BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Social services / Foster care and adoption

Adoption

Adoption is the legal process that makes a child a permanent member of a new family and ends the legal tie to the birth parents, whether the child comes from foster care, from parents who placed a baby, or from another country.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1851 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1851

    The child's welfare comes first

    Massachusetts passed the Adoption of Children Act, which the Adoption History Project at the University of Oregon calls the first modern adoption law. It made adoption a decision for a judge, who had to be satisfied that it was "fit and proper", so the child's welfare, not the adults' interests, became the test. How a judge was to decide was left to the judge.

    pages.uoregon.edu

    Credit

    Massachusetts legislature; described by the historian Ellen Herman's Adoption History Project

  2. 1993

    A treaty for adoption abroad

    The Hague Convention on intercountry adoption, concluded on 29 May 1993 and in force from 1 May 1995, makes each member state name a central authority to handle cases, and allows a child to be adopted abroad only after the possibilities for placing the child in its home country "have been given due consideration". It had 107 contracting parties by June 2025, when South Korea ratified it; it took effect for Korea on 1 October 2025. Adoptions across borders have since fallen: by Peter Selman's compilation of receiving states' figures, published by the Hague Conference, 45,482 children were adopted abroad in 2004 and 3,700 in 2022. Pew Research Center lists the countries that closed: Guatemala halted such adoptions in 2008, Russia barred US adopters from 2013, Ethiopia banned them in 2018 and China in 2024, the Netherlands announced in December 2024 a plan to stop adopting from abroad by 2030, and Denmark's only intercountry agency closed in 2024.

    hcch.netassets.hcch.netpewresearch.org

    Credit

    Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH); figures by Peter Selman, Newcastle University

  3. 1997

    Deadlines and bonuses

    The US Adoption and Safe Families Act (ASFA) generally requires a state to seek to end parental rights once a child has been in foster care for 15 of the most recent 22 months, and pays states $4,000 for each adoption from foster care above a baseline count, plus $2,000 for each adoption of a child with special needs above its own baseline. A 2014 Congressional Research Service report counts adoptions from US foster care rising from fewer than 30,000 a year in the mid-1990s to a peak of about 57,000 in FY2009, and more than $423 million in incentive payments earned by FY2012. The same report found 130,000 to 135,000 children waiting for adoption in most years from FY1998 to FY2012.

    govinfo.goveverycrsreport.com

    Credit

    US Congress; figures by the Congressional Research Service

  4. 2011

    A recruiter for each child

    The Dave Thomas Foundation for Adoption started Wendy's Wonderful Kids in 2004 to find families for the children who wait longest: older children, sibling groups and children with mental health disorders. Its recruiters build a one-to-one relationship with each child and search diligently for possible adoptive families. In a five-year evaluation for the foundation, comparing served children with a control group given usual recruitment in the same areas, Child Trends found served children 1.7 times as likely to be adopted, and children with mental health disorders three times as likely.

    childtrends.orgdavethomasfoundation.org

    Credit

    Dave Thomas Foundation for Adoption; evaluation by Karin Malm, Sharon Vandivere and Tiffany Allen of Child Trends

  5. 2013

    An apology for forced adoption

    In February 2012 an Australian Senate committee reported on the Commonwealth's part in former forced adoption policies and practices, under which young mothers lost their babies to adoption, and recommended a national apology. On 21 March 2013 Prime Minister Julia Gillard delivered it: Parliament "takes responsibility and apologises for the policies and practices that forced the separation of mothers from their babies".

    LessonAn adoption obtained without a mother's free consent can later be judged a wrong done by the state, and the state can be asked to answer for it.

    aph.gov.aupmtranscripts.pmc.gov.au

    Credit

    Senate Community Affairs References Committee; Australian Government

  6. 2023

    A matching algorithm falls short

    Family-Match, an algorithm from the nonprofit Adoption-Share built with former researchers from the dating site eharmony, began matching children and families in Florida and Virginia in 2018, with pilots in Tennessee and Georgia after. The Associated Press found in November 2023 that Virginia's two-year test produced one known adoption, Georgia ended its pilot in October 2022 after two adoptions, and Tennessee dropped the tool before using it; officials said the nonprofit gave little detail on how the algorithm worked. Adoption-Share's chief executive, Thea Ramirez, disputed the states' accounts, and Virginia and Georgia later resumed business with the nonprofit.

    LessonStates put a matching tool into use before anyone outside its maker had tested it, and could not see how it ranked families.

    wabe.org

    Credit

    reporting by the Associated Press

  7. 2025

    Korea's commission finds abuses

    South Korea sent about 141,778 children abroad for adoption between 1955 and 1999, by the count of its Truth and Reconciliation Commission; the flow began after the 1950 to 1953 war, and in 1955 a special act of the US Congress let Bertha and Harry Holt adopt eight Korean children. The government handed every step to private agencies. On 26 March 2025, after investigating petitions from 367 adoptees sent to 11 countries between 1964 and 1999, the commission found that the state had violated their rights: children with families were registered as orphans, an agency gave a child another child's identity when the first child died or was reclaimed, and 99% of adoption approvals in 1984 were granted the same or the next day. It recommended a state apology and ratifying the Hague Convention. On 19 July 2025 two new laws moved adoption decisions from private agencies to central and local government.

    LessonWhen a state leaves every step of adoption to private agencies without oversight, children's identities can be lost for good.

    cdn.ast.dkaljazeera.comasiae.co.krpages.uoregon.edu

    Credit

    Truth and Reconciliation Commission of the Republic of Korea, chaired by Park Sun-young

Watch for

  1. Korea ends adoption abroad

    South Korea's Third Basic Plan for Child Policy, approved in January 2026, puts domestic adoption first and plans to end overseas adoption by 2029, keeping it only for exceptional cases handled directly with foreign governments. Courts approved 58 overseas adoptions and 154 domestic ones in 2024, by the Ministry of Health and Welfare's count.

    Achieved whenKorea's annual figures show overseas adoption reduced to the exceptions the plan allows, and an outside body, such as the National Human Rights Commission of Korea or the Hague Conference, reports on how the state-run system works.

    asianews.networkasiae.co.kr

    Claimed by

    Ministry of Health and Welfare, January 2026

  2. US hubs for AI matching

    The Administration for Children and Families (ACF) says in a 2026 funding notice that most US agencies still match children with families through "static photo listing services, fragmented data systems, and manual caseworker knowledge". It plans $10 million for three regional hubs to build and test "data-informed recruitment tools, AI-assisted matching, and predictive analytics" with at least two pilot jurisdictions each, from 30 September 2026.

    Achieved whenan evaluator independent of the hubs and their vendors publishes how time to adoption and the stability of matches changed against comparison jurisdictions.

    files.simpler.grants.gov

    Claimed by

    ACF, 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Adoption-abroad figures as open data

    An open, machine-readable table of intercountry adoptions by receiving country, country of origin and year, from 2004 to the latest year, built from the statistics forms states send to the Hague Conference, Peter Selman's compiled tables and national reports such as the US State Department's. Every number carries a link to its source, and a second list shows where a receiving country's count and the origin country's count disagree.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Planted errors in adoption files

    A public test set of made-up adoption files of the kind agencies kept for children sent abroad in the 1970s and 1980s: intake forms, orphan registrations, medical checks, travel papers and agency letters, typed or handwritten and rendered as scanned pages. Half the files carry planted problems of the kinds investigators have reported, such as a child registered as an orphan in a file that also records a parent giving the child up, a birth date or height that changes from page to page, a case number out of sequence or a name that changes partway through; the other half are clean. An answer key lists every planted problem, and a script scores AI tools and people on what they find and what they flag wrongly.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Adoption-abroad figures as open data

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open, machine-readable table of intercountry adoptions by receiving country, country of origin and year, from 2004 to the latest year, built from the statistics forms states send to the Hague Conference, Peter Selman's compiled tables and national reports such as the US State Department's. Every number carries a link to its source, and a second list shows where a receiving country's count and the origin country's count disagree.

Why it is still open

The most complete compilation, Selman's February 2024 tables on the Hague Conference site, is a PDF that stops at 2022. Selman notes that some totals differ from what states submitted and that some states do not report numbers below five, and the table's columns do not survive text extraction. Wm. Robert Johnston's online tables, last updated in November 2022, give totals by receiving and by sending country up to 2021, marked incomplete, with sources listed for each table as a whole rather than for each figure. A GitHub search for "intercountry adoption" found one 2018 repository holding only a README, and Pew Research Center's 2025 analysis worked from US State Department figures for the US alone.

hcch.netassets.hcch.netjohnstonsarchive.net

Built with what exists

The published PDFs and forms; table extraction with pdfplumber or Camelot; a small model for pulling rows out of awkward tables, such as Meta's Muse Ember (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Python; CSV files in a public Git repository. Only national totals are used, never records about any child.

  1. First step

    Turn Selman's Table 1 (25 receiving states, 2004 to 2022) into a CSV this month and check each row against his printed totals.

  2. Done looks like

    Yearly totals for 25 receiving countries and their main countries of origin, 2004 to 2024, every cell sourced; the rebuilt totals for 2004 to 2022 match Selman's printed totals or each difference is explained; a second person checks a random 10% of cells against the sources and the error rate is published.

Open 02 · the brief

Planted errors in adoption files

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test set of made-up adoption files of the kind agencies kept for children sent abroad in the 1970s and 1980s: intake forms, orphan registrations, medical checks, travel papers and agency letters, typed or handwritten and rendered as scanned pages. Half the files carry planted problems of the kinds investigators have reported, such as a child registered as an orphan in a file that also records a parent giving the child up, a birth date or height that changes from page to page, a case number out of sequence or a name that changes partway through; the other half are clean. An answer key lists every planted problem, and a script scores AI tools and people on what they find and what they flag wrongly.

Why it is still open

South Korea's Truth and Reconciliation Commission found in March 2025 that children with families had been registered as orphans and that an agency gave a child another child's identity. The Associated Press reported in October 2024 that adoptees compare their files by hand in online forums, that one adoptee worked out her agency's case-numbering system from hundreds of case numbers collected from other adoptees, and that a former director of childcare policy at South Korea's health ministry said even the agencies cannot tell which records are real. Searches found no tool and no public test set for finding contradictions within adoption files.

cdn.ast.dk1news.co.nz

Built with what exists

AI models that read long sets of scanned pages, such as Claude, which Enveda reports raised issues its human reviewers had missed in 1,061 pages of drug-making records (see the Note "Seven more flagged"), Gemini, and open-weight models such as Mistral Large 4 (see the Note "A trillion open parameters"); text recognition for the handwritten pages; Python for scoring. Every file and every person in it is invented; no real adoptee's file is used.

  1. First step

    List the kinds of falsification described in the commission's findings, then write five files by hand, each with five planted problems.

  2. Done looks like

    200 files, 100 of them holding at least 500 planted problems in all and 100 clean; published detection and false-alarm rates for at least three AI models and for a group of people given the same time; the files, answer key and scoring code released.