BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Education / Driving schools

Simulators

Simulator training seats a learner at mock car or truck controls in front of a screen or headset, so they can practice driving and meet hazards without a real vehicle on the road.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1953 to 2023.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1953

    Classroom cars with films

    The Aetna Drivotrainer seated a class of up to 15 students in "dummy cars" with a steering wheel, pedals and gear lever. The cars faced a screen that showed a driving film. A recorder scored each student's moves against the film, and a printer gave the instructor a record for each student. Before it, according to the Brooklyn Public Library, only 1% of New York City students got any on-road instruction. The library dates the Drivotrainer's debut to 1953 at the Brooklyn High School for Automotive Trades. Hagerty dates the system to 1951. Aetna and the city's school system made 22 films for it, and by 1954 Aetna had built a 15-seat classroom in Sweden.

    bklynlibrary.orghagerty.com

    Credit

    Aetna Casualty; Richard O'Connor, New York City's commissioner for driver education

  2. 1965

    Simulator matches the range

    A study at East Lansing High School in Michigan in 1959–60 split 133 students into two groups. One learned on 15 Drivotrainers. The other learned on a 12-car off-street driving range, a fenced practice lot. Each group had ten hours of this, plus a few hours on the street. Robert Nolan's 1965 doctoral thesis at Michigan State University found no significant difference between the groups on an on-street road test, on driving knowledge or on attitudes.

    LessonSimulator hours could replace range hours for early skills, but the study measured a test soon after training, not crashes later.

    d.lib.msu.edu

    Credit

    Robert O. Nolan, Michigan State University

  3. 2007

    Virtual instructors in Dutch schools

    A 2005 estimate, cited by researchers at Delft University of Technology, put about 100 low-cost simulators in use for first-time driver training in the Netherlands. Over one eight-month measurement, 46 Green Dino simulators at 42 Dutch driving schools logged the lessons of 2,530 learners. Software called a "virtual instructor" gave instructions, scored each task against set limits and cut back its feedback as learners improved. The 520 learners who finished all 15 lessons spent 5 h 45 min driving in the simulator before moving to a real car.

    repository.tudelft.nl

    Credit

    Joost de Winter and colleagues, Delft University of Technology; Green Dino

  4. 2016

    US keeps simulators to theory

    The US training rule for new truck and bus drivers, issued in December 2016, lets schools use simulators for the theory part of training only. It does not let them stand in for behind-the-wheel training, where the trainee controls a real vehicle on a range or public road. The simulator maker Virage Simulation had asked that simulators replace up to 50% of behind-the-wheel hours, and the carrier Schneider had asked for 10%. FMCSA, the US truck and bus safety regulator, said there is "simply no substitute" for time in direct control of the vehicle.

    govinfo.gov

    Credit

    Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA)

  5. 2018

    EU caps simulator hours

    The EU's training rules for professional truck and bus drivers, as rewritten in 2018, require 20 hours of individual driving within the 280-hour initial course. At most 8 of those hours may be "on special terrain or on a top-of-the-range simulator". The 140-hour fast-track course allows 4 of its 10 driving hours there.

    legislation.gov.uk

    Credit

    European Parliament and Council (Directive 2003/59/EC, amended by Directive (EU) 2018/645)

  6. 2023

    Simulated drive predicts crashes

    Ohio offers driver license applicants a 15-minute self-guided simulated drive, the Virtual Driving Assessment. It tests basic vehicle control, lane position, following distance and hazard avoidance. Researchers matched the scores of more than 16,000 newly licensed drivers under 25 with police crash reports. In a study in Pediatrics, the best-scoring group had a crash risk 10% below average and the worst group 11% above, by the account of the US National Institutes of Health (NIH). All of these drivers had passed the road test.

    LessonA short simulated drive picked out risk that the road test had passed.

    nichd.nih.gov

    Credit

    Elizabeth Walshe and colleagues, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia; State of Ohio; funded by NIH's child health institute (NICHD)

Watch for

  1. Headset teaches truck reversing

    Researchers in Switzerland trained four learners to reverse a truck with a trailer, either on a conventional simulator or in a low-cost virtual reality (VR) headset. They report that learners in VR learned about as fast as those on the simulator, and that the skill carried over to a real truck. The authors say the sample, four men, was too small for statistical comparison.

    Achieved whena study with enough participants, a group trained on a real truck and a delayed retest finds the same.

    isprs-archives.copernicus.org

    Claimed by

    Andrea Frick and Arzu Çöltekin, University of Applied Sciences Northwestern Switzerland, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    An open simulator transfer trial

    A free set of beginner lessons for an open simulator, covering controls, junctions, roundabouts and motorway merges. It would include automatic scoring, a shared data format and a written trial plan. Several driving schools could then compare learners who used it with learners who did not, on the same outcomes.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    An open trailer-reversing trainer

    A free desktop simulator for the three reversing exercises in the US training curriculum for new truck drivers: straight-line backing, alley dock backing at 45 and 90 degrees, and offset backing. It would score pull-ups (stopping to pull forward and correct), lines crossed and time automatically.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

An open simulator transfer trial

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A free set of beginner lessons for an open simulator, covering controls, junctions, roundabouts and motorway merges. It would include automatic scoring, a shared data format and a written trial plan. Several driving schools could then compare learners who used it with learners who did not, on the same outcomes.

Why it is still open

Systematic reviews in 2023 (Alonso and colleagues) and 2024 (Krasniuk and colleagues) found the evidence that simulator training helps new drivers "still inconsistent". Most studies compared simulators with no training or classroom training and measured gains on the simulator itself, so whether training carries over to the road is "largely unclear". That is the account in the literature review of a 2026 paper. The large Dutch measurements ran on a commercial system and recorded performance inside the simulator. Free practice simulators exist as student projects, such as a Unity game for Malaysia's driving test with four lessons (slope, S-bend, parallel parking and three-point turn), last updated in June 2026, but a GitHub search in November 2026 found none that had been tested against learners' results on the road.

isprs-archives.copernicus.orgrepository.tudelft.nlgithub.com

Built with what exists

CARLA, an open urban driving simulator; DReyeVR, an open VR driving platform built on CARLA with eye tracking, whose authors put the hardware under US$5,000; a game steering wheel and pedals; OSF (Open Science Framework) to register the trial plan in advance; Python for analysis.

arxiv.org

  1. First step

    Write the trial plan and build three lessons in CARLA, then ask one school to try them with five learners.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 10 lessons released under an open license. A trial plan registered before any data is collected. Results from at least two schools in different countries, with at least 30 consenting learners in each group, reporting lessons needed and first-attempt pass rates on the official test.

Open 02 · the brief

An open trailer-reversing trainer

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A free desktop simulator for the three reversing exercises in the US training curriculum for new truck drivers: straight-line backing, alley dock backing at 45 and 90 degrees, and offset backing. It would score pull-ups (stopping to pull forward and correct), lines crossed and time automatically.

Why it is still open

The 2026 Swiss paper calls reversing a truck with a trailer "a particularly difficult task that requires extensive practice". The studies it cites used commercial simulators, among them a 2003 study of 50 people on an Oerlikon Contraves FATRAN simulator that found no significant difference from training on a real vehicle. Virage Simulation told FMCSA that three studies showed backing skills learned on a simulator equal training in the truck. The open simulators found in this research, CARLA (built for self-driving research) and OpenDS (built for driving research), came with no trailer-reversing lesson. Open code for reversing a trailer exists in two other forms: a 2017 browser game, under the MIT license, in which the player backs a trailer into a parking spot with no scoring against any curriculum, and many versions of the "truck backer-upper", a test problem for control software in which the computer, not a person, does the reversing.

isprs-archives.copernicus.orggovinfo.govarxiv.orggithub.comgithub.comgithub.com

Built with what exists

Published equations for how a tractor and semitrailer move; the Godot game engine or CARLA; a USB game steering wheel; Python for scoring.

  1. First step

    Code the tractor-trailer motion and the straight-line backing lane from the curriculum's unit descriptions (Units A2.2 to A2.4 of the 2016 rule).

  2. Done looks like

    Released under an open license. On 50 attempts recorded in the simulator, its pass or fail call matches the scores of three commercial driving instructors at least 90% of the time.