Industries / Mining and materials / Chemicals and petrochemicals / Specialty chemicals
Quality and testing
Quality and testing is the lab work that checks each batch against its specification before it ships, and the standard tests that show whether a coating, glue or flavor will do its job.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1939 to 2022.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1939
A standard salt fog
ASTM B117, which sets out how to run a cabinet that sprays a salt fog onto coated or plated metal samples, was first published in 1939. A testing lab says the method was used as early as 1914, with roots at the US National Bureau of Standards. It gave coating makers a cheap, repeatable way to compare products under the same conditions.
LessonA test can be cheap and repeatable and still say little about how long a coating lasts outdoors, so most salt spray cabinets today serve as production checks rather than as predictors of service life.
Credit
ASTM (then the American Society for Testing and Materials)
1952
Gas chromatography arrives
A. T. James and A. J. Martin described gas-liquid partition chromatography. A stream of gas carries a vaporized sample through a column, and each compound leaves the column at its own time, so it can be measured on its own. Their paper separated and measured small amounts of volatile fatty acids, from formic acid to dodecanoic acid. The method is now a routine check on flavors: a 2025 study used gas chromatography to profile the aroma compounds of vanilla pods and to measure their isotope ratios.
Credit
A. T. James and A. J. Martin
1985
Fake natural vanilla caught
Natural flavors often cost ten times or more than the same molecules made by synthesis, so synthetic vanillin has been sold as natural, according to a 1993 paper by Gérard Martin and colleagues. Isotope ratios, the share of heavier carbon and hydrogen atoms in a molecule, set natural vanillin apart from synthetic. In 1985 Dana and Harold Krueger reported how to detect vanillin that had been labeled with carbon-13 to fake the natural ratio. A newer method, SNIF-NMR, measures the ratio of heavy to ordinary hydrogen at five separate positions in the vanillin molecule, a fingerprint that the 1993 paper says ties closely to the molecule's origin.
LessonA check based on one number invites fakes built to pass it.
Credit
Dana A. Krueger and Harold W. Krueger; Gérard J. Martin and colleagues (SNIF-NMR)
1987
A shared quality standard
The International Organization for Standardization published ISO 9001 in 1987. It sets out what a quality management system must contain, so that a supplier can show customers it delivers products to specification consistently. It was revised in 1994, 2000, 2008, 2015 and 2026, and ASQ, a US quality society, puts the number of certified users at more than 1 million.
Credit
International Organization for Standardization (ISO)
2008
Toys need outside tests
On 2 August 2007 Fisher-Price recalled about 967,000 toys made in China because their surface paints could contain too much lead. The US Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 14 August 2008 then required makers of children's products to send samples to an accredited outside laboratory, starting with tests for lead paint, and to certify compliance from those results.
LessonThe law stopped relying on makers' own checks for children's products and required independent tests.
Credit
US Congress and the Consumer Product Safety Commission
2022
Lab tests miss field results
Researchers at SINTEF and the paint maker Jotun exposed 26 coating systems for two years at an outdoor site rated C5, near the top of ISO's corrosivity scale, and also ran them through a salt spray test, a cyclic aging test and an electrical measurement of coating resistance. Outdoors, zinc-rich primers cut corrosion spreading from a scratch by a factor of about ten. None of the lab tests showed this, and all correlated rather poorly with the field results.
LessonThe authors write that the weight standards give to corrosion creep from a scratch in pre-qualification tests may not be justified.
Credit
Ole Øystein Knudsen and colleagues (SINTEF, Jotun)
Watch for
AI integrates chromatogram peaks
In chromatography software, integration means deciding where each peak starts and ends so its area, and so the amount of the compound, can be measured. Analysts often adjust it by hand. Waters says its AI-Powered Peak Integration for Empower software, trained on each lab's own data, cut manual interventions from 90 to 4 in a side-by-side review of 400 chromatograms with a large drug maker, and cut user-to-user variability by 72% in user testing. Early access begins in December 2026.
Achieved whena lab outside Waters' own pilots, such as a chemical maker's quality lab, publishes a side-by-side comparison on its own chromatograms that shows fewer manual edits and results that match its analysts' integrations.
Claimed by
Waters Corporation, October 2026
Open
01
Pool lab and field results
A public table that pairs, coating by coating, the results of accelerated lab tests (neutral salt spray under ASTM B117 or ISO 9227, and cyclic tests such as ISO 12944-9 and ISO 16701) with the same coatings' results after years outdoors, drawn from published studies. Add the rank correlation between lab and field for each test method, coating type and exposure site.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
An open vanillin origin table
A public, sample-by-sample table of published isotope measurements for vanillin (carbon and hydrogen ratios, and the site-by-site SNIF-NMR values where given), labeled by origin: vanilla beans by country, synthesis from guaiacol, from lignin, from eugenol or ferulic acid, and fermentation from sugar. Add a simple classifier and report which origins the measurements can and cannot tell apart.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Pool lab and field results
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table that pairs, coating by coating, the results of accelerated lab tests (neutral salt spray under ASTM B117 or ISO 9227, and cyclic tests such as ISO 12944-9 and ISO 16701) with the same coatings' results after years outdoors, drawn from published studies. Add the rank correlation between lab and field for each test method, coating type and exposure site.
Why it is still open
Each study tests a few dozen coatings and they disagree. Schmid (2024) found that neutral salt spray correlated with five-year field results in 6 of 12 cases for 19 coatings, and Knudsen and colleagues (2022) found poor correlation for 26 coating systems. Three searches for this file found no pooled, public dataset.
Built with what exists
The Crossref and OpenAlex APIs to find studies; an AI model that reads long documents and pulls out tables, such as Meta's Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"), with each value tied to its page and table; Python with pandas and SciPy for the correlations; Zenodo to publish the table with a DOI.
First step
Put the 19 coatings from Schmid (2024) and the 26 systems from Knudsen and colleagues (2022) into a draft table and publish the column layout for comment.
Done looks like
At least 30 studies and 400 coating-and-test pairs, each row linked to the table or figure it came from. Two people re-extract a random 10% of rows on their own and agree with the table on at least 95% of values. Rank correlations are published for each test method with confidence intervals.
Open 02 · the brief
An open vanillin origin table
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public, sample-by-sample table of published isotope measurements for vanillin (carbon and hydrogen ratios, and the site-by-site SNIF-NMR values where given), labeled by origin: vanilla beans by country, synthesis from guaiacol, from lignin, from eugenol or ferulic acid, and fermentation from sugar. Add a simple classifier and report which origins the measurements can and cannot tell apart.
Why it is still open
Fraud adapts to the tests, and new production routes keep arriving. A 1993 paper notes that carbon-13 enrichment defeated bulk isotope tests for vanilla, and a 2025 study that added minor aroma compounds and their isotopes as markers worked from ten vanilla pods. Reference values sit in small separate studies, and searches for this file found no public table that pools them sample by sample.
Built with what exists
The Europe PMC and Crossref APIs to find papers; an AI model for table extraction such as Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Python with scikit-learn for the classifier; Zenodo to publish.
First step
Extract the sample tables from the 2021 study of vanillin by carbon-13 NMR and the 2025 study of vanilla pods into a draft table.
Done looks like
At least 40 papers and 500 sample rows, each with origin, method, lab and source table. A random 10% of rows re-extracted by a second person with at least 95% agreement. A published table of which origins can be separated using carbon and hydrogen ratios together, with accuracy measured by leaving one study out at a time.