Industries / Government, education and community / Education / Homeschooling
Law and oversight
Deciding whether parents may teach their children at home, what they must tell or show the state, who checks, and whether public money follows the child.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1925 to 2024.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1925
Parents may choose the school
The US Supreme Court struck down Oregon's Compulsory Education Act of 1922, which required children aged 8 to 16 to attend public schools. Justice James McReynolds wrote for the Court that "the child is not the mere creature of the state."
Credit
US Supreme Court, Pierce v. Society of Sisters
1972
Amish exemption after eighth grade
The Court held that Wisconsin could not force Amish parents to send their children to formal high school after eighth grade, because their sincere religious objection outweighed the state's interest in one or two more years of schooling.
Credit
US Supreme Court, Wisconsin v. Yoder, opinion by Chief Justice Warren Burger
2006
Europe's court accepts a ban
Christian parents in Germany, refused permission to teach their children at home, took their case to the European Court of Human Rights, which unanimously declared it inadmissible. The court held that Germany's rule fell within the "margin of appreciation", the room each country has to set its own rules, and accepted its aim of "avoiding the emergence of parallel societies". In Wunderlich v. Germany (2019) the court also found no violation when authorities had placed a family's children in a children's home for three weeks in 2013 to enforce school attendance.
LessonIn both cases the court left the choice to national authorities.
Credit
European Court of Human Rights, Konrad and Others v. Germany
2013
A ban is not persecution
A US immigration judge granted asylum in January 2010 to a German family who homeschooled, the Board of Immigration Appeals reversed it in May 2012, and the Sixth Circuit upheld the reversal, holding that a compulsory-attendance law applied to all parents did not single out homeschoolers for persecution. The Department of Homeland Security then let the family stay under "indefinite deferred action" from 4 March 2014, and after telling them to leave in September 2023 has extended their stay a year at a time.
LessonAsylum law asks whether a group is singled out, so the family's stay rests on executive discretion rather than a court ruling.
Credit
US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit (Judge Jeffrey Sutton), Romeike v. Holder; the Home School Legal Defense Association (HSLDA) argued for the family
2021
France moves to permission
A 2021 law made teaching at home in France depend on prior authorization from the education authority, where parents had only had to declare it. Permission is limited to four grounds: the child's health or disability; intensive sport or arts; a traveling family or distance from any public school; or a situation particular to the child. The Constitutional Council upheld the change on 13 August 2021, on condition that officials decide only on those criteria and without discrimination.
LessonThe Council held that the 1882 law had made teaching at home only one way of meeting compulsory instruction, not part of the freedom of education, so Parliament could narrow it.
Credit
French Parliament; Conseil constitutionnel, decision 2021-823 DC
2022
Public money follows the child
Arizona opened its Empowerment Scholarship Accounts, state-funded accounts that parents spend on approved education costs, to every child eligible to enroll in an Arizona public school from kindergarten to grade 12; the law was approved on 7 July 2022. Parents who take an account agree not to file the state's affidavit of intent to homeschool. Texas went further in 2026: families who choose "homeschool/other" receive $2,000, and more than 102,000 students were awarded accounts for 2026–27, by the Texas Comptroller's count.
LessonIn Arizona the money comes with a different legal label, because families who take it agree not to file as homeschoolers.
Credit
Arizona Legislature (HB 2853); Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts
2024
South Africa requires registration
The Basic Education Laws Amendment Act (BELA) rewrote the home education section of the Schools Act from 24 December 2024. Parents must apply to the provincial head of department to register each child, the program must be at least comparable to the national curriculum, and a "competent assessor" must assess the child at the end of each phase; an application counts as approved if officials do not answer within 60 days.
LessonThe law took effect before its supporting rules; the department said its national regulations would not come during the 2025 school year.
Credit
Parliament of South Africa, BELA Act 32 of 2024
Watch for
England's not-in-school registers
The Children's Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 requires each local authority in England to keep a register of children who are not in school, requires parents to tell the authority their child is eligible and to report changes, and lets authorities fine out-of-school education providers who do not supply information. It received Royal Assent on 29 April 2026, but the register section is so far in force only so that ministers can make regulations, and the full duty starts on a date those regulations set.
Achieved whenCommencement regulations bring the register duty into force and local authorities start keeping the registers.
Claimed by
UK Parliament and the Department for Education (bill sponsor Bridget Phillipson), April 2026
Open
01
Reconcile the state law summaries
A table of all 50 US states and the District of Columbia covering notice, required subjects, days or hours, testing, record keeping and parent qualifications, with the statute or regulation citation and the quoted text in every cell. It is then compared line by line with four published summaries: HSLDA's state pages, the Coalition for Responsible Home Education's (CRHE) ratings, the Johns Hopkins Homeschool Hub and the commercial Homeschool Laws by State dataset. HSLDA and CRHE take opposite policy positions. Every disagreement is listed and resolved by citation.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
A cited world law table
One row for each of the 193 UN member states saying whether home education is allowed, allowed only with permission, or not allowed, with the statute and article, the date of the last change and a link to the official text. The table is compared with HSLDA's international directory, the International Center for Home Education Research (ICHER) world map and a 2026 comparison of the 27 EU countries.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Reconcile the state law summaries
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A table of all 50 US states and the District of Columbia covering notice, required subjects, days or hours, testing, record keeping and parent qualifications, with the statute or regulation citation and the quoted text in every cell. It is then compared line by line with four published summaries: HSLDA's state pages, the Coalition for Responsible Home Education's (CRHE) ratings, the Johns Hopkins Homeschool Hub and the commercial Homeschool Laws by State dataset. HSLDA and CRHE take opposite policy positions. Every disagreement is listed and resolved by citation.
Why it is still open
CRHE sorts states into four oversight levels (12 none, 17 minimal, 19 mixed, 2 moderate, as of March 2026) without statute citations. The commercial dataset gives citations, verified June 2026, but draws "not from any advocacy organization" and compares no sources. This research found no published log of where the summaries disagree.
Built with what exists
A current AI model with web browsing, such as Claude or Gemini, which can read a state's whole education-code chapter and quote the exact clause; official legislature websites; Python; a CSV or JSON schema; git to track changes.
First step
Build the cited cells for five states that CRHE and HSLDA classify differently, and publish the first disagreement log.
Done looks like
51 jurisdictions by 6 fields, every cell cited and quoted; a public log of every conflict between any two published summaries, each resolved with a citation; a second person checks a random 10% of cells and agrees on at least 95%.
Open 02 · the brief
A cited world law table
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
One row for each of the 193 UN member states saying whether home education is allowed, allowed only with permission, or not allowed, with the statute and article, the date of the last change and a link to the official text. The table is compared with HSLDA's international directory, the International Center for Home Education Research (ICHER) world map and a 2026 comparison of the 27 EU countries.
Why it is still open
HSLDA's directory lists about 107 countries with no statute citations or dates on its index. ICHER's map "focuses on countries where home education is clearly permitted." Racewicz's 2026 study covers only the 27 EU states, from Eurydice data.
Built with what exists
AI agents that read and translate official legal databases such as legislation.gov.uk, Sweden's riksdagen.se and France's Légifrance; machine translation; Python; a fixed schema.
First step
Build the 27 EU rows and compare them with Racewicz's four categories of regulation.
Done looks like
193 rows, each with a status, citation, link and date; every difference from the existing sources explained by citation; a reader of the original language checks 20 random rows.