BRENNEN

Industries / Finance and business services / Insurance / Reinsurance

Catastrophe bonds and investors

Passing disaster risk to investors such as pension funds, through bonds, funds and contracts backed by money held in trust.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1992 to 2023.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1992

    Futures that did not catch on

    The Chicago Board of Trade (CBOT) began trading insurance catastrophe futures on 11 December 1992: contracts settled in cash on an index of catastrophe losses, meant to draw money from outside insurance. A paper for the Casualty Actuarial Society concluded that they "provided little additional capacity" and had not changed how catastrophe cover was negotiated.

    LessonMaking a contract easy to trade did not by itself bring new money into catastrophe cover.

    casact.org

    Credit

    Chicago Board of Trade

  2. 1994

    Risk sold to investors

    Hannover Re's KOVER deal of 1994 passed part of its catastrophe reinsurance risk to capital market investors. A 2008 history of Hannover Re's deals in The Geneva Papers calls it "the first-ever (re)insurance risk securitization", done when Hannover Re was owned by a German mutual group and short of capital. Hannover Re's K-Cession, which it traces back to KOVER, still backs its retrocession, the reinsurance a reinsurer buys for itself.

    link.springer.comartemis.bm

    Credit

    Hannover Re

  3. 2006

    Sidecars after Katrina

    After the 2005 hurricanes, reinsurers set up sidecars: separate vehicles funded by outside investors, who tie up their money for two or three years and share the premiums and losses of part of the reinsurer's business. Sidecars had drawn in over $7 billion of new capital since the 2005 storms, Insurance Journal reported in 2008. Bill Dubinsky of Willis Capital Markets & Advisory said in 2015 that once sidecars had shown after 2006 that they could fill the gap in capital after an event, the case for founding new reinsurers "has probably declined".

    insurancejournal.combusinessinsurance.com

    Credit

    the reinsurers that sponsored them, such as Hiscox with Panther Re

  4. 2008

    Collateral that failed

    Several cat bonds relied on Lehman Brothers as the counterparty to a total return swap, a contract meant to guarantee the return on the investors' collateral. After Lehman's bankruptcy in September 2008, A.M. Best downgraded three of them, citing doubt over "the market values of the securities in the collateral account". In May 2009 Ajax Re, sponsored by Aspen, could not repay its principal in full because of "a shortfall in the value of the collateral assets".

    LessonInvestors can lose money with no catastrophe at all if the collateral is not safe.

    insurancejournal.comartemis.bm

    Credit

    A.M. Best and Standard & Poor's, for the ratings

  5. 2017

    Paid on measured shaking

    A magnitude 8.1 earthquake off Chiapas, Mexico, on 7 September 2017 met the trigger of the World Bank's IBRD/FONDEN 2017 cat bond, which pays on measured earthquake data rather than on assessed damage. Mexico confirmed a $150 million payout once the calculation agent had checked the trigger, as Artemis reported on 11 October. Mexico had first bought a cat bond in 2006.

    artemis.bmpreventionweb.net

    Credit

    Government of Mexico; World Bank (IBRD)

  6. 2020

    A pandemic bond pays late

    The World Bank sold $320 million of pandemic bonds in 2017. They did not pay in the 2018 Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo, which killed almost 2,300 people but did not spread "far enough, fast enough" under the bond terms, Insurance Journal reported. For COVID-19 the calculation agent, AIR Worldwide, found the criteria met on 17 April 2020, and $195.84 million went to 64 countries, against $107.2 million of premiums paid by donors. The World Bank said it would not issue a second round.

    LessonA trigger written to settle without argument can be too slow or too narrow for the crisis it was bought for.

    worldbank.orginsurancejournal.com

    Credit

    World Bank; AIR Worldwide

  7. 2023

    Cyber risk in a bond

    In January 2023 Beazley, a specialist insurer, placed what it called the market's first cyber catastrophe bond: $45 million of notes, tradeable under the US Rule 144A, covering its cyber losses above $300 million from one event. Gallagher Securities structured the deal, and Fermat Capital Management was among the investors.

    beazley.comartemis.bm

    Credit

    Beazley; Gallagher Securities

Watch for

  1. Reinsurance on a ledger

    Schroders Capital and Hannover Re say they closed the first live collateralized reinsurance deal on a tokenized platform, where a smart contract between Hannover Re and a Schroders-owned reinsurance company handles work once done on paper. They say this speeds settlement and lets collateral earn money-market returns instead of sitting idle.

    Achieved whenan outside party, such as an auditor or regulator, reports measured settlement times or collateral returns for tokenized deals against conventional ones.

    insurancebusinessmag.comartemis.bm

    Claimed by

    Schroders Capital and Hannover Re, April 2026

Open

  1. 01

    A second opinion on a quake bond

    Recompute, with open tools, the expected loss of the World Bank's 2023 earthquake cat bond for Chile, and publish the method so that the modeling agent's figure has a public check.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A first call on quake bonds

    An open program that watches the US Geological Survey's earthquake feed and, within minutes of a large quake, posts whether it appears to meet the trigger of any outstanding parametric earthquake bond, and what share of principal is at stake. Each call is later scored against the official finding.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A second opinion on a quake bond

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Recompute, with open tools, the expected loss of the World Bank's 2023 earthquake cat bond for Chile, and publish the method so that the modeling agent's figure has a public check.

Why it is still open

The $350 million of bonds pay 30%, 70% or 100% of principal depending on a quake's depth, magnitude and location. Artemis reported a modeled expected loss of 1% and an attachment probability, the yearly chance of any payout, of 1.48%, and lists AIR Worldwide as the deal's modeling and calculation agent. No outside recalculation was found.

artemis.bmworldbank.org

Built with what exists

the OpenQuake engine; GEM's South America hazard model, free to download for non-commercial use under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 licence; the US Geological Survey's free earthquake catalog service; the bond's trigger terms; Python.

globalquakemodel.orgearthquake.usgs.gov

  1. First step

    Find the trigger zones and the depth and magnitude thresholds in the World Bank's public documents for the bond; if they are not published, ask World Bank Treasury for them.

  2. Done looks like

    Published code and inputs; a modeled expected loss and attachment probability, each with an uncertainty range, set beside the modeler's 1% and 1.48%; and a check that the code correctly pays or does not pay for every past Chilean quake that fell inside the trigger zones.

Open 02 · the brief

A first call on quake bonds

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open program that watches the US Geological Survey's earthquake feed and, within minutes of a large quake, posts whether it appears to meet the trigger of any outstanding parametric earthquake bond, and what share of principal is at stake. Each call is later scored against the official finding.

Why it is still open

Official findings take weeks. Mexico's 2017 payout was reported confirmed five weeks after the quake, and the World Bank says earthquake payments are available within about a month. Early calls are made by hand, by trade reporters such as Artemis. No public automatic tool was found.

artemis.bmpreventionweb.net

Built with what exists

the USGS earthquake web service; trigger terms from public bond documents; Python; a public web page or feed.

  1. First step

    Code the trigger of one bond whose terms are public and replay the 2017 Chiapas quake through it.

  2. Done looks like

    The program runs for six months and posts a timestamped call for every quake of magnitude 6.5 or more inside a covered zone; a published tally of its calls against official findings shows no wrong call on whether a bond pays.