phony losses and cost the US at least $2.5 billion in tax. Under an agreement to defer prosecution, announced on 29 August 2005, KPMG agreed to pay $456 million, closed two practice areas, was barred from pre-packaged tax products and took a government-appointed monitor for three years; nine people, including its former deputy chairman, were indicted.
LessonThe charges alleged that KPMG's leaders went ahead despite warnings from the firm's own tax experts that the shelters were "close to frivolous", and KPMG admitted it had not registered them with the IRS as the law required.
Credit
US Department of Justice and IRS
2019
Software reads returns for planners
Holistiplan, released in 2019, "reads" a client's tax return and pulls out the figures a financial adviser needs to look for ways to lower future tax. The 2025 Kitces Research on Advisor Technology found that over 50% of advisers use it for tax planning.
Credit
Holistiplan; adoption measured by Kitces Research
2020
Advisers must report schemes
Under Council Directive (EU) 2018/822 of 25 May 2018, known as DAC6, an intermediary, anyone who designs, markets, organises or manages a cross-border arrangement that shows one of the hallmarks of tax avoidance listed in its annex, must report it to the tax office within 30 days, and the EU's tax offices exchange the reports. It applied from 1 July 2020; where no intermediary reports, the taxpayer must, and arrangements begun between June 2018 and July 2020 had to be reported by 31 August 2020.
Credit
Council of the European Union
2023
Confidential plans shared
Australia's Tax Practitioners Board deregistered Peter-John Collins, a former PwC partner, as a tax agent and banned him for two years, as reported in January 2023. He had taken part in confidential Treasury consultations on new tax laws, in 2014 by PwC's account, and shared what he learned with PwC colleagues, who used it with clients and prospective clients. The board found that PwC had failed to manage conflicts of interest and ordered it to set up processes and training.
LessonThe board treated using a government consultation to win clients as a breach of a tax agent's duty of integrity.
Credit
Tax Practitioners Board
Watch for
EU trims scheme reporting
On 24 June 2026 the European Commission proposed changes to DAC6 that would exempt groups within the Pillar Two minimum tax from reporting, provided no group member benefits from arrangements that cut effective taxation below 15%, remove the generic hallmarks in section A, and extend the reporting deadline from 30 to 90 days, from 1 January 2028.
Achieved whenthe member states agree it unanimously, as the proposal requires, and the changes take effect.
Claimed by
European Commission, June 2026
Open
01
What-if answers, checked
A test of whether AI models answer "what happens to the tax if" questions correctly for made-up households, such as the effect of a raise, a second child, a move to another state or a sale of shares, scored against an open tax calculator. Write 1,000 households and questions, each with a computed answer.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Reportable or not
A labelled set of 500 made-up cross-border arrangements, each written as a planner's memo would describe it and marked by two EU tax advisers as reportable or not under DAC6, with the hallmark that applies; then score AI models on the same calls.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
What-if answers, checked
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A test of whether AI models answer "what happens to the tax if" questions correctly for made-up households, such as the effect of a raise, a second child, a move to another state or a sale of shares, scored against an open tax calculator. Write 1,000 households and questions, each with a computed answer.
Why it is still open
The public AI tax tests score one year's return (TaxCalcBench) or written questions (Vals AI's Tax Agent Bench), and Rivet's test, which includes calculations, is private. I found no public test that compares a model's what-if answers with a rules engine, though PolicyEngine's open model of US federal and state taxes can compute every answer.
Built with what exists
PolicyEngine US (AGPL-3.0 licence) and its TAXSIM emulator, cross-checked with OpenTaxSolver; models tested with and without a calculator tool.
First step
Write 20 households, compute five what-ifs for each in PolicyEngine, and put the 100 questions to one model.
Done looks like
1,000 questions over at least 10 states; for each model, the share of answers within $10 of PolicyEngine's, with and without the tool; every disagreement between PolicyEngine and OpenTaxSolver listed and resolved.
Open 02 · the brief
Reportable or not
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A labelled set of 500 made-up cross-border arrangements, each written as a planner's memo would describe it and marked by two EU tax advisers as reportable or not under DAC6, with the hallmark that applies; then score AI models on the same calls.
Why it is still open
DAC6 has required reports since July 2020, and the Commission's June 2026 proposal would change which hallmarks apply, but I found no public test set of DAC6 decisions.
Built with what exists
the hallmarks in Annex IV of Directive 2018/822; two qualified tax advisers for the labels; a fixed-answer model such as Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass") and general models such as Claude.
First step
Write 20 arrangements, 10 that meet a hallmark and 10 that nearly do, and have one adviser label them.
Done looks like
500 arrangements with labels on which the two advisers agree, their rate of agreement, and for each model the share of reportable-or-not calls and of hallmarks it gets right; a second run once the revised hallmark list is final.