BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Instrumentation and electrical

Drawings and records

This work keeps the drawings, lists and data sheets that say what each instrument is, where it is and how it is wired, and keeps them true as the plant changes.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1949 to 2024.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1949

    Symbols every plant can read

    The Instrument Society of America's first standard, RP 5.1 "Instrument Flow Plan Symbols", appeared in 1949. It set the identification letters and the symbols used to mark instruments on plant diagrams, so that a drawing made by one firm could be read by another. ISA says most of the letter meanings and symbols from the 1949 practice and its 1984 revision "became and remain accepted practice" across the process industries worldwide. It was reissued in 1984, 1992, 2009 and 2022, and in 2024 renamed "Instrumentation and Control Symbols and Identification", with a new table of symbols for loop diagrams.

    isa.orgautomation.comautomation.com

    Credit

    Instrument Society of America, now the International Society of Automation (ISA), its ISA5 committee

  2. 1991

    One sheet per loop

    A loop diagram shows one control loop end to end: the field instrument, each junction box, terminal and wire number, and the control-system input it lands on. ISA-5.4, "Instrument Loop Diagrams", approved on 9 September 1991, set out the minimum information such a sheet must carry. Its foreword says one sheet can hold everything needed for installation, checkout, start-up and maintenance, which otherwise "is spread among many other documents", and that keeping this one sheet "as built" is easier than updating many.

    webstore.ansi.org

    Credit

    ISA's SP5.4 committee

  3. 1991

    A change never drawn

    In Building 30 at NASA's Johnson Space Center, a contractor switched off, tagged and checked all circuits of a 480 volt panel using the facility drawing, and an electrician then got a shock from a lug that was still live. An earlier change had added the lug and its wiring by another route, and nobody had put it on the master drawing; the electrician also had not tested the lug with a meter. NASA recorded the lesson in August 1991, and the fixes were updated drawings and stricter testing for dead before work.

    LessonA drawing is only as good as the last change recorded on it, so it never replaces a test for voltage.

    llis.nasa.gov

    Credit

    NASA Johnson Space Center, lessons-learned record 19

  4. 2008

    Drawings that pass data

    IEC 62424, prepared by the International Electrotechnical Commission's committee for industrial-process measurement and control (TC 65) and issued in August 2008, set how instrument and control requests are shown on P&IDs (piping and instrumentation diagrams, the master drawings of a process plant). It also set an XML format, CAEX, so that a P&ID program and the separate program that designs instrument loops can pass the same tags back and forth instead of retyping them. It replaced a 2005 interim specification, and a second edition followed on 15 July 2016.

    webstore.ansi.orgwebstore.iec.ch

    Credit

    IEC TC 65

  5. 2024

    A public test for P&IDs

    Software that reads scanned plant drawings needs a shared test to be compared. In 2021 Shubham Paliwal and colleagues at TCS Research published Dataset-P&ID, 500 synthetic P&IDs with labels, made available for public use. In November 2024 Jan Marius Stürmer and two co-authors published what they call the first publicly accessible benchmark of real-world P&IDs annotated as graphs, so that a program is scored on how symbols connect as well as on finding them; their own transformer model improved edge detection by more than 25% over a step-by-step baseline.

    arxiv.orgarxiv.org

    Credit

    Shubham Paliwal et al. (TCS Research); Jan Marius Stürmer et al

Watch for

  1. AI reads plant drawings

    SymphonyAI says its IRIS Foundry software reads P&IDs with a vision model, gives each extracted element a confidence score for an engineer to verify, and maps 70 to 80% of entities to the plant's asset list without manual work, so that 500 drawings that would take a team 9 to 12 months can be "substantially complete in weeks". Separately, Engineering Ingegneria Informatica reported 91% accuracy on design text and 93% of components identified on P&IDs of Snam's Italian gas plants, with about 80% accuracy on the plant hierarchy.

    Achieved whenan outside party scores such a tool on a public set of real drawings, loop and wiring diagrams included, and publishes error rates per element type.

    symphonyai.comarxiv.org

    Claimed by

    SymphonyAI, May 2026; Engineering Ingegneria Informatica, November 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Loop sheets into an index

    A public test set of loop diagrams with answer keys, and a scorer. Each sheet is drawn to ISA-5.4 for a made-up but realistic plant, some clean and some printed, marked up and scanned like old paper sheets. The answer key lists, for every loop, the tag, each device, junction box, terminal, cable and wire number and the control-system channel, which is what an instrument index (the plant's master list of instruments) needs.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Find wiring that disagrees

    A photo test of terminal strips wired from loop drawings, with planted mismatches, and a tool that reads the wire markers (the printed sleeves on each wire end) and terminal numbers in the photos and lists every place the wiring and the drawing disagree. The rig is a dead training panel: DIN rail, terminal blocks and wire with no supply connected.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Loop sheets into an index

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test set of loop diagrams with answer keys, and a scorer. Each sheet is drawn to ISA-5.4 for a made-up but realistic plant, some clean and some printed, marked up and scanned like old paper sheets. The answer key lists, for every loop, the tag, each device, junction box, terminal, cable and wire number and the control-system channel, which is what an instrument index (the plant's master list of instruments) needs.

Why it is still open

Public test sets exist for P&IDs (Dataset-P&ID, 2021; the 2024 graph benchmark), but a 2024 review of deep learning on engineering drawings names the lack of datasets as a main obstacle, and a 2026 Chalmers thesis says electrical diagrams are less studied than P&IDs and worked from one company's drawings. A GitHub search for loop diagram projects found tools that draw loop sheets from an index (an AutoLISP script for AutoCAD) but none that read them back.

link.springer.comodr.chalmers.segithub.com

Built with what exists

QElectroTech, a free electrical drawing program, for the sheets; Label Studio for checking the keys; a short Python scorer; vision-language models such as Claude, Gemini and open-weights models like Mistral Large 4 (see the Note "A trillion open parameters").

  1. First step

    Write a made-up instrument index of 20 loops, draw their sheets in QElectroTech, print and scan half of them, and type the answer key.

  2. Done looks like

    200 sheets and their keys published under an open license, with field-by-field accuracy for at least three models, and the share of loops a model gets fully right.

Open 02 · the brief

Find wiring that disagrees

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A photo test of terminal strips wired from loop drawings, with planted mismatches, and a tool that reads the wire markers (the printed sleeves on each wire end) and terminal numbers in the photos and lists every place the wiring and the drawing disagree. The rig is a dead training panel: DIN rail, terminal blocks and wire with no supply connected.

Why it is still open

Wrong drawings keep turning up only when someone tests: in a 2022 IMCA safety flash, heaters left out of a lockout were found live because the drawing and the breaker schedule showed them on the wrong circuit. A 2023 Sapienza University study checked new control panels against their schematics from photos, but on one Italian panel maker's data, and patents cover camera checks of new cabinets in the factory. No public photo set of field-wired terminals with known errors was found.

imca-int.comarxiv.org

Built with what exists

A phone camera; DIN-rail terminal blocks and a wire-marker printer; open OCR such as PaddleOCR; vision-language models; the loop sheets from the item above as the drawings.

  1. First step

    Wire one rail of 40 terminals from a loop sheet, plant ten errors, photograph it from three angles, and record the answer key.

  2. Done looks like

    50 photographed panels holding 200 planted errors (swapped wires, missing or wrong markers, an extra wire not on the drawing), released with the drawings, and a tool's recall and false alarms per error type published.