BRENNEN

Industries / Health / Healthcare / Durable medical equipment

Billing

Billing here means how suppliers of home equipment are paid by public insurers, how the prices are set, and how false claims are caught.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1989 to 2024.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

3

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1989

    Fee schedule replaces charges

    From 1966 Medicare paid for home equipment on "reasonable charges", based on what suppliers had charged the year before; CMS says these rose each year "without any limit on inflation until October 1986". Under the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1987, Medicare began paying from a fee schedule on 1 January 1989. The amounts were the average reasonable charges of 1986 and 1987 in each state, updated yearly, with a national ceiling and floor. Costly items that are usually rented went into a "capped rental" class, where Medicare pays rent for up to 13 months of continuous use. MedPAC, which advises the US Congress, says Medicare spent about $9.2 billion on this equipment in 2023.

    LessonPrices taken from 1986 and 1987 charges were still the base of the schedule more than three decades later.

    federalregister.govmedpac.gov

    Credit

    US Congress; the Health Care Financing Administration, now CMS

  2. 2003

    Power wheelchair spending quadruples

    Medicare and its beneficiaries spent more than $1 billion on power wheelchairs in 2003. GAO found that this spending had risen more than fourfold since 1999 while overall Medicare spending rose about 11%. In 2002, 14% of the spending was for people in Harris County, Texas, where about 1% of beneficiaries lived. Suppliers there had billed for chairs that were never delivered and advertised chairs as "free". A fraud analyst at the claims contractor Palmetto spotted one supplier's billing in early 2002, and in January 2003 Palmetto referred 22 Harris County suppliers for prosecution. One contractor had warned the agency about the growth in 1997, and funding for medical review of equipment claims fell about 22% between fiscal years 1999 and 2003.

    LessonThe payer's own data showed the problem years before anyone acted on it.

    govinfo.gov

    Credit

    Palmetto GBA's fraud unit; GAO

  3. 2011

    Bidding sets Medicare prices

    A 2003 law told Medicare to replace fee schedule prices with prices set by suppliers' bids. A first round took effect on 1 July 2008 and Congress cancelled its contracts. The rebid round began on 1 January 2011 in nine metropolitan areas, and in July 2013 bidding spread to 91 more areas and to a national mail-order program for diabetes testing supplies. CMS says the 2013 prices averaged 45% below the fee schedule, and 72% below for mail-order diabetes supplies. An outside study compared the first round's prices with what national commercial insurers paid from 2011 to 2014 and found them comparable. Economists who ran the auction's rules in a laboratory, with the price set at the median winning bid and winners free to withdraw, had reported in 2012 that the design "fails to generate competitive prices of goods and fails to satisfy demand".

    federalregister.goveuropepmc.orgecon.umd.edu

    Credit

    US Congress and CMS; D. Newman, E. Barrette and K. McGraves-Lloyd for the price comparison; P. Cramton, B. Merlob, C. Plott and Y. Zhang for the experiments

  4. 2016

    Harm claimed, then not found

    G. Puckrein and colleagues studied Medicare claims from 2009 to 2012 for people using insulin. In the nine bidding areas the number getting only part of their prescribed blood-sugar testing supplies, or none, rose 23.0% between 2010 and 2011, against 1.7% elsewhere, and the authors linked the shift to more deaths and hospital admissions. Later studies of other products did not find harm. W. Tarazi and colleagues (2022) looked at breathing machines for sleep apnea, oxygen supplies and walkers from 2009 to 2016 and found lower spending with no change in use, emergency visits, hospital stays or falls. K. Duan and colleagues (2024) followed 5,753,308 people with chronic lung disease and found no significant change in new oxygen prescriptions or in people stopping oxygen.

    LessonThe effect of lower prices on patients was measured product by product, and one product's result did not carry over to the others.

    europepmc.orgeuropepmc.orgpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    Credit

    Puckrein et al.; Tarazi et al.; Duan et al

  5. 2019

    Germany bans tenders

    German public health insurers could put the supply of assistive products, such as incontinence pads, stoma supplies and breathing equipment, out to tender. A 2017 law told them to weigh quality in those tenders. The health ministry's drafting note for the next law said the hoped-for competition on quality "did not come about", and the minister, Jens Spahn, said the price fight went "too often" against patients. The 2019 Appointment Service and Supply Act removed the tender option; insurers must instead sign framework contracts that any supplier meeting the quality standards can join. In September 2026 a planned update to a savings law was reported to bring tenders back, and manufacturers and the pharmacists' association objected.

    LessonWriting quality rules into a lowest-price tender did not produce competition on quality.

    aerzteblatt.depharmazeutische-zeitung.de

    Credit

    German Federal Ministry of Health and the Bundestag

  6. 2020

    A round without savings

    For its 2021 round CMS changed the price rule from the median winning bid to the highest winning bid. It received more than 49,000 bids across 130 areas. On 27 October 2020 it said it would award no contracts for the 13 product categories that had been bid before, "because the payment amounts did not achieve expected savings". Only off-the-shelf back and knee braces went ahead; CMS expected $600 million in savings from them over three years in 2020 and gave an estimate of $934 million in 2025. Those contracts ended on 31 December 2023 and no bidding has been in force since. CMS wrote in 2025 that the round failed because the price rule changed while the number of contracts awarded did not.

    LessonChanging one rule of an auction without the rule it depends on undid the savings.

    cms.govfederalregister.gov

    Credit

    CMS

  7. 2024

    Catheter billing spotted outside

    Accountable care organizations are groups of doctors and hospitals that Medicare holds to a spending target, so they receive their patients' claims. In December 2023 members of their national association, NAACOS, began reporting bills for urinary catheters their patients had never received. NAACOS's review of Medicare claims found catheter payments of $153 million in 2021 and $2.1 billion in 2023, and it traced about $2 billion to seven supply companies. CMS gives a different account: it says it saw the rise in early 2023 among 15 suppliers that had recently changed owners, stopped over 99% of the payments, worth more than $4.2 billion by July 2024, revoked all 15, and replaced hundreds of thousands of beneficiary numbers.

    LessonWhoever sees claims month by month can spot a spike long before public data shows it.

    fiercehealthcare.comcms.gov

    Credit

    NAACOS and its member organizations; CMS

Watch for

  1. Bidding returns in 2028

    CMS has rewritten the bidding rules. The price for the main item in each category will be the 75th percentile of winning bids, CMS will award fewer contracts, prices will rise with inflation from the second contract year, and mail-order contests can cover the whole country. Continuous glucose monitors and insulin pumps join on a monthly rental, along with ostomy, tracheostomy and urological supplies. CMS says the 75th percentile rule "has never been attempted"; it tested it by re-running bids from earlier rounds, which gave 36% fewer contracts and 6% lower prices for oxygen equipment. The round is expected to take effect on 1 January 2028.

    Achieved whencontracts are in force and GAO, the inspector general or an academic team reports the prices, the number of suppliers and patients' access.

    federalregister.govoig.hhs.gov

    Claimed by

    CMS, December 2025

  2. A fraud war room

    CMS says its Fraud Defense Operations Center, opened in March 2025, suspended more than $2.1 billion in possibly fraudulent payments in its first year, over $1.9 billion of it for home equipment and supplies, and that its contractors use AI to find unusual billing. It froze new enrollments of medical supply companies for six months, ending on 27 August 2026, and a rule in force from 2026 requires accredited suppliers to be surveyed at least every 12 months. CMS put improper payments for this equipment at $2.3 billion, 24.1%, in 2025. The inspector general's August 2026 paper says the $50,000 bond suppliers must buy, at a cost of about $1,500, has not kept bad actors out.

    Achieved whenthe inspector general or GAO measures whether the enrollment freeze and the yearly surveys cut the share of newly enrolled equipment suppliers that lose their Medicare billing rights within two years.

    oig.hhs.govcms.gov

    Claimed by

    CMS, August 2026

  3. A $10.6 billion catheter case

    US prosecutors charged 19 people in what they call Operation Gold Rush. They allege that owners in name only, directed from abroad, bought dozens of US medical supply companies and submitted $10.6 billion in claims to Medicare for urinary catheters and other equipment, using the stolen identities of more than one million people. They say Medicare paid about $41 million of the $4.45 billion due to go out, and that supplemental insurers paid about $900 million.

    Achieved whenthe cases end in verdicts or pleas and courts confirm the loss figures.

    cms.gov

    Claimed by

    US Department of Justice and CMS, June 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Ownership changes from public files

    A monthly comparison of the public US registry of provider identifiers (NPPES) for home equipment suppliers. It records when a supplier's authorized official, address or phone number changes, joins that to state business-registry filings, and lists suppliers whose control appears to have changed hands. Each flag is a prompt for review, not an accusation.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Replay the 2028 auction

    An open simulator of the bidding rules in CMS's December 2025 rule: combined bids across a category, the cut-off bid, the price at the 75th percentile of winning bids, bid limits and the smaller number of contracts. Simulated suppliers differ in cost and capacity. The simulator reports prices, the number of winners and unmet demand, and compares the new rule with the median and highest-bid rules used before.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  3. 03

    Two rental price lists

    A table that sets Medicare's monthly rental amounts for about 20 commonly rented kinds of equipment, such as home care beds, standard wheelchairs and walkers, beside Japan's published national average monthly rental price and price cap for the same kinds of product under its long-term care insurance.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Ownership changes from public files

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A monthly comparison of the public US registry of provider identifiers (NPPES) for home equipment suppliers. It records when a supplier's authorized official, address or phone number changes, joins that to state business-registry filings, and lists suppliers whose control appears to have changed hands. Each flag is a prompt for review, not an accusation.

Why it is still open

The inspector general wrote in August 2026 that CMS has no single data source to verify who owns a supplier or to detect unreported changes of ownership, and urged using AI on state ownership data. In the catheter case the suppliers "had recently changed ownership", in CMS's words. Parts exist. An open study, pdecay-utils (August 2026), compares 20 consecutive monthly NPPES files field by field for all 8.4 million provider records and reports how often addresses and phone numbers change, but it does not single out equipment suppliers or test against revocations. An AI assistant for equipment-fraud investigators, built in 2026, searches the inspector general's exclusion list and Missouri's business registry one query at a time. No public tool combines the monthly changes, the supplier subset and a back-test.

oig.hhs.govcms.govgithub.comgithub.com

Built with what exists

the monthly and weekly NPPES files, whose organization records carry the authorized official's name and title; CMS's public list of revoked Medicare enrollments, released in March 2026, as an answer key; state business-registry search pages; a browser agent such as Browser Use 1.0 to look up and read registry filings (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); Python.

download.cms.gov

  1. First step

    Run pdecay-utils on two consecutive monthly files, keep the organizations with a durable medical equipment supplier taxonomy code, and count how many changed their authorized official.

  2. Done looks like

    twelve monthly files compared; code and method published; a back-test showing what share of equipment suppliers on the revoked list had a change of official or address in the year before revocation, against the share among all suppliers; the false-flag rate stated.

Open 02 · the brief

Replay the 2028 auction

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open simulator of the bidding rules in CMS's December 2025 rule: combined bids across a category, the cut-off bid, the price at the 75th percentile of winning bids, bid limits and the smaller number of contracts. Simulated suppliers differ in cost and capacity. The simulator reports prices, the number of winners and unmet demand, and compares the new rule with the median and highest-bid rules used before.

Why it is still open

CMS says the 75th percentile rule "has never been attempted". Its own test re-ran bids from earlier rounds, which were made under other rules and are not public. The 2012 laboratory experiments covered only the median rule with bids that winners could withdraw. Peter Cramton, Sean Ellermeyer and Brett Katzman showed in theory (2015) that median pricing can let high-cost firms displace low-cost ones, and Hui Ding, Mark Duggan and Amanda Starc (2021) measured a 44.8% fall in CPAP prices under the old rules from claims data. Neither models the 75th percentile rule, and a search found comments from industry groups but no independent model of it.

federalregister.govecon.umd.edunber.org

Built with what exists

Python; the rule text in the Federal Register; the 2012 experiment's design as a check; optionally AI models playing the bidders, to see how bidding changes when the rules change.

  1. First step

    Code the price rule for one product category with ten bidders and check the result by hand.

  2. Done looks like

    the code reproduces the direction of the 2012 findings for the median rule; results for the 75th percentile rule are published across at least 1,000 simulated markets with every assumption listed; one economist outside the project reviews the model in writing.

Open 03 · the brief

Two rental price lists

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A table that sets Medicare's monthly rental amounts for about 20 commonly rented kinds of equipment, such as home care beds, standard wheelchairs and walkers, beside Japan's published national average monthly rental price and price cap for the same kinds of product under its long-term care insurance.

Why it is still open

Both lists are public. Japan's Association for Technical Aids publishes the national average rental price and the cap for each product, with caps applied since October 2018, and Medicare publishes its fee schedule. The nearest comparison, a WHO-led review published in April 2026, collected the lowest purchase price of 120 assistive products in 12 countries, Japan among them, for the update of WHO's priority list; it did not collect what public insurers pay or any rental prices. A search found no comparison of rental rates paid by public insurers.

techno-aids.or.jpmedpac.govfrontiersin.org

Built with what exists

CMS's public fee schedule files; the Japanese price files, which are Excel sheets in Japanese; a language model to translate product classes, checked by a Japanese reader; published purchasing-power exchange rates.

  1. First step

    Match one product type, the adjustable home care bed, in both lists and write down what each rental price covers.

  2. Done looks like

    20 product types matched by two reviewers; the median and range on each side, converted at purchasing-power rates; a note for each type on what the rent includes, such as delivery, set-up and maintenance; the table and matching rules published.