BRENNEN

Industries / Finance and business services / Payroll

Time and attendance

Time and attendance is the work of recording when each person starts and stops work and takes breaks, so that pay can be worked out and working-time laws can be checked.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1888 to 2023.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1888

    Clocks that print the time

    Willard Bundy's key recorder of 1888 printed the exact time and the worker's number on a paper tape when the worker inserted a key. IBM, whose International Time Recording Company took over Bundy's business, says it "largely eliminated inaccuracies and disputes in payroll processing". The same year Alexander Dey introduced a dial recorder, and in 1894 Daniel M. Cooper patented the Rochester Recorder, which IBM calls the world's first card-based system to record attendance.

    ibm.com

    Credit

    Willard Bundy; Alexander Dey; Daniel M. Cooper

  2. 1979

    A clock that adds hours

    Electromechanical time clocks stamped only the hour and minute of each punch and left clerks to total them. Kronos, founded by Mark Ain in 1977, introduced an electronic time clock in December 1979 that recorded, totaled and reported each worker's hours; it sold for under $1,000, against about $400 for an electromechanical clock. Building it took nearly three years instead of the six months planned, because the software had to handle hundreds of company policies, such as how overtime was counted and how late a worker could punch in before pay was docked. By early 1987 Kronos had installed nearly 30,000 clocks in about 25,000 companies, by a published company history.

    LessonThe hard part of a time clock is the pay rules applied to the hours, not the clock.

    ukg.comfundinguniverse.com

    Credit

    Mark S. Ain and the inventor Larry Baxter, Kronos

  3. 2019

    Every working day recorded

    In a case the Spanish union CCOO brought against Deutsche Bank SAE, the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled on 14 May 2019 that member states must require employers to set up "an objective, reliable and accessible system" to measure the time each worker works each day. The Spanish court that referred the case reported that 53.7% of overtime hours worked in Spain went unrecorded. Spain had already made a daily record of each worker's start and finish times compulsory by a decree-law of 8 March 2019, applying two months after its publication.

    curia.europa.euboe.es

    Credit

    Federación de Servicios de CCOO; the Court of Justice of the European Union

  4. 2021

    No rounding of meal breaks

    Many clocks round punches to the nearest 5, 6 or 15 minutes, which US federal rules accept only if it does not underpay workers over time. On 25 February 2021 the California Supreme Court held in Donohue v. AMN Services that employers may not round punches for meal periods, and that time records showing missed, short or late meals are presumed to show a violation unless the employer proves otherwise. In that case rounding had overpaid the class by 85 work hours in total, yet the plaintiff's expert counted 40,110 short lunches and 6,651 late ones for which no premium was paid, worth $802,077.08.

    LessonRounding can look even across total hours and still hide short breaks that the law pays for separately.

    courts.ca.govlaw.cornell.edu

    Credit

    Justice Liu, for a unanimous court; Kennedy Donohue, the nurse recruiter who sued

  5. 2021

    Time system held for ransom

    On 11 December 2021 UKG reported a ransomware attack on Kronos Private Cloud, which hosts products including UKG Workforce Central and UKG TeleStaff, used for timekeeping and scheduling. UKG warned the outage could last weeks, and in a 30 December update put full restoration at 28 January 2022; a source told TechTarget that about 2,500 of UKG's more than 50,000 customers were hit. Employers fell back on paper: Care New England paid about 7,500 staff by hand without overtime or holiday pay, and a hospital in Missoula, Montana, said manual entry overpaid some employees and underpaid others.

    LessonA time system is a single point of failure for pay, so an employer needs a fallback that still captures overtime and premiums.

    techtarget.comshrm.org

    Credit

    UKG, as the affected supplier; reporting by TechTarget and SHRM

  6. 2023

    Every fingerprint scan a claim

    Illinois' Biometric Information Privacy Act, in force since 2008, bars a business from collecting a person's fingerprints or other biometric data without first giving notice and getting consent. In February 2023, in a case brought by a White Castle manager who said she had to scan her fingerprint to reach her pay stubs and work computers, the Illinois Supreme Court ruled 4 to 3 that a separate claim arises with every unlawful scan; White Castle estimated class damages could exceed $17 billion. In August 2024 Illinois amended the act so that collecting the same biometric from the same person by the same method is a single violation, with at most one recovery.

    LessonA fingerprint clock carries a privacy duty at every punch, and the legal exposure grew with each scan until the law capped it.

    amp.insurancejournal.comilga.gov

    Credit

    Latrina Cothron, the plaintiff; the Illinois Supreme Court; the Illinois General Assembly

Watch for

  1. Spain's digital time register

    Spain's Ministry of Labour has drafted a royal decree that would make the daily record of working time digital, tamper-proof and open in real time to workers and to the labour inspectorate, with paper records no longer accepted. In spring 2026 the Council of State, the government's advisory body, gave a nearly 100-page unfavourable opinion, citing costs for businesses, data protection, a lack of sector-specific rules and a 20-day window to comply; Labour Minister Yolanda Díaz said the decree would go ahead with minor changes, and the employers' federation CEOE said it would challenge it in court. A search of the official gazette's legislation database for this research found no such decree published by 18 November 2026.

    Achieved whenThe decree is published in the Boletín Oficial del Estado and the labour inspectorate reports checking employers' records remotely.

    remoteworkeurope.eu

    Claimed by

    Spain's Ministry of Labour, May 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Graded tests for time rules

    A public set of at least 500 worked days, each a list of clock punches with the right answer attached: the paid minutes after any rounding, and every meal or rest break breach with the premium owed. Cover California, where Donohue bars rounding of meal periods, and four other states with different break rules. Write each answer from the statute or court decision it rests on, have two people check it, then score the available checkers and AI models against the set.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Rebuilding hours after an outage

    A public drill and an open tool for the weeks when a time system is down. The drill is an invented employer of 500 people over four weeks, with true hours known, and the scraps a real outage leaves: schedules, door-badge logs, photographed paper sheets and notes. The tool rebuilds each person's hours, overtime and premiums from those scraps, flags what it cannot rebuild, and works out the correction owed to each person once the true hours are known.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Graded tests for time rules

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public set of at least 500 worked days, each a list of clock punches with the right answer attached: the paid minutes after any rounding, and every meal or rest break breach with the premium owed. Cover California, where Donohue bars rounding of meal periods, and four other states with different break rules. Write each answer from the statute or court decision it rests on, have two people check it, then score the available checkers and AI models against the set.

Why it is still open

Checkers now exist, but nobody has published an independent answer key to test them. The work-break-rules package, first published in October 2026, codes meal and rest break rules for every US state and the District of Columbia with citations, and says it has not been reviewed by a lawyer. Clockspot's rounding calculator estimates what rounding costs, and its own fact-check page says it is "a quantification tool, not a compliance engine" that leaves meal-period rounding out. A ten-task payroll test of AI models from October 2026 has one California overtime day and no punch-level break cases.

github.comclockspot.comgithub.com

Built with what exists

The MIT-licensed work-break-rules and timeclock-rounding packages as the first systems under test; Python for the scoring script; AI models such as Claude Opus 5.5 and Mistral Large 4, whose weights an employer can run on its own machines (see the Note "A trillion open parameters"), both to draft cases for people to check and as systems under test.

github.com

  1. First step

    Write 50 California days, starting from the two lunches the Donohue opinion works through (23 minutes from 11:02 to 11:25, and 21 minutes from 12:04 to 12:25, both recorded as 30), and run work-break-rules on them.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 500 worked days across five states, each answer citing its source and signed off by two reviewers, released under an open license with a scoring script; published scores for at least three checkers or models, with every disagreement listed.

Open 02 · the brief

Rebuilding hours after an outage

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public drill and an open tool for the weeks when a time system is down. The drill is an invented employer of 500 people over four weeks, with true hours known, and the scraps a real outage leaves: schedules, door-badge logs, photographed paper sheets and notes. The tool rebuilds each person's hours, overtime and premiums from those scraps, flags what it cannot rebuild, and works out the correction owed to each person once the true hours are known.

Why it is still open

In the 2021 Kronos outage employers paid thousands of people by hand for weeks without overtime or holiday pay, one hospital said manual entry overpaid some staff and underpaid others, and a security officer quoted by TechTarget said most organizations were ill-prepared. A GitHub search for this research found no public tool or test set for rebuilding pay records after a time-system outage.

techtarget.com

Built with what exists

Python; invented data only; an AI model that reads photographed handwritten sheets, with a second pass that lists the entries a person should check, in the manner of the record reviewer in the Note "Seven more flagged"; the work-break-rules package for break premiums.

  1. First step

    Generate two weeks of true punches for 50 invented people, then derive the outage scraps from them.

  2. Done looks like

    On the invented employer, rebuilt hours within 15 minutes of the truth for at least 95% of person-days, every other day flagged rather than guessed, and the correction owed matching the truth to the cent for at least 98% of people; data, tool and scores public.