BRENNEN

Industries / Construction and property / Real estate / PropTech

Smart buildings

Software and connected devices that run occupied buildings: controls, sensors, meters, door entry and the data they produce.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2013 to 2024.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2013

    Breach through a contractor's login

    In November and December 2013 attackers took data on about 40 million payment cards, and personal details of up to 70 million customers, from Target, a US retailer. A US Senate committee staff report traced the way in to stolen network credentials of Fazio Mechanical Services, a refrigeration and HVAC (heating, ventilation and air conditioning) contractor that had remote access to Target's network for billing, contract submission and project management, and found that this outer part of the network was likely not fully walled off from the rest (see Payments processing for how the card data was taken).

    Lessona contractor who services a building's equipment needs access that leads nowhere else on the owner's network.

    commerce.senate.gov

    Credit

    majority staff of the US Senate Commerce Committee, report of 26 March 2014, drawing on reporting by Brian Krebs

  2. 2016

    Attack leaves flats without heat

    In Lappeenranta, Finland, a distributed denial-of-service (DDoS) attack, a flood of junk traffic, cut the internet links of the building management systems in two apartment buildings run by Valtia. The controllers rebooted again and again, and residents went without central heating and hot water until the systems were reconnected from behind a firewall. Helsingin Sanomat, a Finnish newspaper, linked the attack to the Mirai botnet, which took over devices that still had default passwords.

    Lessonheating that depends on an internet link needs a firewall and a safe way to keep running when the link fails.

    theregister.com

    Credit

    Valtia, the operator; reported by Helsingin Sanomat and The Register

  3. 2016

    Open labels for building data

    Building control systems name their sensor and setpoint points in each installer's own shorthand, so analytics software has to be set up by hand for every building. In November 2016 a group of university and IBM researchers presented Brick, an open schema that labels each point and records how equipment connects. They tested it on 17,700 points in six buildings, at UC San Diego, UC Berkeley, Carnegie Mellon, the University of Virginia, the University of Southern Denmark and an IBM site in Ireland, and it covered 96% to 99% of the points in each. Project Haystack, a trade group formed in 2014 by six firms including Siemens and SkyFoundry, keeps a second open tagging scheme. Brick is now kept by a non-profit consortium whose members include Johnson Controls, Schneider Electric and Siemens.

    brickschema.orgproject-haystack.org

    Credit

    Bharathan Balaji, Arka Bhattacharya, Gabe Fierro and colleagues; Project Haystack

  4. 2016

    Thermostats rated on real homes

    From 23 December 2016 the US Environmental Protection Agency's ENERGY STAR label for connected thermostats has required makers to prove savings from their customers' homes, not from a lab. A maker runs at least 12 months of run-time data from installed thermostats through EPA's software, and the lower 95% confidence limit of the weighted national average must show heating run time cut by at least 8% and cooling by at least 10%. Makers resubmit the results every six months.

    energystar.gov

    Credit

    US EPA, ENERGY STAR

  5. 2020

    Analytics savings measured

    Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL) ran the US Department of Energy's Smart Energy Analytics Campaign, which helped 104 organizations with 6,500 buildings and more than half a billion square feet of floor space use building analytics software. Its October 2020 report found median energy savings of 3% from energy information systems, which display meter data, and 9% from fault detection and diagnostics software, which flags equipment that is broken or running wrongly, with a simple payback of two years.

    eta-publications.lbl.gov

    Credit

    Hannah Kramer, Claire Curtin, Guanjing Lin, Eliot Crowe and Jessica Granderson, LBNL

  6. 2021

    Rules for apartment entry data

    New York City's Tenant Data Privacy Act, Local Law 63 of 2021, passed by the City Council on 29 April 2021, covers apartment buildings whose doors open with fobs, cards, phones or biometrics. It limits the data owners and vendors may collect, bans selling it, requires entry data to be destroyed within 90 days unless it is anonymized, and lets tenants sue. Owners of existing buildings had until 1 January 2023 to comply. The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) called New York one of the only places with a law written for smart lock data, and described a 2019 case in which tenants won a settlement requiring their landlord to offer physical keys.

    intro.nyceff.org

    Credit

    New York City Council; the bill's first-named sponsor was Council Member Levine

  7. 2024

    Default passwords banned

    From 29 April 2024 UK law has required makers of consumer products that connect to the internet, such as smart doorbells, to give each device a unique password or let the user set one, to publish how to report security flaws, and to state how long security updates will last. The government said the rules aim to stop attacks like Mirai in 2016, which took over 300,000 smart products by its count, and called the UK the first country with such a law.

    gov.uk

    Credit

    UK Department for Science, Innovation and Technology, under Part 1 of the Product Security and Telecommunications Infrastructure Act

Watch for

  1. A standard model of buildings

    ASHRAE's proposed Standard 223P is a machine-readable model of a building's equipment, sensors and controls, meant to let software find a building's systems and configure itself. NIST says it "will be published in FY26"; on a page updated on 2 November 2026 it said comments from the first public review had been addressed and a committee vote on a second review was pending. The US Department of Energy funded national laboratories to build tools that create and check 223P models.

    Achieved whenASHRAE publishes 223 as an approved standard and an outside party shows analytics software setting itself up from a 223 model of a building it had not seen before.

    nist.govenergy.gov

    Claimed by

    NIST and the US Department of Energy, November 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Score smart-entry privacy terms

    A public table that scores the privacy policies and terms of the keyless entry systems sold to apartment buildings (phone apps, fobs, video intercoms) against the rules in New York City's Local Law 63 of 2021: which data they collect, whether entry logs are deleted within 90 days, whether data is sold or shared, and whether a tenant can still use a physical key. Two people score each policy separately. An AI model can pull out the relevant clauses first, but people make each call.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Support dates for building devices

    A public register of the smart locks, video intercoms, door readers and thermostats sold to landlords and building managers, giving for each the end date of security updates that the maker states, where it states it, and the date checked. Report the share with no stated date and, for the rest, how many years of updates remain.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Score smart-entry privacy terms

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table that scores the privacy policies and terms of the keyless entry systems sold to apartment buildings (phone apps, fobs, video intercoms) against the rules in New York City's Local Law 63 of 2021: which data they collect, whether entry logs are deleted within 90 days, whether data is sold or shared, and whether a tenant can still use a physical key. Two people score each policy separately. An AI model can pull out the relevant clauses first, but people make each call.

Why it is still open

EFF wrote in April 2023 that New York is one of the only places with a smart lock data law and reported that one vendor, Latch, changed its policy after a tenant lawsuit. A search found press coverage of single vendors from 2019, but no audit across vendors.

eff.org

Built with what exists

Vendors' public privacy policies and terms, saved as dated PDFs; the text of Local Law 63 from the City Clerk's copy; a spreadsheet; an AI model such as Claude or GPT for clause extraction, checked by hand.

  1. First step

    List the keyless entry systems advertised to New York apartment buildings, save each one's current privacy policy, and turn sections 26-3002 to 26-3005 of the law into a checklist.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 15 vendors scored on at least 6 rules each, every score linked to the dated policy it came from, and the agreement rate between the two scorers published.

Open 02 · the brief

Support dates for building devices

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public register of the smart locks, video intercoms, door readers and thermostats sold to landlords and building managers, giving for each the end date of security updates that the maker states, where it states it, and the date checked. Report the share with no stated date and, for the rest, how many years of updates remain.

Why it is still open

In November 2024 US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) staff checked 184 consumer smart products, including door locks and thermostats, and found that only 21 (11.4%) stated a software support period on the product page. The FTC drew its sample from consumer product lists, not from systems sold to landlords. UK law has required makers to state a minimum support period since 29 April 2024.

ftc.gov

Built with what exists

Makers' product pages and UK statements of compliance, the FTC staff method (product page first, then one web search), a spreadsheet, and optionally a web agent such as Browser Use to collect pages, with people checking each entry.

  1. First step

    Build the product list from the access-control and smart-home vendors that advertise to US and UK apartment owners, and record for each whether its product page states a support period.

  2. Done looks like

    50 products from at least 15 makers, each with a source link and check date and either a stated end date or "none found", plus a recheck six months later showing what changed.