BRENNEN

Industries / Finance and business services / Advertising and marketing / Public relations

Crisis response

Crisis response is what an organization says and does in public when something goes wrong, from an accident to a hoax issued in its name.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1906 to 2023.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1906

    A statement after a wreck

    On 28 October 1906 a train of the West Jersey and Seashore Railroad, a Pennsylvania Railroad subsidiary, crashed at a drawbridge on the New Jersey shore, and 53 of its 87 passengers died. The railroad's new adviser, Ivy Lee, took reporters to the site and issued a statement that The New York Times printed two days later. Billy Penn calls it "what is widely considered to be the first press release." The statement doubted any "defect in either the drawbridge or its mechanism," but an inquest found the bridge had not returned to its proper height.

    LessonA fast, open statement can still be wrong on the facts.

    billypenn.com

    Credit

    Ivy Lee; Pennsylvania Railroad

  2. 1982

    A nationwide recall

    After seven people in the Chicago area died on 29 and 30 September 1982 from Tylenol capsules laced with cyanide, Johnson & Johnson's McNeil unit began what History.com calls "the largest consumer product recall in American history," about 31 million bottles. By 5 October the company had recalled all Tylenol nationwide, worth $100 million, and set up a hotline and a $100,000 reward. The next month the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) required over-the-counter drugs to be packaged so tampering would show, and in 1983 Congress passed the Federal Anti-Tampering Act.

    LessonThe company's response went far beyond the area where the deaths happened, and the rules that followed changed how over-the-counter drugs are packaged.

    history.comheinonline.com

    Credit

    Johnson & Johnson, McNeil Consumer Products; FDA; US Congress

  3. 2010

    A chief executive's remark

    During the Deepwater Horizon oil spill, BP's chief executive, Tony Hayward, apologized to the families of the 11 men who died on the rig "for having said, 'You know, I'd like my life back.'" He had earlier said the Gulf of Mexico "is a very big ocean" and that the spill's environmental impact was "likely to have been very, very modest."

    LessonWhat a leader says off script during a disaster becomes part of the record.

    nbcnews.com

    Credit

    Tony Hayward, BP

  4. 2016

    A fake release sinks shares

    On 22 November 2016 two Bloomberg journalists published, within about a minute, news taken from a forged Vinci press release received at 16:05, and Vinci's share price fell 18.28%. France's market regulator, the AMF, fined Bloomberg €5 million in December 2019 because no "verification" was done before publication. The Paris Court of Appeal cut the fine to €3 million in 2021.

    LessonA regulator held a news agency responsible for checking a release before repeating it.

    amf-france.org

    Credit

    Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF)

  5. 2019

    Releases certified on a blockchain

    Wiztrust launched Wiztrust Protect, which "anchors corporate contents inside blockchain (a press release for example)" and issues a registration certificate on Ethereum, a public shared ledger, so that investors, analysts and reporters can check who issued a document. Wiztrust called it "the first platform that certifies and verifies corporate information." In 2022 the credit insurer Coface said it uses Wiztrust and that a recipient can check Coface is the true issuer by uploading the PDF to wiztrust.com.

    newsroom.wiztrust.comcoface.com

    Credit

    Wiztopic; Coface

  6. 2021

    Fake release on a wire

    A release on the GlobeNewswire service announced that Walmart would accept the cryptocurrency Litecoin. It gave "walmart-corp.com" as the email for Walmart's chief marketing officer and was Walmart's first and only GlobeNewswire release. Several major news organizations picked it up, Litecoin rose about 25% and then fell back to $178, and Walmart said the release was fake. GlobeNewswire removed it minutes after CNN contacted the service.

    LessonA release on a known wire service is not proof that the named company sent it.

    wral.com

    Credit

    GlobeNewswire; Walmart; CNN

  7. 2023

    A fake image dips stocks

    An image of an explosion near the Pentagon, which SiliconANGLE describes as AI-generated, spread from an account called Bloomberg Feed, not affiliated with Bloomberg, and through RT and ZeroHedge. The Arlington County fire department posted that there was "no explosion or incident taking place at or near the Pentagon reservation," and a brief dip in US stocks reversed.

    LessonThe fastest correction came from the local authority with first-hand knowledge.

    siliconangle.com

    Credit

    Arlington County Fire Department, for the denial

Watch for

  1. EU labels for AI fakes

    The European Commission published a voluntary Code of Practice under the AI Act's transparency rules. It asks AI providers to mark generated images, audio, video and text in a machine-readable way, using "at least two layers" such as metadata and watermarks where necessary, and to offer tools that detect the marks. Organizations that publish AI output must label deepfakes, and AI-written text meant to inform the public on matters of public interest unless a person has reviewed it.

    Achieved whenthe major AI providers sign the Code and an outside test shows the marks can still be detected after typical editing and reposting.

    jonesday.com

    Claimed by

    European Commission, June 2026, as summarized by the law firm Jones Day

Open

  1. 01

    A casebook of fake releases

    A public dataset of known forged press releases, recording how each was distributed, how long it stood, who repeated it and what the share price did, together with a checker that tests a new release against public signals: when its web domain was registered, whether it also appears on the company's own site, whether its contacts match the company's, and the issuer's history on that wire.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Clock the first statement

    A public dataset linking each SEC Form 8-K filing about a cybersecurity incident to the company's first public statement about it (a press release, a website notice or a social post) and to the first news report, with the gaps measured in hours.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A casebook of fake releases

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public dataset of known forged press releases, recording how each was distributed, how long it stood, who repeated it and what the share price did, together with a checker that tests a new release against public signals: when its web domain was registered, whether it also appears on the company's own site, whether its contacts match the company's, and the issuer's history on that wire.

Why it is still open

The Vinci and Walmart fakes were repeated by major newsrooms before anyone checked the source. Certification such as Wiztrust works only for releases its clients choose to certify. Searches found reporting on single cases but no public dataset of fake releases and no tested detector.

amf-france.orgwral.com

Built with what exists

public domain-registration lookups (WHOIS and RDAP); companies' investor-relations pages; SEC EDGAR and other regulators' filing databases; wire archives; the Wayback Machine; a large language model to compare text and contact details.

  1. First step

    Search regulators' enforcement records, starting with the AMF and the SEC, and write up the first ten cases with their sources.

  2. Done looks like

    A casebook of at least 30 documented fakes from at least five countries, each with sources, and a checker that flags at least 25 of them while wrongly flagging fewer than 20 of 2,000 genuine releases, all published.

Open 02 · the brief

Clock the first statement

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public dataset linking each SEC Form 8-K filing about a cybersecurity incident to the company's first public statement about it (a press release, a website notice or a social post) and to the first news report, with the gaps measured in hours.

Why it is still open

The SEC's rule requiring companies to report material cybersecurity incidents on Form 8-K took effect in December 2023. Law-firm reviews such as Debevoise & Plimpton's count the filings and the shift of non-material incidents to a different section of the form, Item 8.01, but they do not measure when companies first spoke in public. Searches found no study of that gap.

debevoise.com

Built with what exists

EDGAR full-text search for filings under Items 1.05 and 8.01; company newsrooms and the Wayback Machine for dated statements; news archives such as GDELT; a low-cost extraction model such as Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat") to pull dates and details.

  1. First step

    List the 2024 cyber-incident 8-Ks and find the first public statement for 20 of them.

  2. Done looks like

    Every cyber-incident 8-K from December 2023 to the present, each with the time of the company's first public statement and of the first news report, with a second person checking 10% and medians published by year.