BRENNEN

Industries / Retail, hospitality and personal services / Hospitality and tourism / Gaming and casinos

Lotteries

A lottery sells numbered chances and pays prizes to the tickets drawn at random; most are run or licensed by governments to raise money.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1569 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1569

    A state lottery for harbours

    Elizabeth I advertised England's first recorded lottery in 1567 to pay for harbour repairs and other public works. It offered 40,000 shares at ten shillings each, with a top prize of £5,000 paid partly in money and partly in plate, tapestries and linen. It was drawn at the west door of St Paul's Cathedral in London from 11 January to 6 May 1569.

    lotterygoodcauses.org.uk

    Credit

    the government of Elizabeth I; as told by the UK National Lottery's good-causes site

  2. 1964

    New Hampshire's lottery

    New Hampshire set up a state lottery in 1964, and North America's lottery association counts its members' fundraising from that year. By its count US lotteries have since raised more than $644.6 billion for government programs, and in fiscal 2024 they passed almost $30.6 billion to their beneficiaries.

    naspl.org

    Credit

    State of New Hampshire; figures from the North American Association of State and Provincial Lotteries (NASPL)

  3. 1980

    The Triple Six Fix

    On 24 April 1980 Pennsylvania's televised Daily Number drawing was rigged. Nick Perry, the presenter, and lottery official Edward Plevel injected paint into every ball except the 4s and 6s, so 6-6-6 came up, and partners bet heavily on combinations of those digits. Bookmakers who had taken the bets grew suspicious, and Perry was convicted in 1981.

    LessonLotteries stopped using ping-pong balls for big jackpot draws, according to the Multi-State Lottery Association's director in 2008, and Pennsylvania now has security officers, accountants and public witnesses at every draw.

    archive.triblive.comlotteryusa.com

    Credit

    rigged by Nick Perry and Edward Plevel; reported by Tim Puko, Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, 2008

  4. 2007

    Insiders win too often

    In October 2006 CBC's the fifth estate told how a retailer cheated a customer, Bob Edmonds, out of a C$250,000 prize. Ontario's Ombudsman then found that the Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corporation had known for years that retailers could steal winning tickets. Statistician Jeffrey Rosenthal of the University of Toronto estimated that retail insiders won prizes of C$50,000 or more 3.5 to 5.7 times as often as chance predicts. The corporation's response plan included about C$10 million for ticket checkers that customers use themselves.

    LessonA lottery that earns its money through retailers was slow to police them, and the Ombudsman recommended an independent regulator.

    ombudsman.on.caombudsman.on.ca

    Credit

    André Marin, Ombudsman of Ontario, report "A Game of Trust", March 2007; Jeffrey Rosenthal

  5. 2014

    Frequent winners counted

    In March 2014 The Palm Beach Post showed that serial Florida winners, many of them store owners, had claimed prizes against long odds. Pew's Stateline reported that Florida suspended 14 retailers that year and began tracking frequent winners; a later account puts the number of retailers terminated at 18. In 2021 Pennsylvania's Auditor General found 17 players with 50 or more wins of $600 between July 2017 and March 2020, 1,344 claims worth nearly $2.7 million, which the Lottery had the data to spot but did not analyse. In Massachusetts one family cashed more than 14,000 tickets between 2011 and 2020, and a federal jury convicted the father and one son.

    LessonLotteries held the claim records needed to spot people cashing tickets for others, often to dodge tax or child-support deductions, yet many did not use them, and Pennsylvania's lottery called the statistical method flawed.

    pew.orgpenncapital-star.comlotteryusa.com

    Credit

    The Palm Beach Post; Pennsylvania Auditor General Tim DeFoor

  6. 2017

    A rigged number generator

    Eddie Tipton, who designed and maintained the software for random number generators at the Multi-State Lottery Association, rigged the code so that he knew winning numbers in advance. The scheme covered seven tickets in five states. It unravelled over an Iowa Hot Lotto jackpot from December 2010 that officials refused to pay, after a gas station's security camera showed Tipton buying the ticket. He pleaded guilty in Iowa in June 2017 and was sentenced in August 2017 to up to 25 years and about $2.2 million in restitution.

    LessonWitnesses and sealed draw machines did not reach the code, and an insider who wrote the software could rig it.

    abc15.comtheregister.com

    Credit

    prosecuted by the Iowa Attorney General's office; reported by CNN and The Register

  7. 2025

    A lottery agency abolished

    In 2023 one group bought tickets covering 99% of the 26 million possible Lotto Texas combinations and won a $95 million jackpot, with help from stores tied to courier companies that buy tickets for customers online. Sunset Commission staff estimated couriers made about 9% of the agency's draw ticket sales. Texas abolished its Lottery Commission on 1 September 2025, moved the lottery to the Department of Licensing and Regulation, barred buying tickets by phone or app, made selling them that way for pay a crime, and limited how many tickets one person can buy in one transaction.

    LessonA game whose every combination can be bought at once, through unregulated middlemen, invites bulk buying.

    texasstandard.orgcapitol.texas.govcapitol.texas.gov

    Credit

    Texas Legislature, SB 3070; reported by Ayden Runnels, The Texas Tribune

Watch for

  1. Protection at the till

    Allwyn, which runs the UK National Lottery, says its early-2026 platform change added new protections for every player online and in its app, and it has committed to strengthen support for at-risk players in shops. The regulator noted "teething issues".

    Achieved whenAllwyn or an outside evaluator publishes what the protections do and how many players they reached, online and in shops.

    gamblingcommission.gov.uk

    Claimed by

    Allwyn, as reported by the Gambling Commission's acting chief executive Sarah Gardner, October 2026

  2. Texas under new oversight

    Texas lawmakers moved the lottery to a new regulator to fix the oversight failures found by Sunset Commission staff, with an annual State Auditor audit and a limited Sunset review of the lottery in the two years to 31 August 2027.

    Achieved whenthe first annual audit or the 2027 review reports whether courier sales and bulk buying have stopped.

    capitol.texas.govcapitol.texas.gov

    Claimed by

    Texas Legislature, SB 3070, 2025

Open

  1. 01

    An open frequent-winner monitor

    An open-source tool that takes the prize-claim records states release under public-records law and flags claimants who win more often than any plausible level of play allows. It states the spending each claim count would require, as mathematician Skip Garibaldi did for Florida, and is refreshed each quarter. It publishes only counts and methods; named cases go privately to the lottery and the state auditor, never onto the site.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A draw anyone can check

    A working prototype of a computer-drawn lottery that outsiders can recompute. Before sales close, the lottery publishes a hash of its secret seed and names a future round of the drand public randomness beacon. After the draw it publishes the seed, and a short script lets anyone recompute the winning numbers from the seed and the beacon value.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

An open frequent-winner monitor

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open-source tool that takes the prize-claim records states release under public-records law and flags claimants who win more often than any plausible level of play allows. It states the spending each claim count would require, as mathematician Skip Garibaldi did for Florida, and is refreshed each quarter. It publishes only counts and methods; named cases go privately to the lottery and the state auditor, never onto the site.

Why it is still open

In 2017 a team of Columbia Journalism School graduates, working with PennLive, obtained about 11 million prize claims from 36 of the 45 US lotteries and counted as frequent winners those who claimed 50 or more prizes of $600 or more. Philip Stark's notebook for the probability calculation is public, but the claim data were not released and the analysis was a one-time project. In 2021 Pennsylvania's Auditor General found that the state lottery had the data to spot frequent winners but did not analyse it; the lottery called the method flawed and said it had no legal power to investigate frequent winners who are not retailers. A GitHub search in this research found no maintained public tool.

cjr.orggithub.compenncapital-star.comlotteryusa.com

Built with what exists

State public-records portals, Python with pandas, and Philip Stark's published minimum-spend notebook, which applies the method of Richard Arratia, Skip Garibaldi, Lawrence Mower and Philip Stark (Mathematics Magazine, 2015).

  1. First step

    Send public-records requests for all claims of $600 or more since 2015 to three state lotteries.

  2. Done looks like

    Claim records from at least five states loaded, the method documented and reviewed by an outside statistician, and the tool independently flagging the people in at least three cases that later ended in a conviction or licence loss, such as the Massachusetts ticket cashers.

Open 02 · the brief

A draw anyone can check

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A working prototype of a computer-drawn lottery that outsiders can recompute. Before sales close, the lottery publishes a hash of its secret seed and names a future round of the drand public randomness beacon. After the draw it publishes the seed, and a short script lets anyone recompute the winning numbers from the seed and the beacon value.

Why it is still open

Tipton's case showed that an insider who maintained a lottery's random number software could predict its results. The League of Entropy, which runs drand, names lotteries as a natural use, but its page cites no government lottery using it. This research found checkable draws only in private raffles and crypto lotteries, not in any government lottery.

abc15.comcloudflare.com

Built with what exists

drand's public HTTP API, SHA-256 and HMAC from Python's standard library, and a public Git repository as the draw log.

  1. First step

    Write the commit-and-reveal draw script against drand's API and publish a week of simulated daily Pick 3 draws.

  2. Done looks like

    A log of 1,000 simulated daily draws that a verifier written by someone else recomputes without a mismatch, plus a test in which a planted Tipton-style rule is caught every time.