BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Government / GovTech

Online services

Building the websites, apps and online forms through which residents find information and apply, renew, book or report, whether the work is done by contractors or by governments' own digital teams.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1999 to 2026.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

3

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1999

    Services grouped by life event

    Singapore launched its eCitizen portal in April 1999, grouping information and services by areas of a resident's life instead of by the agency that runs them, under the principle that "All services shall be 'customer-centric' and not 'agency-centric.'" By 2002 it offered more than 1,700 of the 2,600 services the government said could be delivered electronically, and Accenture's surveys ranked Singapore's e-government the second most mature in 2001 and 2002, after Canada, according to a 2002 paper by Mahizhnan and Andiappan that draws on Infocomm Development Authority material.

    imda.gov.sginfitt.org

    Credit

    Government of Singapore; Infocomm Development Authority

  2. 2001

    Countries ranked online

    In 2001 the United Nations and the American Society for Public Administration reviewed the national government websites of 190 UN member states and proposed an index to compare them. The UN has repeated the survey since, and its 13th edition, released in 2024, covered all 193 member states. In that edition Denmark, Estonia, Singapore, Korea and Iceland led, and the US had slipped to 19th, FedScoop reported.

    desapublications.un.orgdesapublications.un.orgfedscoop.com

    Credit

    UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs; American Society for Public Administration

  3. 2012

    One site for government

    A November 2010 report by Martha Lane Fox told the UK government to merge its two main public websites, Directgov and Business Link, under one domain. GOV.UK, built by the new Government Digital Service (GDS), replaced both on 17 October 2012, and the minister, Francis Maude, said it would cost "up to £70 million less per year" than the sites it replaced, a government figure. In April 2013 the Design Museum in London named it Design of the Year.

    gov.ukgov.ukdezeen.com

    Credit

    Martha Lane Fox; Government Digital Service, led by Mike Bracken

  4. 2022

    COBOL blamed, audit disagreed

    As unemployment claims surged in April 2020, New Jersey's governor, Phil Murphy, said the state "literally needed Cobol programmers", COBOL being the decades-old programming language of many government mainframe systems. The State Auditor's IT audit, issued in November 2022, "found no evidence" that delays in processing claims "were caused by deficiencies in the information technology structure or operations": website outages took at most 1.6% of the available filing time from 1 March to 1 May 2020, problems on the mainframe touched 0.18% of daily programs, and the labor department had taken "a reactive approach" to the capacity of its web systems.

    LessonThe oldest part of a system is the easiest to blame, and the measured fault lay in the website's capacity.

    spectrum.ieee.orgdspace.njstatelib.org

    Credit

    New Jersey Office of the State Auditor

  5. 2025

    A digital team closed

    The US General Services Administration (GSA) set up 18F, an in-house team that builds software for other federal agencies, in March 2014. By its tenth anniversary GSA counted 455 projects for 34 agencies, its own figure. On 1 March 2025 GSA eliminated 18F as "non-critical" in a reduction in force that affected about 90 people, Nextgov reported.

    LessonSkills built up inside government can be lost at once when the team that holds them is cut.

    gsa.govnextgov.com

    Credit

    GSA's Technology Transformation Services and the Presidential Innovation Fellows who founded the team

  6. 2026

    A chatbot switched off

    New York City released its MyCity business chatbot, built on Microsoft's cloud, in fall 2023. In March 2024 tests by The Markup and THE CITY found it telling businesses that employers could take workers' tips and landlords could turn away tenants with Section 8 housing vouchers, both against the law. On 30 January 2026 Mayor Zohran Mamdani said he would end it, calling it "functionally unusable" and saying it had cost "around half a million dollars", and the city took it down days later.

    LessonAn assistant on an official site speaks with the government's authority, so it has to be tested against the law before residents rely on it.

    themarkup.org

    Credit

    The Markup and THE CITY, which tested it; Mayor Zohran Mamdani's administration, which ended it

  7. 2026

    Accessibility deadline moved

    A US Department of Justice rule of 24 April 2024 required state and local government websites and apps to meet WCAG 2.1 AA, the level of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines that makes sites usable by people with disabilities, by April 2026 for governments serving 50,000 people or more and by April 2027 for smaller ones. An interim rule that took effect on 20 April 2026, four days before the first deadline, moved the dates to 26 April 2027 and 26 April 2028 without changing the standard. The department called the original dates "infeasible and unfair to covered entities"; the National Federation of the Blind sued over the delay on 21 May 2026, and the case is ongoing.

    LessonA deadline set two years ahead can still move days before it arrives.

    govinfo.govada.govclearinghouse.net

    Credit

    US Department of Justice

Watch for

  1. GOV.UK Chat answers

    GDS says that across two pilots more than 10,000 users asked GOV.UK Chat, an AI assistant that answers from GOV.UK's pages, 26,000 questions, and that its accuracy rose from 76% to 90%, judged by "a combination of subject matter experts, and automated evaluation tools". It runs on Anthropic's Claude models through Amazon Bedrock, GDS says, and went live in the GOV.UK app in May 2026.

    Achieved whenan outside body, such as the National Audit Office or university researchers, publishes a repeatable evaluation that finds accuracy close to GDS's figure.

    insidegovuk.blog.gov.ukpublictechnology.net

    Claimed by

    Government Digital Service, March 2026

  2. An AI front door

    America.gov, launched by GSA's National Design Studio on 29 September 2026, is an AI assistant drawing on about 29,000 government websites and meant to become "the single point of entry for Americans to access covered services online". It runs on Google's Gemini and xAI's Grok models, according to The Next Web. No accuracy figures have been published, and the Associated Press found its answers changing within hours of launch.

    Achieved whenan independent evaluation of its answers is published, and outside reporting or an inspector general confirms that people complete services through it.

    fedscoop.comthenextweb.com

    Claimed by

    GSA and the National Design Studio, September 2026

  3. Public services by chat

    Ukraine's Ministry of Digital Transformation launched Diia.AI in September 2025, an assistant on its Diia portal that issues documents such as an income certificate inside a chat, and calls it "the world's first AI assistant that provides public services to citizens at the national level". The pages read give no usage or accuracy figures.

    Achieved whenan independent study or audit reports how often it completes requests correctly.

    kmu.gov.uagovinsider.asia

    Claimed by

    Ministry of Digital Transformation of Ukraine, September 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Named county accessibility scans

    An open, monthly scan of every US county's official homepage and one service page, such as paying a tax or applying for a permit, against WCAG 2.1 AA, with every county named and the raw results published. Report what automated tools detect, not full conformance, since WPPersona says automated tools catch "roughly 30-40% of violations".

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Application PDFs, checked

    A census of the PDF forms that counties ask people to fill in to apply for services, each tested for the tags and labeled fields that screen readers need.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  3. 03

    Test the national chatbot

    A public set of 200 realistic, made-up questions about US federal services, each with an answer and a link to the official page it comes from, asked of America.gov a few at a time and graded by two people.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Named county accessibility scans

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open, monthly scan of every US county's official homepage and one service page, such as paying a tax or applying for a permit, against WCAG 2.1 AA, with every county named and the raw results published. Report what automated tools detect, not full conformance, since WPPersona says automated tools catch "roughly 30-40% of violations".

Why it is still open

Scans exist, but not openly by name. AccessLumens tested 221 cities in July 2026 and says "Individual cities are not named"; WPPersona scanned 2,412 government sites, of which 11.3% passed automated checks, with the full data "Available via demo"; GSA's open Site Scanning program covers federal sites only.

accesslumens.comwppersona.comdigital.gov

Built with what exists

axe-core, the open-source accessibility checker, run through Playwright; Pa11y and Lighthouse as cross-checks; a public list of counties; GitHub for the data. Respect sites that block automated visitors instead of working around them.

  1. First step

    Scan every county in one state and publish the code, the method and the results.

  2. Done looks like

    at least 90% of counties with an identifiable official site scanned and named, the checker version and scan date recorded for each run, 50 sites checked by hand with the agreement rate stated, and two monthly runs published before the April 2027 deadline.

Open 02 · the brief

Application PDFs, checked

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A census of the PDF forms that counties ask people to fill in to apply for services, each tested for the tags and labeled fields that screen readers need.

Why it is still open

The Justice Department's rule exempts old documents, but not those "currently being used to apply for, access, or participate in" services. The vendor accessiBe says "the majority of public-facing PDFs fail basic accessibility checks" but gives no figure, WPPersona's PDF sample sits behind a demo request, and AccessLumens did not test PDFs.

ada.govaccessibe.com

Built with what exists

a crawler that downloads only public files; AI models such as Claude, Gemini or GPT to sort out which PDFs are application forms (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); veraPDF, an open-source checker for the PDF/UA accessibility standard; pdfinfo; 200 files labeled by hand. Never submit a form.

  1. First step

    Run the crawler and checks on ten counties' sites and publish the table.

  2. Done looks like

    a public table of every application-form PDF found on the sites of the 100 most populous counties, each marked tagged or not and pass or fail in veraPDF, and a sorting step with at least 90% precision on the hand-labeled files.

Open 03 · the brief

Test the national chatbot

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public set of 200 realistic, made-up questions about US federal services, each with an answer and a link to the official page it comes from, asked of America.gov a few at a time and graded by two people.

Why it is still open

No accuracy figures for America.gov have been published, and reporting so far rests on spot checks. The Open Data Institute's CitizenQuery-UK benchmark put 22,066 citizen questions to 11 AI models, but it tested the models, not an assistant a government runs.

fedscoop.comtheregister.com

Built with what exists

answers taken from the Social Security Administration, IRS, State Department and USA.gov pages; a browser, or Playwright, to ask the questions slowly; AI models such as Claude, Gemini and GPT to pre-grade; CitizenQuery-UK as a method to follow; each question asked several times to see whether the answer holds (see the Note "All twenty times").

  1. First step

    Write and source-check 50 questions, and read America.gov's terms of use before asking any.

  2. Done looks like

    questions, transcripts and grades published, agreement between the two graders (Cohen's kappa) of at least 0.7, the share of wrong answers with a confidence interval, and a rerun a month later.