BRENNEN

Industries / Energy, water and waste / Environmental services / Solid waste collection

Bins and containers

Bins and containers is the work of choosing, supplying and placing the cans, carts, dumpsters and street containers that hold waste between pickups, in shapes a truck can lift and empty.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1883 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1883

    Paris orders closed bins

    Eugène Poubelle, prefect of the Seine, the official who ran Paris, issued an order in 1883 that France's patent office (INPI) describes as demanding "closed containers for the daily disposal of waste." Landlords had to give each tenant a wooden container lined with tin, according to the Paris guide Paris Zigzag. A second order, of 7 March 1884, had contractors empty the containers into carts fitted with a lift, according to a City of Paris history of street cleaning. The word poubelle, French for bin, entered the dictionary in 1890, according to Paris Zigzag.

    LessonDealers who lived by buying and reselling worn-out goods were among the first to rise up against the order, according to INPI: a bin changes who can earn from what is thrown away.

    artsandculture.google.compatpro.paris.frpariszigzag.fr

    Credit

    Eugène Poubelle, Prefecture of the Seine

  2. 1986

    One bin fits every lift

    Germany's standards body, DIN, published DIN 30740 in July 1986, a standard for plastic wheeled bins of 120 and 240 litres emptied without dust, setting their dimensions, construction and tests. In July 1997 the European standard EN 840-1 set the dimensions of two-wheeled bins of 80 to 390 litres for comb lifting devices, the toothed bar on a truck that hooks under a bin's front rim. By fixing the shape the lift grips, the standards let a council buy bins and trucks from different makers.

    din.deboutique.afnor.org

    Credit

    DIN; the European Committee for Standardization (CEN)

  3. 2010

    Smart bins fall short

    Philadelphia bought 768 BigBelly bins, solar-powered street bins that squeeze trash down and signal when full, for about US$3 million. The city relied on the vendor's projection of a 70% weekly reduction and did not check it. The City Controller's staff watched the bins for two months and counted an average of 10 collections a week, more than double the five BigBelly Solar had stated.

    LessonIn 2017 the Controller put the program's cost at about US$6.5 million with maintenance and parts, while the Streets Commissioner said savings were US$6.4 million, half the US$13 million first projected; a vendor's savings need counting by someone else.

    controller.phila.govgovtech.com

    Credit

    Philadelphia City Controller Alan Butkovitz; BigBelly Solar

  4. 2024

    New York requires lidded bins

    For about 60 years New York's sanitation workers lifted plastic bags off the curb by hand. From March 2024 every business had to set out trash in bins with secure lids, and from November 2024 so did every building with one to nine homes. By the Department of Sanitation's count, about 70% of the city's waste must now be in containers.

    LessonA 2022–2023 pilot on West 45th Street, where workers carried bags by hand from locked curb bins to ordinary trucks, ended early, and Commissioner Jessica Tisch called that version "not scalable.".

    nyc.govnyc.streetsblog.org

    Credit

    New York City Department of Sanitation (DSNY)

  5. 2025

    Street containers, emptied by arm

    From June 2025 DSNY put a whole district's trash in containers: Manhattan Community District 9, in West Harlem. Buildings with more than 30 homes got Empire Bins, locked containers of about 4 cubic yards (3 cubic meters) bolted into the parking lane, each with an RFID tag, a radio label that identifies it. Automated side loaders empty them: one worker works the truck's arm from inside the cab while a second watches from the street. By August 2026 the district had 997 Empire Bins at more than 760 properties, and 6 bins, about 0.5%, had needed replacing.

    nyc.govnyc.gov

    Credit

    DSNY

Watch for

  1. Fewer rats after bins

    DSNY reports that rat sightings reported to 311, the city's phone and web line for complaints, fell 20.6% citywide, from 25,230 (December 2023 to November 2024) to 20,025 a year later, and 23% in the West Harlem pilot district. It says the drop "coincides with" the bin rule for small buildings.

    Achieved whensomeone outside the city government confirms the drop with the health department's rat inspection results, not only 311 reports, and compares districts with bins against districts without.

    nyc.govnyc.gov

    Claimed by

    DSNY, December 2025 and August 2026

  2. Street bins citywide by 2032

    DSNY plans Empire Bins in Brooklyn Community District 2 from fall 2026, in nine more districts by the end of 2027, and across the city by 2032. It issued a draft environmental impact statement on 1 July 2026.

    Achieved whenthe ten districts are fully containerized on that schedule and an outside count finds few bags left on their sidewalks.

    nyc.gov

    Claimed by

    DSNY, August 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Fill sensors, tested together

    A field test of at least three commercial fill-level sensors, the devices fixed under a bin's lid that report how full it is, mounted together in the same bins and checked against hand readings.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Bags on the curb, counted

    An independent count of trash bags left on the sidewalk along a fixed set of New York blocks on collection nights, before and after the June 2026 deadline for small buildings to use the official NYC Bin, with blocks in districts that have Empire Bins and districts that do not.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Fill sensors, tested together

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A field test of at least three commercial fill-level sensors, the devices fixed under a bin's lid that report how full it is, mounted together in the same bins and checked against hand readings.

Why it is still open

A search of papers and vendor pages found prototypes, route planners that predict fill levels, such as BIN-CT (2019), and vendor claims, but no published test of several products against hand measurements. The closest study, by Yoeri Brouwer and colleagues at the universities of Lisbon and Coimbra in 2023, compared ultrasonic sensors in one Portuguese company's bins with its truck drivers' visual estimates of fill level; it tested one kind of sensor. Sensoneo's page gives its sensors' range, 3 cm to 400 cm, and no accuracy figure or test. Compology, a maker of camera sensors, wrote in 2017 that ultrasonic sensors, which time an echo off the waste, can misread large containers where waste piles unevenly. Philadelphia's Controller found real collections ran at double a vendor's projection.

sensoneo.commedium.comebi.ac.ukebi.ac.uk

Built with what exists

Off-the-shelf ultrasonic, radar and camera fill sensors sold to cities and haulers; a small camera under each lid that takes a photo at every reading; a vision model fine-tuned on one graphics card to read fill level from the photos (see the Note "One GPU to fine-tune"); Python and DuckDB.

  1. First step

    Get written permission to fit sensors to ten bins on a campus or business park, and order two sensor models.

  2. Done looks like

    Three or more sensor models in at least 20 bins for 60 days, at least 1,000 readings matched to a hand measurement or photo, and, for each model, the average error in percentage points of fill and the share of readings more than 20 points off, published with the data.

Open 02 · the brief

Bags on the curb, counted

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An independent count of trash bags left on the sidewalk along a fixed set of New York blocks on collection nights, before and after the June 2026 deadline for small buildings to use the official NYC Bin, with blocks in districts that have Empire Bins and districts that do not.

Why it is still open

The program's results so far are DSNY's own, drawn from 311 reports and its service records. A search for an outside count found only one-block anecdotes from the 2023 West 45th Street pilot.

nyc.govnyc.gov

Built with what exists

A phone or dash camera driven or walked along a fixed route; Ultralytics YOLO trained to tell bags from bins; Label Studio for labeling; face and license-plate blurring before anything is published; NYC Open Data's 311 records for comparison.

  1. First step

    Pick 50 block faces in two districts, film them on two collection nights, and count the bags by hand.

  2. Done looks like

    200 block faces in four districts counted on 16 collection nights, with bags per block face published beside the video frames behind each count; a second person recounts 10% of block faces and the agreement rate is published.