Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Flavors and fragrances
Safety and rules
Safety and rules is the work of deciding which flavor and scent ingredients may be used, at what levels, and what labels must say.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1958 to 2024.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1958
Safe by expert consensus
Under the 1958 Food Additives Amendment to the US Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, any substance added to food needs the FDA's approval before sale, unless qualified experts generally recognize it as safe (GRAS) for its intended use, on scientific evidence or, for a substance used in food before 1958, on its common use. The FDA published its first list of GRAS substances on 9 December 1958, and many substances the food industry considered GRAS were not on it.
Credit
US Congress; US Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
1979
A fragrance harms nerves
AETT (acetyl ethyl tetramethyl tetralin), a fragrance ingredient of soaps, deodorants and cosmetics, made rats hyperirritable and weak in the limbs when they were exposed to it repeatedly. Their brains, spinal cords and nerves turned blue, nerve cells degenerated and the myelin, the insulating sheath around nerves, bubbled, Peter S. Spencer and colleagues reported in Science in 1979; these findings were the basis for the industry's decision to withdraw it from consumer products.
LessonAn ingredient can be in wide use before repeated-dose tests show that it does harm.
Credit
P. S. Spencer, A. B. Sterman, D. S. Horoupian and M. M. Foulds; the fragrance industry
2013
EU flavorings on one list
The EU's flavorings law, Regulation (EC) No 1334/2008, applied from 20 January 2011: a flavor may be called natural only if its flavoring parts are entirely of natural origin, and when a source is named, at least 95% of the flavoring part must come from it. From 22 April 2013 only flavoring substances on its Union list, adopted by Regulation (EU) No 872/2012 with 2,543 entries, may be used in EU food, including some still awaiting evaluation by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA).
Credit
European Parliament and Council of the EU; European Commission
2018
Six flavorings delisted by law
On 9 October 2018 the FDA withdrew its authorization of six synthetic flavoring substances, benzophenone, ethyl acrylate, eugenyl methyl ether, myrcene, pulegone and pyridine, granting in part a petition from consumer and environmental groups. The FDA said they did not pose a risk to public health at their intended use, but the petitioners showed that they caused cancer in laboratory animals, and the Delaney Clause, the part of US food law that bars any additive found to cause cancer in animals, left it no choice.
LessonA law that bans any additive shown to cause cancer in animals removes substances that the regulator itself judges safe at the doses people eat.
Credit
FDA; petitioners including the Breast Cancer Fund, the Center for Science in the Public Interest and the Natural Resources Defense Council
2021
Worst allergens banned outright
The EU's Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) concluded in June 2012 that HICC (hydroxyisohexyl 3-cyclohexene carboxaldehyde), atranol and chloroatranol, the last two found in oakmoss and treemoss extracts, should not be used in cosmetics, because they had caused the most contact allergy cases in recent years. Regulation (EU) 2017/1410 barred new products containing them from 23 August 2019 and all sales from 23 August 2021, a longer delay than usual because reformulating a fragrance is slow and changes its smell.
Credit
SCCS; European Commission
2022
Lilial leaves the shelves
Butylphenyl methylpropional, sold under the trade name Lilial, a floral scent used in perfumes, shower gels and deodorants, was banned from EU cosmetics from 1 March 2022, the day its classification as toxic for reproduction took effect; EU law bans such substances in cosmetics unless an exemption is granted, and none was requested. Great Britain banned its sale from December 2022, and in October 2024 Britain's Office for Product Safety and Standards (OPSS) asked the public to check their homes after reports that banned products might still be on sale.
LessonA ban that takes effect on one day leaves old stock in shops and homes.
Credit
European Commission; OPSS
2024
Smoke flavorings refused
Smoke flavorings give foods a smoked taste instead of, or as well as, traditional smoking. In 2023 EFSA raised safety concerns about eight of the ten authorized in the EU, including, for one, a concern for genotoxicity (damage to genes) from its component furan-2(5H)-one; in July 2024 the European Commission refused to renew those eight, the other two having lapsed, and removed all ten from the Union list. Foods made with them may be placed on the market only until 1 July 2026, or until 1 July 2029 for cheese, meat and fish.
Credit
EFSA; European Commission
Watch for
FEMA flavors filed with FDA
The FDA proposed on 11 August 2026 that companies must notify it of every substance they sell as GRAS on their own conclusion. Flavorings judged GRAS by the expert panel of the Flavor and Extract Manufacturers Association (FEMA) would not be exempt unless the FDA has reviewed them. The FDA estimates that there are 1,740 substances judged GRAS by such association panels; those already on sale would get one year after the rule takes effect to file a short "streamlined submission", which the FDA would post on a public list. Comments close on 9 December 2026.
Achieved whena final rule takes effect and the FDA posts the streamlined submissions for FEMA GRAS flavorings.
Claimed by
US FDA, August 2026
Allergy limits checked in clinics
A study protocol published in May 2025 sets out patch tests, in which small amounts of suspected allergens are taped to the skin, of about 8,100 consecutive patients with suspected contact allergy in 10 European dermatology departments, with seven fragrance materials in wide use. The aim is to judge whether the maximum concentrations now recommended for each, based on the industry's quantitative risk assessment method (QRA2), are adequate. The International Fragrance Association (IFRA) pays for the study, which runs under the multi-stakeholder IDEA project with a supervisory group, and the results are to be published open access.
Achieved whenthe results are published with the share of patients allergic to each material.
Claimed by
Wolfgang Uter and colleagues, May 2025
Open
01
Test formulas for IFRA calculators
A public set of at least 100 perfume formulas, each with answers worked by hand and checked by a second person: the highest dose allowed in each IFRA product category, and which EU-listed allergens must be named on a leave-on and on a rinse-off product. Include hard cases, such as a restricted substance that arrives inside a natural oil, and the allergens that EU labels must name for products placed on the market from 1 August 2026. Run free calculators and AI formulation assistants against the set and publish each tool's errors.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Allergen labels when oils vary
An open model that takes a formula containing natural oils and gives, for each EU-listed fragrance allergen, the chance that a batch crosses the label threshold of 0.001% in a leave-on or 0.01% in a rinse-off product, given how much each oil's make-up varies from lot to lot; then a check of the model against laboratory analysis of real lots.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Test formulas for IFRA calculators
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public set of at least 100 perfume formulas, each with answers worked by hand and checked by a second person: the highest dose allowed in each IFRA product category, and which EU-listed allergens must be named on a leave-on and on a rinse-off product. Include hard cases, such as a restricted substance that arrives inside a natural oil, and the allergens that EU labels must name for products placed on the market from 1 August 2026. Run free calculators and AI formulation assistants against the set and publish each tool's errors.
Why it is still open
Free tools now check formulas against the IFRA Standards, from Perfumers Vault, an open-source formulation manager, to an AI "agent skill" that calls itself "production-ready" and enforces a "mandatory IFRA compliance gate". Searches of GitHub and Europe PMC in November 2026 found no shared set of test formulas with checked answers to measure such tools against.
Built with what exists
The IFRA Standards Library, a searchable database that IFRA publishes alongside the complete Standards up to the 51st Amendment (, ); the allergen list and thresholds in Regulation (EU) 2023/1545 (); Python and pytest to run each tool; suppliers' certificates that list the restricted constituents of natural materials.
First step
Write 20 formulas across four IFRA categories, work out the answers by hand with a second checker, and run them through two free tools.
Done looks like
100 formulas, each with two independent hand-worked answers that agree; at least five tools run against them; a published table of each tool's wrong answers, with each error traced to its cause.
Open 02 · the brief
Allergen labels when oils vary
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open model that takes a formula containing natural oils and gives, for each EU-listed fragrance allergen, the chance that a batch crosses the label threshold of 0.001% in a leave-on or 0.01% in a rinse-off product, given how much each oil's make-up varies from lot to lot; then a check of the model against laboratory analysis of real lots.
Why it is still open
New cosmetics placed on the EU market after 31 July 2026 must name 56 more fragrance allergens above those thresholds, and substances that turn into known allergens in air count as allergens too. Plant scent shifts with plant variety, growth stage, tissue and stress, a 2026 review notes. Searches of Europe PMC in November 2026 found studies of oil composition and no published model that turns lot-to-lot variation into the odds of a label change.
Built with what exists
Python with NumPy for Monte Carlo sampling, which runs a calculation many times with values drawn at random from their measured ranges; allergen values from suppliers' certificates of analysis for several lots of each oil; the EU allergen list and thresholds; a contract laboratory's gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC-MS) analysis of fragrance allergens to check the predictions.
First step
Collect certificates of analysis for three lots each of lavender, bergamot and ylang-ylang oil from two suppliers, and enter their allergen values into one table.
Done looks like
For five common oils, ten bought lots of each analyzed by a laboratory; the model's stated 90% ranges contain the measured level for at least 90% of the allergen readings; model, data and code published.