BRENNEN

Industries / Mining and materials / Steel and metals / Precious metals refining

Tracing origin

Tracing origin is the work of showing where the gold, silver and platinum-group metals that reach a refinery were mined or recycled, through paperwork, audits, trade statistics and the chemistry of the metal itself.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1994 to 2024.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1994

    Gold's chemical fingerprint

    John Watling and colleagues in Western Australia showed that laser ablation ICP-MS, which vaporizes a speck of metal with a laser and counts the elements in the vapor with a mass spectrometer, can record the pattern of trace elements that marks gold from one deposit. Watling's 2014 review says the method has since been used in investigations of stolen gold internationally, and Reuters reported in December 2024 that Brazil's Federal Police had used such analysis, with satellite images, to argue in court papers that 294 kg of exported gold came from three wildcat mines in Pará and not from the Tocantins site the exporter named.

    LessonRefining changes the pattern; the 2014 review says refined gold's fingerprint "may be significantly different" from that of unrefined gold from the same ore, and only some elements survive, at much lower levels.

    rswa.org.aumining.com

    Credit

    R. J. Watling, H. K. Herbert, D. Delev and I. D. Abell; Brazil's Federal Police

  2. 2012

    Refiners audited every year

    LBMA made its Responsible Gold Guidance a formal requirement for every refiner on its Good Delivery List in 2012, and those refiners have been audited against it every year since January 2012. The guidance turns into rules the five-step due diligence framework of the guidance of the OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development) for minerals from conflict-affected and high-risk areas, which the OECD Ministerial Council recommended in May 2011.

    responsiblejewellery.comlbma.org.ukpublications.europa.eu

    Credit

    LBMA; OECD

  3. 2012

    US buyers must ask

    Under section 1502 of the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) adopted a rule, effective 13 November 2012, that a listed company whose products need gold, tin, tantalum or tungsten must check whether those metals came from the Democratic Republic of the Congo or a neighboring country, and if so must report its due diligence, the smelters and refiners used and the country of origin. The first reports were due on 31 May 2014.

    LessonAbout 1,300 companies filed in the first year, not the nearly 6,000 the SEC expected, and only 31% listed the smelters and refiners they used, by the law professor Jeff Schwartz's count for a House subcommittee in 2015; many said their suppliers named every refiner they used, not the ones in a given product.

    govinfo.govfinancialservices.house.gov

    Credit

    US Congress; SEC

  4. 2020

    An auditor's silence, judged

    In 2013 Amjad Rihan, a partner at EY in Dubai, led an assurance audit of the gold dealer Kaloti Jewellery International under the rules of Dubai's regulator, the DMCC, and LBMA. By his account the audit found that Kaloti was knowingly buying gold smuggled out of Morocco coated in silver, and had taken part in cash gold deals of about US$5.2 billion in 2012; EY accepted that these facts gave rise to a reasonable suspicion of money laundering, the judgment records. He refused to sign a report that played the findings down and was replaced. On 17 April 2020 the High Court in London held the EY defendants liable for breach of their duty of care to him and awarded US$10,843,941 and £117,950.

    LessonAn origin audit is worth only what the auditor is willing to report.

    judiciary.uk

    Credit

    Amjad Rihan; Mr Justice Kerr, High Court of England and Wales

  5. 2021

    Europe's importers must check

    EU Regulation 2017/821 took full effect on 1 January 2021. EU companies importing more than 100 kg a year of unrefined or refined gold, or set amounts of tin, tantalum and tungsten, must carry out supply chain due diligence on OECD lines, while recycled metals are mostly outside the rule.

    LessonIn February 2025 the European Commission found LBMA's Responsible Gold Guidance only "partially aligned" with the regulation and declined to recognize it, citing among other gaps weak due diligence on recycled gold by refiners and their auditors.

    publications.europa.eucdn.lbma.org.uk

    Credit

    European Parliament and Council of the EU

  6. 2023

    Brazil drops buyers' good faith

    A 2013 Brazilian law said a gold buyer was presumed to act in good faith, and the gold presumed legal, if it kept on file the information the seller gave. Minister Gilmar Mendes of the Supreme Federal Court suspended that rule in April 2023, and on 24 March 2025 the full court unanimously struck it down, saying the rule had not only eased but encouraged the trade in gold from illegal mining, with harm reaching Indigenous peoples.

    LessonBrazil's gold exports fell from 110 metric tons in 2020 to 77.7 tons in 2023, which the government attributes to enforcement against illegal mining, Reuters reported.

    noticias.stf.jus.brmining.com

    Credit

    Supreme Federal Court of Brazil; the parties PSB, Rede Sustentabilidade and PV, which brought the cases

  7. 2024

    Undeclared African gold counted

    Marc Ummel and Yvan Schulz of SWISSAID, a Swiss development charity, compared the gold production and exports that all 54 African countries report with the imports their trading partners report, for 2012 to 2022. They estimated that 321 to 474 metric tons of gold from artisanal and small-scale mines goes undeclared each year, that at least 435 tons was smuggled out of Africa in 2022, and that the United Arab Emirates took in 2,596 tons of African gold from 2012 to 2022 that had never been declared for export.

    LessonSWISSAID notes that Swiss law treats the last place of processing as gold's origin, so gold imported from the Emirates counts as Emirati even when it was mined elsewhere.

    swissaid.ch

    Credit

    SWISSAID

Watch for

  1. LBMA's tenth gold rulebook

    LBMA's draft Responsible Gold Guidance version 10 would rename recycled gold "secondary gold", set due diligence by type of material, with independent audits for higher-risk supply chains, and make monthly country-of-origin reporting to LBMA part of the rules; LBMA's Gold Bar Integrity database began taking such monthly reports from refiners on a voluntary basis in April 2026. The second public consultation closed on 16 October 2026, and the first assurance reports under version 10 would cover 2028.

    Achieved whenversion 10 is in force and the European Commission, or another outside assessor, reports that the recycled-gold gap it named in 2025 is closed.

    lbma.org.uklbma.org.uk

    Claimed by

    LBMA, 2026

  2. Origin read from a bar

    ABC Refinery in Sydney said in May 2025 that buyers of its numbered one-kilogram bars can scan them with the ProvCheck app, made by Blockhead Technologies, to see the gold's origin and the carbon emissions attributed to it. ShareCafe reported that the app rests on a reference database of trace-element profiles from the refinery's supplying mines, built with the firm Source Certain over four months.

    Achieved whenan outside laboratory runs a blind test of samples against the database and publishes how often it names the right mine.

    pallion.comsharecafe.com.au

    Claimed by

    ABC Refinery (Pallion), May 2025

Open

  1. 01

    An open gold fingerprint library

    A public, openly licensed table of published trace-element and lead-isotope analyses of gold from known deposits, one row per analysis with the deposit, its coordinates, the method and the source paper. Add a scored test: given one sample's analysis and a claimed source, can a method reject a false claim without rejecting a true one. That is the test police need, since, as a Reuters source noted, they have only to show that gold did not come from where a suspect says.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Conflict minerals filings, tabled

    A public table with one row per Form SD, the yearly conflict minerals filing to the SEC, since 2014: the filer, the year, whether it filed a full Conflict Minerals Report, the gold refiners it names, matched to the identifiers in the Responsible Minerals Initiative's public smelter list and to LBMA's list, and whether it says it cannot tell where its gold came from. Then a yearly count of how many filers name their refiners and which refiners appear most.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

An open gold fingerprint library

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, openly licensed table of published trace-element and lead-isotope analyses of gold from known deposits, one row per analysis with the deposit, its coordinates, the method and the source paper. Add a scored test: given one sample's analysis and a claimed source, can a method reject a false claim without rejecting a true one. That is the test police need, since, as a Reuters source noted, they have only to show that gold did not come from where a suspect says.

Why it is still open

The data are split up and mostly closed. Brazil's Federal Police are building a database for police use and hope to analyze the 30,000 gold samples held by the Brazilian Geological Service. The Atlas of Gold Compositions for British Columbia covers 12,509 gold particles from 353 places in one Canadian province. GlobaLID, an openly licensed lead-isotope database, covers ores and minerals for studies of ancient metal objects, not gold metal. ABC Refinery's reference database covers its own suppliers' mines. Searches found no open, cross-country gold library with a public test.

mining.comcdn.geosciencebc.comdatapub.gfz-potsdam.de

Built with what exists

Tables from published papers; GlobaLID (CC BY 4.0 license); the British Columbia atlas, if its authors agree; Meta's Muse Ember to pull tables out of papers (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); a second model that flags doubtful readings for a person to check (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); Python with scikit-learn for the test. Published data only; no samples are collected or bought.

  1. First step

    List 30 papers that publish laser-ablation tables of gold grains, enter the first five in the template, and write to the British Columbia atlas team to ask whether its data can be included.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 5,000 analyses from at least 150 deposits in at least 15 countries, released under an open license, and a leave-one-deposit-out test that reports, for each method, how often it wrongly rejects the true region and how often it catches a false one.

Open 02 · the brief

Conflict minerals filings, tabled

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table with one row per Form SD, the yearly conflict minerals filing to the SEC, since 2014: the filer, the year, whether it filed a full Conflict Minerals Report, the gold refiners it names, matched to the identifiers in the Responsible Minerals Initiative's public smelter list and to LBMA's list, and whether it says it cannot tell where its gold came from. Then a yearly count of how many filers name their refiners and which refiners appear most.

Why it is still open

The counts found are partial. Jeff Schwartz counted the first year's filings for a House subcommittee in 2015: about 1,300 filers, of whom 31% listed their smelters and refiners. Responsible Sourcing Network ranked selected companies' filings for six years, through 2019, in its "Mining the Disclosures" guides, scoring their due diligence rather than listing every refiner named. The filings sit as separate documents on EDGAR, the SEC's filing system, and searches found single filings but no compiled dataset across all filers and years.

financialservices.house.govsourcingnetwork.orgresponsiblemineralsinitiative.org

Built with what exists

EDGAR full-text search and the SEC's free data APIs, which ask automated users to name themselves in the User-Agent header; Muse Ember to pull refiner names from each filing (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); a second model that flags doubtful rows (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); the Responsible Minerals Initiative's public smelter and refiner list; SQLite.

  1. First step

    Pull one year's list of Form SD filings from EDGAR and fill in 50 rows by hand to settle the columns.

  2. Done looks like

    Every Form SD for reporting years 2013 to 2025 in the table, a random 5% of rows checked by hand at 95% or better, and a published chart of the share of filers naming their gold refiners each year.