BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Government / GovTech

Identity

How people prove who they are to use public services online: national ID cards with chips, government sign-in services, checks that match a photo ID to a selfie, and driving licenses held on phones.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2002 to 2026.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2002

    ID cards with chips

    Estonia handed over its first 174 chip-based ID cards on 28 January 2002 and issued 117,609 that year. By 2022 the cards were used for about 3 million digital signatures a month, by the count of Estonia's Information System Authority (RIA).

    ria.ee

    Credit

    Republic of Estonia

  2. 2003

    One sign-in for a country

    Singapore launched Singpass in 2003 as a single sign-in for government e-services. By June 2026 it had 5.5 million users, 97% of citizens and permanent residents aged 15 and over, and handled more than 41 million transactions a month, by the count of GovTech Singapore, the agency that runs it. A 2024 benchmark of 14 countries by the consultancy Sia Partners found that "the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Singapore stand out as the most digitally mature countries" in national identity.

    smartnation.gov.sgisomer-user-content.by.gov.sgsia-partners.com

    Credit

    Government of Singapore; GovTech Singapore

  3. 2017

    A chip flaw suspends cards

    Researchers at Masaryk University showed in October 2017 that RSA keys, the keys an ID card uses to sign and prove identity, could be worked out cheaply when made by a code library from the chip maker Infineon: a 1024-bit key took computing worth $40 to $80. The flaw, called ROCA, affected about 800,000 Estonian ID cards. Estonia suspended the certificates of 760,000 cards on 3 November 2017 and let holders renew them from their own computers or at police service points, and by April 2018, 494,000 cards, 95% of those used electronically, had been renewed.

    LessonIn RIA's words, "governments cannot fully solve problems inherent in technologies they are merely a customer of".

    crocs.fi.muni.czria.eeria.ee

    Credit

    Matúš Nemec, Marek Sýs, Petr Švenda, Dušan Klinec and Vashek Matyáš of Masaryk University; Estonia's RIA

  4. 2019

    Verify verifies under half

    GOV.UK Verify was the UK government's service for proving identity online. The NAO reported in March 2019 that 3.6 million people had signed up, against a 2016 forecast of 25 million users by 2020, that GDS reported a verification success rate of 48% against a projected 90%, and that Verify had cost at least £154 million. It closed in 2023, and GOV.UK One Login replaced it.

    LessonA sign-in that verifies fewer than half of the people who try it cannot become the default way in.

    nao.org.ukglobalgovernmentforum.comgov.uk

    Credit

    Government Digital Service; findings by the NAO

  5. 2021

    Licenses on phones standardized

    ISO and IEC published ISO/IEC 18013-5 on 30 September 2021, the standard for the mobile driving licence (mDL): how a license held on a phone talks to a reader, and how the reader checks that the issuing authority signed it. In the US, the American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators (AAMVA) runs a Digital Trust Service that lets readers check state mobile licenses issued under the standard, and Iowa became its 12th member jurisdiction in July 2026.

    webstore.iec.chkenticoprodupgrade.aamva.orgaamva.org

    Credit

    ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 17, the committee that wrote the standard; AAMVA

  6. 2022

    Selfie made optional

    The US Internal Revenue Service said on 7 February 2022 that it would stop requiring facial recognition through ID.me, a private identity company, for new online accounts, and later that month added a live video interview with an agent as an option that needs no biometrics. In November 2022 two House committees found that ID.me had "inaccurately overstated its capacity" to the IRS: it had said video-chat waits were "about 2 hours", while its own data showed average waits of more than four hours in 14 of the 21 state unemployment programs it served.

    LessonA face-scan route needs a fallback staffed by people with real capacity, and a vendor's claims about that capacity need checking.

    irs.govkrebsonsecurity.comcoronavirus-democrats-oversight.house.gov

    Credit

    IRS; ID.me; House Committee on Oversight and Reform and Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Crisis

  7. 2026

    A national ID dropped

    On 26 September 2025 the UK government announced a free digital ID, to be mandatory for right-to-work checks "by the end of the Parliament". It dropped the mandatory element on 14 January 2026, and in July 2026 it announced that it would not proceed with digital identity at all, as the NAO recorded in a lessons-learned report published in September 2026.

    LessonIn the NAO's words, "Implementing digital identity at scale across fragmented public services is a complex integration challenge".

    gov.ukpublictechnology.netnao.org.uk

    Credit

    UK Prime Minister's Office; NAO

Watch for

  1. Driving license in a wallet

    GDS says the digital driving licence in its GOV.UK Wallet app, tested since December 2025 by "a small group of GDS and DVLA colleagues", will be rolled out to the public in England, Wales and Scotland in 2026, with government credentials "available digitally and securely in the GOV.UK Wallet by the end of 2027".

    Achieved whenany driver can add the license, and someone outside GDS, such as DVLA statistics or the NAO, reports how many people use it.

    gds.blog.gov.ukroadmap-for-modern-digital-government.campaign.gov.uk

    Claimed by

    Government Digital Service and the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency (DVLA), January 2026

  2. One Login at 250 services

    GDS lists "250 central government services accessed via GOV.UK One Login", the sign-in that replaced Verify, as its progress for September 2026. In February 2026 Civil Service World reported that One Login had just regained its certification under the UK's digital identity trust framework after eight months without it, because a supplier had "allowed their certification to lapse".

    Achieved whenan outside body, such as the NAO or Parliament's Public Accounts Committee, confirms the count and that the service holds its certification.

    roadmap-for-modern-digital-government.campaign.gov.ukcivilserviceworld.com

    Claimed by

    Government Digital Service, September 2026

  3. Mobile licenses tested together

    The OpenID Foundation reported that "a significant number" of implementations passed its tests at the 13th ISO interoperability event for mobile driving licenses, held in La Ciotat, France, checked against ISO/IEC 18013-5 and its online companion, 18013-7. It named no vendors and gave no counts.

    Achieved whenresults are published for each implementation, or an independent party reproduces them with the foundation's open-source tests.

    idtechwire.com

    Claimed by

    OpenID Foundation, as reported by IDTechWire, June 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Test license reader apps

    A public test of free mobile driving license reader apps against ISO/IEC 18013-5, using only made-up licenses signed by the tester's own test authority: about ten bad credentials, such as an expired license, an unknown issuer, altered data or a bad signature from the phone, plus one valid control, and a table of which apps reject each bad one. Test only apps that accept a test trust root, never use real state credentials, and tell vendors about failures before publishing.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Routes without a phone

    A public table of national government sign-in services showing, from each service's own help pages, whether a person can prove identity without a smartphone, without a face scan, in person, or with a trusted helper, each cell linked to its page, dated and archived.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Test license reader apps

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test of free mobile driving license reader apps against ISO/IEC 18013-5, using only made-up licenses signed by the tester's own test authority: about ten bad credentials, such as an expired license, an unknown issuer, altered data or a bad signature from the phone, plus one valid control, and a table of which apps reject each bad one. Test only apps that accept a test trust root, never use real state credentials, and tell vendors about failures before publishing.

Why it is still open

The official test methods, ISO/IEC TS 18013-6, published in December 2025, are a paid standard, and the interoperability events publish no results by vendor. The OpenID Foundation's open tests cover presenting a license online, not apps that read one in person, and the OpenWallet Foundation's open-source Identity Reader app offers no conformance mode.

knowledge.bsigroup.comidtechwire.comgithub.com

Built with what exists

the OpenWallet Foundation's Multipaz software and its Identity Reader app; Google's mdl-ref-apps; OpenSSL; Python with the cbor2 and pycose libraries to build bad credentials; two Android phones for NFC and Bluetooth.

  1. First step

    Make a test root and ten bad credentials with Multipaz, and run them against the Multipaz Identity Reader as a control.

  2. Done looks like

    at least five reader apps run against at least ten test cases, with the credentials and scripts published so that anyone gets the same results.

Open 02 · the brief

Routes without a phone

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of national government sign-in services showing, from each service's own help pages, whether a person can prove identity without a smartphone, without a face scan, in person, or with a trusted helper, each cell linked to its page, dated and archived.

Why it is still open

The nearest study, Sia Partners' 2024 benchmark of 14 countries, scores how people apply for passports and ID cards, and notes that "In-person appointments are still a required step in most countries", but does not map these routes. The facts are scattered across help pages: GOV.UK One Login lists an app with a camera, online security questions or a Post Office visit, and the US Department of Veterans Affairs says Login.gov "offers in-person identity verification at participating United States Postal Service (USPS) locations".

sia-partners.comgov.ukva.gov

Built with what exists

Playwright to capture pages; the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine to keep copies; AI models such as Claude, Gemini or GPT to fill a fixed form from each page, with a person checking every cell.

  1. First step

    Fix the fields and fill them for five services: GOV.UK One Login, Login.gov, Singpass, Australia's myID and Estonia's ID card.

  2. Done looks like

    at least 30 services in at least 20 countries, every cell sourced and archived, and a second reviewer agreeing with at least 90% of a random 20% sample.