BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Scaffolding

Design and load calculation

Scaffold design works out how much weight a scaffold and each of its parts must carry, how it is tied to the building against wind, and which drawings or sheets show that it is safe to build.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1971 to 2013.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1971

    Four times the load

    In 1971 the US Department of Labor adopted its construction safety standards as OSHA standards, with the scaffold rules in a section called Subpart L. They required scaffolds and their parts to carry, without failing, at least four times the maximum load intended for them, a margin the trade calls a safety factor of four. The rule stayed largely unchanged until 1996.

    federalregister.gov

    Credit

    US Department of Labor, Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)

  2. 1978

    Anchored to young concrete

    On 27 April 1978 a four-level scaffold at Willow Island, West Virginia, fell with the top of the concrete cooling tower it was anchored to, killing all 51 workers on it. The tower was being cast in 5-foot (1.5 m) rings, one a day. The National Bureau of Standards found the most probable cause was construction loads put on the newest ring before its concrete, less than a day old, was strong enough to carry them.

    LessonA scaffold is only as strong as the structure it hangs from or is tied to.

    nvlpubs.nist.gov

    Credit

    National Bureau of Standards investigators (H. S. Lew and colleagues), at OSHA's request

  3. 1996

    Rules set by performance

    OSHA rewrote its scaffold rules on 30 August 1996, in force from 29 November 1996, replacing the 1971 standard for an estimated 3.6 million construction workers. The rule states the result required where possible rather than the method, and requires every scaffold to be designed by a qualified person, meaning someone whose degree, certificate or proven experience shows they can solve such problems, and to be built and loaded to that design. It also made clear that the factor of four applies to the share of the load each part actually carries, not to the whole scaffold's load.

    LessonRules alone did not end the problem: scaffolding is fourth on OSHA's preliminary list of the standards it cited most in fiscal year 2026.

    federalregister.govosha.govosha.gov

    Credit

    OSHA

  4. 2004

    One code for Europe

    The European standard EN 12811-1:2003 sets performance requirements and general design rules for working scaffolds, with six load classes and seven width classes for the platforms people stand on. Britain published it as BS EN 12811-1 on 16 June 2004 and withdrew its own code of practice, BS 5973:1993.

    shop.standards.ieapacsafety.com

    Credit

    CEN, the European Committee for Standardization, and BSI, the British Standards Institution

  5. 2010

    China codes the disk lock

    China's Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development issued JGJ 231-2010 on 17 November 2010, a safety code for the design, building, acceptance and use of disk-lock steel tube scaffolds, a system type whose parts lock together at fixed points. It took effect on 1 October 2011 and was replaced by JGJ/T 231-2021 in 2021. It sits beside JGJ 130, the code for tube-and-coupler scaffolds, whose current edition took effect on 1 December 2011.

    codeofchina.comcodeofchina.com

    Credit

    Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development of China

  6. 2013

    Design by compliance sheet

    The UK's National Access & Scaffolding Confederation (NASC) issued TG20:13, guidance plus eGuide software that prints a compliance sheet for a standard tube-and-fitting scaffold, giving its safe height, tie loads and leg loads, so it can be built without a one-off design. The NASC estimated that "perhaps as many as 80%" of scaffolds would no longer need a designer, and said design exchanges for non-standard jobs averaged £400 a job. TG20:21 replaced it in April 2021 and added scaffold types such as birdcages and loading bays.

    constructionmanagement.co.ukscaffmag.com

    Credit

    NASC, with CADS (Computer and Design Services) as authors of the software

Watch for

  1. An AI assistant for designers

    Avontus showed an AI assistant that reads a scaffold model, works out areas and quantities, writes a bill of materials, groups parts by where they sit in the structure and plans truck loads within weight limits, linked to its design and inventory software. The demonstration claimed no structural or load checks. Pricing and the commercial rollout were not confirmed, and Avontus describes the platform as a roadmap being developed with selected design partners.

    Achieved whencustomers use it on live jobs and an outside party compares its parts lists and truck plans with hand counts for the same scaffolds.

    scaffmag.com

    Claimed by

    Avontus, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Check designs like a checker

    Software that reads a finished scaffold design package, meaning the drawings and calculation sheets, and flags errors against the rules it claims to meet: tie spacing and tie loads, leg loads against base capacity, the height-to-base limit before a scaffold must be tied, and the platform load class against its intended use. A design checker, a second engineer, would review each flag.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Test the free calculators

    A public side-by-side test of the free and open scaffold calculators, running the same standard scaffolds through each and comparing their leg loads and tie loads with the NASC's TG20:21 compliance sheets and an engineer's hand calculation.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Check designs like a checker

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Software that reads a finished scaffold design package, meaning the drawings and calculation sheets, and flags errors against the rules it claims to meet: tie spacing and tie loads, leg loads against base capacity, the height-to-base limit before a scaffold must be tied, and the platform load class against its intended use. A design checker, a second engineer, would review each flag.

Why it is still open

Research tools generate scaffold layouts inside a building model by rule (Kim and Teizer; Feng and Lu, 2017). CADS's SMART Compliance, launched in 2023 by the team that wrote TG20 with the NASC, produces compliant designs for tied scaffolds and checks a bridge beam the user picks. Scaffcalc, a Swedish firm, says its AI designs and sizes scaffolds itself, and Avontus's 2026 assistant counts parts but claims no load checks. None of these reviews a design that someone else produced. Scaffcalc's project page, citing unnamed industry data, says 61% of scaffolds in Sweden lack the required strength calculations.

iaarc.orgscaffmag.comsmartbuilt.sescaffmag.com

Built with what exists

A document-reading AI model such as the Claude-based reviewer Enveda described (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); the text of OSHA 1926.451 and the NASC's TG20:21 guides as rule sources; Python to recompute tie and leg loads from the numbers read off each sheet.

  1. First step

    Ask a scaffold design firm for ten past designs with client names removed, and write down the checks its design checker applies to each.

  2. Done looks like

    100 design packages, 30 of them with errors planted by a scaffold designer and not disclosed to the tool; the tool's catches and false alarms published next to those of two human design checkers on the same packages; a pass means it misses no planted error that changes a tie or leg load.

Open 02 · the brief

Test the free calculators

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public side-by-side test of the free and open scaffold calculators, running the same standard scaffolds through each and comparing their leg loads and tie loads with the NASC's TG20:21 compliance sheets and an engineer's hand calculation.

Why it is still open

Free tools exist, but none has been tested against the others. SkyCiv's free calculator checks members and couplers against BS EN 12811-1 but computes no tie loads or wind. MechanicalPro's MIT-licensed Blender add-on claims EN 1993 and EN 12811 checks, backed only by its own 421 software tests. TradeCalculator's free tool calls itself indicative; it compared itself with two TG20:21 sheets, whose leg loads were 1.36 and 1.56 times its own.

skyciv.commechanicalpro.vercel.apptradecalculator.co.uk

Built with what exists

The NASC's TG20:21 eGuide (£300 plus VAT a year per login in 2021); the free tools above; a spreadsheet or Python to tabulate results; a coding agent to script repeat runs (see the Note "Checked without being asked"); review by a chartered structural engineer.

  1. First step

    Choose five scaffolds that TG20:21 covers, produce their compliance sheets, and run them through the three free tools.

  2. Done looks like

    30 standard scaffolds, varied by height, bay width, sheeting and wind zone, run through every tool; leg and tie loads published against TG20:21 and the hand calculation; each tool's largest error on the unsafe side stated in kilonewtons and as a percentage.