BRENNEN

Industries / Consumer goods / Furniture / Mattresses

Testing comfort

Comfort testing measures how a mattress feels and how that feel changes with use: how firm it is, how it supports and spreads body weight, how much it sags over the years, and, with sensors in the bed, how its owner sleeps.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1999 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1999

    US lab tests for springs

    ASTM F1566-99, the earliest edition in ASTM's store, set lab tests for firmness, firmness retention, durability and impact, but only for bare innersprings and boxsprings (the sprung base under a mattress). The 2014 edition, reaffirmed in 2021 and still active, covers finished mattresses and cores of foam or air chambers and adds a test of height change. ASTM says its results are "for comparative analysis with no pass/fail criteria".

    store.astm.orgstore.astm.org

    Credit

    ASTM International

  2. 2000

    Europe sets a hardness test

    CEN, the European standards body, published EN 1957 in 2000, a set of lab methods for the hardness and durability of mattresses and beds; the 2012 edition replaced it and was confirmed again in July 2024. An annex gives a firmness rating that tracks how people judge firmness, but the standard says it "cannot be used to demonstrate comfort and/or quality".

    LessonOf the clinical studies in a 2021 review, only one rated its mattresses on this scale; the rest described firmness in their own words.

    evs.eegenorma.compmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    CEN technical committee CEN/TC 207, Furniture

  3. 2003

    Medium-firm beats firm

    In a trial published in The Lancet in November 2003, Francisco Kovacs and colleagues in Spain gave 313 adults with chronic low back pain of no known cause either a firm mattress, rated 2.3 on the European hardness scale, or a medium-firm one, rated 5.6, without telling them which. After 90 days the medium-firm group reported less pain in bed, less pain on rising and less disability. Later reviews agreed: Radwan and colleagues (24 studies, 2015), and Caggiari and colleagues, whose 2026 update of 47 studies calls medium-firm "the most defensible general recommendation".

    LessonFirm mattresses had been commonly recommended for back pain without evidence, the authors noted, and when tested the firm mattress did worse.

    ebi.ac.ukeurekalert.orgebi.ac.ukpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    Francisco Kovacs and colleagues, Kovacs Foundation, Palma de Mallorca

  4. 2014

    Shoppers measured in the store

    By June 2014 Kingsdown, a North Carolina mattress maker, had its bedMATCH system in US stores: the shopper answers questions, then lies on a sensor bed for about five minutes while it takes 18 measurements and assigns one of four color-coded support groups, each pointing to beds of any brand in the store. Beter Bed, a chain of more than 100 stores in the Netherlands and Belgium, took it up in 2022, and in 2019 the UK chain Dreams rolled out a system with the same 18 measurements, Sleepmatch, to its 195 stores. By Kingsdown's count, by August 2026 bedMATCH held more than 25 million shopper profiles in more than 2,000 stores.

    LessonThese systems grew on their makers' own research; the 2010 study behind bedMATCH came from the Sleep to Live Institute, whose system Kingsdown developed.

    rss.globenewswire.comhomenewsnow.comfurniturenews.netbedtimesmagazine.comprnewswire.com

    Credit

    Kingsdown; Beter Bed and Dreams as users

  5. 2022

    Firmness labels checked by machine

    Consumer Reports in the US presses each mattress with a load of up to 1,000 newtons (about the weight of 100 kg) and turns the dent into its own 1-to-10 score. In April 2022 it reported that its results are "often quite a contrast" to makers' labels; the Purple Hybrid, which Purple calls its firmest model, scored 3 out of 10. Stiftung Warentest, the German consumer tester, measures hardness in its lab and wrote in October 2026 that makers' hardness claims "often do not match" ("die Härteangaben der Hersteller stimmen oft nicht"). The testers' scales run in opposite directions: on Consumer Reports' scale 10 is firmest, while on the scale of Which?, the UK tester, 1 is firmest.

    LessonA firmness number tells a buyer little unless they know whose scale it is on.

    yahoo.comyahoo.comtest.dewhich.co.uk

    Credit

    Consumer Reports; Stiftung Warentest; Which?

  6. 2025

    Bed sensors checked against lab

    A Flinders University team in Australia compared the Withings Sleep Analyzer, a sensor pad that goes under the mattress, with polysomnography, a lab sleep study that records brain waves, breathing and heart, over 416 recordings from 183 people. The pad agreed with the lab's sleep-or-wake call 83% of the time: it caught 95% of the time spent asleep but only 37% of the time spent awake, and overstated total sleep by about 48 minutes. A 2022 study of Sleep Number's smart bed, run by the company's own staff, found the same pattern (sleep found 94% of the time, wake 48%). In September 2024 Withings announced that the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) had cleared its Sleep Rx under-mattress device for diagnosing sleep apnea.

    LessonA sensor under the mattress is good at telling that someone is asleep and poor at telling that they are awake.

    pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govhitconsultant.net

    Credit

    Jack Manners, Hannah Scott and colleagues, Flinders University; Withings; Sleep Number

Watch for

  1. Apnea checks from a cover

    Eight Sleep, a US company, sells a mattress cover with built-in sensors. In August 2025 it said it would move into medical uses including sleep apnea, repeated pauses in breathing during sleep, and was "targeting FDA approval for certain applications". In August 2026 its chief executive told Fortune that its FDA filing for detecting and reducing apnea was going "fairly smoothly"; Fortune reported no accuracy figures and said only one independent study of the product's benefits had been published.

    Achieved whenthe FDA lists a clearance for the apnea feature, and a study run outside the company reports its accuracy against polysomnography.

    beddingnewsnow.comfortune.com

    Claimed by

    Eight Sleep (chief executive Matteo Franceschetti), August 2025, repeated August 2026

  2. AI agents in store fitting

    Kingsdown says it is adding "AI-agent capabilities" to bedMATCH; an AI agent is software built on an AI language model that carries out tasks by itself. Kingsdown says the feature will guide both sales staff and shoppers to a mattress, and gives no launch date or performance figures.

    Achieved whenan outside retailer or reporter describes the feature in routine store use and reports how it changes the recommendations.

    bedtimesmagazine.com

    Claimed by

    Kingsdown, July 2026 (in BedTimes magazine)

Open

  1. 01

    An open firmness table

    A low-cost, portable rig, with a published design, that measures how far a mattress sinks under known loads, and a public table of measured firmness built with it, each value set beside the seller's label: a 1-to-10 number, a word such as "medium-firm", or a German hardness grade such as H2 or H3.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Fitting systems, tested twice

    A check of whether in-store fitting systems give the same answer twice: the same people scanned several times, in several stores, on the same system, with the recommended support group logged each time.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

An open firmness table

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A low-cost, portable rig, with a published design, that measures how far a mattress sinks under known loads, and a public table of measured firmness built with it, each value set beside the seller's label: a 1-to-10 number, a word such as "medium-firm", or a German hardness grade such as H2 or H3.

Why it is still open

Several testers measure firmness by machine, but each publishes only its own scores, mostly behind paywalls and on scales that run in opposite directions. Stiftung Warentest keeps its results for 115 mattresses behind a paywall. RTINGS publishes a measured stiffness for each mattress it reviews (47 pascals per millimeter for one Beautyrest model), but its method pages are for members only. GoodBed, which tests with the chemical company Dow, says it will only "selectively share" findings. A 2026 review of the clinical studies calls for "standardized definitions of mattress firmness". Searches in November 2026 found only commercial test machines and patents, no open rig.

test.dertings.comgoodbed.compmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Built with what exists

A rigid plywood disc about 35 cm across; cast-iron gym weight plates stacked in steps up to about 30 kg; an aluminum straightedge bridged across the mattress carrying a long-travel digital dial indicator to read the sink depth; Python to log readings and fit load against depth; an AI language model to sort sellers' free-text firmness labels, collected from product pages in several languages, into one field; GitHub or Zenodo to publish the drawings, code and raw readings.

  1. First step

    Build the disc-and-weights rig, measure one mattress at three spots three times each to check the spread, then measure one model that RTINGS has reviewed and compare.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 30 mattresses from at least 8 brands, each measured at 3 spots, with repeat runs agreeing within 5%; at least 10 carry a German H grade and at least 10 a 1-to-10 or word label; a public table gives measured stiffness in pascals per millimeter beside each label, under an open license; and for 5 models that RTINGS has also measured, the rig ranks them in the same order.

Open 02 · the brief

Fitting systems, tested twice

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A check of whether in-store fitting systems give the same answer twice: the same people scanned several times, in several stores, on the same system, with the recommended support group logged each time.

Why it is still open

Kingsdown reports more than 25 million bedMATCH profiles, and a patent held by Xsensor Technology for a rival method based on pressure mapping (a sheet of sensors that shows where the body presses) says its recommendations "are consistent from store to store". But the evidence behind these systems comes from their makers: the 2010 study behind bedMATCH came from an institute tied to Kingsdown, and the 2019 report on the Dreams rollout cites no independent testing. Searches in November 2026 found no published independent test of repeatability.

patents.google.comfurniturenews.netprnewswire.com

Built with what exists

A written protocol (same clothes, same answers to the questionnaire, body weight within 1 kg); Google Forms or a shared spreadsheet to log each scan; a phone camera to record each result screen or printout; retailers' store-locator pages to find systems; Python with scikit-learn's Cohen's kappa, a measure of agreement beyond chance.

  1. First step

    Find two nearby stores that list bedMATCH, ask each manager for permission to take repeat scans at a quiet hour, and run three scans on one person at each store.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 60 scans, from 5 adults each scanned 3 times in each of 4 stores, with the share of repeat scans giving the same support group reported for each person, each store and overall, and the store list, protocol and raw log published.