Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Industrial cleaning / Tank cleaning
Planning and isolation
This work settles, before a tank is opened, what it held and what is in its sludge, how the product will be taken out, and how every pipe, power supply and moving part connected to it will be shut off so that nothing can flow in or start up while it is cleaned.
5
Milestones achieved, from 1992 to 2024.
0
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1992
Raking sludge never sampled
At Hickson & Welch's chemical works in Castleford, England, workers began raking out the residue from "60 still base", the bottom vessel of a batch still that had not been cleaned since it was installed in 1961. No sample of the sludge was analysed and the air inside was not tested for flammable vapor; the residue was taken to be a stable tar, and steam was run through a coil inside the vessel for about three hours to soften it. The heat started a runaway reaction in the residue, and on 21 September 1992 a jet of flame from the manhole killed five people. The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) found that the vessel's inlet had not been isolated before work began and that no permit to work covered the raking. The company was fined £250,000, with £150,000 in costs, on 30 July 1993.
LessonA cleaning plan starts with a sample of what is in the vessel, above all before anything heats it.
Credit
investigated by the UK Health and Safety Executive, report published 1994
1992
A quicker wash ignites
At an oil refinery in Kawasaki, Japan, the residue in a 2,000 kL asphalt tank was washed out for a turnaround by circulating gas oil, a diesel-like fuel, in place of the usual removal by hand chipping, a change made to save time and cost. About 12 hours after the gas oil was drawn off and three manholes were opened, on 15 October 1992, iron sulfide that had formed over years on the roof and walls from hydrogen sulfide and moisture heated up in the inflowing air and ignited the gas oil and asphalt left on the floor. The refinery went back to chipping by hand.
LessonA change of cleaning method needs the same hazard review as a new job; in sour service, where hydrogen sulfide is present, the tank's iron sulfide can ignite on its own once air reaches it.
Credit
case recorded in Japan's Failure Knowledge Database
2001
A standard and a manual
By August 2001 the American Petroleum Institute's tank cleaning guidance came in two parts: a standard, API Std 2015, "Requirements for Safe Entry and Cleaning of Petroleum Storage Tanks", and a companion, Recommended Practice 2016, with the detailed procedures. The US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) cites both in its guide to tank cleaning, which divides the job into stages from preplanning and isolation through degassing and air testing to returning the tank to service. The ninth edition of API Std 2015, dated August 2024, runs to 152 pages; the first edition of 1968 ran to 14.
Credit
American Petroleum Institute
2006
A guide to isolation
The UK HSE published HSG253, "The safe isolation of plant and equipment", for the onshore and offshore oil and gas industry, chemical manufacturing and pipelines. It sets out a method for choosing baseline isolation standards for work that opens up plant, such as maintenance and sampling, and covers matters from work control and documentation to draining and venting. OSHA's tank cleaning guide lists what a tank's isolation plan should address, which goes well beyond the main pipes: cathodic protection, vapor recovery, the foam fire system, gauging and overfill alarms, and mixers inside the tank.
Credit
UK Health and Safety Executive; OSHA
2024
A lesson left out
On 17 April 2024, during a turnaround on Equinor's Statfjord A platform in the Norwegian North Sea, a fire broke out inside inlet separator CD2101, a vessel about 14 m long that separates oil, gas and water from the wells, while a worker was cleaning out its deposits; the worker, on fresh-air breathing apparatus, escaped unassisted. The deposits held a high content of iron sulfide, which ignited in air. After a similar fire on Snorre B in 2019, Equinor had changed its rules: assume iron sulfide is present unless tests rule it out, keep deposits wet, and start wetting within an hour of opening the manhole. Norway's offshore safety regulator found that iron sulfide was not discussed at the turnaround seminar, that the contractor's cleaning procedure held no information on it, and that the vessel's safe job analysis did not mention the risk, although the entry permit did call for keeping the deposits wet.
LessonA rule written after one fire protects the next job only when it reaches that job's plan.
Credit
investigated by the Norwegian Ocean Industry Authority (Havtil)
Open
01
Tank cleaning accidents, coded
A public table of every tank and vessel cleaning accident in public investigation reports, from the US Chemical Safety Board, the UK HSE, WorkSafeBC in Canada, Norway's Havtil, Japan's Failure Knowledge Database and the European Commission's eMARS database of major accidents. Each accident is coded by the stage at which control was lost (planning, emptying, isolation, degassing, gas testing, opening, sludge removal, or hot work afterward) and by the safeguard that failed, and each code links to the page of the report that supports it.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
What residues do when opened
A desk-study reference table for people who plan tank and vessel cleaning, listing the residues known to heat up, ignite or react when a tank is opened to air, heated to soften its sludge or washed with a different liquid: iron sulfide from sour service, nitro-compound still residues, asphalt wetted with lighter oil, and any others the reports turn up. Each row gives the conditions that form the residue, the trigger (air, heat, drying, a change of washing liquid), the time from trigger to fire seen in reports, the precautions that reports and guidance found to work (keeping deposits wet, treating them chemically before opening, sampling before heating), and a link to the page behind each field. It handles no residue: it is built only from published reports, guidance and papers.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Tank cleaning accidents, coded
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table of every tank and vessel cleaning accident in public investigation reports, from the US Chemical Safety Board, the UK HSE, WorkSafeBC in Canada, Norway's Havtil, Japan's Failure Knowledge Database and the European Commission's eMARS database of major accidents. Each accident is coded by the stage at which control was lost (planning, emptying, isolation, degassing, gas testing, opening, sludge removal, or hot work afterward) and by the safeguard that failed, and each code links to the page of the report that supports it.
Why it is still open
The accidents in this file come from five national sources, each with its own format. A 2015 European Commission review of 47 eMARS major accidents involving contractors names tank cleaning among the contractor jobs that need written procedures but studies only five cases in detail. Havtil's Statfjord A report lists six earlier iron sulfide fires on Norwegian installations, which shows how the same failure recurs between reports. A search found no coded set of tank cleaning accidents.
Built with what exists
The public report databases named above; a model built for reading long documents, such as Meta's Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); an agent that cites the page behind each code, such as one built with Cursor's agent kit (see the Note "Findings that cite notes"); a spreadsheet; Zenodo to publish with a DOI.
First step
Code the five accidents in this file's Planning and isolation and Gas testing domains (Hickson & Welch, Kawasaki, Statfjord A, Partridge-Raleigh and the British Columbia rinsing explosion) and the six earlier iron sulfide fires listed in Havtil's report, to settle the list of stages and safeguards.
Done looks like
At least 150 accidents from at least five countries' sources, each code linked to a report page; two process safety engineers each code 30 randomly chosen accidents without seeing the table and agree with it on at least 90% of codes; a published count of failures by stage.
Open 02 · the brief
What residues do when opened
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A desk-study reference table for people who plan tank and vessel cleaning, listing the residues known to heat up, ignite or react when a tank is opened to air, heated to soften its sludge or washed with a different liquid: iron sulfide from sour service, nitro-compound still residues, asphalt wetted with lighter oil, and any others the reports turn up. Each row gives the conditions that form the residue, the trigger (air, heat, drying, a change of washing liquid), the time from trigger to fire seen in reports, the precautions that reports and guidance found to work (keeping deposits wet, treating them chemically before opening, sampling before heating), and a link to the page behind each field. It handles no residue: it is built only from published reports, guidance and papers.
Why it is still open
Guidance is written one hazard at a time. The hazard identification note of AFPM, the US refiners' trade association, covers pyrophoric iron sulfide alone, and WorkSafeBC's 2016 bulletin covers pyrophoric materials in storage tanks; neither covers residues that run away when heated, as at Hickson & Welch, where steam was used to soften a residue no one had sampled. At Statfjord A in 2024 the cleaning procedure held no information on iron sulfide. A search found no table that brings these residues together for planners.
Built with what exists
Public investigation reports from the CSB, the UK HSE, Havtil, WorkSafeBC and Japan's Failure Knowledge Database; guidance such as AFPM's hazard notes; Crossref and OpenAlex, free APIs for finding papers on self-heating tests; a model built for reading long documents, such as Meta's Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); an agent that cites the page behind each field, such as one built with Cursor's agent kit (see the Note "Findings that cite notes"); a spreadsheet published on Zenodo.
First step
Fill in the rows for iron sulfide, nitrotoluene still residue and asphalt washed with gas oil from the reports cited in this domain, to settle the columns.
Done looks like
At least 25 residue types, each with at least two independent sources, one of them an investigation report or a measured test; every row reviewed by two process safety engineers; a check against 30 public accidents in which a residue heated up or ignited, in which the table holds the residue and its trigger for at least 27.