Industries / Consumer goods / Firearms and ammunition
Proof and standards
Proof is the firing of a new gun with a deliberately overloaded cartridge to show it is sound, after which an official mark is stamped on it, and standards bodies set the sizes and limits that let ammunition from one maker be used safely in guns from another.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1637 to 1999.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1637
London's proof charter
Charles I granted the Gunmakers' Company of London a royal charter in 1637, after gunmakers had petitioned for their own company since 1581. The charter let its members prove guns, testing them "with an overcharge", and mark them in London and for 10 miles around, and to search for and seize guns sold unproved. The crowned "GP" mark it set is still used. The proof house has stood in Whitechapel since about 1675, and the company calls it the world's oldest.
Credit
the Worshipful Company of Gunmakers and its first master, Henry Rowland
1672
Liège makes proof compulsory
After complaints about the quality of arms made in the Principality of Liège, its prince-bishop decreed on 10 May 1672 that proof was compulsory, to be carried out by a certified prover and marked with the city's emblem, the Perron. The CIP, the international proof body, calls the decree the birth of firearms proof at Liège. An edict of 1689 strengthened the rules "for the good of the trade and the safety of the user", and a Napoleonic decree of 14 December 1810 set one proof procedure for every proof house in the French Empire.
Credit
Prince-Bishop Maximilian of Bavaria; the Liège Proof House
1813
Proof becomes British law
The first Proof Act, passed in 1813, wrote the London company's proof work into law and set up a second proof house in Birmingham for "the compulsory and statutory proof of small arms". The Gun Barrel Proof Act 1868 still governs proof in Britain. It makes it illegal to sell or transfer an unproved gun and requires new, imported, materially altered and repaired guns to be proved. An amendment in 1978 aligned British proof law with the international convention run by the CIP.
Credit
Parliament; the London and Birmingham proof houses
1914
Countries recognize each other's marks
A convention signed on 15 July 1914, with the Liège proof master Joseph Fraikin among its founders, created the Permanent International Commission for the Proof of Small Arms (CIP), based in Belgium, to set common proof rules so that member states accept each other's proof marks. Under its 1969 convention, every civilian small arm and its most highly stressed parts must be proved at a proof house in the member state where it is made, or where it is first imported, and the same applies to commercial ammunition. The CIP lists 16 member states, among them Chile, Russia and the United Arab Emirates.
Credit
Joseph Fraikin; the CIP
1926
SAAMI trims the load list
In 1925 Congress, acting through the Commerce Department, asked the industry to revive a wartime technical society, and in January 1926 makers of smokeless powder, ammunition and firearms founded the Sporting Arms and Ammunition Manufacturers' Institute (SAAMI). Makers' and distributors' warehouses then held more than 4,000 different shotshell loads and 350 centerfire rifle and pistol loads, and SAAMI's first project cut shotshell loads by 95% and metallic cartridge loads by 70%. Its standards are voluntary; they have gone through the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) process since the 1970s, and in the mid-2000s SAAMI began working with the CIP to bring the two sets of standards together. The National Institute of Justice notes that in the United States proof is done by SAAMI members under voluntary guidelines, while in most other countries it is the job of a government proof house.
Credit
SAAMI; US Department of Commerce
1972
Product safety law excludes guns
The US Consumer Product Safety Act of 1972 set up the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) but left out of its "consumer products" any article subject to the federal excise tax on firearms and ammunition. A 1976 amendment added that the CPSC "shall make no ruling or order that restricts the manufacture or sale of firearms, firearms ammunition, or components of firearms ammunition." No federal agency can order a gun recall, so makers issue their own safety notices and recalls.
LessonWith no agency collecting notices, nobody can say how many defective guns are recalled or repaired, and the two private lists that exist, kept by the Violence Policy Center and The Smoking Gun, both say they are incomplete.
Credit
US Congress
1999
California tests handguns
California adopted safety standards for handguns in 1999. Since 1 January 2001 no handgun model may be made in, imported into or sold in the state unless it has passed firing, safety and drop tests and been certified by the state Department of Justice, which keeps a roster of certified models; private sales between individuals are exempt. Giffords Law Center, a gun-control group, counts seven states and the District of Columbia with handgun design and safety standards, and reports that five of the six "Ring of Fire" companies, Los Angeles-area makers of cheap pistols that made a third of US handguns in the early 1990s, had declared bankruptcy by 2003.
Credit
California Legislature and Department of Justice
Watch for
Pistols firing in holsters
A technical report by the FBI's Ballistic Research Facility, dated 30 August 2024 and released by the Michigan State Police in July 2025 after a public records request, examined a commercial version of SIG Sauer's M18 pistol, part of the P320 family, after an officer's holstered pistol fired in July 2024. It concluded that handling like an officer's everyday movements could leave one of the pistol's internal safeties unable to stop it firing, and it recorded nine firings of a primed test case, a cartridge case holding only its primer, in about 50 attempts. US Immigration and Customs Enforcement then joined the agencies that had stopped issuing the P320. SIG Sauer disputes the findings and says the FBI could not reproduce them under a test method both sides agreed; the US Army made no changes to its M17 and M18 pistols. The P320 had already been the subject of a 2017 voluntary upgrade over drop safety.
Achieved whenan independent laboratory publishes a test whose method both the maker and the agencies accept, or a court rules on the defect claims.
Claimed by
the FBI Ballistic Research Facility report, made public in July 2025, as reported by The War Zone; disputed by SIG Sauer
Open
01
Proof marks read from photos
A free tool that takes a photograph of a proof mark already published by a museum, auction archive or collector and suggests which proof house stamped it and in which period, with the matching reference image shown beside it. It works from photographs alone, so nobody needs to handle a firearm.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
World table of test laws
A sourced table showing, for each country, whether new civilian firearms must be proved or pass other safety tests before sale, who does the testing (a state proof house, an approved laboratory or the maker), and the legal citation.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Proof marks read from photos
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A free tool that takes a photograph of a proof mark already published by a museum, auction archive or collector and suggests which proof house stamped it and in which period, with the matching reference image shown beside it. It works from photographs alone, so nobody needs to handle a firearm.
Why it is still open
The reference images are public. The CIP posts the marks now in force for each member state and country tables of older marks. The nearest work found is Basegun, an app built by France's Ministry of the Interior and issued to every gendarmerie phone in February 2024: it sorts a seized firearm into a family of mechanisms from a photo, and one of its open models recognizes alarm guns from their markings, but it does not identify proof houses. Searches also found printed directories of proof marks, paid gun databases and phone apps that try to name a whole gun from a picture, but no tool that matches a photo of a proof mark to its proof house. Checks of Hugging Face and GitHub found no proof-mark dataset or model.
Built with what exists
The CIP's tables of current and old marks; open museum images, such as the Metropolitan Museum of Art's collection API, where a search for "proof mark" returns 158 objects with images (some of them armor, which was also proved); an open image-embedding model such as DINOv2 or CLIP to compare a photo with the reference marks; a small web page to show the top matches.
First step
Download the CIP's mark tables, and collect 50 museum catalog photos whose records name a proof house.
Done looks like
A published test set of at least 200 museum photos whose catalog records name the proof marks, with the correct proof house among the tool's top three suggestions for at least 80% of them, and the scores and errors published.
Open 02 · the brief
World table of test laws
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A sourced table showing, for each country, whether new civilian firearms must be proved or pass other safety tests before sale, who does the testing (a state proof house, an approved laboratory or the maker), and the legal citation.
Why it is still open
The CIP lists its 16 member states, and Giffords Law Center maps the US states with handgun design and safety standards, but searches found no table covering the rest of the world. The National Institute of Justice's statement that most countries outside the United States use a government proof house has never been counted country by country.
Built with what exists
National legislation databases such as legislation.gov.uk and EUR-Lex; the CIP member list; California's handgun roster rules as a worked example of a non-CIP test regime; a language model to read statutes in other languages and pull out the test requirements, with a person checking every row against the text (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); a spreadsheet published on Zenodo.
First step
Fill in the 16 CIP members, the United States (federal law and the seven states with standards), Canada, Australia, Japan and Brazil.
Done looks like
At least 60 countries classed as proof required, other tests required, or no test required, each with a link to the statute, and a second reader agreeing on a random 10%.