Industries / Government, education and community / Nonprofits / Foundations
The endowment
Foundations invest the money they hold so that it pays for grants every year, often with the aim of lasting forever.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1500s to 2020.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1500s
Endowments made of cash
In the Ottoman Empire a cash waqf was an endowment of money rather than land, whose interest paid a teacher or preacher or, under some deeds, went back to the founder, as the historian Jon Mandaville described in 1979. Jurists argued in the 16th century over whether such endowments were valid and binding, and the judge Çivizade banned them for a time while he was kazasker, a chief military judge; Mandaville called the result "the legitimized practice of usurious piety".
Credit
Ottoman founders of cash waqfs; the jurist Ebussuud Efendi, whose 1563 book of legal forms included a model cash waqf deed
1968
Loans as well as grants
In 1968 the Ford Foundation's trustees authorized a $10 million experiment in program-related investments (PRIs): loans and stakes in for-profit projects, such as minority-owned businesses, farms, factories and housing, made to serve the foundation's mission rather than to earn a profit. Early results were mixed, as some businesses failed or did not repay their loans, and PRIs cost much more to run than grants; one trustee, Vivian Henderson, said "we're now becoming bankers".
LessonInvesting for a mission takes banking skills and costs that grantmaking does not.
Credit
Ford Foundation; John Simon, who wrote the legal framework in federal tax regulations that let foundations lend to for-profit companies, by the Rockefeller Archive Center's account
1976
Five percent a year
Before 1969 no US rule required foundations to make any grants. The Tax Reform Act of 1969 closed that gap with rules that proved complicated, and in 1976 Congress set the "five percent payout requirement". The law now ties a foundation's minimum yearly payout to its "minimum investment return", 5% of the market value of the assets it does not use directly for its charitable work.
LessonThe floor became the norm; the median payout of independent foundations in Candid's surveys has stayed at 5% for five years.
Credit
US Congress
2009
The deepest cut in giving
After the 2008 crash, US foundation assets fell 17%, and foundation giving fell an estimated 8.4% in 2009, from $46.8 billion to $42.9 billion, by far the largest decline the Foundation Center had tracked.
LessonFoundations cut giving by less than half as much as their assets fell, but a payout tied to asset values still shrinks in a crash.
Credit
Foundation Center, Foundation Growth and Giving Estimates (2010 edition)
2014
Selling fossil fuels
The Rockefeller Brothers Fund announced in 2014 that it would sell its fossil fuel investments. A 2025 review by the consultancy The Investment Integration Project (TIIP) found the portfolio 99.7% free of fossil fuels at the end of 2024, with a return of 7.76% a year over the ten years to 2024, more than one percentage point a year above its main benchmark and with 27% less risk, as AI-CIO reported.
Credit
Rockefeller Brothers Fund; TIIP (review)
2020
Borrowing to give more
In June 2020 the Ford Foundation offered $1 billion of social bonds, rated Aaa and AAA by Moody's and S&P, so it could pay out more than 10% of its endowment in 2020 and 2021, double the legal minimum; Ford said it was the first nonprofit foundation to offer a labeled social bond in the US taxable corporate bond market. With the Doris Duke, MacArthur, Kellogg and Mellon foundations, it expected over $1.7 billion above normal payouts over about two years. By mid-2022 Ford had spent more than 90% of the money, 87% of it as general support, the Associated Press reported.
LessonTwo years on the foundations stood by the debt but said they were unlikely to repeat it, because repaying it puts pressure on endowment earnings.
Credit
Ford Foundation; Doris Duke Charitable Foundation, MacArthur Foundation, W.K. Kellogg Foundation and Andrew W. Mellon Foundation
Watch for
Spending down by 2045
Bill Gates said in May 2025 that the Gates Foundation, then holding a $77 billion endowment, would spend $200 billion over 20 years and close in 2045. In January 2026 its board approved a record budget of $9 billion for 2026, capped operating costs at $1.25 billion, about 14% of the budget, and planned to cut up to 500 of its 2,375 staff positions by 2030.
Achieved whenThe foundation's audited accounts and tax returns show spending near the pledged pace each year and the endowment drawing down on schedule.
Claimed by
Bill Gates and the Gates Foundation, May 2025 and January 2026
Open
01
What foundations own
A public dataset of the stocks, bonds and other investments that the 1,000 largest US private foundations list with their tax returns, for each year, with every holding matched to a standard security identifier and an industry. A second table flags holdings that clash with a foundation's own stated mission, such as tobacco shares held by a health foundation, for a person to review.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Pledges checked against filings
A public tracker of foundations that have pledged to give more than the legal minimum, such as the Gates Foundation's spend-down, the MacArthur Foundation's pledge to pay out at least 6% in 2025 and 2026, and the signers of the Meet the Moment pledge, with each pledge set beside the payout on the foundation's filed tax return, year by year.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
What foundations own
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public dataset of the stocks, bonds and other investments that the 1,000 largest US private foundations list with their tax returns, for each year, with every holding matched to a standard security identifier and an industry. A second table flags holdings that clash with a foundation's own stated mission, such as tobacco shares held by a health foundation, for a person to review.
Why it is still open
The IRS instructions for Form 990-PF, the private foundation tax return, tell foundations to "attach a schedule that lists each security held at the end of the year" and to list each "other" investment. The IRS publishes e-filed returns as data, and the Urban Institute's National Center for Charitable Statistics (NCCS) turns 990-PF returns into 80 tables, but its description names no table of these holdings lists. A 2022 summary of a study of foundation investments, built from 990-PF returns for 1991 to 2016, says research has been thin "mostly due to the lack of high-quality data", and it measured returns, not holdings. This research found no public dataset of what each foundation owns.
Built with what exists
The IRS's bulk e-file data for Form 990-PF and the NCCS tables; OpenFIGI, a free service that matches security names to standard identifiers; a small AI model for reading attached schedules, such as Meta's Muse Ember, built for extraction and long-document parsing (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Python.
First step
Download the e-filed returns of the 50 largest foundations for one year and count how many attach their holdings as structured data and how many as scanned pages.
Done looks like
Holdings for at least 1,000 foundations for two tax years, with at least 90% of holdings by value matched to an identifier; a hand check of 300 random rows against the returns finds at least 98% correct; data and code published.
Open 02 · the brief
Pledges checked against filings
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public tracker of foundations that have pledged to give more than the legal minimum, such as the Gates Foundation's spend-down, the MacArthur Foundation's pledge to pay out at least 6% in 2025 and 2026, and the signers of the Meet the Moment pledge, with each pledge set beside the payout on the foundation's filed tax return, year by year.
Why it is still open
The pledges are public, but the progress figures are the foundations' own. MacArthur estimates its 2025 charitable spending at $647 million against an original budget of $457 million, as MinistryWatch reported; the Trust-Based Philanthropy Project's Meet the Moment pledge asks signers to "increase your grantmaking budget"; CEP's 2020 count of foundations that raised their grantmaking came from what foundations said; and Candid's payout figures come from surveys. This research found no published check of such pledges against filed returns.
ministrywatch.comtrustbasedphilanthropy.orgcep.orgcandid.org
Built with what exists
ProPublica's Nonprofit Explorer and the IRS e-file data, which report each foundation's qualifying distributions (the grants and costs that count toward its payout) and its minimum investment return; the public lists of pledge signers; Python; a shared spreadsheet for corrections from foundations.
First step
List every public payout pledge made since 2020, and pull the filed payouts of the first ten pledgers for 2019 to 2024.
Done looks like
At least 50 pledging foundations tracked, with pledged and filed payout side by side for each year; each foundation sent its figures before publication; the table updated as new returns appear.