BRENNEN

Industries / Mining and materials / Mining and quarrying / Rare earth processing

Mining and concentrating

Mining and concentrating is digging rare earth ore out of rock or washing it out of clay, then removing most of the waste so that a richer mix of rare earths, called a concentrate, can be sent on for separation.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1887 to 2025.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1887

    Sand mined for thorium

    In 1887 a few short tons of monazite, a heavy sand mineral that holds rare earths and thorium, were washed out of streams in the Piedmont of North and South Carolina, which made the region the world's first supplier of thorium, by the US Geological Survey's (USGS) account. Small sluice operations there produced 4,973 metric tons of monazite from 1887 to 1917. They stopped not because the ore ran out but because beach sands in India and Brazil produced thorium at lower cost.

    LessonA deposit can close with ore still in it when a cheaper one opens elsewhere.

    pubs.usgs.gov

    Credit

    sluice miners of the Carolina Piedmont, as recorded by the USGS (citing Olson and Overstreet, 1964)

  2. 1927

    Iron ore with rare earths

    In July 1927 Ding Daoheng, a geologist at Peking University, found the iron deposit at Bayan Obo in Inner Mongolia, and in 1935 He Zuolin of Academia Sinica published the first report of two rare earth minerals in its ore, according to a 2023 review in the journal China Geology. The deposit was worked as an iron mine for Baotou Steel; the mine's own annals start in 1957. The USGS counted about 55,000 of the world's 120,000 metric tons of rare earth production in 2010 as a by-product of the Bayan Obo iron mine.

    LessonThe USGS notes that by-product output follows demand for the main product, here iron, and not demand for the rare earths.

    journal.hep.com.cnpubs.usgs.gov

    Credit

    Ding Daoheng; He Zuolin; Baotou Steel

  3. 1949

    Found with a Geiger counter

    In April 1949 uranium prospectors noticed radioactivity at Mountain Pass in California's Mojave Desert. The US Bureau of Mines and the USGS found the rock rich in bastnäsite, a rare earth carbonate mineral, and Molybdenum Corporation of America bought the claims in 1950 and began mining in 1952. By about 1995 the mill took ore of about 7% rare earth oxide and floated it, using air bubbles and reagents that make the mineral cling to a froth, into a concentrate of about 60%. Peak output, around 1990, was 20,000 metric tons of rare earth oxide a year. Mining stopped in 2002, when the permit expired, by the USGS's account (see "Leaks stop a separation plant" under Radioactive waste for the owner's reasons); in 2025 the mine produced about 51,000 metric tons, by the USGS's estimate.

    LessonWith its one mine shut, the United States got all its rare earth raw materials from imports, mainly from China, the USGS wrote in 2010.

    pubs.usgs.govpubs.usgs.gov

    Credit

    the prospectors; US Bureau of Mines and USGS; Molybdenum Corporation of America (later Molycorp)

  4. 2010

    Washing rare earths from clay

    In southern China, rare earths held loosely on weathered clay over granite are washed out with salt solutions instead of being crushed out of hard rock. The USGS counted about 25,000 metric tons of 2010 production from these ion-adsorption clays, which were then known only in southern China; ore from Longnan in Jiangxi Province is rich in the heavy rare earths, the scarcer, heavier members of the group. The method moved from leaching dug clay in vats and pools to injecting ammonium sulfate solution into whole hillsides, called in-place leaching. A 2025 study of a Jiangxi mine says this spares the surface plants but lets solution leak through cracks, and that oversaturated ground risks landslides.

    LessonLeaching a hillside in place saves digging but makes the solution hard to control.

    pubs.usgs.govfrontiersin.org

    Credit

    mines of Jiangxi Province, including Longnan and Xunwu (USGS)

  5. 2022

    Leaching crosses into Myanmar

    Global Witness, a campaign group, commissioned satellite images from the company Planet in March 2022 and counted more than 2,700 collection pools at almost 300 sites in Myanmar's Kachin State, on the Chinese border, where a few years earlier there had been a handful of mines. It linked the growth to China closing many of its own heavy rare earth mines from 2016. In 2024 it reported that sites in Kachin Special Region 1 grew by more than 40% between 2021 and 2023, and the International Crisis Group, analyzing free Sentinel-2 satellite images, put the mined area there at 1,622 hectares in 2018 and 3,565 hectares in 2025. New mines have also opened in Shan State, upstream of Thailand, and in February 2026 Thailand's Pollution Control Department found arsenic above its 0.01 mg/L limit at four points on the Kok River and every point on the Sai.

    LessonClosing polluting mines in one country moved the same method, and its pollution, across a border.

    globalwitness.orgglobalwitness.orgcrisisgroup.orgaljazeera.comnationthailand.com

    Credit

    mine operators under local militias, by Global Witness's account; measured by Global Witness and the International Crisis Group

  6. 2025

    Clay ore mined in Brazil

    The USGS reported that in 2025 a mine in Brazil produced mixed concentrates from ionic clays with high terbium and dysprosium content, and that in November the US International Development Finance Corporation approved a $465 million loan to the company to raise its heavy rare earth output. Brazil's estimated mine output rose from 560 metric tons of rare earth oxide in 2024 to 2,000 in 2025, by the USGS's count. Fifteen years earlier the USGS had described these clays as known only in southern China.

    pubs.usgs.govpubs.usgs.gov

    Credit

    the USGS does not name the mine (see Checks)

Watch for

  1. Rare earths from coal

    Ramaco Resources says its Brook Mine near Sheridan, Wyoming, opened at a ribbon-cutting on 11 July 2025, is "perhaps" the largest "unconventional deposit of rare earth elements" in the United States, held in its coal and the clays mixed with it, and its chief executive said it may hold enough "to supply this country for well over the next 100 years". Wolfpack Research, a firm that bets on share prices falling, called the project a "hoax" in October 2025, and investors filed a class action in January 2026; Ramaco says it has "meritorious defenses to all claims". On its February 2026 earnings call Ramaco said it had set aside several hundred tons of enriched ore for further testing.

    Achieved whenthe mine reports regular output of rare earth concentrate and an outside party, such as a buyer or the USGS, confirms it.

    wyofile.comdeseret.com

    Claimed by

    Ramaco Resources, July 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Score mine start dates

    A public table of every rare earth mine project outside China that has announced a year for first production since 2010, with each promised year, the date the promise was made, and the year production began, if it has.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Flotation model for other ores

    Fit the open flotation model in PrOMMiS, a free process-modeling package from US national laboratories, to published flotation circuits for ores other than Mountain Pass, and publish how well it predicts concentrate grade and recovery. Flotation is the step that floats the rare earth mineral off on bubbles and leaves most rock behind.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Score mine start dates

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of every rare earth mine project outside China that has announced a year for first production since 2010, with each promised year, the date the promise was made, and the year production began, if it has.

Why it is still open

In 2010 the USGS wrote that outside China there had been almost no rare earth mine development for 50 years, so "we have no real REE exploration and development record to draw upon" for judging how fast new mines arrive. Holger Paulick and Erika Machacek analyzed the resources found in the boom that followed in a 2017 paper in Resources Policy (closed access; only its record was read). Gareth Hatch of Technology Metals Research began an index of advanced rare earth projects outside China in January 2011, when he tracked 275 projects in all and counted 17 as advanced, and in 2016 said TMR tracked almost 60 projects under development; the posts read describe projects' status and resources, not promised start dates. Searches for this brief found news lists of projects to watch, but no public table that sets promised start dates against actual ones.

pubs.usgs.govdoi.orgseekingalpha.comwap.asianmetal.com

Built with what exists

company announcements on stock exchange filing systems (ASX announcements, SEDAR+ in Canada, SEC EDGAR in the United States); USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries from 2011 on; a language model such as Claude to pull dated promises out of filings, with every figure checked against its page by a person.

  1. First step

    Take the deposits listed in tables 10 and 11 of the USGS's 2010 report and record which of them had produced any concentrate by 2026.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 40 projects, each promised year linked to the filing that made it, and a published share of projects that began production within two years of the first year they promised.

Open 02 · the brief

Flotation model for other ores

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Fit the open flotation model in PrOMMiS, a free process-modeling package from US national laboratories, to published flotation circuits for ores other than Mountain Pass, and publish how well it predicts concentrate grade and recovery. Flotation is the step that floats the rare earth mineral off on bubbles and leaves most rock behind.

Why it is still open

PrOMMiS added rare earth flotation models in July 2026, and every flotation flowsheet and parameter file in it is for the Mountain Pass ore. A search of the Crossref index of papers found laboratory flotation studies of bastnäsite and monazite but no open model tested across several ores.

github.com

Built with what exists

PrOMMiS (Python, built on the IDAES process-modeling platform); published mass balances, meaning the tonnage and assay of feed, concentrate and waste, from plant and pilot papers; a language model to pull tables out of papers, with each number checked by hand.

  1. First step

    Run PrOMMiS's Mountain Pass fixed-recovery flowsheet and check that it reproduces the USGS's flowsheet of about 1995, which takes 7% ore to a 60% concentrate.

  2. Done looks like

    Predicted against reported rare earth oxide grade and recovery for every stream of at least two published circuits other than Mountain Pass, with the errors posted and the parameter files offered to PrOMMiS as a contribution.