Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Food and beverage processing / Sugar refining
Quality
Measuring how much sugar is in cane, beet, juice and finished crystals, grading sugar for trade and tax, and paying growers for the sugar their crop holds.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1883 to 2023.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1883
Duty by polariscope, not color
Before the 1840s, US customs appraisers judged imported sugar by eye, and from the 1860s the law set duty by comparing its color with the Dutch standard samples. Importers dyed sugar darker so that it paid a lower grade's duty. A polariscope passes polarized light through a sugar solution; the angle by which the solution turns the light shows how much sucrose it holds. In 1882 the Supreme Court ruled that only Congress could choose the test and ordered millions of dollars in duties refunded; a congressional commission then recommended the polarimeter, and customs began using it in 1883. The Tariff Act of 24 July 1894 made testing necessary.
Lessongrading by color invited fraud, and the test had to be written into law to hold up in court.
Credit
US Treasury and Customs Service; Congress
1916
Cane paid by sugar content
Queensland's Regulation of Sugarcane Prices Act 1915 set up boards to split raw sugar income between growers and millers, two thirds and one third. This became a formula that prices each tonne of cane by its CCS (commercial cane sugar), an estimate of the share of sugar a mill can recover from it, with a constant based on industry production values in 1916. An Australian Senate committee reported after the 2014 season that the formula, adjusted, was still generally used after deregulation.
Credit
Queensland Government; Central Sugar Cane Prices Board
1932
One sugar scale for trade
The International Commission for Uniform Methods of Sugar Analysis (ICUMSA) first met in Hamburg in 1897, with A. Herzfeld of Germany as president, to agree how sugar is tested. Frederick Bates of the US Bureau of Standards later found that the 100-degree point of the scale used on saccharimeters, the polarimeters made for sugar, was a tenth of a degree too high, an error that had cost the US government half a million dollars in tariff revenue over the previous decade. The First World War stopped the commission for two decades. At its eighth session, in Amsterdam in September 1932, with Bates as president, it adopted the Bureau's corrected scale for buying and selling sugar worldwide, though not every country took it up.
Lessona tenth of a degree was worth large sums across the sugar trade, and fixing it needed a working international body.
Credit
Frederick Bates, US Bureau of Standards; ICUMSA
1996
Online NIR at the mill
Near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy works out what a material contains from the invisible light, just beyond red, that it absorbs. Australian sugar researchers used it in the laboratory for cane from the late 1980s, trialled it next to the mill in the mid 1990s, and installed the first online system, which measures shredded cane as it passes, in 1996. By 2020 millions of CCS measurements had been made this way and used in grower payments, at far lower cost than laboratory analysis, by the account of Justin Sexton's James Cook University thesis.
LessonNIR calibrations can misread unusual cane, such as stale or dirty cane, which affects what growers are paid.
Credit
researchers at BSES (the Bureau of Sugar Experiment Stations, now Sugar Research Australia) and Australian mills
2000
Paying for what is recovered
Since 1 April 2000, South African growers have been paid by the recoverable value (RV) of their cane, not by its sucrose alone. RV % cane = S − dN − cF, where S is sucrose, N is the other dissolved solids (non-sucrose) and F is fiber; d and c are set each season and are about 0.38 and 0.02. The formula estimates the sugar and molasses a mill will recover. Each delivery is sampled and analyzed at the mill by the Cane Testing Service, which works under contract to the mill group boards as a neutral party.
Credit
South African Sugar Association
2001
EU grades by points
Council Directive 2001/111/EC of 20 December 2001 sets what may be sold in the EU as white and extra-white sugar. Faults are scored in points: one point is 0.5 units of color type, 0.0018% ash, or 7.5 ICUMSA units of color in solution. Extra-white sugar may total no more than eight points, with color in solution at no more than three, that is 22.5 ICUMSA units.
Credit
Council of the European Union
2023
Software grades trash in loads
Trash, or extraneous matter, is the leaves, tops and soil that come to the mill with harvested cane; it lowers the sugar the mill recovers. The Brazilian firm Cromai sells an AI system that estimates the share of plant trash in the sample a probe takes from each truck, reading texture and shape patterns. NovaCana, a trade news site, reported in February 2023 that it was running at ten mills, among them Agropéu and Adecoagro units, and could check up to 95% of daily loads, where manual checks covered about ten trucks a day. No accuracy figures were given.
Credit
Cromai
Watch for
Trash measured by NIR
A Louisiana State University team reports NIR calibrations on shredded cane that predicted soil content (R² 0.88, against ash analysis) and total leaves (R² 0.88), and, for the first time by their account, brown and green leaves (R² 0.72 and 0.73). R² is the share of the variation a model explains, 1 being perfect. They built the models on mixtures of clean cane, soil and leaves made in the lab, and write that trash cannot now be measured routinely in factories and so is left out of cane payment.
Achieved whena mill or cane testing service runs the method on delivered cane and an outside party publishes its error against hand-separated samples.
Claimed by
Stephania Imbachi-Ordonez, Kevin McPeak and Gillian Eggleston, ACS Agricultural Science & Technology, August 2025
São Paulo cane pricing revised
On 16 April 2026, UNICA, the mills' association, and ORPLANA, the growers' association, signed an agreement to revise Consecana-SP, the model that prices cane in São Paulo state by its total recoverable sugar (ATR). Growers get an extra 4.5%, backdated to the 2024/25 crop under standard contracts; an outside audit will check how the ATR price is worked out; and the model's criteria will be reviewed every five years.
Achieved whenConsecana-SP's board approves the changes and publishes the seventh edition of its manual, and growers' associations confirm the backdated payments.
Claimed by
UNICA and ORPLANA, April 2026
Open
01
White sugar color by phone
A phone app and a cheap light box that estimate the ICUMSA color of white sugar, the trade's measure of how much color a dissolved sample holds, from a photo of the dry crystals.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
A shared trash test set
A public set of cane samples, each with photographs, NIR spectra where possible, and hand-separated weights of clean stalk, green leaves, dry leaves, tops and soil, so that camera and NIR methods for trash can be scored on the same samples.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
White sugar color by phone
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A phone app and a cheap light box that estimate the ICUMSA color of white sugar, the trade's measure of how much color a dissolved sample holds, from a photo of the dry crystals.
Why it is still open
Alves and colleagues (2024) predicted the ICUMSA color of brown sugar from smartphone photos, with R² of at least 92.33%. Ziafar and colleagues (2026) measured whiteness and yellowness indexes of sugar with a flatbed scanner, with a correlation of 0.947 against a spectrophotometer. SugarScope, a March 2026 GitHub app, asks a general AI vision model to estimate a sugar's ICUMSA grade from an uploaded photo, and publishes no accuracy figures. None reports ICUMSA color for white sugar checked against laboratory values, where the EU's extra-white grade allows at most 22.5 ICUMSA units of color in solution.
Built with what exists
a phone camera; a 3D-printed light box with a gray reference card; ICUMSA solution color measured on a laboratory spectrophotometer by the method in the ICUMSA Methods Book; scikit-learn for the model.
First step
buy 30 retail sugars, from white to golden, have their solution color measured in a university or contract laboratory, and photograph each in the light box.
Done looks like
on 100 white and near-white sugars from at least ten producers, with laboratory values from about 10 to 200 ICUMSA units, the phone estimate is within 10 units of the laboratory value for 90% of blind samples.
Open 02 · the brief
A shared trash test set
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public set of cane samples, each with photographs, NIR spectra where possible, and hand-separated weights of clean stalk, green leaves, dry leaves, tops and soil, so that camera and NIR methods for trash can be scored on the same samples.
Why it is still open
Cromai's system runs at mills, but no accuracy figures have been published for it. The 2025 Louisiana State University NIR models were built on mixtures made in the lab. A 2020 study by Wesley Guedes and colleagues predicted stalk content from images taken with a lab-made imaging rig, with a single kind of impurity. The Sugar Research Australia camera project for cane arriving at mills runs until February 2027 and has published no dataset. No shared set was found.
novacana.comapi.openalex.orgagris.fao.orgsugarresearch.com.au
Built with what exists
a phone or machine vision camera; a balance; a drying oven; an ash test for soil, as the Louisiana team used; Zenodo or Hugging Face Datasets to publish.
First step
buy cane with its leaves from a market or farm, make 50 samples with known shares of leaf and soil, photograph and weigh them, and publish the protocol.
Done looks like
at least 500 samples from at least three growing regions or cane varieties, each with photos and component weights, released under an open license with a baseline model and its error.