BRENNEN

Industries / Retail, hospitality and personal services / Retail and e-commerce / Pawn shops

Jewelry and metals

This is the work of finding out at the counter how much gold, silver or platinum a piece of jewelry really holds, and paying or lending a fair share of its melt value, the worth of its metal once melted.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1906 to 2024.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

3

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1906

    Karat stamps get a tolerance

    The US National Gold and Silver Stamping Act of 13 June 1906 made it unlawful to mail, import or ship between states any gold article made after 13 June 1907 whose fineness mark, such as "14K", overstated its gold, but it let the metal fall up to half a karat below the mark, or one karat when the solder was counted. A 1976 amendment, in force from 1981, cut the margin to three thousandths of fineness, or seven thousandths with solder for most articles.

    law.cornell.edulaw.cornell.edu

    Credit

    US Congress

  2. 2009

    Mail-in buyers pay a fraction

    Old gold sold back for melting rose 27% in 2009 to an all-time high as the price climbed, by the consultancy GFMS's count as reported by the US Geological Survey. Cash4Gold, a Florida mail-in buyer that advertised during the 2009 Super Bowl, offered as little as 11% of the melt value of gold necklaces in a test that Consumerist.com ran with Consumer Reports, published in September 2009. In February 2010 Florida's attorney general opened a civil investigation after 72 complaints, some about checks "as small as 7 cents" and gold "already melted" when sellers asked for it back, and the company went bankrupt in 2012, Fortune reported.

    LessonA seller who mails jewelry away cannot watch it weighed and tested, and cannot take it back once it is melted.

    d9-wret.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.comconsumerreports.orgjckonline.comfortune.com

    Credit

    Consumerist.com and Consumer Reports (test); Florida Attorney General's Office (investigation); GFMS and the US Geological Survey (figures)

  3. 2010

    Same gold, offers far apart

    KPIX, the CBS television station in San Francisco, had a refinery value a 24-karat chain, an 18-karat band and a 14-karat necklace at $1,320 of melt value, then offered them to five buyers with a hidden camera. A jeweler offered $852, about 65% of melt; two mall kiosks offered 58% and 41%; a gold-buying event said the 24-karat chain was not gold and offered 41% for the rest with a coupon; and a pawnshop in Oakland offered $265, 20%.

    LessonThe same pieces drew offers more than three times apart, so the station's advice was to ask each buyer what percentage of the melt it pays.

    cbsnews.com

    Credit

    KPIX (CBS San Francisco) ConsumerWatch

  4. 2019

    Fake gold behind 186 loans

    India's Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) booked a senior branch manager of Bank of Baroda in May 2019, alleging that from December 2017 to July 2018 he sanctioned 186 gold loans worth ₹12.51 crore (₹125.1 million) to 57 borrowers against spurious ornaments, meaning fake or base-metal pieces, and forged the signatures of the bank's approved appraiser and joint custodian, at a loss to the bank of ₹10.68 crore, Deccan Herald reported from the case filing.

    LessonA gold loan rests on the appraiser's certificate, and fake gold passed once that signature could be bypassed.

    deccanherald.com

    Credit

    Central Bureau of Investigation (case); Bank of Baroda (complaint)

  5. 2024

    A gold lender halted

    After inspecting IIFL Finance, a large Indian gold lender, on its accounts at 31 March 2023, the RBI barred it on 4 March 2024 from making new gold loans. The regulator cited "serious deviations in assaying and certifying purity and net weight of the gold" both when loans were made and when pledges were auctioned after default, loans above the loan-to-value cap, and cash payouts far above the legal limit. It lifted the bar on 19 September 2024, according to the company's stock-exchange filing as reported by Business Today.

    LessonErrors in testing and weighing gold were enough for the regulator to stop a large lender's new loans for six months.

    rbi.org.inbusinesstoday.in

    Credit

    Reserve Bank of India

Watch for

  1. Photo checks for fake gold

    Satyabrat Maharana, writing from the cyber security wing of Canara Bank, an Indian state-owned bank, proposed a photo-only check for gold-loan branches: one model estimates an ornament's karat from a photo, another its volume and so its density, and pieces whose density does not fit the claimed purity go to a second human valuer. He puts manual valuation at 8 to 15 minutes and about ₹300 a packet, against under a minute for the photo method, and the paper reports no test results and says the method must still be checked against XRF and water-displacement measurements before any rollout.

    Achieved whena test on real pledged ornaments, checked against XRF or fire assay, publishes how many plated or mixed-alloy pieces the method caught and missed.

    theijire.com

    Claimed by

    Satyabrat Maharana (Canara Bank), July to August 2026

  2. Machine purity checks in branches

    IIFL Finance wrote that gold lenders increasingly use X-ray fluorescence (XRF) machines, which read the metals in a piece without harming it, with machine-learning calibration; that a scan takes 30 to 90 seconds per ornament; and that such systems "may" flag surface plating, unlike karatmeters, which mainly measure surface conductivity. It says it applies documented testing methods across its branches but gives no detection rates.

    Achieved whena lender, an auditor or the RBI publishes how many plated or fake ornaments branch XRF screening caught and missed, checked against assay.

    iifl.com

    Claimed by

    IIFL Finance, May 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Counter testers, tested blind

    A blind test of the cheap tools used at pawn and gold-loan counters, namely electronic gold testers, conductivity karatmeters and a phone-photo karat estimate, on 150 pieces: solid 9 to 22 karat, gold-plated, gold-filled, and base-metal chains sold as look-alikes. A laboratory's XRF and fire assay give the true answer. Report each tool's error in karats and how often it passed a plated or base piece as solid.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A melt-value payout tracker

    A public weekly table of what gold buyers offer for scrap jewelry as a share of melt value (the day's gold price times the piece's purity and weight), covering mail-in buyers and pawn and jewelry chains that post per-gram or per-karat prices online, in the US and the UK.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  3. 03

    A register of fake-gold loans

    An open table of court judgments, CBI cases and press reports since 2015 in which Indian lenders lent against fake or plated gold, or had pledged gold swapped, coding the lender type, amount, number of loans, how it came to light (audit, revaluation, auction or default) and the appraiser's role.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Counter testers, tested blind

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A blind test of the cheap tools used at pawn and gold-loan counters, namely electronic gold testers, conductivity karatmeters and a phone-photo karat estimate, on 150 pieces: solid 9 to 22 karat, gold-plated, gold-filled, and base-metal chains sold as look-alikes. A laboratory's XRF and fire assay give the true answer. Report each tool's error in karats and how often it passed a plated or base piece as solid.

Why it is still open

Seth Gold, a Detroit pawnbroker named Pawnbroker of the Year for 2013 by the US National Pawnbrokers Association, wrote in a post on the site of Thermo Fisher, whose XRF analyzers he uses, that the acid test sorts gold only into 10, 14, 18 and 22-karat steps and that some stainless steels pass it, but gave no counts. Quicktest, a British seller of testers, reviews nine electronic testers from its own use without blind figures, IIFL contrasts karatmeters with XRF without figures, and Maharana's photo method is untested by his own account. A search found no independent controlled comparison.

thermofisher.comquicktest.co.ukiifl.com

Built with what exists

Two or three electronic gold testers and a karatmeter as sold to jewelers; a phone camera and a light box; an image model built to Maharana's description or a fine-tuned classifier; a laboratory accredited to ISO/IEC 17025 that runs XRF and fire assay. The team uses no acids and no X-ray equipment; the laboratory does.

  1. First step

    Buy 20 pieces, 10 hallmarked solid and 10 sold as plated, and read them with one electronic tester, two people each, to fix the procedure.

  2. Done looks like

    150 pieces, each read three times with each tool by two operators; the error in karats, the false-pass rate on plated and base pieces, and the spread between operators published with the raw readings.

Open 02 · the brief

A melt-value payout tracker

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public weekly table of what gold buyers offer for scrap jewelry as a share of melt value (the day's gold price times the piece's purity and weight), covering mail-in buyers and pawn and jewelry chains that post per-gram or per-karat prices online, in the US and the UK.

Why it is still open

The 2009 Consumerist and Consumer Reports test and KPIX's 2010 test were one-off checks, and KPIX's found offers from 20% to 65% of melt for the same pieces. In 2010 Rob Bates, JCK's news director, asked whether there should be an industry standard for how much buyers pay, and none was found. A September 2025 report by WCPO, a Cincinnati TV station, explained low payouts without measuring them.

cbsnews.comjckonline.comwcpo.com

Built with what exists

A Python scraper that keeps to each site's robots.txt and terms; a daily gold benchmark such as the LBMA Gold Price or a free spot-price feed; SQLite; a public chart. No gold is sold.

  1. First step

    List 30 buyers that post scrap prices online and record one week of their prices by hand.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 30 buyers tracked weekly for six months, with payout as a share of melt value for 10, 14 and 18 karat, and the method and raw data published.

Open 03 · the brief

A register of fake-gold loans

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open table of court judgments, CBI cases and press reports since 2015 in which Indian lenders lent against fake or plated gold, or had pledged gold swapped, coding the lender type, amount, number of loans, how it came to light (audit, revaluation, auction or default) and the appraiser's role.

Why it is still open

The RBI's 2024 circular lists weaknesses but gives no counts, and Maharana's paper cites "field experience and internal loss analysis" without publishing them. A search found about ten separate news reports from 2019 to 2026, at Bank of Baroda, Canara Bank, Union Bank of India, Karnataka Bank and others, and no compiled count.

rbi.org.intheijire.com

Built with what exists

Indian Kanoon, a free search engine for Indian court judgments; CBI press releases; newspaper archives; a document-reading model to pull the fields (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"), with a person checking every row; pandas.

  1. First step

    Search Indian Kanoon for "spurious gold" judgments from 2024 to 2026 and code the first 20.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 150 cases coded, each linked to its source, with the share caught by audit against the share found only at auction or default, and the median loss, published with a codebook.