BRENNEN

Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Food and beverage processing / Meatpacking

By-products

By-products are everything from the animal that is not sold as meat, such as fat, bone, blood, hides, glands and intestines, which plants turn into feed, fuel, leather, medicine and sausage casings, or must destroy.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1923 to 2021.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1923

    Insulin from animal pancreas

    After insulin was discovered at the University of Toronto in 1922, Eli Lilly and Company signed an agreement with the university in May 1922 and made it from beef or hog pancreas. A large-scale plant ran from spring 1923, Lilly released insulin for prescription on 15 October 1923, and by the year's end it had sold almost 60 million units, by the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis's account.

    Lessona by-product's market can vanish; in 1982 Lilly brought out human insulin made by genetic engineering, which became the standard treatment.

    indyencyclopedia.org

    Credit

    University of Toronto; Eli Lilly and Company, through its research director George H. A. Clowes

  2. 1988

    Feed ban after BSE

    Rendering turns slaughter waste and dead animals into fat and meat-and-bone meal, which was fed to cattle. British government scientists first recognized BSE in November 1986, and the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) later agreed that it spread by feeding processed infected cattle to cattle, through processes that did not fully destroy the agent. The United Kingdom banned feeding ruminant protein to ruminants in 1988. Cases in Great Britain, over 165,000 by November 1996, peaked in January 1993, a lag that fits the disease's two- to eight-year incubation. The FDA's own ban on most mammal protein in cattle feed took effect on 4 August 1997, after an FDA survey in 1992 found a voluntary ban was not being kept.

    Lessonfeeding a species its own remains can multiply a disease, and voluntary limits did not stop it.

    federalregister.govfederalregister.gov

    Credit

    UK government; US FDA

  3. 2002

    Waste sorted by risk

    After crises with foot-and-mouth disease, BSE and dioxins in feed, an EU regulation of 2002, rewritten in 2009, sorted animal by-products into three categories by risk and required plants to keep them apart. Category 1, which includes specified risk material, may only be disposed of, for example by incineration. Category 3, parts of animals passed fit to eat but not sold as food, may go into pet food and animal feed.

    Lessonby-products can be put to use safely once the risky parts are kept out of the stream.

    eur-lex.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Parliament and Council of the EU

  4. 2008

    Contaminated heparin kills patients

    Heparin, a blood thinner, is drawn from the intestinal lining of slaughtered pigs, about 300 mg per animal, and the first extraction usually takes place at the slaughterhouse outside drug-manufacturing rules. In early 2008 heparin lots containing oversulfated chondroitin sulfate, a semi-synthetic look-alike, caused sudden allergic-type reactions. A 2009 review counts nearly 100 deaths in the United States, and the lots were withdrawn in March 2008.

    Lessona drug that starts as slaughterhouse waste is only as safe as its least-watched step, and since 2013 EU drug-manufacturing rules cover the heparin chain from the collection of raw material.

    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    an international group of laboratories working with the FDA, which identified the contaminant (Kishimoto and colleagues, New England Journal of Medicine, 2008); review by Robert Linhardt's laboratory at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute

  5. 2013

    Animal fat becomes diesel

    Diamond Green Diesel, a joint venture of the renderer Darling International and Valero Energy, began operating at Norco, Louisiana, in June 2013. It converts animal fats, used cooking oil and other feedstocks into renewable diesel, at a design rate of about 1.1 billion pounds of feedstock a year. By the US Energy Information Administration's monthly figures, US biofuel plants used about 7.3 billion pounds (3.3 million tonnes) of tallow, the hard fat of cattle and sheep, in 2024.

    sec.goveia.gov

    Credit

    Darling International; Valero Energy; UOP, which licensed the Ecofining process

  6. 2019

    Hides sent to landfill

    Cattle hides once added as much as $60 to the value of a fed steer and made up two-thirds of the value of all by-products, by beef columnist Steve Kay's account. After prices fell from 2018, the Leather and Hide Council of America said about 5.5 million US cattle hides, nearly 16% of those produced, failed to reach tanneries in 2019 and almost all went to landfill. Branded cow hides had no market at all.

    Lessona by-product's value depends on markets outside the plant, here shoe and car makers' shift to synthetic materials.

    wlj.net

    Credit

    figures from the Leather and Hide Council of America, reported in Western Livestock Journal in 2020

  7. 2021

    Pig protein back in feed

    In August 2021 the EU again allowed processed animal protein from pigs in poultry feed and from poultry in pig feed, and insect protein in both, all long barred under its BSE rules. It kept the ban on feeding any species its own kind and the ban on ruminant protein, though it now allows collagen and gelatin from ruminants in pig and poultry feed. It relied on DNA (PCR) tests, validated in 2012, 2015 and 2018, that can find ruminant, pig or poultry material in feed.

    Lessona blanket ban can be narrowed once a test can show that the narrower rule is kept.

    eur-lex.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Commission; the EU Reference Laboratory for Animal Proteins in feedingstuffs; EFSA

Watch for

  1. Cattle heparin invited back

    The FDA is encouraging companies to make heparin from cattle again and offers early meetings to sponsors, saying a second source would protect supply against shortage or contamination of pig heparin. The first US heparins of the 1930s came from cattle lung, which makers withdrew in the late 1990s over BSE fears, and heparin from cattle intestine is made today in Brazil and Argentina.

    Achieved whenthe FDA approves a heparin made from cattle and it goes on sale in the United States.

    fda.govpharmanow.live

    Claimed by

    US FDA, notice of June 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Tannery grade from packer photos

    A camera station where hides come off the carcass that photographs each green (untreated) hide and predicts the grade the tannery will give it after the first tanning step, with each hide's tag carried through to the tannery's grading table. It would also count flay cuts, the knife cuts made in removing the hide, which are the packer's own fault.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Machine check of natural casings

    An inline camera system that checks cleaned pig intestines for leftover impurities before they are sold as natural sausage casings, and a published comparison with human graders on the same casings.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Tannery grade from packer photos

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A camera station where hides come off the carcass that photographs each green (untreated) hide and predicts the grade the tannery will give it after the first tanning step, with each hide's tag carried through to the tannery's grading table. It would also count flay cuts, the knife cuts made in removing the hide, which are the packer's own fault.

Why it is still open

Hides are graded by eye for brands, horn marks, scratches, insect damage and flay cuts, usually at the tannery and often after the first tanning step, the "wet-blue" stage, because some faults are hard to see later. A 2016 Meat & Livestock Australia project by Scott Automation found hyperspectral imaging could not tell defects from clean hide after chemical treatment. It suggested 3D and color cameras for wet-blue hides, and noted that green hides shipped overseas could not be checked against their later grades. Fraunhofer ITWM says leather is usually still inspected by eye, 100% of it, and the leather-defect projects found on GitHub work on tanned leather, not raw hides. Nothing found for this file predicts tannery grades from the packer's side.

mla.com.auitwm.fraunhofer.de

Built with what exists

An overhead color camera and LED lighting over the hide conveyor; a low-cost depth camera such as an Intel RealSense or Orbbec unit; numbered tags or RFID tags that survive tanning; and an open segmentation model such as Ultralytics YOLO, fine-tuned on a single GPU.

  1. First step

    Agree with a packer and the tannery that buys its hides to track 100 tagged hides, photograph them at the packer, and collect the tannery's grade sheet for each.

  2. Done looks like

    For 2,000 hides tracked from one packer to one tannery, the model gives the tannery's grade exactly for at least 70% of hides and within one grade for at least 95%, and finds at least 90% of the brands and flay cuts the tannery records. Photos, grades and the tally are published.

Open 02 · the brief

Machine check of natural casings

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An inline camera system that checks cleaned pig intestines for leftover impurities before they are sold as natural sausage casings, and a published comparison with human graders on the same casings.

Why it is still open

In a 2021 report from the Danish Technological Institute, Aske Bach Lassen wrote that pig intestines are cleaned in Europe and then sent to China for manual quality control and grading. A machine already checks leaks and grades and cuts casings, he wrote, and checking for impurities is the one step left to automate. His report compared two image segmentation methods on still images and reported no trial on a line or against graders. A search for this file found patents for calibrating machines but no impurity checker in published use.

zenodo.org

Built with what exists

A backlit area or line-scan camera; open segmentation software such as Detectron2 or Ultralytics YOLO; and a reference set of casings graded by experienced graders.

  1. First step

    Buy cleaned, ungraded hog casings from a casing supplier, photograph 100 meters of them on a light table, and have one experienced grader mark the impurities to make a first labeled set.

  2. Done looks like

    On 500 casing bundles graded separately by two experienced graders, the system flags at least 95% of the impurities both graders mark and wrongly flags no more than 10% of clean lengths. Images, labels and the tally are published.