BRENNEN

Industries / Energy, water and waste / Propane distribution

Safety and leak checks

This is the work of keeping propane from leaking unnoticed at the customer's site: adding the smell that warns people, checking systems for leaks, fitting detectors, writing the rules installers follow, and learning from accidents.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1932 to 2023.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1932

    A national rule book

    The first draft of Pamphlet 58, the NFPA standard for the containers and equipment used to store and handle liquefied petroleum gas, was published in 1932, jointly with the National Board of Fire Underwriters, an insurers' body. A complete revision in 1947, by a 1951 planning report, became the basis of practically all US state and city rules for the gas, and practically every state law accepted the pamphlet whole or with small changes. The standard continues as NFPA 58, the Liquefied Petroleum Gas Code.

    planning.org

    Credit

    National Fire Protection Association and National Board of Fire Underwriters

  2. 1987

    Older noses miss the odorant

    Propane has no smell of its own, so a strong-smelling sulfur compound, usually ethyl mercaptan, is added to warn of leaks. In two studies published in Fire Technology in 1987, 50 of 110 people over 60 failed to detect commercial odorized propane reliably when it was diluted to the US Department of Transportation's standard of one fifth of the lower explosive limit (the leanest mix of gas in air that can burn), and 6 of 52 people under 40 also failed. In the first study the threshold at which people noticed ethyl mercaptan was on average ten times higher for 21 people aged 70 to 85 than for 21 aged 18 to 25.

    Lessona smell warning fails many older people, so smell cannot be the only safeguard.

    link.springer.com

    Credit

    J. C. Stevens, W. Cain and D. E. Weinstein

  3. 1997

    Japan's accident count falls

    Japan's LP-gas accidents at homes and other customers peaked in 1979 at 793, with 63 deaths and 825 people injured, and fell to 68 accidents and 6 deaths in 1997. The national figures, compiled by the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI) and summarized by the Tokyo Metropolitan Government, credit the fall to the spread of microcomputer meters that shut the gas off on abnormal flow, fuse gas cocks that close when a hose comes off, and gas leak alarms. Counts rose again from 2006, to 139 to 260 a year, after stricter reporting of accidents was enforced; in 2019 there were 198 accidents, no deaths and 31 people injured, the fewest injured since Japan's LP-gas law was passed in 1967.

    Lessonsafety devices fitted at every customer, combined with full accident reporting, can bring accidents down across a whole country.

    kankyo1.metro.tokyo.lg.jp

    Credit

    Japan's LP-gas retailers and METI

  4. 2013

    Odorant that fades

    On 30 July 2010 an explosion at a condominium complex under construction in Norfolk, Massachusetts, killed one person and injured seven; the investigation questioned whether the propane in the site's storage tanks held enough odorant, and no smell had warned of the leak. In 2013 the US Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) issued a safety alert on "odor fade": new or freshly cleaned steel tanks can absorb odorant into their shells, leaving the gas too weak to smell. It asked that people receiving new tanks be told, that fillers check for it, that manual odorant injection be checked and automatic injectors calibrated, and that propane carried in rail tank cars and cylinders be odorized as tank trucks already must be (1.0 pound of ethyl mercaptan per 10,000 gallons).

    Lessonodorant measured at filling may not still be there when a new tank leaks.

    govinfo.gov

    Credit

    Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration

  5. 2019

    Soil strips the smell

    On 16 September 2019 a building of LEAP Inc., a nonprofit in Farmington, Maine, exploded after about 400 gallons of propane leaked from its outdoor tank, killing fire captain Michael Bell and injuring seven others. The State Fire Marshal's Office found that an auger drilling posts into the parking lot six days earlier had pierced the buried line from the tank to the building, and the state utilities commission's staff found the contractor had possibly broken Maine's "Dig Safe" law by not notifying it before digging. A 2022 report by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health listed improper gas sampling and detection among the causes, noted that investigators found a high concentration of ethyl mercaptan in the soil around the line, and recommended training firefighters on how soil scrubs odorant from propane and on using gas meters.

    Lessonsoil can strip the odorant from leaking propane, so responders need gas meters to judge the danger.

    bangordailynews.combangordailynews.com

    Credit

    Maine State Fire Marshal's Office and NIOSH, as reported by the Bangor Daily News

  6. 2021

    Maine requires gas detectors

    A Maine law of 2021 (Public Law 2021, chapter 194) requires building owners to install at least one fuel gas detector, listed by an independent testing laboratory, in every room with an appliance that burns propane, natural gas or other LP gas, in apartments, dormitories, children's homes, hotels and buildings that mix homes with other uses. From 1 January 2026 the duty extended to business, shop and assembly buildings.

    legislature.maine.gov

    Credit

    Maine Legislature

  7. 2023

    A standard for gas alarms

    NFPA 715, a standard for choosing, placing, installing, testing and maintaining fuel gas detectors and alarms in buildings, had its first edition in 2023, by NFPA's account; the current edition is from 2026. NFPA says its requirements rest largely on research by the Fire Protection Research Foundation; that it does not itself require detectors but governs them where another code or an owner does; and that household alarms are tested to product standards such as UL 1484 and sound at or below 10% of the lower explosive limit. NFPA also warns that people stop noticing a steady smell after a minute or two and cannot smell anything while asleep or away.

    nfpa.orgfireandsafetyjournalamericas.com

    Credit

    National Fire Protection Association; Fire Protection Research Foundation

Watch for

  1. Detectors in schools and clinics

    Maine's Department of Public Safety submitted a bill, LD 2100, that would move the start of the detector rule for business, shop and assembly buildings to 1 January 2027 and, from 1 January 2028, add day care centers, schools, hospitals and other health care buildings, and jails, with enforcement by fire marshals, fire inspectors and police.

    Achieved whenthe bill is enacted and the State Fire Marshal's Office reports inspections of the newly covered buildings.

    lldc.mainelegislature.org

    Claimed by

    Maine Department of Public Safety, January 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Japan's accident list, in English

    A machine-readable English table of the LP-gas accidents at customers that Japan's METI lists one by one each year: date, prefecture, grade, what happened, type of building, cause, the appliance and its maker, and whether each of eight safety devices was fitted, among them the microcomputer meter, the fuse gas cock, the gas leak alarm, the carbon monoxide alarm and remote monitoring. Then a published analysis of how deaths and injuries differed with the devices fitted.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Who marks the house line

    A sourced table, for every US state and Canadian province and territory, of who must find and mark the buried propane line between a customer's tank and building before anyone digs (the one-call center, the propane retailer or the property owner), whether propane retailers must join the one-call center, and a list of documented cases where such a line was struck.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Japan's accident list, in English

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A machine-readable English table of the LP-gas accidents at customers that Japan's METI lists one by one each year: date, prefecture, grade, what happened, type of building, cause, the appliance and its maker, and whether each of eight safety devices was fitted, among them the microcomputer meter, the fuse gas cock, the gas leak alarm, the carbon monoxide alarm and remote monitoring. Then a published analysis of how deaths and injuries differed with the devices fitted.

Why it is still open

METI's 2025 summary lists each of the 277 accidents that year with all of these fields, but as a Japanese PDF whose tables ordinary text tools scramble. The Tokyo Metropolitan Government's summary gives national totals by year back to 1979, not cases. No English or machine-readable table of the cases was found, so the device fields cannot yet be compared across accidents by anyone who does not read Japanese.

meti.go.jpkankyo1.metro.tokyo.lg.jp

Built with what exists

PyMuPDF to pull the Japanese tables (pdftotext drops the text); machine translation checked by a Japanese reader; a document-reading model that quotes the page for each value (see the Note "Findings that cite notes"); Python and pandas.

  1. First step

    Extract METI's 2025 list into a spreadsheet and translate its column headings and the eight device names.

  2. Done looks like

    All 277 accidents of 2025, and every earlier year METI's site still offers, in one CSV with English field names and a page reference for each row; 50 rows picked at random rechecked against the PDF by a Japanese reader; a published table of deaths and injuries per 100 accidents by which devices were fitted.

Open 02 · the brief

Who marks the house line

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A sourced table, for every US state and Canadian province and territory, of who must find and mark the buried propane line between a customer's tank and building before anyone digs (the one-call center, the propane retailer or the property owner), whether propane retailers must join the one-call center, and a list of documented cases where such a line was struck.

Why it is still open

Tennessee 811 lists propane lines from a tank to a home among private lines that its members may not mark, and Minnesota's Gopher State One Call says private lines are not notified and may not be marked unless their owner takes part. At Farmington in 2019 such a line was cut by a post auger. PHMSA points to the Common Ground Alliance's state map, which sums up each state's damage prevention law under three headings (excavator duties, operator response and the one-call center), none of them about customer-owned lines; the model one-call law proposed by the American Petroleum Institute and the Association of Oil Pipe Lines would make underground propane distribution companies members, but it is a proposal, not a count of what states require. No comparison of the rules for tank-to-building lines was found.

tenn811.comgopherstateonecall.orgprimis.phmsa.dot.govapi.org

Built with what exists

State and provincial one-call laws (law.cornell.edu and provincial statute sites), one-call centers' own pages, a language model that quotes the clause it relied on, a spreadsheet, two checkers.

  1. First step

    Read the private-facility pages of ten one-call centers and draft the table's columns.

  2. Done looks like

    63 rows (50 states, 13 provinces and territories), each citing its clause, and at least 20 documented strikes on tank-to-building lines with sources.