BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Industrial cleaning

Handling the waste

This work decides what happens to what cleaning removes: oily sludge, scale, dirty water and spent chemicals are separated, treated, recycled or disposed of under waste rules.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1980 to 2024.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1980

    Cleaning sludge listed as hazardous

    When the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) published its first lists of hazardous wastes on 19 May 1980, the wastes named from petroleum refining included heat exchanger bundle cleaning sludge (waste code K050), the deposit washed out of the tube bundles of heat exchangers, and leaded tank bottoms (K052), the sludge from tanks that held leaded gasoline. Both were listed as toxic. A listed waste must be managed as hazardous waste without any need to test each batch.

    govinfo.govgovinfo.gov

    Credit

    US EPA

  2. 1982

    Limits on boiler-cleaning wastewater

    EPA's rules for steam electric power plants, dated 19 November 1982, define metal cleaning waste as wastewater from cleaning metal process equipment, with or without cleaning chemicals, including boiler tube cleaning. Before it is discharged it may carry no more than 1.0 milligram per liter each of total copper and total iron, and no more than 20 milligrams per liter of oil and grease on any day.

    law.cornell.edulaw.cornell.edu

    Credit

    US EPA

  3. 1986

    Radioactive scale in pipe yards

    In 1986 investigators found significant radioactivity at an oilfield pipe cleaning yard run by Street, Inc. near Laurel, Mississippi, which removed scale and residue from used oilfield equipment for companies including Chevron and Shell. The scale held naturally occurring radioactive material, or NORM: radium dissolved in water from oil reservoirs settles out with mineral scale inside pipes and tanks. In January 1989 OSHA, the US workplace safety agency, warned its inspectors that reaming or cutting such pipe could put radioactive particles in the air, citing radium-226 in scale at up to 100,000 picocuries per gram, against less than 1 to about 7 in Louisiana soils, and contaminated pipe used in school bleachers in Mississippi.

    LessonWhat cleaning removes can be more hazardous than the equipment it came from, so scale needs checking before it is handled or dumped.

    tulanelawreview.orgosha.gov

    Credit

    reported by James R. Cox in the Tulane Law Review (1993) and by OSHA (1989)

  4. 1988

    Refinery sludge must be treated

    EPA's land disposal rule of 17 August 1988 set treatment standards that refinery sludges K048 to K052, including heat exchanger cleaning sludge and leaded tank bottoms, must meet before they go into the ground. It based them on two methods: incineration, and solvent extraction, which washes the oil out of sludge so it can be reused. EPA added solvent extraction after industry data showed no significant difference from incineration for 11 of the 13 organic chemicals compared, and because it recovers oil. EPA estimated that about 154 million gallons of these wastes a year needed treatment, against about 1 million gallons of commercial solvent extraction capacity and 7 million gallons of sludge incineration capacity, most of it needed for other wastes, so it gave a two-year national capacity variance, a delay in the deadline.

    LessonA rule can call for treatment faster than plants to do it can be built.

    archive.epa.gov

    Credit

    US EPA

  5. 1998

    Crude tank sediment listed

    On 6 August 1998 EPA listed crude oil storage tank sediment from refineries as hazardous waste K169, effective 8 February 1999. Its model put the high-end added cancer risk from benzene reaching groundwater from off-site landfills at about 4 in 100,000. The same rule excluded oil-bearing residues from the definition of waste when they are put back into the refining process, including the coker, which rewards refiners for recycling sludge instead of disposing of it. Tank sediment and heat exchanger cleaning sludge are also exempt when discharged to the refinery's oil recovery sewer ahead of its first separation of oil, water and solids.

    govinfo.gov

    Credit

    US EPA

  6. 2003

    Global guidance on radioactive scale

    The International Atomic Energy Agency's Safety Report No. 34, published in November 2003, set out how the oil and gas industry should protect workers and manage radioactive waste. For removing radioactive scale from equipment, it says dry grit blasting, milling and grinding should normally be avoided because they spread radioactive dust, and it describes high-pressure water jetting at 10 to 250 megapascals, usually done at a few specialist facilities authorized for the work, which collect the water and the scale for disposal.

    www-pub.iaea.org

    Credit

    International Atomic Energy Agency

  7. 2024

    Where Europe's tank sludge goes

    Concawe, a research body whose members are refining companies, surveyed its members' European refineries for 2019 to 2021. Tank bottom sludges averaged 0.10 tonnes per thousand tonnes of oil processed. By weight, 25% of tank bottoms went to landfill, 24% to incineration and 23% to incineration with energy recovery, and about 41% received no treatment before disposal or recovery. The report cites a review that puts crude tank bottoms at typically 60% oil, 25% water and 15% solids.

    LessonSludge that is mostly oil is still often burned or buried.

    concawe.eu

    Credit

    Concawe, report 11/24 (August 2024), prepared by Alfio Mianzan of NewFields UK

Watch for

  1. Cavitation frees oil from sludge

    Envorem, a British company, says its system, which breaks up sludge with hydraulic shock and cavitation (bubbles that form when water vaporizes and then collapse), treated 1,300 cubic meters of sludge at Saudi Aramco's Shaybah gas oil processing station, recovering 2,080 barrels of oil and 920 cubic meters of water and cutting the remaining waste by 97%. It says a full-scale unit assembled near Jubail in early 2026 is fully commissioned. All figures come from the company; a search found no data published by Aramco or an outside laboratory.

    Achieved whenAramco or an independent laboratory publishes a mass balance (the oil, water and solids in and out) for a full-scale job, including the oil left in the treated solids.

    oilreviewmiddleeast.comomanobserver.om

    Claimed by

    Envorem, March 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Oil recovery on equal terms

    A public table of every published result for recovering oil from tank and refinery sludge, by centrifuge, thermal desorption (heating sludge to drive off the oil), solvent extraction, sonication, pyrolysis and other methods, recomputed on one definition: oil recovered as a share of the oil in the feed. Each row would give the feed's oil, water and solids, the scale (laboratory, pilot or full plant), energy used per tonne, oil left in the solids, and who measured.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Map where scale is radioactive

    A public map that shows, by oil and gas basin and rock formation, how likely pipes, tanks and vessels are to carry radium-bearing scale, so cleaning contractors and waste handlers can plan screening and disposal before a job starts. It is a desk study of public data and handles no radioactive material.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Oil recovery on equal terms

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of every published result for recovering oil from tank and refinery sludge, by centrifuge, thermal desorption (heating sludge to drive off the oil), solvent extraction, sonication, pyrolysis and other methods, recomputed on one definition: oil recovered as a share of the oil in the feed. Each row would give the feed's oil, water and solids, the scale (laboratory, pilot or full plant), energy used per tonne, oil left in the solids, and who measured.

Why it is still open

Concawe's 2024 assessment for European refiners, published in a journal in 2025 by Mianzan and co-authors, scored six options with weighted criteria rather than pooled measurements, and some of its inputs are claims, such as "Up to 98% oil recovery efficiency was stated by a contractor." Single best results hide the spread: a 2026 study of sonication on California tank bottoms reported recoveries up to 98.2% but a mean of 27.4%. Searches found narrative reviews but no pooled dataset.

concawe.eudoi.orgdoi.org

Built with what exists

Crossref and OpenAlex to find papers and reports; Meta's Muse Ember for reading long documents (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Gemini Decision 1 to answer fixed questions about each result (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); Python and a spreadsheet; Zenodo to publish with a DOI.

  1. First step

    Pull every oil recovery figure from the Concawe report's technology section and the 2026 sonication paper, and use them to fix the fields.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 150 results from at least 60 sources, each recomputed on the common definition or marked as not recomputable and why; a tenth of rows coded again by a second person, with at least 90% agreement; the table published with a DOI.

Open 02 · the brief

Map where scale is radioactive

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public map that shows, by oil and gas basin and rock formation, how likely pipes, tanks and vessels are to carry radium-bearing scale, so cleaning contractors and waste handlers can plan screening and disposal before a job starts. It is a desk study of public data and handles no radioactive material.

Why it is still open

The US picture of radioactive oilfield equipment still rests largely on a 1989 survey for the American Petroleum Institute that the USGS calls "nonstatistical"; it found readings above natural background at 42% of sites. The USGS National Produced Waters Geochemical Database (version 2.3, 2019) has radium-226 values for only 720 samples, 0.6% of its records. A 2022 master's thesis at the University of New Mexico by Richard Haaker modeled radium-226 from that database and found that salinity and barium appear to predict it, but had only about 254 usable samples and made no map. A search found no published map that predicts which equipment carries radioactive scale.

pubs.usgs.govsciencebase.govdigitalrepository.unm.edu

Built with what exists

The USGS produced waters database, now at version 3.0 (2023); Haaker's models as a starting point; Python with pandas and GeoPandas; a statistical model relating radium to water chemistry, such as total dissolved solids, by formation; state NORM survey reports where they are public, read with a model such as Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass").

  1. First step

    Download the database and count radium measurements by basin and formation.

  2. Done looks like

    A map covering every basin with at least 30 radium measurements; with a fifth of the measured samples held back, the model predicts radium within a factor of two for at least 70% of them; code, data and map published.