BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Nonprofits / Standards bodies

Committees and consensus

This work is how standards bodies are set up and governed, who sits on their committees, and how a committee decides that a draft has enough support to be published.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1947 to 2017.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1947

    One member per country

    In October 1946 delegates from 25 countries met in London to discuss a new approach to international standardization, and the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) was formally established on 23 February 1947, with its secretariat in Geneva. ISO's members are national standards bodies, one per country, designed so that "all countries had equal rights and responsibilities"; its structure and procedures followed those of the International Federation of the National Standardizing Associations (ISA), founded in 1926 and idle during the Second World War. ISO began with 67 technical committees, on subjects from screw threads to food and paints, and published its first document in 1951, ISO/R 1:1951, which fixed the standard reference temperature for industrial length measurement. By its own count ISO now has 177 members, 850 technical committees and subcommittees, and 26,580 published standards and other documents.

    help.iso.orgiso.org

    Credit

    the delegates of 25 national standards bodies at the London meeting of October 1946; ISO

  2. 1992

    Rough consensus, not votes

    The Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF), which writes the internet's protocols in working groups that anyone can join, has no national delegations and no formal ballots. Its credo comes from a 1992 plenary talk by David Clark: "We reject: kings, presidents and voting. We believe in: rough consensus and running code." RFC 7282, published in June 2014 by Pete Resnick, explains how this works: requiring full agreement would let "a single intransigent person" stop the process, so a working group chair judges whether objections have been answered rather than counting them, and a room is often asked to "hum" for or against an option instead of raising hands. A section heading of the RFC warns that "Humming should be the start of a conversation, not the end", not a vote under another name.

    rfc-editor.org

    Credit

    David Clark; Pete Resnick for the written account

  3. 1995

    Trade law points to standards

    The World Trade Organization's Agreement on Technical Barriers to Trade (TBT), negotiated in the Uruguay Round and in operation since 1 January 1995, encourages member governments to base their technical regulations on existing international standards unless "their use would be ineffective or inappropriate", and regulations that follow such standards are presumed, unless shown otherwise, not to create an unnecessary obstacle to trade. Its Annex 3, a Code of Good Practice, sets rules for how any standardizing body, public or private, prepares and adopts standards, and is open for any body to accept. In 2000 the WTO's TBT Committee agreed on six principles to guide the development of international standards: transparency, openness, impartiality and consensus, effectiveness and relevance, coherence, and attention to the concerns of developing countries.

    wto.orgwto.orgwto.org

    Credit

    WTO members; the TBT Committee

  4. 1996

    US agencies use consensus standards

    The National Technology Transfer and Advancement Act (Public Law 104-113), introduced by Representative Connie Morella as H.R. 2196 and presented to the President on 7 March 1996, says that "all Federal agencies and departments shall use technical standards that are developed or adopted by voluntary consensus standards bodies", unless that is against the law or impractical; an agency that uses other standards must explain why to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), which reports the explanations to Congress each year. OMB's Circular A-119, in a revision in effect from 27 January 2016, says what such a body is: its process has openness, balance ("no single interest dominating the decision-making"), due process, an appeals process, and consensus, defined as "general agreement, but not necessarily unanimity." ASTM International's committee rules show balance in numbers: on a committee whose standards cover products for sale, the voting users, consumers and general-interest members together must equal or outnumber the voting producers; a subcommittee ballot needs two-thirds of the votes cast and a main committee ballot 90%, each with at least 60% of voters returning ballots, and an item with a negative vote can proceed only if the voter withdraws it or the committee votes it "not persuasive" or "not related".

    nist.govwhitehouse.govastm.org

    Credit

    Representative Connie Morella and the US Congress; OMB; ASTM International

  5. 2008

    A fast-track vote appealed

    Ecma International, a standards association, approved Microsoft's Office Open XML document format as ECMA-376 and sent it to JTC 1, the joint information technology committee of ISO and the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC), which put it on a fast-track process as draft standard DIS 29500. ISO and IEC announced in April 2008 that it had been approved. The national standards bodies of Brazil, India, South Africa and Venezuela appealed, questioning whether members had had time to see the final revisions before they voted. In August 2008 ISO and IEC said none of the appeals had won the support of two-thirds of the ISO Technical Management Board and IEC Standardization Management Board that their rules require, so the standard could be published, and that the experience would "provide important input" to their efforts "to continually improve standards development policies and procedures."

    LessonA fast track that left voting members unsure they had seen the final text produced formal appeals from four countries and public complaints about the process, even though the result stood.

    consortiuminfo.orgthejournal.com

    Credit

    ISO/IEC JTC 1; Ecma International; the four appealing national bodies

  6. 2016

    A court reads a standard

    A builder, James Elliott Construction, laid floors at a youth facility in Ballymun, Dublin, on crushed stone supplied by Irish Asphalt; cracks then made the building unusable, repairs cost €1.5 million, and Ireland's High Court found that pyrite in the stone meant it failed the Irish version of EN 13242:2002, a European standard for aggregates written by the European Committee for Standardization's committee CEN/TC 154 under a Commission mandate. On a question from Ireland's Supreme Court, the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled on 27 October 2016 (case C-613/14) that a harmonised standard of this kind, adopted under a mandate and referenced in the Official Journal of the European Union, "forms part of EU law", so the Court can interpret it.

    LessonA standard written by a private committee at a government's request can be read and ruled on by a court like any other law.

    eur-lex.europa.eu

    Credit

    the Court of Justice of the European Union (Third Chamber); the Supreme Court of Ireland

  7. 2017

    China adds group standards

    The Standing Committee of China's National People's Congress revised the country's 1988 Standardization Law on 4 November 2017, with effect from 1 January 2018. Article 2 of the revised law names five kinds of standard: national, industry, local, group and enterprise standards, with national standards split into mandatory and recommended ones and industry and local standards made recommended only. The revision gave legal status to group standards adopted by "lawfully established social groups, including academies, associations, chambers of commerce and federations", which need no government approval but are supervised by the Standardization Administration of China, according to a legal commentary published on Mondaq; Article 7 encourages enterprises, social groups, educational institutions and research institutions to take part in standardization. The Standing Committee passed the revision by 148 votes to 1.

    lexiscn.comchinajusticeobserver.comwebiis06.mondaq.comnpcobserver.com

    Credit

    the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress

Watch for

  1. Europe redraws its standards law

    The European Commission proposed a regulation to replace Regulation (EU) No 1025/2012, the law under which it asks the three European standards organizations (CEN, CENELEC and ETSI) to write harmonised standards. Its evaluation of the old law found that a harmonised standard now takes six years on average, down from more than nine, but still often misses legislative deadlines. The proposal sets deadlines at each step, lets the Commission send a request to a designated standards development organization outside the three when they cannot deliver good standards on time, and requires free access to referenced standards.

    Achieved whenthe European Parliament and the Council adopt the regulation and it is published in the Official Journal, and a first harmonised standard is delivered within its deadlines or a first request goes to a designated body other than CEN, CENELEC or ETSI.

    data.consilium.europa.euibf-solutions.com

    Claimed by

    European Commission, COM(2026) 780, October 2026

  2. Citations in under a year

    CEN and CENELEC, answering a claim in the European Parliament that a standard takes eight years, split the Commission's 6.1-year average for 2024 into 1.7 years for the Commission to adopt a request, 3.1 years to draft a standard written in Europe (4.4 years for one based on ISO or IEC work), and 1.2 years to publish and cite it, of which 0.9 years was the Commission's citation step. They say the citation step fell to 0.7 years in 2026 and that, since 2025, they offer each standard for citation as soon as it is published instead of in quarterly batches.

    Achieved whenthe Commission or an outside study publishes the time from publication to citation for every harmonised standard cited in 2026, and the median is 0.7 years or less.

    cencenelec.eucencenelec.eu

    Claimed by

    CEN and CENELEC, March 2026

Open

  1. 01

    A clock for every standard

    A public table, one row per harmonised European standard, with the date the Commission adopted the request behind it, the date CEN or CENELEC published it, and the date its reference appeared in the Official Journal, refreshed every month, so that anyone can see which step holds up which standard and check the deadlines Europe now proposes.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Who sits on British committees

    A census of the organizations on every committee of BSI, the UK's national standards body, sorted into the interest classes ASTM uses (producers, users, consumers, general interest) plus government, universities and consultants or certifiers, with a table showing for each committee which interests are present and which committees would fail ASTM's balance test, repeated every six months.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A clock for every standard

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table, one row per harmonised European standard, with the date the Commission adopted the request behind it, the date CEN or CENELEC published it, and the date its reference appeared in the Official Journal, refreshed every month, so that anyone can see which step holds up which standard and check the deadlines Europe now proposes.

Why it is still open

The only figures found are averages: the Commission's 2025 evaluation gives 6.1 years from request to citation, and CEN and CENELEC split that into three phases, but neither publishes the dates for each standard, and the two sides disagree in public about where the time goes. The nearest work is a one-off count by DIGITALEUROPE, a trade association of digital companies, in July 2024: it checked by hand, "Due to the lack of automated tools", whether each standard cited under three directives (EMC, Low Voltage and Radio Equipment) was still the latest edition, and found that 46% of those cited under the EMC Directive had been superseded and withdrawn. It named "the mean time for citation after publication" as a measure that "would also be useful" but did not compute it. The Commission's October 2026 proposal adds deadlines at each step, which a per-standard clock is needed to check. No public per-standard dataset was found.

cencenelec.eucdn.digitaleurope.orgdata.consilium.europa.eu

Built with what exists

The Commission's harmonised standards pages, which give the latest lists of references for each law; EUR-Lex for the Commission decisions that cite each reference in the Official Journal; CEN's and CENELEC's public catalogues; the Commission's database of standardisation requests, which loads by script and can be read with a web agent such as Browser Use (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); Python with pandas; a public GitHub repository with a monthly scheduled run.

single-market-economy.ec.europa.eu

  1. First step

    Take the current list of references for the Low Voltage Directive and fill in the three dates by hand for 30 standards to see which dates are hard to find.

  2. Done looks like

    Every harmonised standard cited from 2013 to 2026 under five laws (the Machinery Directive, the Low Voltage Directive, the EMC Directive, the Toy Safety Directive and the Construction Products Regulation), with at least 95% of the three dates filled and each linked to its source, medians per step published and compared with the evaluation's averages, DIGITALEUROPE's share of out-of-date citations recomputed automatically and matched against its 2024 hand count, and a monthly update running for six months.

Open 02 · the brief

Who sits on British committees

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A census of the organizations on every committee of BSI, the UK's national standards body, sorted into the interest classes ASTM uses (producers, users, consumers, general interest) plus government, universities and consultants or certifiers, with a table showing for each committee which interests are present and which committees would fail ASTM's balance test, repeated every six months.

Why it is still open

BSI publishes the nominating organizations of each committee on its standards development site; its artificial intelligence committee, ART/1, lists about 110 organizations, from 5Rights Foundation and Amazon Web Services UK to the Equality and Human Rights Commission and Imperial College London, plus more than 30 people who sit "in an individual capacity". The ICE's history of BSI puts the number of BSI committees at 1,200. But nobody has turned these lists into counts: a Pacific Institute survey of ISO in 2004 found that "publicly available information on the stakeholder representation" was "very limited", with "no consistent and systematic protocol for tracking" it, and no later census of BSI or ISO committees by interest was found.

standardsdevelopment.bsigroup.compacinst.orgice.org.uk

Built with what exists

Python with requests and a cookie jar (the BSI site redirects before it serves a page) and BeautifulSoup; Companies House and the Charity Commission registers to identify each organization; ASTM's interest definitions as the coding rules; an AI model that gives probabilities for fixed-choice questions in bulk, such as Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"), checked against two human coders.

astm.org

  1. First step

    Capture 20 committee pages from different sectors and classify their organizations by hand to fix the coding rules.

  2. Done looks like

    Every BSI committee page captured, each nominating organization classified, two people agreeing on a random 500 organizations with Cohen's kappa of at least 0.8 and the model matching their agreed label for at least 90%, a per-committee table and the code published, and a second run six months later showing what changed. The table states that it counts organizations, not votes, since BSI committees decide by consensus.