Industries / Health / Healthcare / Home health
Documentation and billing
Recording what was assessed and done at each visit, in the form payers require, so the agency gets paid and the payer can check the claim.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1999 to 2020.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1999
One assessment for everyone
On 25 January 1999 the US Health Care Financing Administration, now CMS, required Medicare home health agencies to complete OASIS (Outcome and Assessment Information Set), a fixed set of questions about the patient's condition and abilities, as part of each patient's assessment, and to report the answers electronically to a national database.
Credit
Health Care Financing Administration
2000
Paying per episode
From 1 October 2000, Medicare stopped repaying home health agencies their reasonable costs and paid a set amount per 60-day episode of care, adjusted for each patient's needs using selected OASIS answers.
Credit
Health Care Financing Administration, under the Balanced Budget Act of 1997
2012
Billing outliers mapped
The OIG screened 2010 Medicare claims against six measures of unusual billing and found that about one in four home health agencies exceeded the threshold on at least one, mostly in Texas, Florida, California and Michigan. Medicare had also paid about $5 million for claims that overlapped hospital or nursing home stays or came after the patient had died.
Lessonsimple rules run over claims data show where to look, though passing a threshold does not prove fraud.
Credit
HHS-OIG
2013
New agencies barred
CMS used new powers under the Affordable Care Act, in its own words "for the first time", to stop new home health agencies enrolling in the Miami and Chicago areas for six months from 30 July 2013. Agencies already enrolled could keep billing.
Lessonwhen fraud clusters in places, a payer can control who may enter, not only check claims.
Credit
CMS
2017
Germany's new needs test
Germany's Second Care Strengthening Act brought in a new definition of who needs care and a new assessment tool from 2017, to give equal access to long-term care benefits whether a person's impairment is physical, mental or psychological, with particular attention to dementia. The contribution rate rose by 0.2 percentage points, about €5 billion a year.
Credit
Federal Ministry of Health
2019
Review before payment
CMS's Review Choice Demonstration began in Illinois in June 2019 and spread to Ohio, Texas, Florida, North Carolina and Oklahoma. Agencies choose to have claims checked before submission (pre-claim review) or after payment. In fiscal year 2024 reviewers received 1,791,226 pre-claim requests and approved 97% of those completed; California joins from 18 January 2027.
Credit
CMS; Palmetto GBA as reviewer
2020
Paying by patient type
From 1 January 2020 CMS's Patient-Driven Groupings Model pays for 30-day periods instead of 60-day episodes. Each period falls into one of 432 groups built from where the patient came from, timing, clinical group, function and other illnesses, so payment depends more on the patient than on the number of therapy visits.
Credit
CMS
Watch for
AI notes during visits
VNS Health in New York says its home care clinicians use the Nestmed app on a tablet during visits. The app listens and drafts structured notes for the clinician to review, and VNS says it cuts documentation time "significantly", without a figure or method.
Achieved whenan outside evaluation reports minutes saved per visit and the error rate of drafted notes against clinician-checked records.
Claimed by
VNS Health and Nestmed, April 2026
Open
01
Open checker for Medicare paperwork
A tool that reads a synthetic certification packet (a face-to-face encounter note, a homebound statement and a plan of care) and reports, step by step, whether it meets Medicare's home health documentation rules. The face-to-face encounter is the required visit with a doctor or allowed practitioner, which must fall between 90 days before and 30 days after home care starts and relate to the reason for it; homebound means leaving home takes a considerable and taxing effort. Each flag cites the step it failed in CMS's published Home Health Review Tool.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Outlier screen from public data
An open, repeatable analysis of CMS's public file of payments, visits and patients for each home health agency ("Post-Acute Care Utilization: Home Health Agency by Geography/Provider and Case-Mix Grouping"), joined to the public file of agency owners. It flags agencies far from their peers in the style of the OIG's 2012 measures, with each flag explained and framed as a statistical outlier, not an accusation.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Open checker for Medicare paperwork
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A tool that reads a synthetic certification packet (a face-to-face encounter note, a homebound statement and a plan of care) and reports, step by step, whether it meets Medicare's home health documentation rules. The face-to-face encounter is the required visit with a doctor or allowed practitioner, which must fall between 90 days before and 30 days after home care starts and relate to the reason for it; homebound means leaving home takes a considerable and taxing effort. Each flag cites the step it failed in CMS's published Home Health Review Tool.
Why it is still open
CMS says insufficient documentation caused 51.4% of home health improper payments in its 2024 reporting period, out of an estimated $1.1 billion. CMS publishes its review steps as a flowchart, but searches found only proprietary vendor tools and no open checker or public test set.
Built with what exists
hard-coded rules for dates and provider types; a language model such as Claude for the narrative tests (see the Note "Seven more flagged"), or a local model run through llama.cpp (see the Note "A first stable number for local AI"); test packets written by volunteer clinicians or generated, with no real records.
First step
Turn the Review Tool flowchart into a written rule list, and write 30 packets, 10 clean and 20 with one known defect each.
Done looks like
A public set of at least 300 synthetic packets with seeded defects, labelled by two independent reviewers. On 100 held-out packets the tool catches at least 95% of seeded defects, wrongly flags no more than 5% of clean packets, and maps every flag to a numbered Review Tool step.
Open 02 · the brief
Outlier screen from public data
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open, repeatable analysis of CMS's public file of payments, visits and patients for each home health agency ("Post-Acute Care Utilization: Home Health Agency by Geography/Provider and Case-Mix Grouping"), joined to the public file of agency owners. It flags agencies far from their peers in the style of the OIG's 2012 measures, with each flag explained and framed as a statistical outlier, not an accusation.
Why it is still open
The OIG's 2012 screen used claims data that are not public, and CMS still checks millions of requests one by one under the Review Choice Demonstration. A limited search found no published open method that applies the OIG approach to the public files.
Built with what exists
Python or R; the public CMS files; a language model to draft plain-language explanations of each flag in batches (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass").
First step
Download one year of the provider-level file and reproduce CMS's national totals before building any score.
Done looks like
Code and method published, plus a back-test on an earlier year showing what share of agencies later named in public OIG or Department of Justice actions fell in the top 5% of scores, against the 5% expected by chance.