BRENNEN

Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Agriculture and farming / Nut and fruit orchards

Pruning and training

Pruning and training is cutting and shaping trees from planting onward so that light reaches the fruit and each tree carries a crop it can size, including thinning surplus flowers and young fruit.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1693 to 2016.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1693

    Pruning rules in print

    Jean de La Quintinie directed the fruit and kitchen gardens of the French royal family at Versailles. His Instruction pour les jardins fruitiers et potagers appeared in English in 1693 as The Compleat Gard'ner, translated by John Evelyn. An abridged English edition of 1701 still promised readers "the Principal Rules of Pruning, either as to Dwarfs, or Wall-Trees", that is, small free-standing trees and trees trained flat against walls.

    archive.orgarchive.org

    Credit

    Jean de La Quintinie; John Evelyn, translator

  2. 1970s

    A V-shaped trellis

    At the Irrigation Research Institute in Tatura, Victoria, Australia, researchers trained peach, apricot and pear trees as two arms leaning out at 60° from the horizontal over the alleys, on a V-shaped trellis, at 1,670 to 2,000 trees per hectare and without dwarfing rootstocks. In apricot trials from 1976, trees fruited in their second year, reached full bearing in the fifth and gave average yields almost three times the district average from free-standing orchards at 300 trees per hectare; the trellis cost more to build and run, but returns more than paid for it, by the developers' figures.

    ishs.orgapi.crossref.org

    Credit

    Bas van den Ende, David Chalmers and J. E. Kenez, Irrigation Research Institute, Tatura

  3. c. 1994

    Olive trees as hedges

    Traditional Mediterranean olive groves hold 70 to 80 trees per hectare. In the 1990s growers and private companies in Catalonia, Spain, planted the first super-high-density orchards: narrow hedgerows of small-growing varieties such as Arbequina at 1,500 to 2,000 trees per hectare, pruned into a continuous wall so that a modified grape harvester can straddle the row. A 14-year University of Córdoba trial found its hedgerows still fully productive, against earlier experience of yields falling after 7 or 8 years from vigor and shade.

    LessonThe oldest such orchard, in its ninth season in 2002, had been set out east–west and too close for its deep, moist soil, and growers who skipped hard pruning in years three and four to take bigger crops left large side branches that shaded the lower canopy and cut the fifth year's yield, so row direction and early pruning decide whether a hedge orchard lasts.

    ucanr.edupmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    Catalan growers and private companies; Concepción Díez, Diego Barranco, Luis Rallo and colleagues (University of Córdoba); Paul Vossen (University of California Cooperative Extension), who reported the early history

  4. 2012

    Thinning advice from weather

    Thinning sprays make an apple tree drop some of its young fruit (fruitlets) so the rest grow large and the tree flowers again the next year. Measuring thinner response every year from 2000 to 2009 on Royal Gala, McIntosh and Ace Delicious trees, Cornell researchers found that fruitlets are most sensitive at 10–15 mm across and thin harder when the tree is short of carbohydrates, the sugars made by photosynthesis. They used the MaluSim carbon-balance model and weather forecasts to predict thinning response across New York "with good but not perfect success", and the Cornell Apple Carbohydrate Thinning Model now runs on NEWA, a public network of weather stations and crop forecasts.

    agris.fao.orgnewa.cornell.edu

    Credit

    Terence Robinson, Alan Lakso and Steve Hoying (Cornell University); NEWA

  5. 2016

    Thinning after carbaryl

    Carbaryl (sold as Sevin), alone or mixed with the growth regulators NAA or benzyladenine, was the most used post-bloom thinner in Brazilian apple orchards until its registration for that use was cancelled. Researchers led by José Luiz Petri tested metamitron, a compound that slows photosynthesis, on Fuji Suprema, MaxiGala and Fred Hough apples at Caçador, Santa Catarina, and found it reduced crop per tree and raised fruit weight in all three varieties, though the higher rate thinned MaxiGala too much (Revista Brasileira de Fruticultura, 2016).

    LessonWhen a standard orchard chemical loses its approval, a replacement with a different action has to be retested rate by rate and variety by variety, because the margin between thinning enough and thinning too much is narrow.

    doi.org

    Credit

    José Luiz Petri, Marcelo Couto, Gentil Carneiro Gabardo, Poliana Francescatto and Fernando José Hawerroth

Watch for

  1. Robot thins apples by size

    An automated fruitlet thinner built in Ontario, Canada, worked in 14 commercial high-density orchards in the 2026 season. It makes up to 10 thinning decisions a second, its six arms "cut, suck, eject" fruitlets that miss its size criteria, and its top rate was about 1,000 removals an hour; the developers plan 20 arms for 2027, which they project would cover 18 acres (about 7.3 ha) a day. They say it cannot yet recognize deformed or insect-damaged fruit when that fruit is the largest in a cluster.

    Achieved whena trial not run by the developers publishes, for robot-thinned and hand-thinned rows in the same block, fruit left per tree, wrong removals, hours per hectare, and fruit size at harvest and return bloom (flowering) the next spring.

    freshplaza.com

    Claimed by

    the developers, led by company president Matt Stevens, reported by Farmtario and FreshPlaza, August 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Score the thinning model

    A public scorecard of the Cornell Apple Carbohydrate Thinning Model: for every thinning spray in a set of orchard blocks, record the date, product, rate, fruitlet size and the model's predicted carbohydrate balance, then count the fruit set on tagged limbs and check whether the thinning was as strong or as weak as the model called it.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Benchmark for pruning choices

    An open benchmark of pruning decisions for Tall Spindle apple trees, a system with a central trunk and no permanent scaffold limbs: 3D scans of dormant trees in commercial blocks, each limb marked as kept or removed by three experienced pruners, published with a baseline model that marks the limbs to remove from the scan alone.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Score the thinning model

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public scorecard of the Cornell Apple Carbohydrate Thinning Model: for every thinning spray in a set of orchard blocks, record the date, product, rate, fruitlet size and the model's predicted carbohydrate balance, then count the fruit set on tagged limbs and check whether the thinning was as strong or as weak as the model called it.

Why it is still open

Cornell's developers call chemical thinning "one of the more unpredictable parts of apple production" and report predicting thinner response in New York "with good but not perfect success" (Robinson, Lakso and Hoying, 2012). The model is offered to growers on NEWA, but a search found no published hit rate across many orchards, regions and years.

agris.fao.orgnewa.cornell.edu

Built with what exists

The Cornell model on NEWA for stations in the US Northeast and Midwest; for other regions, a reimplementation from Cornell's published descriptions run on station data or Open-Meteo weather; fruitlet counts on tagged limbs; calipers or a phone fruit-sizing app; Python or R for the scoring.

  1. First step

    Apple orchards in southern Brazil, Chile, South Africa and New Zealand are thinning in November, so recruit two or three of them to tag ten limbs per sprayed block and log each spray; in the north, collect last season's spray and fruit-set records from extension thinning trials and rerun the model on the same dates.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 200 thinning sprays in at least 20 orchards over two seasons, each logged with the model's call and the measured fruit set, published with a hit rate (how often the measured response fell in the class the model called) and a list of the misses with their weather.

Open 02 · the brief

Benchmark for pruning choices

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open benchmark of pruning decisions for Tall Spindle apple trees, a system with a central trunk and no permanent scaffold limbs: 3D scans of dormant trees in commercial blocks, each limb marked as kept or removed by three experienced pruners, published with a baseline model that marks the limbs to remove from the scan alone.

Why it is still open

A Washington State University team identified pruning branches in Tall Spindle trees from 3D camera images (Karkee, Adhikari, Amatya and Zhang, Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 2014). A University of Sydney method suggests cuts from LiDAR scans to let more light into the tree, and its authors checked it against pruned tree models they built by hand, not against pruners' cuts (Westling, Underwood and Bryson, 2021). Interviews in Prosser, Washington, found that horticulturists, growers and pruners each approach pruning decisions differently (Flynn and colleagues, 2024). The newest robot work, from Oregon State University, steers a cutter to cut points that people choose: 10 of 14 field attempts succeeded on V-trellis apple trees (Jain, Grimm and Lee, September 2026). No public set of scanned trees carrying several pruners' decisions was found to score a model against.

api.crossref.orgarxiv.orgarxiv.orgarxiv.org

Built with what exists

A phone or tablet with a LiDAR sensor, or an Intel RealSense depth camera; CloudCompare and Open3D to clean and label point clouds; AdTree, an open tool from TU Delft that builds tree skeletons from scans; colored tape for pruners to mark limbs before a second scan; Python for the baseline model and the scoring.

  1. First step

    Before winter pruning starts in the Northern Hemisphere, scan 30 trees in one block, have two pruners tag the limbs they would remove with colored tape, scan again, and measure how often the two agree.

  2. Done looks like

    300 dormant Tall Spindle trees from at least three orchards and two varieties, scanned before pruning, with every limb labeled by three pruners, published openly with the pruners' agreement with one another and a baseline model whose agreement with each pruner is reported against that figure.