Industries / Mining and materials / Mining and quarrying / Frac sand
Washing and drying
Washing rinses clay and silt off mined sand with water that the plant cleans and reuses, and drying heats the clean sand until it is dry enough to screen and ship.
5
Milestones achieved, from 2013 to 2019.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
2013
Wash ponds tested for metals
Wash plants reuse their water after letting the clay settle out in ponds. When Wisconsin's DNR sampled wash water in 2013, it found aluminum at 178 times the state standard and lead and manganese at four times the level it recommends for groundwater, but the water was so cloudy that the agency could not tell whether the metals were in the water or in the sediment.
LessonA cloudy sample cannot show whether metals are dissolved or only carried on fine sediment.
Credit
Wisconsin DNR, as reported by Wisconsin Public Radio in 2016
2017
No flocculant residue found
Plants add flocculants, chemicals that clump fine clay so it sinks, to clear wash water for reuse. The usual one is polyacrylamide; the polymer has no documented health effects, but its building block, acrylamide, is a probable human carcinogen. Chippewa County, Wisconsin, required acrylamide monitoring at four mine sites, and the state's 2017 review of industrial sand mining reported none in soil or groundwater sampled downstream of where it could escape, while saying more research on wash water and sludge may be needed.
Credit
Chippewa County Department of Land Conservation and Forest Management; Wisconsin DNR
2018
Wash pond drained in rescue
On 21 May 2018 Hi-Crush drained 10 million gallons of wash water from a holding pond at its mine in the Town of Lincoln, Trempealeau County, Wisconsin, to rescue a worker trapped in a submerged bulldozer. The water crossed fields and reached the Trempealeau River; DNR samples where it entered a creek held 67 parts per billion (ppb) of arsenic, 2,340 ppb of copper and 1,440 ppb of lead, and early results showed that most of the metals settled out soon after.
LessonMetals that build up in a recycled wash pond leave with the water when the pond is emptied in a hurry.
Credit
Wisconsin DNR and Hi-Crush (sampling), as reported by Wisconsin Public Radio
2019
Rocks named as metal source
Geologists found metal-bearing sulfide minerals, such as pyrite, in the Wonewoc sandstone that western Wisconsin mines wash and in the Tunnel City rock piled on top of it. They concluded that these rocks are a likely natural source of the high metal levels in some wash ponds, released when the sulfides meet air and oxidize, and that the sulfides vary from site to site.
Credit
James J. Zambito IV, Lisa D. Haas and Michael J. Parsen (Wisconsin Geological and Natural History Survey) and Patrick I. McLaughlin (Indiana Geological and Water Survey)
2019
Sand pumped without drying
Drying washed sand in gas-fired kilns takes 300,000 to 400,000 British thermal units (Btu) per ton by the estimate of PropX, a maker of sand-handling equipment, and drying and dry storage often limit how much a mine can ship. In 2019 Ovintiv and PropX pumped damp sand, 1% to 10% water by weight, into more than 100 fracturing stages on an Oklahoma pad, and Chesapeake Energy first tried it on a few Eagle Ford stages in August 2019 and later reported savings of about $11 a ton; SLB reported a similar pilot for Vista Energy in Argentina's Vaca Muerta in 2022.
LessonChesapeake's engineers found loading problems above about 6% water, and damp sand freezes, so the method suits warm basins.
Credit
PropX and Ovintiv (field test and first conference paper, SPE 199975); Chesapeake Energy
Watch for
Dry sand added beside wet
Wallstreet Sand Co. says it has started dry frac sand operations at its plant in Kermit, Texas, alongside its existing wet sand, so it can serve operators and service companies whose jobs still call for dry sand.
Achieved whena state air permit or a customer confirms that the dryer is running and gives its output in tons per hour.
Claimed by
Wallstreet Sand Co., as reported by World Oil, January 2026
Open
01
Dryer fuel per ton
A public table that gives, for each frac sand plant with a dryer, the gas or propane it burns and the tons it dries in a year, so fuel per ton can be compared across plants, dryer types (rotating drum or fluidized bed, where hot air blown up through a plate lifts the sand) and basins.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Which wash ponds turn acid
An open dataset that joins wash-pond water tests (pH and dissolved metals) at Wisconsin sand mines to the rock layers each mine digs, and a published test of whether ponds at mines that move Tunnel City rock run more acid and higher in metals.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Dryer fuel per ton
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table that gives, for each frac sand plant with a dryer, the gas or propane it burns and the tons it dries in a year, so fuel per ton can be compared across plants, dryer types (rotating drum or fluidized bed, where hot air blown up through a plate lifts the sand) and basins.
Why it is still open
The drying figures in print, 300,000 to 400,000 Btu per ton and nearly 1 million tons of carbon dioxide in the Permian Basin in 2022, are estimates by PropX's founder and an executive, whose company sells wet-sand equipment; no plant-by-plant tally was found.
Built with what exists
The US Environmental Protection Agency's Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program data through its Envirofacts API, where 8 facilities coded as industrial sand mining reported for 2023, among them U.S. Silica's Ottawa plant, Covia's Wedron, Crane and Kermit plants and Hi-Crush's Kermit and Wyeville plants; state air permits, which list dryer burner ratings in million Btu per hour and limits in tons per hour; a language model that reads permit PDFs and pulls out those numbers, such as Claude (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); Python.
First step
Download the 2015 to 2024 emissions of the eight industrial sand facilities from Envirofacts and list the other frac sand plants that report under different industry codes.
Done looks like
At least 25 plants in at least three states, each with carbon dioxide per ton dried worked out from reported emissions and reported or permitted throughput, each number linked to its document, and the median compared with PropX's 300,000 to 400,000 Btu per ton.
Open 02 · the brief
Which wash ponds turn acid
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open dataset that joins wash-pond water tests (pH and dissolved metals) at Wisconsin sand mines to the rock layers each mine digs, and a published test of whether ponds at mines that move Tunnel City rock run more acid and higher in metals.
Why it is still open
The 2019 survey report found the metal-bearing sulfides "spatially and stratigraphically variable" and wrote that "more work is needed to be able to predict their distribution as the current dataset is limited in areal extent and spatial resolution."
Built with what exists
The survey report's appendices (portable X-ray fluorescence readings and laboratory metal analyses of rock); pond and outfall monitoring reports held by the Wisconsin DNR and counties, obtained by public records request; county reclamation plans, which describe the overburden; Python with pandas and scikit-learn.
First step
Download the survey's appendices and send the DNR a records request for wash-water monitoring results from mines in Trempealeau, Chippewa and Jackson counties.
Done looks like
Results from at least 15 ponds at 10 or more mines joined to each mine's rock layers, with the share of samples below pH 6 or above Wisconsin groundwater standards compared between mines with and without Tunnel City rock, and the data and code public.