BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Pump and valve repair

Teardown and inspection

Teardown and inspection is the shop work of taking a pump or valve apart, cleaning it, measuring the wear on its parts and reading the damage, to decide what to repair and to find out why it failed.

4

Milestones achieved, from 1978 to 2024.

0

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1978

    A broken shaft is read

    S. Danyluk and G. M. Dragel of Argonne National Laboratory examined a water pump from the Synthane coal-gasification pilot plant whose 3.18 cm (1.25 in) steel shaft and the capscrew holding its impeller had both broken after 500 to 800 hours of running. From the broken surfaces and hardness tests they found that the capscrew, about twice as hard as specified because of faulty heat treatment, broke first and put a heavy twisting load on the shaft, and that a fatigue crack, one that grows a little with each turn of the load, then started at a keyway corner rounded to 0.021 cm where normal practice called for 0.067 cm.

    LessonThe part that failed first was a small bolt, and the shaft broke only because a sharp corner let that failure spread.

    osti.gov

    Credit

    S. Danyluk and G. M. Dragel, Argonne National Laboratory

  2. 1989

    Check valves opened by sample

    A check valve lets liquid flow one way and closes when it reverses. On 21 November 1985 five feedwater check valves at the San Onofre Unit 1 nuclear plant in California failed at once, and the water hammer that followed, a pressure surge in the pipe, caused a leak and damaged equipment; an NRC investigation team found the valves had failed in less than a year without anyone noticing, and Southern California Edison traced the cause to flow-induced vibration that kept knocking each valve's disc against its stop. In April 1989 the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission's Generic Letter 89-04 accepted taking check valves apart and inspecting their insides, for worn or corroded parts, where a full-flow test was not practical: valves of the same maker, size, materials and service could be grouped, one valve per group opened at each refueling outage, and the whole group opened if that valve was found failing.

    LessonA check valve can pass its routine test while its insides wear out, so some valves have to be opened to be known.

    osti.govosti.govnrc.gov

    Credit

    US Nuclear Regulatory Commission; Southern California Edison

  3. 1992

    Coolant pump shafts compared

    For the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), Structural Integrity Associates reviewed cracked and broken shafts in the main coolant pumps of nuclear reactors made to four designs: Westinghouse, Byron Jackson, KSB and Sulzer-Bingham. Every design had at least one shaft-cracking event, and nearly all the failures shared heat effects from seal cooling and purge flow together with uneven sideways thrust from the impeller, made worse in some cases by long running away from the design point, by holes and keyways, and by chrome plating and poorly machined surfaces.

    LessonSome of the causes lay in how the shafts were finished, such as chrome plating, and not only in how the pumps were run.

    osti.gov

    Credit

    W. R. Brose, K. L. Chen, A. Y. Kuo and P. C. Riccardella of Structural Integrity Associates, for EPRI

  4. 2024

    Faces flat until installed

    Seal shops measure the flatness of a relapped seal face with an optical flat, a polished glass plate laid on the face under one-color light, and count the dark bands that appear; one helium light band is 0.29 µm (11.6 millionths of an inch). EPRI, the US power industry's research institute, reported that a 2023 root-cause investigation at a nuclear power station found 20-year-old seal face holders for main reactor pump seals out of tolerance. In 2024 laboratory tests, a face that measured 2.77 light bands (0.82 µm) out of flat on its fixture measured 17.25 bands (5.1 µm) once fitted in its holder, and up to 21 bands depending on how carefully the O-ring was placed, against about 10 bands that seal experts accept in the holder. EPRI noted that readings are normally taken only on the loose face and recommended checking flatness before and after the face goes into its holder.

    LessonA part that passes inspection on its own can fail once assembled, so check it in the state in which it will run.

    restservice.epri.com

    Credit

    EPRI (Electric Power Research Institute)

Open

  1. 01

    Name the damage on parts

    A public, labeled photo set of worn pump and valve parts taken on the teardown bench, such as impellers, wear rings, shaft sleeves, valve discs and seats, each labeled by experienced repairers with the damage it shows: cavitation (pitting from vapor bubbles that collapse against the metal), erosion by solids, corrosion, rubbing or fatigue cracks. Add a baseline image model scored on parts it has not seen.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    How fast clearances open

    A public table of wear ring clearances measured at teardown, the gap between the spinning impeller and the stationary ring that limits leakage back to the pump's inlet, set against each pump's running hours, liquid, speed and ring materials, with fitted wear rates that tell a planner how long a given pump can run before its clearance doubles.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Name the damage on parts

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, labeled photo set of worn pump and valve parts taken on the teardown bench, such as impellers, wear rings, shaft sleeves, valve discs and seats, each labeled by experienced repairers with the damage it shows: cavitation (pitting from vapor bubbles that collapse against the metal), erosion by solids, corrosion, rubbing or fatigue cracks. Add a baseline image model scored on parts it has not seen.

Why it is still open

The public pump images that exist are of new castings, not worn parts: a set of submersible pump impeller castings labeled defective or not has been used to train defect detectors (Hami and co-authors, 2024). Roboflow sells valve-inspection models that find seat and stem wear, scoring and pitting, but says they are trained on each customer's own images and gives no public data or accuracy. Siemens Energy says its shops measure compressor impellers from 3D scans against tolerances and draft repair recommendations with generative AI, with no accuracy figures (February 2025). Searches of Hugging Face and Zenodo for impeller, valve seat, cavitation and pump damage images found no labeled set of worn parts.

arxiv.orgroboflow.comturbomachinerymag.com

Built with what exists

A phone or mirrorless camera with a light box and turntable; CVAT, an open labeling tool; Meta's Segment Anything Model 2 to speed outlining; an Ultralytics YOLO11 classification or segmentation model as the baseline.

  1. First step

    Ask one repair shop, with its customers' permission, to photograph every impeller and wear ring on its teardown bench for a month in a light box, and label the first 50 with two of its repairers.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 1,000 parts from at least three repair shops, each labeled by two experienced repairers with their rate of agreement reported; the baseline model's accuracy for each damage type, tested on parts from a shop it was not trained on, published beside the repairers' agreement; photos, labels and code released.

Open 02 · the brief

How fast clearances open

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of wear ring clearances measured at teardown, the gap between the spinning impeller and the stationary ring that limits leakage back to the pump's inlet, set against each pump's running hours, liquid, speed and ring materials, with fitted wear rates that tell a planner how long a given pump can run before its clearance doubles.

Why it is still open

Studies of wear ring clearance set the gap by hand on one pump in a lab or in a computer model. Wu and co-authors (2021), for example, found that worn rings cut a marine pump's head by 3.56% and its efficiency by 9.62% at its design flow, and a search of the Directory of Open Access Journals for wear ring clearance studies returned ten papers, all lab tests or simulations. No public data was found on how fast clearances grow in service, measured on pumps when they were taken apart.

doaj.org

Built with what exists

Anonymized teardown sheets from repair shops or plants; a model that answers the same fixed questions about each sheet, such as Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); DuckDB or a spreadsheet; a survival analysis in Python with the lifelines library.

  1. First step

    Ask one repair shop for 30 anonymized teardown sheets that record wear ring clearances and the pump's hours, and code them by hand to settle the fields.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 500 pump teardowns from at least three shops or plants coded, with a second person checking 50; published medians and ranges of clearance growth in millimeters per 10,000 running hours for each liquid and ring material pair, compared with each pump's starting clearance.