BRENNEN

Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Flavors and fragrances

Supply

Supply is how flavor and fragrance houses, the companies that design and make flavors and scents for brands, secure their raw materials and win and keep customers.

6

Milestones achieved, from 2007 to 2024.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2007

    Briefs and core lists

    When Givaudan bought Quest International from the British chemical group ICI, the European Commission cleared the deal on 21 February 2007 and set down how the trade buys and sells. Flavors are almost always made for one product. Customers invite several suppliers to tender through "briefs", and many keep "core lists" of preselected suppliers chosen for service, quality and price. The Commission found enough rivals, such as Symrise, IFF and Firmenich, for customers to turn to.

    ec.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Commission; Givaudan; ICI

  2. 2017

    One fire, two shortages

    On 31 October 2017 a fire broke out while BASF was starting up its citral plant in Ludwigshafen, Germany. Citral, a lemon-scented chemical, is the base of most of BASF's aroma ingredients, such as geraniol, linalool and menthol, and of its vitamins A and E. BASF declared force majeure, notice that it could not deliver as contracted, on its citral- and isoprenol-based aroma ingredients, then on vitamins A and E and several carotenoids. In January 2018 it said the plant would restart in March 2018 at the earliest.

    LessonOne plant near the start of a chain can stop supply to two industries at once.

    basf.combasf.comaroma-ingredients.basf.com

    Credit

    BASF

  3. 2019

    Bribes found after a takeover

    IFF completed its purchase of the flavor maker Frutarom on 4 October 2018. In August 2019 IFF said it had learned during the merger that two Frutarom businesses operating mainly in Russia and Ukraine made improper payments to representatives of customers, and that key members of Frutarom's senior management at the time knew. IFF put the affected sales at under 1% of the two companies' combined 2018 sales.

    LessonChecks before a purchase can miss how the target won its customers.

    sec.govsec.gov

    Credit

    IFF, which disclosed it

  4. 2020

    A vanilla floor price fails

    After vanilla prices peaked in 2018, Madagascar, the main exporter, set a minimum export price in 2020. Mintec, a commodity price firm, says US$250 a kilogram applied from July 2020; a report by the vanilla trader Aust & Hachmann, cited by Food Business News, gave an earlier 2020 floor of US$350/kg. In May 2023, with much of the previous crop still unsold, the government lifted the floor and banned only exports below "cost price". In 2026 extraction-grade beans sold for about US$30/kg, back to 2012–2013 levels, according to exporters cited by Capmad.

    LessonA floor set above what buyers will pay leaves the crop in storage.

    mintecglobal.combakingbusiness.comcapmad.comlinnean.org

    Credit

    Government of Madagascar; price accounts by Mintec, Aust & Hachmann and Capmad

  5. 2023

    DSM and Firmenich merge

    The European Commission cleared the merger of DSM, a Dutch maker of vitamins, enzymes and flavors, with Firmenich, a Swiss fragrance and flavor house, on 22 February 2023, without conditions. It found that the deal added less than 5% to their share of flavors for savory foods, gave a combined share of 20–30%, and left other suppliers in that market, among them Givaudan, IFF, Symrise, Mane, Robertet, Kao and Takasago.

    ec.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Commission; DSM; Firmenich

  6. 2024

    Deleted chats draw a fine

    In 2023 the European Commission inspected fragrance companies over possible anticompetitive practices, and on 7 March 2023 the UK's Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) opened its own investigation. In June 2024 the Commission fined IFF €15.9 million because a senior employee, told of the inspection, deleted WhatsApp messages exchanged with a competitor; the Commission found the deletion itself. IFF got a 50% reduction for admitting the facts and cooperating. The law firm Clifford Chance calls it the first Commission fine for deleting messages exchanged through social media on a mobile device.

    LessonMessages on staff phones count as evidence in a competition inspection.

    cliffordchance.comgov.uk

    Credit

    European Commission

Watch for

  1. Fragrance cartel probes

    The CMA suspects anticompetitive conduct by Firmenich, Givaudan and IFF in the supply of fragrances and fragrance ingredients, and in January 2024 widened its case to suspected coordination on hiring each other's staff. It closed its case against Symrise in May 2025 on administrative priority grounds, says no assumption should be made that the law was broken, and reported the investigation still ongoing in September 2026.

    Achieved whenthe CMA or the European Commission issues a statement of objections or a final decision.

    gov.uk

    Claimed by

    CMA (suspicion under investigation), September 2026

  2. Citral from a second continent

    BASF says its new citral plant in Zhanjiang, China, has made in-specification product since the first quarter of 2026 and supplied customers since April 2026, feeding new menthol and linalool plants in Ludwigshafen. Its 2023 investment plan put its total citral capacity at 118,000 tonnes a year.

    Achieved whensomeone outside BASF, such as a customer or a trade data series, confirms regular deliveries from Zhanjiang.

    basf.combasf.com

    Claimed by

    BASF, April 2026

  3. Farm-gate floor for vanilla

    Madagascar's Council of Ministers set a floor of 10,000 ariary a kilogram (about US$2.27) for green vanilla longer than 13 cm in June 2026, by Capmad's account, after a 2024–2025 season with no official floor. Capmad reports that some collectors in the SAVA region paid 10,000 to 11,000 ariary/kg in July 2026 and up to 23,000 for organic vanilla.

    Achieved whena survey by someone outside the government shows farm-gate prices at or above the floor across the whole season.

    capmad.com

    Claimed by

    Government of Madagascar, June 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Who makes each aroma chemical

    An open register of every known production site for 100 aroma chemicals, starting with citral and the chemicals made from it, with owner, country and a source for each row, and a flag on any chemical made at only one or two sites.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Cyclone loss model for vanilla

    A model that takes a cyclone's track and wind field and estimates the share of vanilla vines damaged in each growing district of Madagascar, tested against past storms.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Who makes each aroma chemical

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open register of every known production site for 100 aroma chemicals, starting with citral and the chemicals made from it, with owner, country and a source for each row, and a flag on any chemical made at only one or two sites.

Why it is still open

The 2017 Ludwigshafen fire showed that one plant can cut supply of many aroma chemicals at once. Producers publish their own site lists, as BASF does, but a search in November 2026 found no public register that maps aroma chemicals to the plants that make them.

basf.comaroma-ingredients.basf.com

Built with what exists

The US EPA's Chemical Data Reporting files, which give site-specific production volumes for 2020 to 2023; the European Chemicals Agency's public list of REACH registrations; producers' site pages and annual reports; a language model to pull site names from those documents, with every row checked by a person.

epa.gov

  1. First step

    List every producer of citral, geraniol, citronellol, ionones, linalool and menthol found in the EPA files and company sources.

  2. Done looks like

    100 chemicals and their sites published as an open table with a source link on every row, and a second reader re-checking 20 chemicals chosen at random and reporting the error rate.

Open 02 · the brief

Cyclone loss model for vanilla

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A model that takes a cyclone's track and wind field and estimates the share of vanilla vines damaged in each growing district of Madagascar, tested against past storms.

Why it is still open

The World Bank's open cyclone risk data for Madagascar estimate losses to buildings, not crops. A search in November 2026 found cyclone hazard maps for the SAVA region, a main vanilla-growing area, but no crop-loss model for vanilla.

datacatalog.worldbank.org

Built with what exists

IBTrACS, the US National Centers for Environmental Information's global archive of cyclone tracks; the World Bank's wind hazard layers (CC BY 4.0); Sentinel-2 satellite images to compare plant cover before and after storms; Madagascar's vanilla export statistics.

ncei.noaa.gov

  1. First step

    Download IBTrACS tracks for the south-west Indian Ocean since 2000 and list the storms that passed within 100 km of the SAVA region.

  2. Done looks like

    For at least three cyclones that crossed the SAVA region since 2000, the model's estimated loss compared with the next season's export volume, published with code and data.