Industries / Consumer goods / Luxury goods
Resale
Resale is the buying and selling of used luxury goods: consignment sites that check, grade and price them, the trade-in schemes some houses run, auctions of rare pieces, and disputes between houses and resellers over what is genuine.
6
Milestones achieved, from 2009 to 2025.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
3
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
2009
A site for used luxury
Fanny Moizant and Sophie Hersan started Vestiaire Collective in Paris, first as "Vestiaire de Copines", an online market for used luxury pieces. In March 2021 Kering took a stake of about 5% and a board seat in a €178 million funding round backed by Kering and Tiger Global, and François-Henri Pinault said pre-owned luxury was "a real and deeply rooted trend, especially among younger customers".
Credit
Fanny Moizant and Sophie Hersan; Kering
2019
Fakes at a listed reseller
The RealReal, founded by Julie Wainwright and incorporated in March 2011, sells used luxury goods on consignment, selling for the owner and keeping a share, and listed its shares in June 2019. In November 2019 CNBC, after interviewing nearly three dozen former employees, reported that copywriters with "little training on how to spot fakes" were doing some authentication and that staff worked to quotas such as 105 items a shift; the company pointed to its "zero-tolerance policy for counterfeiting". Chanel's lawsuit against The RealReal, filed in 2018, is still open, and in March 2026 a judge dismissed five of The RealReal's counterclaims.
LessonA promise to authenticate every item is only as good as the training and time behind each check.
Credit
CNBC (investigation)
2020
Houses sell used goods
In October 2020 Gucci opened an online shop with The RealReal selling used Gucci pieces, which The RealReal called the first time a brand had encouraged its community "not only to consign, but to shop resale". In February 2021 Alexander McQueen began "Brand Approved" with Vestiaire Collective, checking clients' old pieces itself and giving them store credit, and in March 2023 Gucci began taking used pieces back in its stores for credit in seven European markets, on Vestiaire's software.
Credit
Gucci, Alexander McQueen, The RealReal and Vestiaire Collective
2024
Chanel wins on serial numbers
Chanel sued What Goes Around Comes Around (WGACA), a New York reseller, in 2018. About 30,000 serial numbers had been stolen in 2012 from Renato Corti, a factory that made Chanel bags, and in March 2022 the court ruled for Chanel on eleven bags carrying stolen numbers. In February 2024 a jury found WGACA liable on all counts and awarded Chanel $4 million in statutory damages. The final judgment of February 2025 bars WGACA from claiming its goods are genuine without documented proof of its own checks, and the federal appeals court upheld it on 3 November 2026.
LessonA house's records of which serial numbers are valid can decide what a court treats as genuine.
thefashionlaw.comkatten.comthefashionlaw.comthefashionlaw.com
Credit
Chanel; US District Court for the Southern District of New York
2025
A €8.6 million Birkin
In July 2025 Sotheby's sold in Paris the original Birkin bag that Hermès made for Jane Birkin in 1985, for €8.6 million ($10.1 million), which Sotheby's says is the most valuable handbag ever sold at auction. The Irish Times reported that the buyer was a private collector from Japan.
Credit
Sotheby's; Hermès
2025
Birkin premiums shrink
The premium a Birkin or Kelly bag fetched on resale over its shop price fell from 2.2 times in 2022 to 1.4 times, by Bernstein's secondhand pricing tracker as reported by Fortune in December 2025. Reuters reported in October 2026 that a Birkin 25 resold for about 1.7 times retail in the third quarter, down from about 2.6 times at the 2022 peak, though the reseller Fashionphile said its prices had "remained firm and even risen slightly". Rebag's annual Clair report put Hermès's value retention at 138% in 2025.
LessonMeasures of the same bags point in different directions, so a resale price depends on whose data it comes from.
Credit
Bernstein; Reuters
Watch for
AI checks at The RealReal
The RealReal says its AI tool Athena proposes item descriptions and prices and helps tell authentic products from fakes, and that 27% of the items it processed in late September 2025 went through Athena, a share it expected to reach as much as 40% by the end of December; a second tool, Vision, works from magnified images. It has published no accuracy rate.
Achieved whenthe company reports the share in a filing and an outside party measures how often items Athena passes prove fake, or genuine items it rejects.
Claimed by
The RealReal, January 2026, as reported by the Wall Street Journal
Used luxury inside ChatGPT
Vestiaire Collective opened its catalogue inside ChatGPT in November 2026, so shoppers can search and compare items there and then buy on Vestiaire's own site; its chief product officer said "AI has a role to play at both ends of our value chain".
Achieved whenVestiaire reports how many orders or how much sales value come through ChatGPT.
Claimed by
Vestiaire Collective, November 2026
Open
01
Same bag, many quotes
A controlled test in which the same 30 genuine used bags are submitted, with the same photos and honest descriptions, for instant purchase and consignment quotes and condition grades to five resellers in each of three countries, with every quote, grade and photo set published.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
An open sold-price index
A free monthly index of sold prices, not asking prices, for the 20 most-traded used bag models, gathered from at least five platforms and auction results, matched by model, size and material, with the method and data published.
The briefCredit · unclaimed03
Grade bag condition openly
A public set of photos of at least 1,000 used bags, each graded for condition by at least three authenticators on one published scale, with how often they agree and a baseline model that grades from the photos.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Same bag, many quotes
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A controlled test in which the same 30 genuine used bags are submitted, with the same photos and honest descriptions, for instant purchase and consignment quotes and condition grades to five resellers in each of three countries, with every quote, grade and photo set published.
Why it is still open
The nearest test found is a blog post from around 2020 that sent one Louis Vuitton Lockit bag to six platforms and got quotes from $350 to $840–980. Secondsense's Spread Index of August 2026 compares asking prices with sold prices for 198 listings, not quotes for the same item. A search found no controlled study across many bags or countries.
Built with what exists
Bags lent by owners or a consignment shop; the resellers' own quote forms, such as Rebag's Clair; Browser Use to record each form's answer where the site's terms allow (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); a spreadsheet.
First step
Photograph five bags to each platform's instructions and request quotes from five US resellers in one week.
Done looks like
30 bags, five resellers and three countries, with the highest and lowest quote for each bag, how often the condition grades agree, and the spread by brand published.
Open 02 · the brief
An open sold-price index
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A free monthly index of sold prices, not asking prices, for the 20 most-traded used bag models, gathered from at least five platforms and auction results, matched by model, size and material, with the method and data published.
Why it is still open
Rebag's Clair Report is yearly and draws on "retail price, demand, and research". Glampot publishes quarterly sold prices for Malaysia only and bars bulk reproduction of its tables. Secondsense shares its underlying data only by email. A search found no open, monthly series of sold prices across platforms.
Built with what exists
Platforms and auction houses that show sold prices publicly; Browser Use (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); a vision-language model such as Claude Fable 5.2 to check that each listing's photos match its stated model and size (see the Note "Three working devices"); a spreadsheet or database.
First step
List the 20 models and find which platforms show sold prices without a login.
Done looks like
12 months of median price and range for 20 models from at least five sources, every sale linked, with a published comparison against the resale figures reported by Bernstein and Rebag for the same period.
Open 03 · the brief
Grade bag condition openly
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public set of photos of at least 1,000 used bags, each graded for condition by at least three authenticators on one published scale, with how often they agree and a baseline model that grades from the photos.
Why it is still open
RISE, the Swedish research institute, published 31,997 second-hand garments with condition grades on a 1-to-5 scale under CC BY 4.0, but no such set was found for bags: Innovatiana's Chanel image set carries no condition grades, The RealReal uses its own scale running from Pristine to As-Is, and Entrupy sells condition grading without a published method.
zenodo.orginnovatiana.comresources.therealreal.comentrupy.com
Built with what exists
A light box and a phone camera; Label Studio; a vision-language model such as Claude Fable 5.2 to draft grades for people to correct (see the Note "Three working devices"); Meta's DINOv2 as a baseline.
First step
Borrow 50 bags from one consignment shop and have three of its graders score them from the same photos.
Done looks like
1,000 bags from at least ten brands, three grades each, an agreement score published for each grade, and the share of bags the baseline grades within one step of the graders' median.