Industries / Finance and business services / Payroll
Benefits and deductions
This is the work of taking amounts other than tax out of pay, or adding them to it, and sending each to where it belongs: pension and retirement contributions, court-ordered garnishments and child support, and pay given up before tax.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1968 to 2024.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1968
A cap on garnishment
Garnishment is a court order that makes an employer take part of a worker's pay for a creditor. Title III of the US Consumer Credit Protection Act, signed on 29 May 1968, limits an ordinary garnishment to the lesser of 25% of a week's disposable earnings (pay after legally required deductions) or the amount above 30 times the federal minimum wage. Child support orders may take 50% to 60%, plus 5% when payments are more than 12 weeks behind, and an employer may not fire a worker for a garnishment for any one debt.
Credit
US Congress
1992
Super set aside by law
Australia's superannuation guarantee, introduced in 1992 at 3% of an employee's ordinary time earnings, makes employers pay into a retirement fund for nearly all employees, and the rate reached 12% on 1 July 2025. The government's Retirement Income Review (2020) cites an estimate by Gruen and Soding (2011) that compulsory superannuation raised Australia's private saving by about 1.5% of GDP.
Credit
The Australian government of Paul Keating and the Australian Parliament
1996
New hires reported
The US welfare reform law of 1996 (PRWORA) set up the National Directory of New Hires. Employers report each new hire to a state directory, generally within 20 days, and the states pass the reports on, so child support agencies can find a parent's employer and send an order to withhold from pay. HHS estimates that about 815 million records were posted to the directory in fiscal year 2023, and about three quarters of child support is collected through income withholding, by the Congressional Research Service's account.
Credit
US Congress; the Office of Child Support Services at the US Department of Health and Human Services
1998
Enrolled unless they opt out
From 1 April 1998 one large US company enrolled each new hire in its 401(k) retirement plan, paid by payroll deduction, unless the worker declined, at 3% of pay in a money market fund. Brigitte Madrian and Dennis Shea found that 86% of the new hires took part, against 37% of an earlier group at similar tenure, but that most of them stayed at the 3% default and in the money market fund, which they traced to inertia and to workers reading the default as advice.
LessonWorkers keep the default that payroll sets, so the default rate and fund matter as much as enrollment itself.
Credit
Brigitte C. Madrian and Dennis F. Shea (NBER working paper, 2000; Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2001)
2012
Automatic enrolment in Britain
Under the Pensions Act 2008, UK employers began in October 2012 to enroll eligible workers in a workplace pension paid by deduction from pay, largest employers first; the phased introduction finished in April 2019, when minimum contributions reached 8% of qualifying earnings, at least 3% from the employer. By the Department for Work and Pensions' figures, 70% of eligible employees saved in a workplace pension in 2014, 15 percentage points more than in 2012, and about 90%, or 22.6 million people, in 2025; at private employers with fewer than five staff the figure was about 55%.
Credit
The UK Parliament; the Department for Work and Pensions
2024
Unpaid super counted
Australian employers could pay superannuation contributions quarterly, weeks after the wages they belonged to. An Australian Taxation Office analysis published on 1 November 2024 put the gap between the superannuation guarantee employers owed and what they paid at $5.2 billion, or 6.3%, in 2021–22, as cited by the Parliamentary Library, and the Australian National Audit Office reported non-compliance was more common among small and micro businesses. The government's stated aim in moving the due date to payday was to reduce that gap.
LessonA deduction paid long after the wage it belongs to can go missing without the worker noticing.
Credit
The Australian Taxation Office, for the estimate
Watch for
Super due with wages
From 1 July 2026, Australian employers must pay superannuation guarantee contributions so that they reach each employee's fund within 7 business days of payday, instead of each quarter, under the Treasury Laws Amendment (Payday Superannuation) Act 2025, which received assent on 6 November 2025; the tax office's free clearing house for small businesses was retired on 1 July 2026. For the first year, the tax office's guideline PCG 2026/1 sorts employers into low, medium and high risk by how promptly and accurately they pay, and says low-risk employers will not be the focus of compliance action.
Achieved whenThe tax office publishes a superannuation guarantee gap estimate for a year under the new rule that is below the 6.3% of 2021–22.
Claimed by
The Australian government, announced 2 May 2023, and the Australian Taxation Office, February 2026
Employer money for children
Under the same 2025 US law, Public Law 119-21, employers may from 4 July 2026 put up to $2,500 a year, excluded from the employee's income, into a Trump account, a new kind of individual retirement account for a child under 18, of an employee or an employee's dependent; the amounts are reported on the W-2 under box 12 code TA.
Achieved whenThe IRS or another outside party reports how many employers made such contributions in 2026 and their total.
Claimed by
Internal Revenue Service, January 2026
Open
01
Plan pay definitions, checked
A tool that reads the definition of compensation in a 401(k) plan document, sorts each payroll pay code (bonus, overtime, commission, car allowance) into counted or not counted, and flags paychecks where the deferral or the employer match was taken on the wrong pay. Alongside it, a public test set of invented plan documents and payroll registers with planted errors.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Stacked garnishments, computed
A public test set of invented paychecks that carry several orders at once (a child support withholding order, a federal tax levy, a creditor's garnishment, a defaulted student loan order), with the correct amount for each order under federal and state limits and the order of priority, and a published score for AI models and payroll calculators on it.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Plan pay definitions, checked
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A tool that reads the definition of compensation in a 401(k) plan document, sorts each payroll pay code (bonus, overtime, commission, car allowance) into counted or not counted, and flags paychecks where the deferral or the employer match was taken on the wrong pay. Alongside it, a public test set of invented plan documents and payroll registers with planted errors.
Why it is still open
The IRS's 401(k) Plan Fix-It Guide treats not applying the plan's own definition of compensation as a plan mistake; its examples are bonuses counted after the plan excluded them and overtime left out though the plan included it, and its fixes include an employer contribution of 50% of each missed deferral (25% if found and fixed quickly). Julie Isom of Milliman (January 2023) describes the error arising when employers added new pay, such as COVID-19 pay, without updating deferral and match calculations, and advises checking periodically. Searches of GitHub and Hugging Face in this research found no public test set or open tool for the check.
Built with what exists
An AI model that reads long documents, such as Claude Opus 5.5; Enveda says a Claude-based reviewer of its drug-making records flagged issues people had missed (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); Python to generate the registers; the IRS examples as the first planted errors.
First step
Write five compensation definitions covering the two IRS examples and a 20-employee register with ten planted errors, and test one AI model on it.
Done looks like
50 invented plan documents and 50 payroll registers with 200 planted errors, released openly, and a tool that finds at least 95% of them with no more than one false flag per register, scored by someone other than its builder.
Open 02 · the brief
Stacked garnishments, computed
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public test set of invented paychecks that carry several orders at once (a child support withholding order, a federal tax levy, a creditor's garnishment, a defaulted student loan order), with the correct amount for each order under federal and state limits and the order of priority, and a published score for AI models and payroll calculators on it.
Why it is still open
One piece exists. A Hugging Face dataset records, from each statute, the ordinary-judgment garnishment limits of 39 states (last verified October 2026). The only public AI test found that mixes orders is one task in a ten-task payroll eval, in which Claude Haiku 5.5 stated the child support caps backwards in two of three runs. This research found no larger test set.
Built with what exists
The federal limits in the Labor Department's fact sheet; the state dataset above; Python for the answer keys; AI models including one a payroll firm can run on its own machines, such as Mistral Large 4 (see the Note "A trillion open parameters").
First step
Write 20 cases for one state that is stricter than federal law, work the answers by hand, and run the ten-task eval's runner on them.
Done looks like
200 cases across at least ten states, each answer citing its statute, no real person's data, and a public table for at least three models run three times each and one payroll calculator.