BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Industrial cleaning

Work in confined spaces

Cleaning crews often work inside tanks, vessels, boilers and pits, spaces with small openings where the air can be short of oxygen, toxic or flammable; this work keeps people out where possible and, when they must go in, tests the air, watches them and stands ready to get them out.

4

Milestones achieved, from 1961 to 2007.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

3

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1961

    Certified safe for entry

    Section 30 of Britain's Factories Act 1961 covered work inside "any chamber, tank, vat, pit, pipe, flue or similar confined space" where dangerous fumes might be present. Nobody could go in without breathing apparatus and permission from a responsible person, and, where practicable, a rope held by someone keeping watch outside. The exception was a space that a responsible person had certified safe for a set period, which required stopping fumes from getting in, removing any sludge that could give off fumes, and ventilating and testing the air. The Act also set a minimum manhole size of 18 by 16 inches (46 by 41 cm).

    legislation.gov.uk

    Credit

    UK Parliament

  2. 1986

    Rescuers die in the space

    NIOSH, the US workplace safety research agency, published recommended criteria for working in confined spaces in December 1979. In January 1986 it issued an alert, describing 16 deaths, which said that "more than 60% of confined space fatalities occur among would-be rescuers," and so a well-designed rescue plan is a must. NIOSH's 1994 summary found a lower share in the cases its own investigators examined: 39 of 109 confined-space deaths (36%) from December 1983 to September 1993 were rescuers. It also counted 670 confined-space deaths on US death certificates from 1980 to 1989, about 67 a year, and said the true number is probably higher.

    LessonThe sources disagree on the rescuers' share, but all of them call for a rescue plan before anyone goes in.

    archive.cdc.govstacks.cdc.govarchive.cdc.gov

    Credit

    NIOSH

  3. 1997

    Stay out if you can

    Britain's Confined Spaces Regulations 1997, in force from 28 January 1998, repealed section 30 of the Factories Act. They say no one at work may enter a confined space to do work "unless it is not reasonably practicable to achieve that purpose without such entry." When entry cannot be avoided, the work must follow a safe system, and rescue arrangements must be ready before anyone goes in. The regulations define a confined space by its risks: fire or explosion, passing out from heat, gas, fumes or lack of oxygen, drowning, or being buried in a free-flowing solid such as grain.

    legislation.gov.uk

    Credit

    the UK Health and Safety Commission, which proposed the rules, and the Secretary of State, who made them

  4. 2007

    Rescue over an hour away

    On 2 October 2007 painting contractors were recoating the inside of a penstock, a long tunnel that carries water to the turbines, at Xcel Energy's Cabin Creek hydroelectric plant west of Denver, Colorado. About 16 gallons (61 liters) of methyl ethyl ketone (MEK), a flammable solvent, was being used inside to clean the epoxy spraying equipment, and it ignited, likely from a static spark. Five of the 11 workers were trapped on the far side of the fire from the only way out, and talked with coworkers and responders by radio for about 45 minutes before dying of smoke inhalation. No rescuers certified for confined spaces were on site, and the nearest certified service was about 1 hour 15 minutes away.

    LessonA rescue plan has to put trained rescuers where they can reach the entrants in time, before the work starts.

    csb.govcsb.gov

    Credit

    investigated by the CSB, final report 25 August 2010

Watch for

  1. A drone goes in instead

    Bureau Veritas, the inspection and ship classification company, says its surveyors in France, Türkiye, Greece and Denmark use the X1 drone from Nolvis of Dallas to inspect ballast tanks, cargo holds, boilers and other enclosed spaces on ships and offshore installations, while the surveyor makes the decisions from its video and 3D scans. Nolvis says the drone is about 40 cm across and fits through 18-inch (46 cm) openings. The companies say it can reduce the need for entry and shorten inspections, but give no figures.

    Achieved whenBureau Veritas or a ship operator publishes how many entries the drone replaced over a period, and how its findings compared with a surveyor's inside the same spaces.

    roboticsandautomationnews.com

    Claimed by

    Bureau Veritas and Nolvis, November 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Time to clear the air

    An open set of simulations of how long a blower at a manway takes to make the air in common plant vessels (vertical tanks, horizontal drums, heat exchanger shells, boiler drums) fit to breathe after they held nitrogen or solvent vapor, by vessel size, blower airflow, duct position and number of openings, published as a lookup table and checked against a small bench model.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Rescue time for every space

    A planning tool that takes a site's map, its list of permit spaces (confined spaces that need a written permit to enter) and where its rescue team or the local fire service is based, and estimates for each space how long it would take from the alarm to getting an entrant out: raising the alarm, travel, setting up, reaching, packaging and lifting. It flags the spaces where that time is longer than the hazard allows, and is checked against timed rescue drills.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  3. 03

    Score the manway camera

    A public video test of camera systems that watch the opening of a permit space. Staged entries and exits are filmed at a mock manway built on open ground (a plywood frame, not a confined space), in the light and from the angles found on plants, and every crossing, every absence of the attendant and every blocked view is labeled. Any camera system's misses and false alarms are then counted against the labels.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Time to clear the air

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open set of simulations of how long a blower at a manway takes to make the air in common plant vessels (vertical tanks, horizontal drums, heat exchanger shells, boiler drums) fit to breathe after they held nitrogen or solvent vapor, by vessel size, blower airflow, duct position and number of openings, published as a lookup table and checked against a small bench model.

Why it is still open

Purge-time charts sold with blowers assume a fixed number of air changes, about seven in Air Systems' chart, which cites a Bell System standard, and free online calculators assume the air mixes fully. Validated simulations exist for other spaces: H. B. Manbeck, D. J. Murphy and J. Zhao (2008) simulated fan-ventilated manure storage tanks and found that larger tanks cleared more slowly at the same air exchange rate. For purging process vessels with nitrogen, Alan Collier (HAZARDS 31, 2021) showed that the simple formula that assumes the gas mixes fully can mislead, because gas can bypass parts of a vessel, and that tall vessels with the inlet and the vent both on top are hard to purge. A search found no published table for clearing plant vessels with air blowers.

airsystems.comstacks.cdc.govicheme.org

Built with what exists

OpenFOAM, a free program for simulating gas flow; typical vessel dimensions; a clear plastic model at one-tenth scale with a small fan, a little carbon dioxide from a soda-maker cylinder as a tracer, and low-cost carbon dioxide sensors, in a ventilated room.

  1. First step

    Rerun one tank from the 2008 manure-storage study in OpenFOAM to check the setup against its published results, then change the shape to a horizontal drum.

  2. Done looks like

    Times to reach a set oxygen level everywhere in the vessel, such as 19.5%, for at least four vessel types, three sizes, three airflows and two duct positions, published with the input files; the bench model's measured times within 20% of the simulated times in at least three setups, and each simulated time set beside what a seven-air-change chart gives.

Open 02 · the brief

Rescue time for every space

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A planning tool that takes a site's map, its list of permit spaces (confined spaces that need a written permit to enter) and where its rescue team or the local fire service is based, and estimates for each space how long it would take from the alarm to getting an entrant out: raising the alarm, travel, setting up, reaching, packaging and lifting. It flags the spaces where that time is longer than the hazard allows, and is checked against timed rescue drills.

Why it is still open

At Cabin Creek in 2007 the nearest certified rescue service was about 1 hour 15 minutes away. MSA Safety publishes a rescue trainer's formula for adding up response time by hand, and Matterport promotes 3D scans of spaces for rescue planning (February 2026), but a search found no tool that works out the times space by space from a site plan, and no published comparison of estimated times with drilled ones.

csb.govblog.msasafety.commatterport.com

Built with what exists

Site plans or phone LiDAR scans; walking routes worked out with NetworkX, a free Python library for networks; timings from a site's own drill records; a spreadsheet.

  1. First step

    Ask a confined-space rescue training center for its drill timing records and the layout of its training props.

  2. Done looks like

    For one site or rescue training center with at least 20 spaces, estimated times within 20% of the timed drills for at least 15 drills, with the method and anonymized data published.

Open 03 · the brief

Score the manway camera

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public video test of camera systems that watch the opening of a permit space. Staged entries and exits are filmed at a mock manway built on open ground (a plywood frame, not a confined space), in the light and from the angles found on plants, and every crossing, every absence of the attendant and every blocked view is labeled. Any camera system's misses and false alarms are then counted against the labels.

Why it is still open

Roboflow sells vision AI that counts entrants against exits at a permit space's opening and checks that the attendant stays at the post. It gives no accuracy figures for this use, and says the camera tracks only who crosses the opening. A search found other sellers of such systems but no independent accuracy test of any of them.

roboflow.com

Built with what exists

Phone or site cameras; open models that detect and track people, such as Ultralytics YOLO; CVAT or Label Studio, free tools for labeling video.

  1. First step

    Build the mock opening and film 50 staged crossings at a safety training center.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 500 labeled crossings and 50 attendant absences, by day, at night and against bright light, published with an open model's scores as a baseline (misses and false alarms per hour of video).