BRENNEN

Industries / Health / Healthcare / Imaging centers

Paying for scans

How imaging is paid for: a scan's fee is split into a technical part, for the staff, machine and supplies, and a professional part, for the doctor's reading, and payers decide which scans they will pay for and at what price.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2007 to 2024.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2007

    Office scans capped

    The US Deficit Reduction Act of 2005 limited what Medicare pays for the technical part of a scan done in a doctor's office or freestanding center to what a hospital outpatient department would be paid for the same scan, from 1 January 2007. In 2007 radiologists' Medicare payments for office MRI fell 30.1%, and other doctors' fell 23.5%. Growth in outpatient CT, MRI and nuclear medicine flattened, but a later study found no shift of CT or MRI from offices to hospitals by 2009, and some loss of access to nuclear medicine.

    LessonA price cut slowed growth without the closures that were feared, except in nuclear medicine.

    federalregister.goveuropepmc.orgeuropepmc.org

    Credit

    US Congress; Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS); David C. Levin, Vijay M. Rao and Laurence Parker measured the effects

  2. 2008

    Insurers ask before scans

    In June 2008 the US Government Accountability Office (GAO) reported that Medicare spending on imaging paid under its physician fee schedule had more than doubled from 2000 to 2006, to about $14 billion, and that the private plans it interviewed relied chiefly on prior authorization, approval before the scan. Much of that work is done by radiology benefit managers (RBMs), companies whose main tool is prior authorization. A 2011 model of a typical RBM estimated that 28% of the savings it projected were shifted to doctors' offices, and RBMs lowered total costs in only 45% of the model's simulations.

    LessonApproval before a scan moves cost onto the people who order it, as well as cutting scans.

    gao.goveuropepmc.orgeuropepmc.org

    Credit

    GAO; D. W. Lee, J. V. Rawson and S. W. Wade (model)

  3. 2012

    Owning the scanner, ordering more

    A self-referred scan is one ordered by a doctor whose own practice performs and bills it. GAO found that from 2004 to 2010 self-referred MRI services rose by more than 80%, against 12% for other MRI services, and that doctors who began self-referring in 2009 raised their MRI and CT referrals by about 67% in 2010 compared with 2008. It estimated that self-referring providers made about 400,000 more advanced imaging referrals in 2010 than they otherwise would have, costing Medicare about $109 million.

    LessonWho owns the machine changes how many scans are ordered.

    gao.gov

    Credit

    GAO (report GAO-12-966)

  4. 2014

    Software that could not decide

    From 2011 to 2013 Medicare's Imaging Demonstration had clinicians order advanced scans through decision support software that rated each order against appropriateness guidelines. RAND's evaluation for Congress found that the software could not rate nearly two-thirds of orders, and that ordering patterns changed only a little.

    LessonPublished guidelines covered only part of what doctors actually order.

    rand.orgrand.org

    Credit

    CMS; Justin W. Timbie, Katherine L. Kahn and colleagues at RAND (evaluation)

  5. 2020

    Medicare pays for stroke AI

    For its year starting October 2020, CMS approved a new technology add-on payment (NTAP), money paid on top of the fixed hospital payment for a stay, for Viz.ai's ContaCT, the stroke alert software described under AI reading aids. The maximum was $1,040 a case, and CMS estimated $72.1 million in payments for 69,336 patients. A 2023 review called it the only inpatient radiology AI to have won an NTAP; CMS turned down Rapid ASPECTS and Aidoc's software for pulmonary embolism in 2021.

    LessonCMS paid when the maker showed that faster diagnosis led to better outcomes for patients, not just faster alerts.

    federalregister.govnature.com

    Credit

    Viz.ai; CMS

  6. 2022

    Japan pays a little

    In April 2022 Japan's national fee schedule added a fee for radiological management of imaging studies that pays hospitals 340 points when AI is used and 235 points when it is not. At about 10 yen a point, a 2026 commentary in the Korean Journal of Radiology puts the difference at about US$6 per inpatient per month and about US$200,000 to 400,000 a year for a large hospital, "barely enough to purchase one or two AI tools". The fee pays for managing AI's proper use, not for the AI itself.

    doi.org

    Credit

    Japan's Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare

  7. 2024

    Medicare drops its scan rule

    The Protecting Access to Medicare Act of 2014 required doctors ordering advanced imaging for Medicare patients to consult appropriate use criteria (AUC) through approved software, and the imaging provider to report that on the claim, with prior authorization to follow for doctors who were outliers. After an education and testing period from 2020, CMS paused the program and rescinded its rules from 1 January 2024, calling the real-time reporting on claims "an insurmountable barrier".

    LessonA rule that needed new data on every claim failed on the claims system after almost ten years.

    cms.govfederalregister.gov

    Credit

    US Congress; CMS

Watch for

  1. A Medicare lane for AI

    The Health Tech Investment Act would have Medicare pay for "algorithm-based healthcare services", devices cleared or approved by the FDA that use AI, machine learning or similar methods, through a new technology payment class in hospital outpatient care, priced from the maker's costs including subscriptions, and kept there for at least five years.

    Achieved whenthe bill becomes law and CMS posts payment rates for imaging AI under it.

    govinfo.govgovinfo.gov

    Claimed by

    Senators Rounds, Heinrich and Blackburn (S. 1399, 9 April 2025) and Representative Joyce of Pennsylvania with five cosponsors (H.R. 6197, 20 November 2025)

  2. AI codes without a doctor

    The American Medical Association's Digital Medicine Coding Committee has proposed, for discussion, a new family of CPT codes, the US billing codes for medical services, called Clinically Meaningful Algorithmic Analyses (CMAA), for services in which software turns data such as images into "medically actionable outputs" with no physician directly involved at the point of service. The CPT 2027 code set, released on 9 September 2026, added 10 AI-related codes, for 43 in all, and its release did not mention CMAA.

    Achieved whenCMAA codes appear in a published CPT code set and Medicare or a large insurer posts a payment rate for one used on images.

    ama-assn.orgama-assn.org

    Claimed by

    American Medical Association, October 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Which AI gets paid, where

    A public, dated register of every route by which a payer pays separately for imaging AI: country, payer, route (a billing code with a rate, an add-on payment such as NTAP, Japan's AI management fee, Korea's conditional-use pathways), product where one is named, amount, start and end dates, and the source document. One row per product, payer and route.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Payer scan rules compared

    A public comparison of the published advanced-imaging rules of radiology benefit managers such as eviCore by Evernorth and Carelon Medical Benefits Management against the American College of Radiology's (ACR) Appropriateness Criteria, for 20 common outpatient complaints such as low back pain, headache and shoulder pain. Each rule is coded into the same fields: weeks of treatment required before the scan, whether an X-ray must come first, the warning signs that allow an immediate scan, and the scan recommended. Every difference is listed, and the table is updated when a rule changes.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Which AI gets paid, where

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, dated register of every route by which a payer pays separately for imaging AI: country, payer, route (a billing code with a rate, an add-on payment such as NTAP, Japan's AI management fee, Korea's conditional-use pathways), product where one is named, amount, start and end dates, and the source document. One row per product, payer and route.

Why it is still open

Studies cover one country or one route at a time. Wu and colleagues counted US claims for AI billing codes from 2018 to mid-2023 and found only AI for coronary artery disease and for diabetic eye disease above 10,000 claims. Lobig and colleagues counted 8 of more than 200 FDA-cleared radiology applications evaluated by CMS by 2023. The Korean Journal of Radiology's 2025 and 2026 series describes Korea, Japan, Taiwan, Singapore, Thailand and other countries one essay at a time. A search in November 2026 found no maintained register across countries outside paid market reports.

europepmc.orgnature.comdoi.org

Built with what exists

CMS's payment files for the physician fee schedule and hospital outpatient care, and the NTAP tables in the Federal Register; Japan's and Korea's published fee schedules and pathway lists; the AMA's yearly CPT release for the count of AI codes; Python; a web agent such as Browser Use to recheck payer pages each quarter (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over").

doi.org

  1. First step

    Match the AI-related codes in CPT 2027 to Medicare's 2027 payment files and record which have a rate.

  2. Done looks like

    Every US AI-related billing code with a 2027 Medicare rate, every NTAP granted to imaging AI, and the payment routes of at least ten other countries, each row linked to a source opened in the last 90 days, published under an open license and refreshed each quarter for a year.

Open 02 · the brief

Payer scan rules compared

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public comparison of the published advanced-imaging rules of radiology benefit managers such as eviCore by Evernorth and Carelon Medical Benefits Management against the American College of Radiology's (ACR) Appropriateness Criteria, for 20 common outpatient complaints such as low back pain, headache and shoulder pain. Each rule is coded into the same fields: weeks of treatment required before the scan, whether an X-ray must come first, the warning signs that allow an immediate scan, and the scan recommended. Every difference is listed, and the table is updated when a rule changes.

Why it is still open

Published comparisons cover one complaint at a time. Berman and colleagues compared the neck MRI rules of the four utilization management companies used by 30 large US insurers and found differences in every category they checked; a 2023 appraisal by five raters scored eviCore's spine imaging guideline 2 to 4 out of 7. A 2020 review found 15 studies from 2013 to 2018 of disagreement among imaging guidelines. Gupta and colleagues compared which services five Medicare Advantage insurers require approval for, but not the clinical criteria behind the approval.

europepmc.orgeuropepmc.orgeuropepmc.orgeuropepmc.org

Built with what exists

the ACR Appropriateness Criteria, free to read online, starting with the eight priority clinical areas CMS named for its AUC program; eviCore's public guideline pages and Carelon's, which keep an archive of past versions; a low-cost model that its maker says is built for extraction and long documents, such as Meta's Muse Ember, to draft the coded fields for a person to check (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); two coders and a spreadsheet.

acsearch.acr.orgevicore.comguidelines.carelonmedicalbenefitsmanagement.com

  1. First step

    Code eviCore's and Carelon's low back pain imaging rules against the ACR's low back pain criteria.

  2. Done looks like

    20 complaints coded from at least two payer rule sets and the ACR criteria, two coders agreeing on at least 90% of fields before they reconcile, every difference listed with its source page, and the table updated within 30 days of each rule change for a year.