Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Agriculture and farming / Nut and fruit orchards
Water and frost
This is keeping trees supplied with water through droughts and pumping limits, and keeping buds, blossoms and fruit alive through freezes, spring frosts and changing winters.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1915 to 2025.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1915
Oil fires against frost
Much of Southern California's citrus belt had been sold to investors as "frost free", but freezes struck it in 1913, 1922, 1927, 1932, 1937 and 1949. Growers burned low-grade crude oil in pots among the trees, called smudge pots for their sooty smoke, and there were at least a million in the groves by 1915, the writer D.J. Waldie records. Floyd Young of the US Weather Bureau told growers in 1937 that the freeze that year was more severe than 1913's except where temperatures were "materially affected by mass orchard heating". The soot shut the Port of Los Angeles during the 1922 freeze, a 1947 state law outlawed many older smoky heaters, and by 1949 growers were trying wind machines: aircraft propellers on towers, driven by 125 hp motors, that pull down the slightly warmer air lying above the cold layer.
LessonFrost protection that blackens a region's air gets regulated; the 1947 law pushed growers toward cleaner heaters and wind machines.
Credit
Southern California citrus growers; Floyd D. Young, US Weather Bureau, Pomona
1989
Freezes push citrus south
The freeze of Christmas Day 1983 cost Florida's citrus industry $1.5 billion, by the count of Florida Citrus Mutual, a growers' association. By January 1985 the state had 120,000 fewer acres (about 49,000 ha) of citrus than the more than 800,000 acres (about 324,000 ha) it had before that freeze, and a new freeze that month killed many replanted trees. Florida Citrus Mutual says the state lost some 2,000 to 2,500 growers after the 1983 and 1985 freezes. After the Christmas freeze of 1989, the fourth in ten years, the USDA expected Florida's orange juice output to fall 42%, and growers in northern counties such as Lake moved to the flat land farther south or left the business.
LessonAn industry planted at the cold edge of its crop's range moved rather than replant once freezes came every few years.
Credit
a failure; counts by Florida Citrus Mutual and the USDA, reported by The Christian Science Monitor
1992
A bagged leaf reads thirst
A pressure chamber measures how hard a tree is pulling on its water: a cut leaf is sealed in a steel chamber and gas pressure is raised until sap appears at the cut end. Harold McCutchan and K. A. Shackel showed in prune trees that stem water potential, read from a leaf that has been enclosed in a bag before it is cut, varied less than the usual leaf reading, followed the day's evaporative demand, and picked up the mild stress of irrigating only after half the soil moisture was used, which leaf readings missed (Journal of the American Society for Horticultural Science, 1992). PMS Instrument, a maker of pressure chambers, sells foil-laminate bags for the method cut to fit almond, prune and walnut leaves.
Credit
Harold McCutchan and K. A. Shackel
2009
Winters too warm for nuts
Many fruit and nut trees need a certain amount of winter cold, called chill, before they flower and leaf out normally. Eike Luedeling, Minghua Zhang and Evan Girvetz of the University of California, Davis modeled chill across California from temperature records for 1950 and 2000 and for 18 future climate scenarios, and mapped "safe winter chill", the amount growers can expect in nine winters out of ten. In every emissions scenario chill fell, and for many tree species and varieties the area with enough safe chill shrank 50–75% by the middle of the century and 90–100% by its end. They wrote that California's tree crop industry would likely need low-chill varieties and dormancy-breaking chemicals, and that some crops might no longer be possible.
Credit
Eike Luedeling, Minghua Zhang and Evan H. Girvetz (PLoS ONE, July 2009)
2012
Early warmth, then frost
In Michigan, normally the largest tart cherry state, record high temperatures early in spring 2012 brought trees into growth early, and the cold and repeated frosts that followed killed the crop; the USDA's June forecast said "the majority of growers lost all of their harvestable crop". The final USDA count was 11.6 million pounds (about 5,300 t) of tart cherries, 92% less than 2011's 157.5 million pounds (about 71,400 t) and the worst year since records began in 1925, and Michigan's apple crop was its smallest since 1945.
LessonEarly warmth does the damage, by pushing buds out before the usual spring frosts have passed.
Credit
a failure; counts by USDA's National Agricultural Statistics Service, reported by Michigan Public
2014
Groundwater gets a deadline
In 2014 Governor Jerry Brown signed three bills, AB 1739, SB 1168 and SB 1319, known together as the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA), California's first framework for keeping groundwater use sustainable; local groundwater sustainability agencies must write and carry out plans for each high- and medium-priority basin, and basins have until 2040 or 2042 to reach sustainable use. Orchards need water every year, rain or drought. In 2026 growers on the eastern side of the Turlock subbasin may pump 1.6 acre-feet per acre (about 490 mm of water), while almonds typically need 3 to 4 acre-feet (about 910 to 1,220 mm), and in 2025 orchard removal companies in the valley could not keep up with demand (California Farm Bureau's Ag Alert, May 2026). Land IQ's satellite mapping for the Almond Board of California counted 37,149 acres (about 15,000 ha) of almonds removed between September 2024 and March 2025, for all causes, and 19,927 acres (about 8,100 ha) potentially abandoned.
LessonA tree cannot be left unwatered for a dry year the way a field of an annual crop can be left fallow, so when water is cut for good the orchard is pulled out.
Credit
California Legislature (Assembly member Roger Dickinson, Senator Fran Pavley) and the Department of Water Resources; mapping by Land IQ
2025
Turkey's April frost
Turkey is the world's largest supplier of hazelnuts. After an April 2025 frost, the Turkish Statistical Institute (TurkStat) put the hazelnut crop at 520,000 t in June, against an initial forecast of 750,000 t; the International Nut and Dried Fruit Council later gave 601,000 t in shell, citing the Black Sea exporters' association, a 22% fall with about 167,000 t lost to frost. Hazelnut prices rose by more than 35%. TurkStat's year-end figures put the country's fruit, beverage and spice crops down 30.9% to about 19.6 million t in a year of frost and drought.
Credit
a failure; counts by TurkStat and the International Nut and Dried Fruit Council, reported by FreshPlaza and bianet
Watch for
Drones stir warm air down
On clear, calm nights the coldest air settles at the ground under a layer of warmer air, and helicopters are sometimes flown over orchards to mix the two. A fruit grower in Franklin County, in the United States, worked with Precision Drone Services to fly a four-rotor drone with a 10-foot (3 m) span over the trees on a frost night for the same purpose; the grower reported some damage to apricots but less to nectarines and cherries, and said the result was still being assessed.
Achieved whentemperature loggers in rows the drone flies over and in rows it does not, on the same nights, show how many degrees it adds at blossom height and for how long, with bud kill counted in both.
Claimed by
the grower and Precision Drone Services, reported by the TV station WGAL and by FreshPlaza, April 2026
Open
01
Track orchards lost to pumping
A public, yearly table and map of almond, pistachio and walnut acres planted, removed and left stressed in each groundwater subbasin of the San Joaquin Valley, set beside each subbasin's pumping limit per acre.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Freeze claims against bloom
A public table of crop-insurance freeze and frost losses for apples, peaches and cherries in every US county from 1989 to 2026, set beside each year's modeled bloom date and the coldest night after bloom, and a model that estimates from weather alone which counties will suffer losses.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Track orchards lost to pumping
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public, yearly table and map of almond, pistachio and walnut acres planted, removed and left stressed in each groundwater subbasin of the San Joaquin Valley, set beside each subbasin's pumping limit per acre.
Why it is still open
Land IQ's mapping for the Almond Board counts removed and potentially abandoned almond acres for the whole state, not by subbasin, and does not cover other nut crops (Land IQ, November 2025). Removals under SGMA are reported grower by grower, such as a Merced County farmer who pulled about 170 acres of almonds and walnuts (Ag Alert, May 2026). Searches in November 2026 found no public table that ties orchard removals in each subbasin to that subbasin's pumping allocation. The state's own field-by-field crop maps, needed to build one, are public for water years 2014, 2016 and 2018 to 2023, with 2024 provisional (California Department of Water Resources).
Built with what exists
DWR's Statewide Crop Mapping files; DWR's Bulletin 118 groundwater subbasin boundaries; Sentinel-2 satellite images through Google Earth Engine or the Copernicus Data Space to cover years not yet mapped; OpenET field water-use estimates; QGIS or Python with GeoPandas; a small language model built for extraction, such as Meta's Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"), to pull each subbasin's allocation out of its groundwater sustainability plan and annual reports, with each figure checked by hand.
First step
Download DWR's 2014 and 2023 crop maps and the subbasin boundaries, and compute almond, pistachio and walnut acres per subbasin for both years.
Done looks like
A published table and map for every critically overdrafted San Joaquin Valley subbasin, with orchard acres by crop for each mapped year from 2014 to 2025, acres removed and stressed, and the allocation in force, where 300 randomly drawn fields checked against high-resolution imagery agree with the classification at least 95% of the time.
Open 02 · the brief
Freeze claims against bloom
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table of crop-insurance freeze and frost losses for apples, peaches and cherries in every US county from 1989 to 2026, set beside each year's modeled bloom date and the coldest night after bloom, and a model that estimates from weather alone which counties will suffer losses.
Why it is still open
In late April 2026 a freeze caused catastrophic damage to perennial crops in 13 states, from Michigan and Illinois to New York and Virginia, by the account of the Risk Management Agency (RMA), the USDA agency that runs crop insurance. Penn State Extension estimated losses of 70% to 90% for Pennsylvania apples and 90% to 100% for peaches, said that unusual spring weather pushed peaches and apples into vulnerable bloom stages at nearly the same time, and tracks the losses through weekly phenology reports, which record the trees' growth stages. RMA publishes its cause-of-loss records, with the month of loss, for every year since 1989, but searches found no published county-by-county analysis that ties these losses to bloom timing.
Built with what exists
RMA's Summary of Business with Month of Loss files; PRISM or Daymet daily temperature grids; chillR, an open R package by Eike Luedeling that turns temperature records into chill and heat sums and relates them to bloom dates; published critical temperatures for each bud stage; Python or R for the model.
First step
Download RMA's cause-of-loss files for 2012 and 2026, keep apples, peaches and cherries with freeze or frost as the cause, and map the indemnities by county for both years.
Done looks like
A published table covering every county with insured apples, peaches or cherries for each year from 1989 to 2026, and a model fitted on 1989 to 2020 that ranks counties by freeze loss for 2021 to 2026 from weather alone, scored against the indemnities actually paid and against a baseline of each county's past average.