BRENNEN

Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Agriculture and farming / Seed production

Selling seed

Getting seed to farmers and gardeners, deciding who owns a variety, and setting the rules on saving and sharing seed.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1876 to 2025.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1876

    Seed sold by catalog

    In 1850 the United States still had fewer than 50 seed companies, because most farmers and gardeners saved and traded their own seed, by the Smithsonian Libraries' account. W. Atlee Burpee & Company, set up in Philadelphia in 1876, sold through mail-order catalogs, tested varieties on its own trial farm before offering them, and became the world's largest mail-order seed business in the early 1900s; by 1911 it received 3,000 to 7,000 mail orders a day.

    library.si.edu

    Credit

    W. Atlee Burpee

  2. 1923

    Free government seed ends

    From 1862 the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) mailed free packets of seed to farmers on behalf of members of Congress, one of its largest programs in the late 1800s. At Senate committee hearings in 1907 the seedsman Landreth said that the government gave out 40 million packets a year while the seed trade sold 75 million. Congress ended the practice in 1923.

    cambridge.org

    Credit

    US Congress and USDA; history by Kathy J. Cooke (Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era, 2018)

  3. 1961

    Breeders get a property right

    The International Union for the Protection of New Varieties of Plants (UPOV) was set up in 1961. Its convention gives the breeder of a new variety an intellectual property right, called the breeder's right, over how the variety is sold, and each member country writes that right into its own law. UPOV lists 80 members.

    upov.intupov.int

    Credit

    UPOV and its member states

  4. 2001

    Patents reach seed varieties

    The US Plant Variety Protection Act, in force from 24 December 1970, gives breeders a certificate for a seed-grown variety but lets a farmer save its seed for use on the farmer's own land and lets anyone use the variety in research. On 10 December 2001, in J.E.M. Ag Supply v. Pioneer Hi-Bred, the US Supreme Court held that new plant varieties can also get ordinary utility patents, which carry neither exemption. Pioneer held 17 utility patents on its inbred and hybrid corn and sold the seed under a license "solely to produce grain and/or forage".

    LessonA US seed variety can carry two kinds of protection, and only the variety certificate leaves the farmer a right to save seed.

    law.cornell.edulaw.cornell.edu

    Credit

    US Supreme Court (opinion by Justice Thomas); Pioneer Hi-Bred

  5. 2016

    India caps cotton seed prices

    In March 2016 India's central government used its Cotton Seed Price (Control) Order to set one price in every state for genetically modified Bt cotton seed: at most Rs 800 for a 450 g packet in the 2016-17 season, against Rs 830 to Rs 1,030 before. It cut the trait fee, the royalty paid to the developer of the built-in insect resistance, by about 70%, from Rs 163 plus taxes to Rs 49 a packet. Mahyco Monsanto Biotech, the trait's licensor, challenged the order and said it would "re-evaluate" its India operations.

    business-standard.com

    Credit

    India's Ministry of Agriculture

  6. 2018

    Six seed firms become four

    Three deals proposed in 2015 and 2016 joined Dow with DuPont, ChemChina with Syngenta (a $43 billion offer) and Bayer with Monsanto (a $66 billion offer), turning the "Big Six" seed and pesticide firms into four, as USDA's Economic Research Service put it. On 21 March 2018 the European Commission cleared Bayer's purchase of Monsanto, then the world's largest seed supplier, on condition that Bayer sell businesses worth "well over €6 billion", with BASF proposed as the buyer. A March 2023 USDA report found that the top four firms (Bayer, Corteva, ChemChina and BASF) held 95% of the variety patents and certificates for corn and 84% for soybeans. On 1 October 2026 Corteva split its seed business off as Vylor, a separate company listed on the New York Stock Exchange, and kept its pesticide business.

    ers.usda.govec.europa.euams.usda.govsec.gov

    Credit

    European Commission (review); Bayer, Monsanto and BASF

  7. 2025

    Kenyan farmers may share seed

    Kenya's Seed and Plant Varieties Act made it a crime to sell or exchange seed of unregistered, uncertified varieties, with up to two years in prison or a fine of 1 million shillings (about $7,800 by IPS's conversion). In 2022 fifteen smallholder farmers petitioned the High Court against those sections. In November 2025 Justice Rhoda Rutto declared Section 3D(1) and other punitive sections unconstitutional, so farmers may save, share and exchange indigenous seed. The Attorney-General and the Kenya Plant Health Inspectorate Service (KEPHIS) have filed notice of appeal.

    ipsnews.netbeta.nation.co.ke

    Credit

    the petitioning farmers; Kenya's High Court

Watch for

  1. EU seed law nears adoption

    EU negotiators reached a provisional deal in June 2026 on one regulation to replace the EU's separate directives on marketing seed and other plant reproductive material, some dating from the 1960s. It keeps compulsory variety registration and certification. By Inf'OGM's reading, it also lets conservation varieties (old or local varieties kept to protect crop diversity) of all species be sold across the EU, adds locally adapted varieties that can be registered without the usual tests for distinctness, uniformity and stability, lets conservation networks exchange unregistered seed, and regulates non-commercial seed exchange between farmers. The farmers' group ECVC calls for its rejection.

    Achieved whenthe regulation is adopted and published in the EU's Official Journal; Parliament's agriculture committee approved the agreed text on 14 July 2026, the Legislative Observatory gives 18 January 2027 as the indicative plenary date, and the rules would apply four years after adoption. ).

    infogm.orgoeil.secure.europarl.europa.euseedworld.com

    Claimed by

    European Parliament and Council negotiators, June 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Which US varieties are patented

    A free public table that takes seed variety names as they appear in US catalogs and on seed bags and shows, for each one, any US plant variety protection certificate and any US utility patent that covers it, with a link to the document behind each match.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Bag tags against real rights

    A public count of how often seed sellers' bag tags and license terms forbid saving, research or breeding for varieties that carry no certificate or patent, with the restriction text, the seller and the variety's actual protection status for each case.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Which US varieties are patented

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A free public table that takes seed variety names as they appear in US catalogs and on seed bags and shows, for each one, any US plant variety protection certificate and any US utility patent that covers it, with a link to the document behind each match.

Why it is still open

In March 2023 USDA's Agricultural Marketing Service reported that there is "not a comprehensive source of information" on the restrictions that apply to specific seeds, that breeders must search the certificate database, patent databases and company websites, and that patents sometimes name a variety only by an internal code; the Heritage Grain Alliance told USDA it found it "impossible to get a list of the patented varieties". Europe's PINTO database, run by the seed industry group Euroseeds, links varieties to patents, but only from voluntary entries by patent holders and only for varieties sold in the EU and EFTA. Searches found no US equivalent.

ams.usda.goveuroseeds.eu

Built with what exists

USDA Plant Variety Protection Office certificate records; USPTO full-text patent data; UPOV's PLUTO database for official variety names; an AI model that reads patent claims and seed deposit records and proposes matches for a person to confirm (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); Python with DuckDB.

  1. First step

    Take 100 tomato and lettuce varieties from three US seed catalogs and look each one up by hand in the certificate and patent records to make a test set.

  2. Done looks like

    1,000 variety names from five crops, each labeled "certificate", "patent", "both" or "neither" with a cited document; 200 labels drawn at random checked by two people, with their agreement and the table's error rate published; and, for varieties sold in both markets, a comparison with PINTO.

Open 02 · the brief

Bag tags against real rights

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public count of how often seed sellers' bag tags and license terms forbid saving, research or breeding for varieties that carry no certificate or patent, with the restriction text, the seller and the variety's actual protection status for each case.

Why it is still open

A bag tag is a license printed on seed packaging, and a buyer who opens the bag is deemed to accept it. USDA's 2023 report quotes an independent seed company founder who found bag tags on an heirloom variety "not protected by any form of IP at all", and USDA committed to teach farmers when bag-tag terms do and do not rest on intellectual property. Vermont Law School's Center for Agriculture and Food Systems compared the 2024 technology use agreements of the three largest US seed companies (Bayer, Corteva and Syngenta) in February 2025; a search found no count across sellers and no check of tags against each variety's real status.

ams.usda.govcafs.vermontlaw.edu

Built with what exists

Photos and web copies of bag tags and seller terms; the variety table above, or hand lookups in the certificate and patent records; an AI model to transcribe and sort the restriction language, checked by a person (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); a spreadsheet or DuckDB.

  1. First step

    Collect the online bag-tag or license text for 30 varieties from five vegetable seed companies and look up each variety's status.

  2. Done looks like

    Bag-tag or license text for at least 300 varieties from at least 20 sellers, covering vegetable and field crops, each matched to its protection status, with the share of restrictive tags on unprotected varieties and every such case published with its evidence.