Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Instrumentation and electrical
Loop checks and commissioning
This work proves that each instrument, its wiring and the control system agree, from the device in the field to the reading or command on the control-room screen, before a plant starts up.
4
Milestones achieved, from 2006 to 2024.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
2006
Standards for loop checks
A loop check comes after the wiring has been installed and checked point to point, and before cold commissioning, when equipment is first run on water or inert substances instead of chemicals. The IEC, the international body for electrical standards, published IEC 62382 in November 2006, prepared by its technical committee 65 for industrial-process measurement and control; it replaced a 2004 provisional version (IEC/PAS 62382) and sets out a documentation check, a visual inspection, a function check and extra tests for quality- and safety-relevant loops. A companion standard of the same year, IEC 62381, covers the factory acceptance test (FAT) of a control system at the supplier's works and the site acceptance and site integration tests (SAT and SIT). Both were revised in 2012.
Credit
IEC technical committee 65
2018
Open punch items cause leaks
A punch list is the running list of faults found during construction and commissioning, each to be fixed before a set milestone. The UK HSE's inspection guide on loss of containment at offshore installations, version 2 of March 2018, tells its inspectors that releases have followed punch-list items left open, either before start-up (a leak test not completed) or months later (open ends of small-bore pipework not plugged), and that commissioning should not move to its next phase until the relevant items are closed. It also expects function tests to show that instrumented protective systems actually trip, with results recorded and signed off by management.
LessonHSE warns that punch items seen as low risk are the ones that do not get done in time.
Credit
UK Health and Safety Executive, Energy Division
2020
Acceptance tests by camera
When the COVID-19 pandemic stopped travel, factory acceptance tests moved online. At Phillips 66's Bayway refinery in Linden, New Jersey, the team tested a new Honeywell control system remotely, with a Honeywell engineer in the factory wearing a helmet camera and sharing screens; the refinery's process controls lead, Patrick Robinson, said 80% to 90% of a FAT could be done this way, with final sign-off on site and extra contingency for the site tests. A 2022 field study in ISPE's Pharmaceutical Engineering, covering five automation projects in Ireland, Germany and Australia, found that testers and reviewers saved travel but "overwhelmingly" preferred to return to testing in person.
Lessonremote tests save travel, but reviewers lose sight of the work and some of the trust between the parties.
Credit
Phillips 66 and Honeywell; a researcher at University College Cork for the study
2024
Tests across the plant's life
IEC 62381's third edition, published on 30 July 2024, added an optional factory integration test (FIT) and replaced its sample forms with detailed checklists. The third edition of IEC 62382, issued in Britain as BS EN IEC 62382:2024 on 30 September 2024, says loop checks can be done throughout a plant's life, including after commissioning, and that loops in safety instrumented systems need further testing under IEC 61511.
Credit
IEC
Watch for
Loop checks from a tablet
In the usual method, technicians in the field call out tag numbers and milliamp values by radio while an operator confirms each reading in the control room. Emerson says its ProofCheck software, an add-on to its AMS Device Manager that replaced an earlier QuickCheck tool, simulates each device's output, reads the control system's response and records the result, and that in one customer example it cut loop and interlock checks from about 140 minutes to about 25 minutes per device, or from 4,000 to 470 person-hours across 1,000 devices. It also reports that DuPont cut loop checkout on two expansion projects from 700 hours to 100.
Achieved whenan owner or outside party publishes timed records from one project that compare the method with radio checks on similar loops, including the faults each method found.
Claimed by
Emerson, July 2026
A third off loop testing
KENT, an engineering and commissioning contractor, says conventional loop checks use up to 50% of all commissioning work hours, and that its "smart loop testing", which can start before the full control system is running, has cut loop-testing hours by 30%.
Achieved whena client or auditor publishes a project's loop counts and hours with and without the method.
Claimed by
KENT, June 2025
Open
01
An open loop-check runner
Free software that reads a plant's I/O list, the spreadsheet of every signal and its channel, drives each loop on a test bench through a HART modem or a programmable 4 to 20 mA source, reads what the control system shows, and writes one record per loop following the checks in IEC 62382.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Count what loop checks find
A public tally of the faults that loop checks and punch lists catch, by type, cause and how each was found, built from the closed-out loop sheets of finished projects with names removed.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
An open loop-check runner
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
Free software that reads a plant's I/O list, the spreadsheet of every signal and its channel, drives each loop on a test bench through a HART modem or a programmable 4 to 20 mA source, reads what the control system shows, and writes one record per loop following the checks in IEC 62382.
Why it is still open
Automated loop checks exist only inside makers' own products, such as Emerson's ProofCheck, which works through its AMS Device Manager; Honeywell was granted a US patent on 1 July 2025 for a method in which a dongle runs a check file built from a database of loop data. Open projects stop short: LoopCheckTool on GitHub (2021) only fills Word templates from an I/O list, and an open repository of commissioning tools lists a "Loop Check Validator" as "coming next week", but in November 2026 it held no such code and had not changed since January 2026.
Built with what exists
OpenPLC or another soft controller as a stand-in control system; Modbus or OPC UA libraries such as open62541; HART_for_all, an open HART master posted on GitHub in 2026 that works with low-cost USB HART modems and includes a device emulator; an Analog Devices AD5700 HART modem board; a programmable current source; an AI coding agent to write device drivers against the emulator and tests.
First step
Wire five loops to a soft controller and script one HART-driven check from I/O list to finished record.
Done looks like
On a 40-loop, 24 V bench with ten faults planted by someone else (swapped pairs, wrong tag, wrong range, reversed polarity, a dead channel), the runner finds all ten, keeps a record of every loop, and takes one person under five minutes per loop, timed against a two-person radio check of the same bench.
Open 02 · the brief
Count what loop checks find
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public tally of the faults that loop checks and punch lists catch, by type, cause and how each was found, built from the closed-out loop sheets of finished projects with names removed.
Why it is still open
Firms publish hours, not faults: KENT gives the share of commissioning hours that loop checks take, and an ISA blog post by Beamex gives only an estimate of 263 hours for 150 loops. HSE says releases have followed punch items left open, but searches of the web, Zenodo and GitHub in November 2026 found no published count of what loop checks find.
Built with what exists
scanned or exported loop sheets and punch lists given by owners and contractors with permission; an AI model that reads scanned forms and handwriting to pull out the fault, cause and fix; a script that removes names and tag prefixes; an open spreadsheet with a published coding scheme.
First step
Draft a ten-category fault code from IEC 62382's documentation, visual and function checks, and ask two contractors for one closed-out project's loop sheets.
Done looks like
At least 5,000 loop records from at least three projects in at least two countries, each fault coded against the published scheme, with a second coder agreeing on at least 90% of a 500-record sample, and the tally posted openly.