BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Pump and valve repair

Seals and bearings

Seals and bearings work is replacing and rebuilding the parts that stop a pump or valve leaking where a turning shaft or a moving stem passes out through its casing, and the bearings that carry the shaft.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1925 to 2007.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1925

    A spring-loaded seal ring

    George J. Cooke of Chicago applied in February 1923 for a patent on a seal for rotating shafts, granted as US 1,545,080 on 7 July 1925. Instead of soft packing squeezed around the shaft, a spring pressed a metal ring with a flat face against a fixed surface, so that only one pair of flat faces rubbed, to stop gas such as the ammonia in ice machines escaping along the crankshaft. Two flat faces held together by a spring, one turning and one fixed, is the layout of the end-face mechanical seal, and Wikipedia's history of that seal says it "appears to have been invented" by Cooke.

    patentimages.storage.googleapis.comen.wikipedia.org

    Credit

    George J. Cooke

  2. 1947

    Bearing life by formula

    Gustaf Lundberg and Arvid Palmgren of SKF, the Swedish bearing maker, published "Dynamic Capacity of Rolling Bearings" in 1947, based on thousands of SKF tests. Before it, each maker calculated bearing life in its own way. Their method gives L10, the life by which 10% of a group of identical bearings under the same load will have failed from fatigue, from the bearing's rated capacity and the load on it, and ISO adopted it in Recommendation R281 in 1962. In 2010 Myron McKenzie, chief engineer of the American Roller Bearing Co., called the 1947 report "still the basis for all the bearing life calculations that are done today."

    stle.org

    Credit

    Gustaf Lundberg and Arvid Palmgren, SKF

  3. 1947

    Pumps with no shaft seal

    In a magnetic drive pump the motor turns the impeller through a magnetic field acting across a closed metal shell, so no shaft passes out of the casing and there is no shaft seal to leak or to rebuild. Hydraulic & Mechanical Developments (HMD), founded by Geoffrey and Charles Howard in Eastbourne, England, says it built the first sealless magnetic drive pump in 1947, for ICI, to handle the heat-transfer fluid Dowtherm at 300°C, and began making permanent-magnet drive pumps of up to 20 hp in 1951. EPA's 2007 guide to leak detection names canned motor and magnetic drive pumps among the common sealless pumps that minimize or eliminate leaks, though materials and operating conditions limit where they can be used.

    sundyne.comepa.gov

    Credit

    Geoffrey and Charles Howard, HMD, now part of Sundyne

  4. 1994

    A standard for pump seals

    In the late 1980s refinery engineers led by V. R. Dodd of Chevron began comparing how their pump seals performed, and the American Petroleum Institute formed a task force in 1990 that published API 682 in October 1994. Its stated aim was seals with a high probability of at least three years of uninterrupted service while meeting emissions rules. Makers had to prove each seal design in qualification tests on five fluids (water, propane, 20% caustic soda, cold oil and hot oil), ending with a simulated upset that included loss of the flush, the liquid piped in to cool and clean the seal faces, and every assembled seal had to pass an air test before shipping. Authors from Flowserve, John Crane and the Fluid Sealing Association wrote in 2015 that seal makers had spent an estimated $5 million to $10 million on test equipment, and that the second edition (2002, also issued as ISO 21049) set a test leakage limit of 1,000 ppm of vapor by volume, measured by EPA Method 21.

    turbolab.tamu.edu

    Credit

    V. R. Dodd of Chevron and the API 682 task force

  5. 2007

    Bearing life counts dirt

    Bearings had come to outlast the 1947 formula: Myron McKenzie reported that Fafnir/Torrington test bearings lived four times the ISO prediction by 1984 and nearly 14 times by 1994. A 2000 amendment to ISO 281 let each maker supply its own correction factor, and Martin Correns of Schaeffler, who led the German working group, said three makers calculating the same bearing got lives from 6,500 to 34,000 hours. ISO 281:2007 replaced this with one factor, aISO, that combines lubrication, contamination, load and a fatigue stress limit for the steel, based on a 1985 model by Stathis Ioannides and Ted Harris and a German DIN standard of 2003. Erv Zaretsky, an engineering consultant who had worked at NASA's Glenn Research Center, argued in the next issue of the same magazine that a fatigue limit for bearing steel is unproven and should not have been included.

    LessonWhen each maker filled in the formula its own way, the same bearing was given lives five times apart.

    stle.orgstle.org

    Credit

    ISO; Martin Correns's DIN working group; Stathis Ioannides and Ted Harris

Watch for

  1. Seals for ethane pipelines

    John Crane says multiphase lubrication of the faces of its Type 8628VL, a fully non-contacting mechanical seal for ethane and ethylene pipeline operators, "helps extend mean time between repairs to up to 48 months and even longer." The only field result reported is from an unnamed ethane transmission company on the US Gulf Coast: zero failures and "very low leakage" over three months.

    Achieved whenan operator or another outside party publishes run hours, repairs and measured leakage for installed seals over at least 48 months.

    johncrane.comturbomachinerymag.com

    Claimed by

    John Crane, September and November 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Read flatness from a photo

    A phone app that photographs a relapped seal face under an optical flat (a polished glass plate that shows dark bands where the face is not flat; see Teardown and inspection) and one-color light, traces the bands across the ring, and reports the face's flatness in helium light bands with the image saved, so that a seal shop has a number and a record for every face it relaps, before and after the face goes into its holder.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Repack a valve by robot

    A robot arm that, on a bench and with the valve out of service and unpressurized, pulls the old packing rings from the stuffing box (the recess where the stem passes out of the valve), fits new rings one at a time with their joints staggered, tamps each ring down and tightens the gland nuts evenly to a set torque.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Read flatness from a photo

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A phone app that photographs a relapped seal face under an optical flat (a polished glass plate that shows dark bands where the face is not flat; see Teardown and inspection) and one-color light, traces the bands across the ring, and reports the face's flatness in helium light bands with the image saved, so that a seal shop has a number and a record for every face it relaps, before and after the face goes into its holder.

Why it is still open

Flatness is still mostly read by eye. EPRI wrote in September 2024 that for many years the optical flat was the only way to measure seal face flatness, that readings are likely to differ between users, and that digital instruments such as the Mahr MarForm MMQ 400 and the Talyrond 585 give repeatable readings but are not a standard tool at most utility seal rebuild stations. Machines have read such bands for other lapped parts since the 1980s: Toshiaki Wada of Sumitomo Special Metals patented an apparatus in 1986 that reads the bands with an image sensor to measure the flatness of magnetic tape head sliders. Open software that turns photographs of interference bands into a surface map exists for telescope mirrors (DFTFringe, GPL-3.0, on GitHub since 2016), and Ahmad Shakleya's 2024 bachelor's thesis at the University of Antwerp simulated optical-flat bands and rebuilt surfaces from them in Python, tested on simulated images. A 1980 patent by Calvin Hartman of Texas describes a way to view the bands under a seal face, but a search of Crossref, GitHub and the web found no tool for seal faces with a published accuracy.

restservice.epri.compatentimages.storage.googleapis.comgithub.comgithub.compatentimages.storage.googleapis.com

Built with what exists

A phone camera on a fixed stand; the helium or sodium lamp and optical flat that seal shops already own; OpenCV to find the ring and trace the bands; DFTFringe's open code as a starting point for fitting a surface to the bands; Meta's Segment Anything model to mask the face from the background.

  1. First step

    Ask a seal repair shop to let you photograph 20 faces on its optical flat next to the technician's written readings.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 100 relapped faces of carbon and silicon carbide, each read by the app, by two technicians and by a lab instrument such as an optical profiler; the app within 0.5 light band (0.15 µm) of the instrument on at least 90% of faces, and repeat photos of the same face within 0.25 band of each other; images, readings and code published.

Open 02 · the brief

Repack a valve by robot

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A robot arm that, on a bench and with the valve out of service and unpressurized, pulls the old packing rings from the stuffing box (the recess where the stem passes out of the valve), fits new rings one at a time with their joints staggered, tamps each ring down and tightens the gland nuts evenly to a set torque.

Why it is still open

A trade guide calls repacking "the most common valve maintenance task", and it is done by hand: old rings are pulled with a hook tool, new rings are cut on a mandrel, joints are staggered by 90 degrees and each ring is seated with a tamping tool. EPA's leak guide lists tightening packing gland nuts and injecting packing as first attempts at repairing a leaking valve. A web search and Crossref and arXiv queries found patents for packing removal tools and for valves that can be repacked under pressure, but no robot that repacks valves.

blog.projectmaterials.comepa.gov

Built with what exists

A low-cost arm such as the SO-101 with Hugging Face's LeRobot software (see the Note "No download"); a policy trained from a few demonstrations with NVIDIA's GR00T 2 (see the Note "Five demonstrations per task") or Runway's open Praxis-1 weights (see the Note "Open robot model weights"); a hook extractor and tamping tool adapted to the gripper; a torque-sensing driver; scrap 2-inch gate valves and die-formed graphite rings.

  1. First step

    Buy two scrap gate valves and film an experienced technician repacking each five times from two angles, to use as demonstrations.

  2. Done looks like

    20 filmed attempts on two valve sizes, with a published tally of rings fitted in the right number and order, joints at least 90 degrees apart as checked by a technician, gland nut torque within 10% of target and the stem still free to move; each finished valve then passes a bench air test of its body at no more than 1.7 bar (25 psi), with soap solution showing no bubbles at the stem for five minutes.