BRENNEN

Industries / Health / Healthcare / Senior living and assisted care

Keeping families informed

Keeping families informed is the public record a family can check before and after choosing a home: ratings, inspection results, owners, visiting rights and, in some places, a camera in the room.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1998 to 2026.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1998

    Nursing homes compared online

    In 1998 the US Medicare agency, now CMS, began publishing quality information about each nursing home on its Nursing Home Compare website, by the account of Hari Sharma and colleagues.

    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    CMS, then the Health Care Financing Administration

  2. 2001

    Cameras allowed in rooms

    A Texas law effective 15 June 2001 let nursing home residents place an electronic monitoring device, such as a camera, in their room after asking the home. Karen Levy, Lauren Kilgour and Clara Berridge counted seven states with rules in force by 2019: Texas (2001), New Mexico (2004), Washington (2008), Oklahoma (2013), Illinois (2015), Utah (2016) and Louisiana (2018). Recording Law's guide, checked in November 2026, counts 17 states with statutes and Washington by regulation.

    Lessonthe authors found that cameras meant to deter abuse create new privacy risks for residents who cannot consent, roommates and care workers, which each state handles differently.

    texas.public.lawmicounties.orgrecordinglaw.com

    Credit

    Texas Legislature

  3. 2008

    Star ratings invite gaming

    In December 2008 CMS began giving each nursing home one to five stars, with staffing taken from figures the homes reported themselves. Hari Sharma, R. Tamara Konetzka and Fabrice Smieliauskas found that after the stars began, reported registered nurse and licensed practical nurse staffing became less closely tied to what homes spent on staff, which they read as "potential gaming".

    Lessona public rating built on a home's own figures invites inflation, and CMS later took staffing from payroll records instead.

    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    CMS; Sharma, Konetzka and Smieliauskas (2017)

  4. 2019

    Germany drops near-perfect grades

    Germany graded its care homes with school marks, the Pflegenoten ("care grades"), and over 95% of homes scored 2.0 or better, by the insurer Barmer's account. From 1 November 2019 a new system replaced the grades with quality indicators that homes collect themselves, information each home gives about itself, and regular outside inspections, with results to be published from spring 2020.

    Lessona grade that nearly every home receives does not help families tell homes apart.

    barmer.de

    Credit

    Germany's statutory long-term care insurance, by Barmer's account

  5. 2023

    Owners named, private equity included

    The 2010 Affordable Care Act required disclosure of the owners and operators of US nursing homes. CMS proposed rules in 2011 and again in February 2023, posted a nursing home ownership file on data.cms.gov in September 2022, and finalized the rule on 17 November 2023, effective 16 January 2024, with definitions of private equity companies and real estate investment trusts. CMS put the share of nursing homes run for profit at about 70% in 2021, including about 11% owned by private equity firms.

    Lessona disclosure duty written into law in 2010 took 13 years to become a working rule.

    federalregister.gov

    Credit

    CMS

  6. 2024

    Visiting written into rules

    From 6 April 2024 Regulation 9A in England requires care homes, hospitals and hospices to help the people staying with them receive visits unless there are exceptional circumstances, and bars care homes from discouraging residents' visits out. Government guidance adds that even in exceptional circumstances, end-of-life visits should be allowed.

    legislation.gov.ukgov.uk

    Credit

    Department of Health and Social Care; enforced by the Care Quality Commission (CQC), England's care regulator

  7. 2026

    Complaint counts taken down

    When CMS moved its nursing home inspection data to a new cloud system on 14 July 2025, it dropped a filter that had shown only substantiated complaints, and Care Compare began counting every allegation and self-reported incident from the past three years, including duplicates and unverified claims. CMS removed the counts of complaint allegations and facility-reported incidents from 25 February 2026 while it decides how to show them; complaint inspections and the citations from them stay on the site.

    Lessona change in how data are filtered can change a public count with no change in care.

    cms.gov

    Credit

    CMS

Watch for

  1. England resets care ratings

    The CQC says it will bring back a separate assessment framework for each sector, including adult social care, and written descriptions of what each rating level looks like, after a consultation that drew 1,703 responses, about 80% of them agreeing with its proposed changes to how it inspects and rates. It cites independent reviews by Penny Dash, Mike Richards and the Care Provider Alliance.

    Achieved whencare homes are being rated under the new adult social care framework and an independent review finds the ratings consistent and up to date.

    cqc.org.uk

    Claimed by

    CQC, March 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Do camera laws change findings

    A before-and-after comparison of abuse and neglect citations at nursing homes in US states that passed resident-room camera laws against states that did not, built only from public inspection data.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Family questions, public data

    A tool that lets a family ask about any US nursing home in plain words and answers only from CMS's public files, naming the file and its date for every number, with a published test set.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Do camera laws change findings

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A before-and-after comparison of abuse and neglect citations at nursing homes in US states that passed resident-room camera laws against states that did not, built only from public inspection data.

Why it is still open

Legal studies describe the laws, and Levy, Kilgour and Berridge compared seven states' rules in 2019, but a search of Europe PMC found no study that measures whether the laws change abuse or neglect citations. Recording Law's guide, checked in November 2026, counts 17 states with statutes, so there are now enough laws with different start dates to compare.

micounties.orgrecordinglaw.com

Built with what exists

CMS's public Health Deficiencies file, one citation per row with its tag number, date and severity, and archived copies of it; each law's effective date from its statute; Python with pandas and an open event-study method for laws that start in different years.

  1. First step

    Download the current Health Deficiencies file, count abuse and neglect citations by state and year, and mark each state's law from Recording Law's list.

  2. Done looks like

    Yearly abuse and neglect citation rates per 100 homes for every state, as far back as CMS's archived files go, with an estimate for each state that passed a law in that period and all code public.

Open 02 · the brief

Family questions, public data

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A tool that lets a family ask about any US nursing home in plain words and answers only from CMS's public files, naming the file and its date for every number, with a published test set.

Why it is still open

Care Compare shows the data but does not answer questions. ProPublica's Nursing Home Inspect lets users search more than 90,000 inspection reports by home, state or text, with data updated in October 2026, but it searches rather than answers questions in plain words, and web and GitHub searches found no AI tool built on these files. The files also shift: CMS's move to a new data system in July 2025 introduced discrepancies, and complaint counts were removed from Care Compare on 25 February 2026, so any tool must show dates and changes.

projects.propublica.orgcms.gov

Built with what exists

The CMS Provider Data Catalog downloads (provider information, staffing, penalties, ownership, health deficiencies); DuckDB; Claude or another AI model that calls SQL queries as tools.

  1. First step

    Write 50 test questions, such as a home's nurse hours per resident day, its stars, its owners and its fines, and compute the answers with pandas from the latest files.

  2. Done looks like

    300 test questions about 100 homes with answers computed by script, the tool getting at least 98% of numbers exactly right and naming a source for every answer, rerun after each monthly data refresh.