BRENNEN

Industries / Finance and business services / Insurance / Insurance brokerage

Compliance

Compliance covers the rules brokers work under: who may act as one, how they must disclose what they are paid, and how they must treat clients.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2004 to 2023.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2004

    Paid to steer

    On 14 October 2004 New York's attorney general, Eliot Spitzer, sued Marsh, alleging that it steered clients to insurers that paid it contingent commissions, extra pay tied to the volume or profit of the business a broker places, and that it "solicited fake bids". Insurance Journal reported that Marsh collected about $800 million in contingent commissions in 2003. In January 2005 Marsh agreed to pay $850 million in four yearly instalments and to give clients "comprehensive disclosure of commissions", while it "neither admits nor denies the allegations".

    everycrsreport.cominsurancejournal.comcanadianunderwriter.ca

    Credit

    Eliot Spitzer

  2. 2005

    Regulated for what they do

    The UK Insurance Brokers (Registration) Act 1977 set up a register of insurance brokers and the Insurance Brokers Registration Council to regulate "their professional standards". It was repealed on 30 April 2001, and the industry briefly regulated itself through the General Insurance Standards Council. From 14 January 2005 the FSA regulated all firms that arrange insurance, under the EU Insurance Mediation Directive (2002/92/EC).

    LessonThe rules moved from those using the title to anyone doing the work, which, as one insurer warned its members, could include firms that had not "considered themselves to be intermediaries".

    legislation.gov.uklegislation.gov.ukinsurancejournal.comukpandi.com

    Credit

    UK Parliament; the FSA; the EU

  3. 2010

    Commissions allowed back

    In February 2010 regulators in New York, Illinois and Connecticut let Aon, Marsh and Willis begin "accepting contingent commissions again", provided they followed New York's disclosure rules. In July 2010 a New York judge, James A. Yates, vacated the convictions of two former Marsh managing directors, William Gilman and Edward J. McNenney, because of evidence that "undermines the court's confidence in the verdict"; three other executives had been acquitted.

    LessonAfter the scandal, US regulators chose to make brokers disclose their pay rather than ban the commissions.

    insurancejournal.combusinessinsurance.com

    Credit

    New York State Insurance Department; Justice James A. Yates

  4. 2015

    A national register never built

    In the US, agents and brokers, called producers, are licensed by each state in which they work. In 1996 the states set up the National Insurance Producer Registry (NIPR) as a shared licensing system; it handled 38 million transactions in 2020. Congress created NARAB, a national licensing clearinghouse, on 12 January 2015, but the Senate never confirmed its board, and in April 2024 Leader's Edge reported that "NARAB does not yet exist as a functional entity".

    LessonA law can create a body that never starts work if no one is appointed to run it.

    nipr.cominsurancejournal.comleadersedge.com

    Credit

    NAIC and NIPR; US Congress

  5. 2018

    Demands and needs

    The EU Insurance Distribution Directive has applied since 1 October 2018. Before any sale, a seller must set out the customer's demands and needs; it must disclose "the nature of the remuneration received"; and it may not use pay or sales targets "that could provide an incentive" to sell against the customer's interest. In 2022 EIOPA, the EU insurance supervisor, reported that some demands-and-needs tests were "too formalistic or even non-existent" and that customers were "sometimes nudged into ticking a box".

    LessonA required test can shrink to a tick-box unless supervisors check how it is done.

    dirittobancario.it

    Credit

    EU legislators; EIOPA

  6. 2021

    No selling by cold call

    In February 2019 the Australian government said it would act on "all 76 recommendations" of the Royal Commission into misconduct in financial services, led by Kenneth Hayne, including that "anti-hawking laws be extended". Hawking is selling financial products, insurance among them, by unsolicited contact. The ban began on 5 October 2021, and ASIC's guidance requires any consent to contact to be "positive, voluntary, clear".

    rnz.co.nzasic.gov.au

    Credit

    Kenneth Hayne; ASIC

  7. 2023

    India lifts commission caps

    India's broker rules of 2018 allow fees only if the fee "is not a percentage of premium or claim amount". From 1 April 2023 IRDAI removed "the limits prescribed earlier on the maximum commission payable" to agents and intermediaries. Each insurer now needs "a Board approved policy for payment of commission", and a general insurer's expenses are capped at "up to 30 percent of the gross premium".

    legal500.comlegal500.com

    Credit

    IRDAI

Watch for

  1. Lighter rules for business cover

    The first part of the FCA's simplified insurance rules (PS25/21) came into force on 9 December 2025. In June 2026 it proposed more (CP26/22), including narrowing where its conduct rules apply to business customers and cutting duplicate disclosures, with comments due by 19 September 2026. In July 2026 it also set out how general insurance groups must manage conflicts of interest, saying "disclosing a conflict to customers does not remove a firm's obligation to actively manage it".

    Achieved whenfinal rules are published and in force.

    fca.org.ukinsurancebusinessmag.com

    Claimed by

    FCA, June and July 2026

  2. EU keeps commissions, with limits

    The European Commission said the deal reached on 18 December 2025 on its Retail Investment Strategy amends the Insurance Distribution Directive, keeping commissions but adding "stricter safeguards and transparency where inducements are allowed". The deal "now awaits formal adoption by both the European Parliament and the Council."

    Achieved whenthe text is published in the EU's Official Journal.

    europa.eu

    Claimed by

    European Commission, December 2025

  3. One register for Brazil

    Brazil's National Council of Private Insurance (CNSP) issued Resolution 493/2026, which gives brokers a "registro único, válido em todo o território nacional", one registration valid across the country, granted by the regulator SUSEP or by a self-regulatory body. It "entrará em vigor a partir de 17 de janeiro de 2027", takes effect from 17 January 2027.

    Achieved whenit is in force and brokers are being registered under it.

    demarest.com.br

    Claimed by

    CNSP, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Broker pay in one table

    A public, machine-readable table of how the 25 largest brokers say they are paid, in up to three countries each: fees, commissions, contingent or profit commissions, volume-based pay, income from facilities and from agencies they own, and income from financing premiums, with whether amounts are disclosed by default or only on request. Every cell carries a link and a quote from the broker's own terms or disclosure page.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Demands and needs, checked

    A marking scheme drawn from the EU directive's rule on demands and needs and from EIOPA's findings, and a tool that applies it to a written demands-and-needs statement. It is tested on 100 made-up statements, 50 that meet the rule and 50 with planted defects taken from the supervisors' findings, such as a statement that describes the product rather than the customer.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Broker pay in one table

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, machine-readable table of how the 25 largest brokers say they are paid, in up to three countries each: fees, commissions, contingent or profit commissions, volume-based pay, income from facilities and from agencies they own, and income from financing premiums, with whether amounts are disclosed by default or only on request. Every cell carries a link and a quote from the broker's own terms or disclosure page.

Why it is still open

The FCA found in 2019 that only "One-third of brokers" disclosed their commission "as a matter of course". In Australia, the Insurance Brokers Code Compliance Committee reported that brokers' self-reported breaches of pay disclosure rules rose "to 106 from 23" in 2023-24. Brokers publish their pay terms as prose, such as Marsh's UK guide. The one large structured source found, US Form 5500 Schedule A, "covers only insured arrangements" in employee benefits.

fca.org.ukinsurancenews.com.aumarsh.cominsurancebusinessmag.com

Built with what exists

a browser agent such as Browser Use to collect the pages (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); a document-reading AI model to make the first coding; a spreadsheet and a short codebook.

  1. First step

    Write the codebook from the FCA study's findings on disclosure, then code five brokers' UK pages by hand.

  2. Done looks like

    25 brokers coded, with a link and a quote in every cell. A second person recodes 20% of cells and agrees on at least 90%. The table is republished every six months, with changes marked.

Open 02 · the brief

Demands and needs, checked

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A marking scheme drawn from the EU directive's rule on demands and needs and from EIOPA's findings, and a tool that applies it to a written demands-and-needs statement. It is tested on 100 made-up statements, 50 that meet the rule and 50 with planted defects taken from the supervisors' findings, such as a statement that describes the product rather than the customer.

Why it is still open

EIOPA found tests that were "too formalistic or even non-existent". Searches found supervisors' guidance, such as Malta's, and AI tools for needs analysis, but no tool that checks the statements themselves.

dirittobancario.itmfsa.mt

Built with what exists

the directive's text on EUR-Lex; document-reading AI models; a browser agent to step through public online quote journeys up to the point of purchase, so that real statements can be collected without buying anything.

  1. First step

    Write the marking scheme from the directive's text and EIOPA's report, and write 20 statements.

  2. Done looks like

    On the 100 made-up statements, the tool flags at least 90% of defects, with no more than 10% false flags. It is then run on 30 real statements collected from public journeys, and two people check its findings.