BRENNEN

Industries / Construction and property / Engineering and architecture

Structural design

Structural design is the work of calculating how a building, bridge or plant structure carries its loads, then choosing the size of each beam, column and connection so that it does.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1743 to 2010.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1743

    Calculating a cracked dome

    In 1742 Pope Benedict XIV sent three mathematicians to study cracks in the dome of St. Peter's in Rome, and the physicist Giovanni Poleni made a further study. Between 1743 and 1747 five iron rings were fitted around the dome under Poleni's direction. The historian Hermann Schlimme (2006) counts these assessments as an important step toward modern structural science.

    theamericanscholar.orgdialnet.unirioja.es

    Credit

    Tommaso Leseur, Francesco Jacquier and Ruggiero Giuseppe Boscovich; Giovanni Poleni; the architect Luigi Vanvitelli

  2. 1907

    Quebec Bridge falls

    The unfinished Quebec Bridge in Canada fell on 29 August 1907, and by the Royal Commission's count only 11 of the 86 men on the work survived. The Commission found that the main compression members, the parts that are squeezed, failed "due to their defective design", and that the bridge's estimated own weight was not checked against the drawings until at least 18 months after steel fabrication began.

    LessonCanada's Iron Ring ceremony for new engineers, first held in Montreal on 25 April 1925, traces its history to this collapse.

    archive.orgironring.ca

    Credit

    designer P. L. Szlapka of the Phoenix Bridge Company and consulting engineer Theodore Cooper, who approved the design; the Royal Commission chaired by Henry Holgate

  3. 1940

    Wind tunnels for bridges

    The first Tacoma Narrows Bridge in Washington State twisted and broke up in a windstorm on 7 November 1940. Professor F. B. Farquharson's tests of scale models in a University of Washington wind tunnel pointed to the deck's solid stiffening girders, and models of the replacement design were tested for wind before it opened in 1950.

    LessonBy the account of WSDOT, the state's transportation department, the replacement came through storms in early 1951 with winds up to 75 mph and "no vertical or torsional movement.".

    wsdot.wa.govwsdot.wa.gov

    Credit

    F. B. Farquharson, University of Washington

  4. 1956

    The finite element method

    A 1956 paper by M. J. Turner, Ray Clough, H. C. Martin and L. J. Topp described how to compute the way complex structures bend by splitting them into many small pieces, called elements, whose behavior is simple, and having a computer solve them together. Clough named the method in a paper he presented in September 1960.

    LessonENR's obituary of Clough says finite element analysis "became routinely used in engineering.".

    senate.universityofcalifornia.edupeer.berkeley.eduenr.com

    Credit

    M. J. Turner, Ray W. Clough, H. C. Martin and L. J. Topp

  5. 1981

    Hyatt Regency walkways fall

    Two hanging walkways in the Hyatt Regency Hotel in Kansas City fell on 17 July 1981, and the US National Bureau of Standards (NBS, now NIST) counted 113 dead and 186 injured. Its 1982 report found the rod-to-beam connections too weak even as first designed, and that a change during construction, from one continuous rod to two shorter ones, "essentially doubled the load" on the fourth-floor connections.

    LessonIn 1988 a Missouri appeals court upheld revoking the engineers' licenses and ruled that "design of connections is, under the statute, a matter for which the engineer is responsible.".

    nvlpubs.nist.govhallapproved.com

    Credit

    structural engineers Jack Gillum and Daniel Duncan of G.C.E. International; the NBS investigation led by R. D. Marshall

  6. 2010

    Europe shares design codes

    The Eurocodes are ten European design standards in 58 parts, covering loads, concrete, steel, timber, foundations and earthquakes. National standards bodies, BSI in the UK among them, withdrew conflicting national design standards by 31 March 2010, and the European Commission's Joint Research Centre says the Eurocodes are now adopted in 31 EU and EFTA countries and the United Kingdom. A second generation must replace them by 30 March 2028.

    assets.publishing.service.gov.ukeurocodes.jrc.ec.europa.eueurocodes.jrc.ec.europa.eu

    Credit

    the European Committee for Standardization (CEN) and national standards bodies

Watch for

  1. Tallest hybrid timber tower

    Atlassian Central in Sydney combines a concrete core, a steel exoskeleton (an outer steel frame) and about 10,000 cubic meters of engineered timber, according to New Atlas. Its owners say it will be "one of the world's tallest commercial hybrid timber buildings upon completion", and developer Dexus says it has 50% less embodied carbon, the greenhouse gas released in making its materials and building it, than a conventional tower. The CTBUH Skyscraper Center lists it as architecturally topped out at 182.6 m and classes it as a concrete-steel-timber composite.

    Achieved whenThe building is complete, CTBUH confirms its final height and class, and an independent assessment measures the carbon saving.

    skyscrapercenter.comatlassiancentral.com.audexus.comnewatlas.com

    Claimed by

    Atlassian and Dexus, with topping out reported in July 2026

  2. AI that builds analysis models

    University of Miami researchers say their tool CivilBot turns a written description of a structure, with its spans, supports and loads, into code that builds a computer analysis model for programs such as SAP2000. A professor who used it in a senior design course said it can cut a job of one to five days to "an hour or so", and a student put it at 20 to 30 times faster; no outside test was found. For comparison, the software maker Graitec says the AI assistant in its Advance Design 2027 "does not validate structural adequacy, code compliance, or constructability."

    Achieved whenA peer-reviewed study by people outside the team shows its models match engineer-built ones across many structures, and design firms use it on real projects.

    news.miami.edugraitec.com

    Claimed by

    Minghui Cheng and colleagues, University of Miami, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Seeded errors in calc packages

    A public test of whether AI reviewers catch mistakes in structural calculations. Write or collect calculation packages for ordinary members (beams, columns, footings, a wind load), plant known errors in them (a wrong load, a wrong unit, a wrong code factor, a member checked for the wrong span), and score each reviewer on errors caught and false alarms. Having a second engineer check a design is routine; this measures software doing that check.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Old bridge drawings to models

    A pipeline that reads scanned drawings of an existing bridge and writes a working analysis model: member layout, sizes, supports and materials, ready for free software such as OpenSees. Start with steel truss bridges, whose drawings list each member.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Seeded errors in calc packages

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test of whether AI reviewers catch mistakes in structural calculations. Write or collect calculation packages for ordinary members (beams, columns, footings, a wind load), plant known errors in them (a wrong load, a wrong unit, a wrong code factor, a member checked for the wrong span), and score each reviewer on errors caught and false alarms. Having a second engineer check a design is routine; this measures software doing that check.

Why it is still open

Firms now sell AI checks of structural drawings and calculations. InspectMind lists the codes it checks against but publishes no catch rate or miss rate, and Nomic calls its tool "a first-pass QA/QC layer, not a replacement for the engineer of record" without measured results. StructureClaw-Bench (July 2026, Sizhong Qin, Xinzheng Lu and colleagues) scores agents that carry out structural analysis, not agents that review someone else's package for planted errors.

inspectmind.ainomic.aiarxiv.org

Built with what exists

Hand calculations confirmed with free analysis software such as OpenSees; AI models as reviewers, with a second model that flags doubtful findings for a person (see the Notes "Seven more flagged" and "Checked without being asked").

  1. First step

    Write five beam and footing calculations to one code, plant two errors in each, and run one AI reviewer over them.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 50 packages holding at least 100 planted errors, each confirmed by a licensed engineer, published with a table of errors caught, errors missed and false alarms for at least two AI reviewers and one human checker.

Open 02 · the brief

Old bridge drawings to models

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A pipeline that reads scanned drawings of an existing bridge and writes a working analysis model: member layout, sizes, supports and materials, ready for free software such as OpenSees. Start with steel truss bridges, whose drawings list each member.

Why it is still open

Most existing bridges lack digital design data, and for older ones even 2D CAD files are often missing, by the account of Shuhei Abe and colleagues at the University of Tokyo (2025). Their method picks out structural parts in simplified bridge cross-sections with 97.9% mean accuracy, and a full analysis model from raster drawings is their stated long-term aim.

jstage.jst.go.jp

Built with what exists

Scanned bridge drawings from public archives such as the Historic American Engineering Record (HAER), which the Library of Congress publishes online; a vision-language model to read member tables and dimensions; OpenSees or another open analysis program.

  1. First step

    Download the HAER drawings of one small steel truss bridge and build its model by hand, to serve as the first answer key.

  2. Done looks like

    Ten truss bridges, each with a model whose member lengths and sizes match a person's reading of the drawings for at least 95% of members, and whose support reactions under the bridge's own weight agree with a hand calculation within 5%, with drawings, models and code published.