BRENNEN

Industries / Construction and property / Janitorial and facility services / Facility management

Energy

Energy work is running a building's heating, cooling, lighting and equipment so that it uses less fuel and power, and proving how much was saved.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1973 to 2020.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1973

    Thermostats turned down

    On 7 November 1973, during the Arab oil embargo, President Richard Nixon told Americans that heating oil supplies would run about 15% short that winter. He asked households to lower thermostats by at least 6 degrees, to a national daytime average of 68 °F, asked offices and factories for an equivalent cut, and ordered federal offices held at 65 to 68 °F. He said the government had already cut its own energy use by 7%.

    presidency.ucsb.edu

    Credit

    Richard Nixon, President of the United States

  2. 1986

    Paid for by savings

    A law signed on 7 April 1986 (Public Law 99-272) let US federal agencies sign energy savings performance contracts. The contractor pays for the audit, equipment and training and is repaid from a share of the energy savings it guarantees, and the agency's payments to the utility and the contractor together may not exceed what it would have paid for utilities without the contract. Today such contracts may run up to 25 years and must include an annual energy audit. The Federal Energy Management Program (FEMP) has offered agencies a ready-made contract for such projects since 1998.

    law.cornell.eduenergy.gov

    Credit

    US Congress; Federal Energy Management Program

  3. 1997

    One method to count savings

    Savings cannot be read off a meter: they are the gap between what a building used and what it would have used without the change. The US Department of Energy began working with industry on a shared method in 1994, and the North American Energy Measurement and Verification Protocol followed in 1996. In December 1997 the Department issued a revised version (report DOE/EE-0157), drawn up with experts from more than 20 countries, as the International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP). It gives four options, from measuring one retrofitted system to reading the whole building's meters or calibrating a computer simulation, and states that savings in a performance contract are "a contractual quantity, not a measured quantity." The protocol's committee formed a nonprofit in 2001, renamed the Efficiency Valuation Organization (EVO) in 2004, which still maintains it.

    evo-world.orgepa.gov

    Credit

    US Department of Energy and the protocol's committee; Efficiency Valuation Organization

  4. 2009

    Tune-ups pay back fast

    Commissioning checks that a building's systems work as intended; done on an existing building, it is called retro-commissioning and finds the drift that builds up over years. In July 2009 Evan Mills of Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL) compiled 643 US commercial buildings and found more than 10,000 energy-related problems; existing buildings saved a median 16% of their whole-building energy, at a median cost of $0.30 per square foot and a payback of 1.1 years. A 2020 update covering about 1,500 buildings found lower medians for existing buildings: 5% for projects run through utility programs and 14% for those outside them, with a payback of 1.7 years.

    LessonSavings held over three to five years in the 2009 data, but there were no data for longer periods, so the report urged owners to "trust but verify.".

    osti.govosti.gov

    Credit

    Evan Mills; Eliot Crowe and colleagues, LBNL and the Building Commissioning Association

  5. 2014

    Owners must check savings

    New York State's Comptroller audited nine energy performance contracts at eight school districts, begun between 2002 and 2012 at a total cost of about $20.6 million, and reported in April 2014. Seven would produce net savings, but only six would meet the savings the energy service company had guaranteed, and most of the savings came from grants and state aid that helped pay for the equipment. The districts that met their guarantees had tracked results themselves, apart from the contractor's own reconciliation; the districts that missed had no monitoring in place.

    LessonA savings guarantee is only as good as the owner's own check of the bills.

    osc.ny.gov

    Credit

    Office of the New York State Comptroller

  6. 2019

    A state caps energy use

    Washington's Clean Buildings law of 2019 told the state Department of Commerce to set energy use intensity targets, a limit on energy used per square foot each year, by building type, for existing commercial buildings, starting from ASHRAE Standard 100-2018. Buildings that miss their target must take a set path instead: an energy management plan, an operations and maintenance program, energy audits and investment in the measures the audits find. The first reports, from buildings over 220,000 square feet, were due on 1 June 2026, and smaller buildings follow through 2028.

    app.leg.wa.govcommerce.wa.gov

    Credit

    Washington State Legislature; Washington State Department of Commerce

  7. 2020

    Audits alone save little

    New York City's Local Law 87 of 2009 requires buildings over 50,000 square feet to have an energy audit and retro-commissioning every ten years, in a year set by the last digit of the building's tax block number. Because that year falls by chance, Constantine Kontokosta, Danielle Spiegel-Feld and Sokratis Papadopoulos could measure the law's effect without the self-selection that clouds studies of voluntary audits: in about 4,000 buildings from 2011 to 2016, energy use fell about 2.5% in multifamily buildings and 4.9% in offices.

    LessonThe authors conclude that mandatory audits, by themselves, give owners too little reason to invest in efficiency at the scale cities need.

    nature.comnyc.gov

    Credit

    Constantine Kontokosta, Danielle Spiegel-Feld and Sokratis Papadopoulos, in Nature Energy

Watch for

  1. Guarantees met, by contractors' count

    Oak Ridge National Laboratory compiled 205 measurement and verification reports for 200 federal energy savings performance contract projects for the year to 30 September 2024. Reported cost savings were $647.8 million against $601.6 million guaranteed, or 107.7% of the guarantee. The reported figures are the savings the energy service companies verified under each project's own measurement plan, and FEMP says the annual reports rest on information the companies report.

    Achieved whenan independent party re-measures a sample of these projects from utility meter data and publishes how far its figures differ from the reported ones.

    osti.govenergy.gov

    Claimed by

    energy service companies, compiled by Oak Ridge National Laboratory, October 2025

  2. Europe's worst buildings first

    The EU's recast Energy Performance of Buildings Directive (2024/1275) brings in minimum energy performance standards for non-residential buildings that, by the European Commission's account, will trigger renovation of the worst-performing 16% by 2030 and 26% by 2033. Member states had to write it into national law by 29 May 2026; on 15 July 2026 the Commission sent letters of formal notice to all 27 for not having fully done so.

    Achieved whenmember states' laws set the thresholds and national data show the worst-performing 16% of non-residential buildings renovated by 2030.

    energy.ec.europa.eutransition-pathways.europa.eu

    Claimed by

    European Commission, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Ten years between two audits

    A study of the New York City buildings that filed a Local Law 87 audit in 2013 and filed again in 2023 or 2024. For each building, list the energy conservation measures the first audit recommended, check against the second audit's description of the building's equipment which of them were carried out, and compare yearly energy use between the two audits for buildings that acted and buildings that did not.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A public ledger of guarantees

    A public table of guaranteed against reported savings for at least 100 energy performance contracts at US schools, cities and universities, built from the measurement and verification reports filed in public board documents and obtained by public records requests, with an independent re-measurement of 20 of them from monthly utility bills.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Ten years between two audits

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A study of the New York City buildings that filed a Local Law 87 audit in 2013 and filed again in 2023 or 2024. For each building, list the energy conservation measures the first audit recommended, check against the second audit's description of the building's equipment which of them were carried out, and compare yearly energy use between the two audits for buildings that acted and buildings that did not.

Why it is still open

New York publishes both rounds as open data: 6,175 records for audits filed from 2013 to 2018 and 10,702 for 2019 to 2024. Matched by tax lot, 537 buildings filed in 2013 and again in 2023 or 2024, by this file's own count of the city's data on 19 November 2026. Kontokosta and colleagues measured the effect of audits only up to 2016. The City University of New York's Building Performance Lab has compared audit recommendations with building permit filings, which it describes as recording very little about the work done, and a search found no comparison of the first audit with the second. The city does report on its own buildings: its energy management division says in its fiscal 2020 report that it had completed nearly 1,100 audits and carried out more than 2,870 recommended measures in city facilities. A search found no such count for private buildings.

data.cityofnewyork.usaceee.orgnature.comnyc.gov

Built with what exists

NYC Open Data's LL87 Energy Audit Data (the 2012 to 2018 file and the 2019 to 2024 file) and the yearly Local Law 84 benchmarking data; Python with pandas; a low-cost language model such as Claude Haiku 5.5 or Meta's Muse Ember to map the two rounds' differently worded measure fields onto one list (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"), checked by hand on a sample; OpenDSM (formerly OpenEEmeter), an open-source package for weather-normalized energy use.

  1. First step

    Download both files, normalize the tax lot numbers, and hand-check 20 matched buildings to see how well the two rounds' heating, lighting and controls fields line up.

  2. Done looks like

    All 537 buildings matched, a published table of the share of each type of recommended measure carried out within ten years, the energy change for buildings that acted against those that did not, and the code and matched data released.

Open 02 · the brief

A public ledger of guarantees

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of guaranteed against reported savings for at least 100 energy performance contracts at US schools, cities and universities, built from the measurement and verification reports filed in public board documents and obtained by public records requests, with an independent re-measurement of 20 of them from monthly utility bills.

Why it is still open

The large records of these contracts rest on the contractors' own figures. Data for about 75% of the projects in the LBNL/NAESCO project database, by its own description the largest database of energy service company projects in the world with more than 3,600 projects, came through the industry association NAESCO's voluntary accreditation program, and Oak Ridge's federal reports compile savings the companies verified. New York's Comptroller checked nine school contracts independently in 2014. A search found no public, independent ledger across states. Other independent checks have been one-offs: in November 2017 the US Energy Department's Inspector General found that contracts at Los Alamos and Y-12, guaranteeing savings of at least $33.4 million and $54 million, had not achieved their full savings, and Los Alamos's own electricity meter data confirmed the shortfall in most buildings where thermostats had been upgraded.

energy.govosti.govosc.ny.govenergy.gov

Built with what exists

An AI agent such as Claude to find and read contracts and measurement reports in board-meeting documents (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat" for low-cost models suited to extraction); OpenDSM (formerly OpenEEmeter), an open-source package that implements the CalTRACK methods for metered savings; IPMVP Option C, which measures savings at the building's main meters; public records requests for bills.

  1. First step

    Find the measurement and verification reports of ten school districts in one state in their posted board packets and tabulate guaranteed against reported savings.

  2. Done looks like

    100 contracts in at least five states, each with its guaranteed and reported savings linked to the source document, 20 of them re-measured from bills, and the gap between reported and re-measured savings published with the method.