Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Food and beverage processing / Pet food
Treats and chews
Treats and chews are the biscuits, dried meats, chews and soft treats fed between meals, made by baking, extruding, drying or molding.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1908 to 2020.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1908
A biscuit for dogs
The F. H. Bennett Biscuit Company baked the first Milk-Bone dog biscuits, then called Maltoid Milk-Bone, in a small bakery on New York City's Lower East Side in 1908. The brand moved to a larger plant in Buffalo, New York, in 1957 and is still made there, by the brand's own account.
Credit
F. H. Bennett Biscuit Company
1997
A seal for dental claims
The American Veterinary Dental College set up the Veterinary Oral Health Council (VOHC) on 27 April 1997, after meetings since 1989, to review makers' trial data on plaque and tartar control against an agreed protocol. The council does not test products itself; products that meet its standard may carry its seal.
Credit
American Veterinary Dental College; C. E. Harvey, the council's first director
2006
A dental chew remade
By 1 March 2006 the FDA had confirmed 35 complaints involving 34 dogs and one cat over Greenies dental chews, and media reports counted at least 13 dead dogs. In October 2006 the maker, S&M NuTec, bought by Mars earlier that year, released a new formula it said was easier to chew and digest, and VOHC lists its seal for Canine Greenies from 2007.
Lessona chew must break down once swallowed, not only clean teeth.
Credit
S&M NuTec; Mars
2013
Bully sticks put to test
A Tufts University study measured bully sticks, a popular dried meat chew, at 9 to 22 kcal per inch (23 to 56 kcal per cm). Of 26 sticks tested for bacteria, one carried Clostridium difficile, one methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) and one a tetracycline-resistant E. coli.
Credit
L. M. Freeman, N. Janecko and J. S. Weese
2013
Jerky treats, no cause found
From 2007 the FDA received reports of pets falling ill after eating chicken, duck or sweet potato jerky treats, most often, but not always, made in China. Complaints fell after several leading brands left the shops in January 2013, when New York State's agriculture department found low levels of antibiotic residues in them; by 31 December 2015 the FDA counted about 5,200 complaints involving more than 6,200 dogs, 26 cats and three people, including more than 1,140 dog deaths.
LessonAbout 530 samples tied to complaints and more than 450 bought in shops were tested without finding a root cause, and the FDA judged the antibiotic traces an unlikely one.
Credit
FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine and its Vet-LIRN laboratory network; New York State Department of Agriculture and Markets
2018
A tooth's breaking point
University of Pennsylvania researchers pressed 24 upper fourth premolars, the large cutting teeth, from dog cadavers at an angle of about 60 degrees until they broke; the mean breaking force was 1,281 N (± 403 N). A summary of the work published by the British Veterinary Dental Association names Mars Petcare as a partner and says chews that do not yield below that force should be treated as a fracture risk.
Credit
M. Soltero-Rivera, A. M. Reiter and colleagues, University of Pennsylvania; Mars Petcare
2020
Treats digested in a dish
A University of Illinois team digested 25 commercial treats with enzymes in the lab, a method that imitates a dog's stomach and small intestine. After the stomach phase as little as 8.4% of a treat had dissolved; after both phases most types passed 85%, but rawhide ranged from 35.1% to 95.7%.
Lessona large treat that stays whole in the stomach may block the gut.
Credit
F. He, G. Holben and M. R. C. de Godoy
Watch for
Microwave drying for treats
EnWave says its REV vacuum-microwave dryers dry pet treats in 30 to 60 minutes a cycle, against 24 to 48 hours for commercial freeze-drying, with 70% less power, and that 20 beagles at a USDA-registered kennel ate nearly all the REV-dried chicken hearts and livers offered in a trial run in 2019.
Achieved whenan independent laboratory or university publishes energy per kilogram of water removed, moisture and shelf life for REV-dried and freeze-dried treats made from the same batch.
Claimed by
EnWave, March 2026
Open
01
Test chews against tooth strength
A public table of the force it takes to dent or break the chews sold for dogs: antlers, nylon and other plastic bones, hard cheese chews, rawhide, bully sticks and dental chews. Five pieces of each product are pressed by a steel probe shaped like a dog's upper fourth premolar until they yield, and the force is set beside the 1,281 N mean at which such teeth broke in the Pennsylvania study.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Watch chews break down
Time-lapse records of 50 popular chews and treats dissolving in simulated stomach and intestinal fluids, photographed every 30 minutes, with the size of the largest remaining piece measured by software.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Test chews against tooth strength
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table of the force it takes to dent or break the chews sold for dogs: antlers, nylon and other plastic bones, hard cheese chews, rawhide, bully sticks and dental chews. Five pieces of each product are pressed by a steel probe shaped like a dog's upper fourth premolar until they yield, and the force is set beside the 1,281 N mean at which such teeth broke in the Pennsylvania study.
Why it is still open
The 2020 Illinois texture test reached its analyzer's 30 kg (about 294 N) limit on 7 of the 22 treats it measured, and the Pennsylvania study measured teeth, not chews. Europe PMC lists seven papers citing the tooth study, none of them a test of chews. Mars Petcare, which funded the tooth study, says it checked its whole range of chews against the breaking force under an internal protocol, but it publishes no results by product.
Built with what exists
A universal testing machine with a 5 kN load cell (Instron, ZwickRoell or MTS) in a university materials laboratory, or a bench rig made from an arbor press, an S-type 5 kN load cell and an HX711 amplifier read by an Arduino; a probe cast or machined from a 3D scan of a canine tooth model.
First step
Book an hour on a university materials tester and run five pieces each of an antler, a nylon bone and a dental chew.
Done looks like
40 products from at least 10 brands, five pieces each, with peak force, force at first yield and photos, published as an open table with the probe's drawing.
Open 02 · the brief
Watch chews break down
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
Time-lapse records of 50 popular chews and treats dissolving in simulated stomach and intestinal fluids, photographed every 30 minutes, with the size of the largest remaining piece measured by software.
Why it is still open
The Illinois study weighed what was left of 25 treats only at the end of each digestion phase and found rawhide anywhere from 35.1% to 95.7% digested. The risk it names is a large piece that stays whole, which an end weight does not show.
Built with what exists
The Boisen and Eggum in vitro method used in the Illinois study (pepsin and hydrochloric acid, then pancreatin) in a shaking water bath; a camera over each glass vessel; OpenCV or Meta's Segment Anything 2 to measure the outline of each piece.
First step
Run the stomach phase on five rawhide and five dental chews, photographing each vessel every 30 minutes.
Done looks like
50 products, three runs each, with curves of the largest piece's area against time over 6 hours, and the raw images and code published.