Industries / Media, arts and recreation / Fitness and gyms
Memberships
Memberships is how gyms and health clubs sell access: the monthly price, the contract, how people join and quit, and who pays the fee.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1936 to 2025.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1936
A health studio for all
Jack LaLanne opened a gym in Oakland, California, that taught weight training and diet to ordinary members. His estate's site says many doctors at the time thought such training was dangerous. The California Museum's Hall of Fame calls it the nation's first modern health studio, opened when LaLanne was 21, and says that by the 1980s more than 200 health clubs carried his name.
Credit
Jack LaLanne
1997
Budget gyms at scale
Rainer Schaller opened the first McFIT gym in Würzburg, Germany, in 1997. By the chain's own history it had 416,000 members by 2006 and its millionth member in 2011. In the US, Planet Fitness charged $10 a month for its standard plan in 2016, when it had about 8.9 million members. At the end of 2025 it had about 20.8 million members in 2,896 clubs, with standard plans from $15 a month, against an industry average of $69 a month in 2024 as estimated by the trade association, the Health & Fitness Association. The Planet Fitness figures are from its annual reports to the US Securities and Exchange Commission.
Credit
Rainer Schaller (McFIT); Planet Fitness
2006
Paying not to go
The economists Stefano DellaVigna and Ulrike Malmendier studied 7,752 members of three US health clubs over three years. Members who chose a flat fee of over $70 a month came 4.3 times a month on average, so each visit cost them more than $17 when a 10-visit pass cost $10 a visit. On average 2.31 full months, about $187 in fees, passed between a monthly member's last visit and the end of the membership. They published their data and code.
Lessonpeople overestimate how often they will go, and contracts that renew by default earn money from that overestimate.
Credit
Stefano DellaVigna (University of California, Berkeley) and Ulrike Malmendier (Stanford), in the American Economic Review
2008
Membership fees misbooked
The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) charged Bally Total Fitness, which in 2000 was the market leader with 4 million members by the DellaVigna and Malmendier paper's count. The SEC alleged that from at least 1997 to 2003 Bally's accounts overstated its 2001 stockholders' equity by nearly $1.8 billion, more than 340%, and that $1.2 billion of that came from how it booked members' initiation fees, prepaid dues and reactivation fees and the cost of signing members up. Bally, just out of bankruptcy, settled without admitting or denying the charges.
Lessonfees paid up front for months of access have to be counted as those months are delivered, or the books overstate what a club has earned.
Credit
US Securities and Exchange Commission
2021
Fifty-four nudges, one chain
In what its authors call a megastudy, 30 scientists from 15 US universities tested 54 four-week programs meant to get 61,293 members of the chain 24 Hour Fitness to the gym more often, all measured on the same check-in records. 45% of the programs raised weekly visits by 9% to 27%; the best one gave small rewards for coming back after a missed workout. Only 8% left an effect still measurable after the four weeks, and outside judges asked to forecast the results could not pick the winners.
Lessonwhat gets people to the gym is hard to guess and fades fast, so ideas need testing side by side.
Credit
Katherine Milkman, Angela Duckworth and colleagues, Behavior Change for Good Initiative, University of Pennsylvania, with 24 Hour Fitness
2022
A cancel button by law
Germany's Act for Fair Consumer Contracts changed the Civil Code. From 1 March 2022, a contract in standard terms that renews by itself may only roll on month to month, with at most one month's notice. From 1 July 2022, any ongoing paid contract that can be signed on a website must be cancellable there through a button labeled "Verträge hier kündigen" ("cancel contracts here"). In January 2023 the Federation of German Consumer Organisations (vzbv) found no lawful button on 72% of 2,995 websites it checked. In July 2026 the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) ruled against the gym chain FitX, whose cancel page prominently offered a free pause instead: the court held that the confirmation page may only collect what the cancellation needs (case I ZR 200/25).
gesetze-im-internet.degesetze-im-internet.degesetze-im-internet.devzbv.denordkurier.de
Credit
German Bundestag; vzbv; Federal Court of Justice
2025
A US cancel rule vacated
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) issued a rule by a 3-2 vote on 15 November 2024 that required cancelling any subscription or membership to be at least as easy as signing up. Trade groups challenged it, with the Health & Fitness Association among those filing in support of the challenge. On 8 July 2025, six days before companies had to comply, the US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit vacated the whole rule because the FTC had not issued a preliminary regulatory analysis, an early public study of costs and alternatives that the law requires for a rule this large.
Lessona rule can fall on procedure alone, and in the US easy cancellation now rests on case-by-case enforcement of older laws.
Credit
US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, Custom Communications v. FTC
Watch for
The LA Fitness cancellation case
The FTC claims that Fitness International, which runs LA Fitness, Esporta Fitness, City Sports Club and Club Studio (more than 600 locations and over 3.7 million members), made cancelling exceedingly difficult and charged members hundreds of millions of dollars in unwanted fees. It says members could for years cancel only by handing in a printed form during limited hours or by mail, while they could join online. The company's lawyers argue that it offers online cancellation with fewer clicks than joining and never required mail. At an April 2026 hearing on the company's request to dismiss the case, the judge's tentative order noted that for many years there had been no online cancellation at all, by the account of the law firm Frankfurt Kurnit Klein + Selz.
Achieved whenthe court rules for the FTC, or a settlement requires simpler cancellation and refunds.
Claimed by
US Federal Trade Commission, August 2025
UK subscription rules
The UK's Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 contains rules for subscriptions, gym memberships among them: clearer information before signing, reminders before renewals, cooling-off periods with refunds, and online cancellation wherever joining was online. The law firm Brodies reported in September 2026 that the government had moved the start forward to January 2027, from spring 2027.
Achieved whenthe rules are in force and a regulator or court reports checking gym contracts against them.
Claimed by
UK Government, as reported by Brodies, September 2026
Open
01
A register of cancel terms
A public dataset of the membership terms of the largest gym chains in at least five countries. For each chain it records how a member can cancel (website, app, in person, letter), the notice period, the minimum term, fees, how the contract renews, and whether the cancel page pushes a pause instead, each field linked to a dated copy of the chain's own page or contract. A checker then flags terms against each country's rules, such as Germany's cancel button, the US Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act as the FTC applies it, and the UK rules due in January 2027. The data is collected again every month.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Members' own price per visit
An open-source tool that reads a member's own check-in history, exported from the chain's app or obtained through a data-access request, and works out what each visit cost against the chain's own day-pass or class-pack price. With consent, members donate the anonymized result to a public dataset that repeats the 2006 DellaVigna and Malmendier test across many chains and countries.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
A register of cancel terms
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public dataset of the membership terms of the largest gym chains in at least five countries. For each chain it records how a member can cancel (website, app, in person, letter), the notice period, the minimum term, fees, how the contract renews, and whether the cancel page pushes a pause instead, each field linked to a dated copy of the chain's own page or contract. A checker then flags terms against each country's rules, such as Germany's cancel button, the US Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act as the FTC applies it, and the UK rules due in January 2027. The data is collected again every month.
Why it is still open
The vzbv checked about 3,000 German websites in 2022 and 2023 and found most without a lawful cancel button, but its published results give no breakdown by sector and no dataset. The FTC's case covers one chain. In the UK, the Competition and Markets Authority's 2016 evaluation of earlier action against gym contracts was a one-off check, made by sending questionnaires to 15 gym operators and surveying members. Searches found no public register of gym cancellation terms across chains or countries.
Built with what exists
A headless browser such as Playwright to save dated copies of each chain's terms pages; a general AI model such as Claude to pull the fields out of terms and contract PDFs into a fixed form; a model built to answer fixed-choice questions in bulk, such as Gemini Decision 1, for yes-or-no fields like "can a member cancel online" (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); a Git repository to keep every monthly version.
First step
Pick the 20 largest chains in one country, write a 15-field coding sheet, and code five chains by hand from their own websites.
Done looks like
100 chains in five countries, twelve monthly snapshots, every field linked to a dated source, and the automated extraction agreeing with two human coders on at least 95% of fields in a 200-contract check sample. Data, code and agreement scores are public.
Open 02 · the brief
Members' own price per visit
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open-source tool that reads a member's own check-in history, exported from the chain's app or obtained through a data-access request, and works out what each visit cost against the chain's own day-pass or class-pack price. With consent, members donate the anonymized result to a public dataset that repeats the 2006 DellaVigna and Malmendier test across many chains and countries.
Why it is still open
The 2006 study used three US clubs in the late 1990s, and its data and code are public. The 2021 megastudy used 24 Hour Fitness check-ins under a research partnership. Searches found no repeat of the price-per-visit finding with recent data from many chains.
Built with what exists
The right of access in the EU and UK General Data Protection Regulation (Article 15) and the California Consumer Privacy Act, with request templates; a parser written in Python and run in the browser with Pyodide, so raw logs stay on the member's device; standard statistics code in Python or R; the 2006 paper's posted data for comparison.
First step
File a data-access request with your own gym, record what comes back and how long it takes, and write the parser for that format.
Done looks like
Donated summaries from 1,000 members of at least 10 chains in three countries, a published distribution of cost per visit against each chain's per-visit price, and a stated answer to whether the 2006 gap (over $17 against $10) still holds, with all code public.