Industries / Finance and business services / Insurance / InsurTech
Insurance sold inside other products
Cover offered at the moment of another purchase, such as a phone, a flight, a ride, a car or an online order, often through software that links the seller to an insurer.
6
Milestones achieved, from 2014 to 2024.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
2014
Add-ons rarely paid out
Add-on insurance is cover sold alongside another product. In a market study of it, the FCA found that GAP insurance, which covers the gap between a written-off car's value and what was paid or owed for it, paid out an average of 10% of premiums in claims from 2008 to 2012. Personal accident add-ons paid out less than 9%, against 64% for personal insurance generally. It proposed banning pre-ticked boxes, a delay before GAP cover could be sold, and the publication of claims ratios.
LessonCover sold as an extra to a bigger purchase faced little competition and paid out little.
Credit
FCA (Christopher Woolard)
2016
Protection plans at checkout
SquareTrade, founded in 1999, sold protection plans for electronics through retailers including Amazon, Costco, Sam's Club, Target and Staples. It had "25 million plans in force" when Allstate agreed to buy it for about $1.4 billion in November 2016, Insurance Journal reported.
Credit
SquareTrade; Allstate
2016
Returns insured at checkout
On Taobao, Alibaba's shopping site, ZhongAn sold insurance that pays the shipping cost if a buyer returns an item, for an average fee of CNY 0.4 against an average shipping cost of CNY 12. In 2014 this cover brought in CNY 613 million, 77% of ZhongAn's premiums, falling to 35% in 2016. On 11 November 2016, a shopping festival day, more than 600 million such policies were sold. Gen Re calls that a world record for a single product line in a single day.
Credit
ZhongAn; Alibaba's Taobao
2016
Nine cents a dollar
ASIC, Australia's corporate regulator, found that add-on insurance sold through car dealers paid "only nine cents for every dollar of premium paid", $144 million in claims against $1.6 billion in premiums. Insurers had paid $602.2 million in commissions to car dealers, some as high as 79% of the premium. From 5 October 2021 Australia required a "mandatory four-day pause" between the main sale and the sale of add-on insurance.
LessonWhere sellers earned more in commission than buyers got back in claims, the remedy chosen was to slow the sale down.
Credit
Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC)
2018
Cover for each ride
In April 2018 Ola, the Indian ride-hailing company, began offering in-trip insurance for INR 1 a ride within a city, with Acko General Insurance as the first insurer. Once a rider agreed, the premium was added to later rides until they switched it off. By February 2019 riders were taking "20 million in-trip micro-insurance policies" a month, The News Minute reported.
LessonAgreeing once and paying on every ride made the cover a default.
Credit
Ola; Acko General Insurance
2024
GAP sales paused
The FCA found that in 2022 "only 6% of the amount customers paid in premiums for GAP insurance was paid out in the claims", and that some firms paid "as much as 70%" in commission. Firms agreed to pause sales on 9 February 2024. Four firms restarted in May 2024 with "materially lower levels of commission". The FCA's figures put the claims ratio for stand-alone GAP at 7% in 2022, 22% in 2023, 104% in 2024, when sales were paused for part of the year, and 53% in 2025. The FCA says these figures "should still be used with caution".
LessonAfter commissions were cut, buyers got back a much larger share of what they paid.
Credit
FCA
Watch for
Cover offered by AI agents
Cover Genius, which sells insurance through other companies' checkouts, launched a product that lets AI agents "surface context-aware protection natively inside consumer conversations". Its own survey found "fewer than 7% want an agent selecting or purchasing paid protection autonomously". It names no launch partners. Insurance Journal reported in July 2026 that Cover Genius had raised $100 million at a $1.9 billion valuation.
Achieved whena named AI assistant offers the cover and an outside party reports how many buyers take it up and claim on it.
Claimed by
Cover Genius, October 2026
Open
01
Checkout add-ons on record
A public audit of how insurance is offered at the online checkouts of 50 airlines, electronics shops and ticket sellers in five European countries, repeated every quarter. A script goes through each checkout up to the payment page, without buying. It records whether cover is pre-selected, the price shown, whether the IPID and the insurer's name are shown, and how many clicks it takes to decline.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Add-on value over time
A free explorer of the FCA's General Insurance Value Measures, covering every release since the pilot. The measures include claims frequency, the share of claims accepted, average payouts and claims ratios by product. Add-on and stand-alone versions of a product are shown side by side, and each change in the FCA's method is marked.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Checkout add-ons on record
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public audit of how insurance is offered at the online checkouts of 50 airlines, electronics shops and ticket sellers in five European countries, repeated every quarter. A script goes through each checkout up to the payment page, without buying. It records whether cover is pre-selected, the price shown, whether the IPID and the insurer's name are shown, and how many clicks it takes to decline.
Why it is still open
The work found is one-off or broader. Which? reported on airlines' travel insurance in 2009 and 2014. EIOPA's 2019 review of travel insurance used supervisory data, and found commissions of about 24% of premiums against an average claims ratio of 40%. The EU's 2023 sweep of 399 online shops for misleading design does not mention insurance.
Built with what exists
Playwright to script the checkouts and take screenshots, used within each site's terms; the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine to keep copies; a browser agent such as Browser Use for checkouts that change often (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over").
First step
Script one airline's checkout to the payment page and record the five fields by hand.
Done looks like
50 sites in five countries checked every quarter for a year, each finding backed by a dated screenshot. A second person rechecks 20 sites and agrees on at least 95% of the fields.
Open 02 · the brief
Add-on value over time
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A free explorer of the FCA's General Insurance Value Measures, covering every release since the pilot. The measures include claims frequency, the share of claims accepted, average payouts and claims ratios by product. Add-on and stand-alone versions of a product are shown side by side, and each change in the FCA's method is marked.
Why it is still open
The FCA publishes the data as yearly spreadsheets, warns that "care is needed if comparing this publication with historic data", and lists pilot releases for the years to 31 August 2016 to 2019. The only comparison found ranks 19 gadget insurers for a single year.
Built with what exists
the FCA's spreadsheets; Python with pandas or DuckDB; Observable Plot for the charts.
First step
Load the 2023, 2024 and 2025 releases and chart the GAP figures from each.
Done looks like
Every release loaded and every product followed across the years, with breaks in method flagged. Figures for 20 product-years are checked by hand against the FCA files, with no differences.