BRENNEN

Industries / Health / Healthcare / Fertility clinics

Freezing and storage

Freezing sperm, eggs, embryos and ovarian tissue, keeping them in liquid nitrogen at −196 °C for years, and running the banks that supply donor sperm.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1953 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1953

    Frozen sperm makes babies

    At the University of Iowa, Jerome Sherman, a zoology graduate student, worked out how much glycerol to add to human semen so that sperm survived freezing and thawing, adapting a glycerol method that had already produced a calf. In spring 1953 the infertility clinic of the urologist Raymond Bunge inseminated three married women with their husbands' frozen and thawed sperm, and all three became pregnant. The pair reported the work in Nature in October 1953, the births were made public in April 1954, and a member of the Iowa Legislature denounced it as "a pagan device". Little Village, an Iowa news site, calls the university's semen store the world's first sperm bank.

    littlevillagemag.comeuropepmc.org

    Credit

    Raymond G. Bunge and Jerome K. Sherman, University of Iowa

  2. 1984

    Baby from a frozen embryo

    IVF often makes more embryos than can safely go back at once. Alan Trounson and Linda Mohr, at Monash University and the Queen Victoria Medical Center in Melbourne, froze spare four- and eight-cell embryos and in 1983 reported a pregnancy from an eight-cell embryo stored for four months in liquid nitrogen; it ended at 24 weeks with an infection. Zoe Leyland, from a frozen embryo, was born in Melbourne on 28 March 1984 under the care of Drs Trounson and Wood, and Planer, the maker of the freezer used, calls her the first baby born from a frozen embryo. In 1984 Mario and Elsa Rios, who had two embryos in storage in Melbourne, died in a plane crash, and nobody could say what should happen to the embryos.

    LessonFreezing embryos raised questions about ownership and storage time that the law had not answered.

    europepmc.orgembryo.asu.eduplaner.com

    Credit

    Alan Trounson, Linda Mohr and the Monash IVF team

  3. 2004

    Ovarian tissue restores fertility

    Cancer treatment can destroy the ovaries, and there is not always time to stimulate and collect eggs first. In 1997 doctors at the Cliniques Universitaires St Luc of the Université catholique de Louvain in Brussels froze strips of ovarian tissue from a woman with stage IV Hodgkin's lymphoma before her chemotherapy. Her ovaries then failed. In 2003 the thawed tissue was put back, regular cycles returned within five months, a pregnancy followed at 11 months, and the team reported the live birth in The Lancet in 2004.

    europepmc.org

    Credit

    J. Donnez, M. M. Dolmans and colleagues

  4. 2012

    Egg freezing stops being experimental

    In 1986 C. Chen reported the first pregnancy, twins, from human eggs that had been frozen slowly with the protective chemical DMSO; 80% of 40 eggs survived thawing. In 2005 M. Kuwayama, G. Vajta, O. Kato and S. P. Leibo described vitrification on the Cryotop, a thin plastic strip that holds an egg in less than 0.1 microliter of fluid so it cools fast enough to solidify without ice crystals. Of 64 vitrified human eggs, 58 (91%) survived, and seven babies had been born. On 22 October 2012 the practice committees of the ASRM and the Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology (SART) said egg vitrification "should no longer be considered experimental".

    europepmc.orgeuropepmc.orgeuropepmc.org

    Credit

    C. Chen; M. Kuwayama and colleagues; ASRM and SART

  5. 2018

    Two tanks fail one day

    In 2018 a liquid nitrogen storage tank failed at the Pacific Fertility Center in San Francisco, destroying about 3,500 frozen eggs and embryos, and on the same day a tank at a clinic in a Cleveland suburb failed, ruining more than 4,000. The Associated Press called them the largest such losses on record in the US. In June 2021 a federal jury awarded nearly $15 million to five patients, finding a manufacturing defect in the controller that monitored the tank's nitrogen level; it held the tank maker, Chart Industries, 90% responsible, partly for failing to recall the part, and the clinic 10%. Hundreds of other patients had also sued.

    LessonA tank needs a warning that does not depend on its own controller.

    nbcnews.com

  6. 2022

    Storage up to 55 years

    UK law had limited storage of eggs, sperm and embryos to 10 years for most people, with longer storage only for medical need. From 1 July 2022 everyone may store them for their own treatment for up to 55 years if they renew consent every 10 years, and donors' eggs and sperm may be kept for 55 years without renewal. Clinics had to audit the consent behind every stored sample and contact patients whose consent would lapse by 30 June 2023. The government cited advances including egg freezing.

    LessonA longer limit turns storage into record-keeping, since every sample needs live consent and an owner who can be reached.

    hfea.gov.ukgov.uk

    Credit

    UK Department of Health and Social Care; the HFEA

  7. 2025

    One donor, 197 children

    A man who donated at Denmark's European Sperm Bank from 2005 passed its screening, but up to 20% of his sperm carried a change in the TP53 gene, which causes Li-Fraumeni syndrome, about a 90% chance of cancer by age 60. His sperm went to clinics in at least a dozen countries over about 17 years, and an investigation by 14 European news organizations, published in December 2025, found at least 197 children, some of whom have died. In Belgium 38 women had 53 children from him, although only six families per donor are allowed there. The bank stopped selling his sperm in 2023, when the variant was found.

    LessonNational limits on families per donor do not hold when one bank ships to many countries and no registry counts across borders.

    statnews.comeshre.eu

    Credit

    the investigation by 14 European public broadcasters, among them the BBC, DW and the Danish Broadcasting Corporation

Watch for

  1. Tanks that track every straw

    Reprotech, which combined with TMRW Life Sciences in April 2026, says its TMRW Vault received CE marking as a Class IIa medical device in the EU in July 2026. The Vault keeps eggs, embryos and sperm in liquid nitrogen in RFID-tagged holders called CryoBeacons, with software that checks each sample's identity and location, a monitoring service that the company says runs thousands of system checks a day, and room for as much as ten ordinary tanks in about a third of the floor space.

    Achieved whenclinics not paid by the company publish at least a year of data on lost, warmed or misidentified samples and alarm response times, compared with standard tanks.

    aap.com.au

    Claimed by

    Reprotech, July 2026

  2. An EU-wide donor limit

    In a July 2026 position paper the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) asks the EU to set a limit of 50 families per sperm or egg donor, lowered over time to 15 or fewer; to stop giving a donor's eggs or sperm to new families 20 years after the first donation; and to set up an EU donor registry, by a delegated act under the EU's Substances of Human Origin (SoHO) Regulation. It notes that some banks set their own limits as high as 75 families, or none.

    Achieved whenthe EU adopts a binding limit and a registry that counts families per donor across member states is running.

    eshre.eu

    Claimed by

    ESHRE, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Tank alarms tested in software

    An open simulator of liquid nitrogen storage tanks that produces weight, nitrogen level and temperature readings for normal use and for slow, medium and fast failures, tuned to the two published IVF tank-failure tests, plus everyday events that cause false alarms: an open lid, a refill, a sensor dropout. Use it to score alarm rules (a temperature threshold, a 10% weight loss, a rate of weight loss, combinations) on warning time and false alarms per tank-year. No liquid nitrogen is handled.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Counting donor families across borders

    A working prototype that lets sperm and egg banks in different countries count how many families have received a donor's eggs or sperm, and flag donors over a set limit, without sending donors' identities to each other or to one central list. Test it only on made-up records: 20 simulated banks in 30 countries and 10,000 made-up donors, some of whom give at several banks.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Tank alarms tested in software

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open simulator of liquid nitrogen storage tanks that produces weight, nitrogen level and temperature readings for normal use and for slow, medium and fast failures, tuned to the two published IVF tank-failure tests, plus everyday events that cause false alarms: an open lid, a refill, a sensor dropout. Use it to score alarm rules (a temperature threshold, a 10% weight loss, a rate of weight loss, combinations) on warning time and false alarms per tank-year. No liquid nitrogen is handled.

Why it is still open

Michaelson and colleagues (2019) put tanks on scales and simulated three rates of nitrogen loss. In a slow loss a 10% weight alarm sounded more than 30 days before the tank warmed to −185 °C, but in a fast loss the tank emptied in under 3 minutes. Allen and colleagues (2026) drilled the vacuum port of one new tank and found that weight and vacuum signs came before the usual temperature alarm. A University of Wisconsin–Madison student team built a weight-based dewar monitor in 2019 and presented it at the College of Reproductive Biology's symposium. All are single setups, and no public set of readings or method for scoring alarm rules was found; a November 2026 search also found no open-source tank-monitoring project.

europepmc.orgeuropepmc.orgbmedesign.engr.wisc.edu

Built with what exists

Python with NumPy and SciPy for a heat-leak model of a tank; WebPlotDigitizer to read numbers off the published curves; an AI coding agent such as Claude Code or Cursor to write and test the simulator and scoring code; optionally a room-temperature rig, a bucket of water on a load cell read by an HX711 board and an ESP32 microcontroller, to test the sensor chain without nitrogen. The advance is coding agents that can turn a paper's figures and methods into a tested simulator in days.

  1. First step

    Digitize the weight and temperature curves in Michaelson 2019 and fit a two-parameter nitrogen boil-off model to them.

  2. Done looks like

    The simulator reproduces the timelines of both published tests within 10%; at least six alarm rules are scored over 10,000 simulated tank-years for warning time and false alarms per tank-year; code, readings and scores are public under an open license; and one clinic or monitor maker runs its own rule through it and publishes the score.

Open 02 · the brief

Counting donor families across borders

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A working prototype that lets sperm and egg banks in different countries count how many families have received a donor's eggs or sperm, and flag donors over a set limit, without sending donors' identities to each other or to one central list. Test it only on made-up records: 20 simulated banks in 30 countries and 10,000 made-up donors, some of whom give at several banks.

Why it is still open

ESHRE wrote in July 2026 that there is no central international registry of donations, that building one would be challenging, costly and slow, and that an EU registry would have to follow the GDPR's rule of collecting the least data needed. The four Nordic national ethics councils have also called for an international limit and asked sperm and egg banks to set voluntary ones until it exists. The Donor Sibling Registry, a US site started in 2000, lists 107,279 members and says it has connected 28,983 donor-conceived people with half-siblings or donors, but it counts only people who sign up. In the TP53 case, 38 Belgian women had children from one donor despite Belgium's six-family limit.

eshre.euetiskraad.dkdonorsiblingregistry.comstatnews.com

Built with what exists

Keyed hashing of donor identifiers; private set intersection, a way for two parties to find the entries their lists share without showing the rest, from open libraries such as OpenMined's PSI; Python; a script that makes the synthetic records; an AI coding agent to write the tests. The advance is open cryptography libraries that run such comparisons on an ordinary laptop, and coding agents that make a tested prototype quick to build.

  1. First step

    Write and publish a generator of made-up donors, banks and distributions with known true family counts.

  2. Done looks like

    Across 100 runs on the made-up records, the prototype flags every donor over a 50-family limit with no false flags; each bank learns only counts; a run for 10,000 donors takes under an hour on a laptop; and a review by an independent cryptographer is published with the code.